SECOND SECTION
DECISION
AS TO THE ADMISSIBILITY OF
Application no. 8498/05
by Abdulkahar AKSOY and 158 other applications
against Turkey
The European Court of Human Rights (Second Section), sitting on 11 January 2011 as a Chamber composed of:
Françoise Tulkens, President,
Ireneu Cabral Barreto,
Danutė Jočienė,
András Sajó,
Nona Tsotsoria,
Işıl Karakaş,
Kristina Pardalos, judges,
and Stanley Naismith, Section Registrar,
Having regard to the above applications,
Having regard to the observations submitted by the respondent Government and the observations in reply submitted by some of the applicants,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
THE FACTS
A. The circumstances of the case
The applicants are Turkish nationals and at the time of lodging their applications they were serving their prison sentences in various establishments. The names and dates of birth of the applicants, as well as the names of their representatives, and the dates of introduction of the applications appear in the appendix.
All of the applicants were found guilty of breaching prison order by decisions of the respective disciplinary boards of prisons in which they are held. Pursuant to the Regulations on the administration of penitentiary institutions and the execution of sentences, various types of disciplinary sanctions were imposed on them. Their appeal requests were rejected respectively by the Enforcement Judges and the Assize Courts, on the basis of the case file, without hearing the applicants or their lawyers, pursuant to Law No. 4675 on Enforcement Judges, dated 16 May 2001.
The details of the applications as well as the complaints raised by the applicants appear in the table below.
Application no.
and case name
Disciplinary Act committed
Type of sanction imposed on the applicant
Date of Board’s decision
Date of final decision delivered by the Assize Court
Intro-duction date of the application
Complaints raised by the applicant
8498/05
Aksoy
v. Turkey (no. 1)
pressing emergency buttons in the cell and refusing to participate in social activities, or work shops in prison.
ban from corres-pondence for 15 days
29/12/2004
26/01/2005
14/02/2005
Articles 6, 8 and 13
8534/05
Akay
v. Turkey
pressing emergency buttons in the cell and refusing to participate in social activities, or work shops in prison.
ban from corres-pondence for 15 days
29/12/2004
26/01/2005
14/02/2005
Articles 6, 8 and 13
9021/05
Araci
v. Turkey
pressing emergency buttons in the cell and refusing to participate in social activities, work shops in prison
ban from corres-pondence for 15 days
29/12/2004
26/01/2005
03/03/2005
Articles 6, 8 and 13
9096/05
Bahadır
v. Turkey
pressing emergency buttons in the cell and refusing to participate in social activities, work shops in prison
ban from corres-pondence for 15 days
29/12/2004
24/01/2005
24/02/2005
Articles 3, 6, 7, 9, 10 and 13.
13442/05
Ekelik
v. Turkey
pressing emergency buttons in the cell and refusing to participate in social activities, work shops in prison
ban from corres-pondence for 15 days
29/12/2004
26/01/2005
21/02/2005
Articles 6 and 8
14030/05
Kutlu
v. Turkey
pressing emergency buttons in the cell and refusing to participate in social activities, work shops in prison
ban from corres-pondence for 15 days
29/12/2004
26/01/2005
18/02/2005
Articles 6 and 8
24822/05
Gerez
v. Turkey
a) possessing a sharp cutting object
b) avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
a) ban from receiving visitors for 1 month
b) ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
a)
28/03/2005
b)
04/07/2005
a)
05/04/2005
b)
21/10/2005
a)
09/06/2005
b)
14/11/2005
a)
Articles 3, 6 and 7
b)
Articles 6 and 7
40676/05
Çakal
v. Turkey
a) chanting illegal slogans
b) avoiding visits and telephone calls as well as court hearings to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
a) ban from corres-pondence for 45 days
b) ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
a)
25/07/2005
b)
01/08/2005
a)
26/09/2005
b)
26/09/2005
15/11/2005
Articles 2, 6 and 10
43339/05
Sayhan
v. Turkey
a) chanting illegal slogans
b) avoiding visits and telephone calls as well as court hearings to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
a) ban from corres-pondence for 45 days
b) ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
a)
25/07/2005
b)
01/08/2005
a)
26/09/2005
b)
26/09/2005
17/11/2005
Articles 8, 9 and 10
43655/05
Şek
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
15/11/2005
Articles 6 and 7
43681/05
Yavuz
v. Turkey
a) chanting illegal slogans
b) avoiding visits and telephone calls as well as court hearings
to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
a) ban from corres-pondence for 45 days
b) ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
a)
25/07/2005
b)
01/08/2005
The applicant did not appeal against the respective decisions of the Enforcement Judge, dated 24/08/2005
15/11/2005
Article 6
43732/05
Kıran and others
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
21/11/2005
Articles 6 and 8
43736/05
Okul
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
22/11/2005
Articles 6 and 7
43737/05
Karatay
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
22/11/2005
Articles 6 and 7
45875/05
Koyuncu
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
23/11/2005
Articles 6 and 7
45876/05
Sarıkaya
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
24/11/2005
Articles 6 and 7
1797/06
Yağız
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls as well as court hearings
to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
01/08/2005
02/09/2005
21/11/2005
Articles 6 and 8
8763/06
Yulu
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
15/02/2006
Articles 3, 6 and 7
8766/06
Mustafa
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
13/02/2006
Articles 3, 6 and 7
8767/06
Karataş
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
13/02/2006
Articles 3, 6 and 7
8768/06
Kaya
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
13/02/2006
Articles 3, 6 and 7
8769/06
Muhammet
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
13/02/2006
Articles 3, 6 and 7
9047/06
Nazlıer
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
21/02/2006
Articles 3, 6 and 7
9123/06
Çırak
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
14/02/2006
Articles 3, 6 and 7
9509/06
Yılmaz
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
23/02/2006
Articles 3, 6 and 7
9558/06
Arslan and others
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
20/02/2006
Articles 3, 6 and 7
9575/06
Eşiyok and Ahmet v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
20/02/2006
Articles 3, 6 and 7
9953/06
İlboğa
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
13/02/2006
Articles 3, 6 and 7
9958/06
Güzelaydın
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
13/02/2006
Articles 3, 6 and 7
10685/06
Öztürk
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
15/02/2006
Articles 3, 6 and 7
10686/06
Eker
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
15/02/2006
Articles 3, 6 and 7
15919/06
Yıldız
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
13/02/2006
Articles 3, 6 and 7
15921/06
Oruç
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
20/02/2006
Articles 3, 6 and 7
15922/06
Zengeralp
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
20/02/2006
Articles 3, 6 and 7
16249/06
Yamalak
v. Turkey
a) chanting slogans in support of an illegal organisation
b) launching a hunger strike to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
a) ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
b) ban from social activities for 1 month
a)
02/12/2005
b)
20/02/2006
a)
23/01/2006
b)
03/04/2006
12/04/2006
Article 6
17798/06
Kaya
v. Turkey
avoiding visits and telephone calls to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
04/07/2005
21/10/2005
30/03/2006
Articles 3, 6 and 7
20990/06
Çelik and others
v. Turkey
chanting slogans in support of an illegal organisation
ban from corres-pondence for 2 months
19/09/2005
22/11/2005
14/04/2006
Articles 6, 8, 10 and 13
24619/06
Yavuz
v. Turkey
chanting slogans in support of an illegal organisation
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
01/03/2006
27/04/2006
09/05/2006
Articles 6 and 8
27796/06
Alkış
v. Turkey
praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
ban from using common areas for 45 days
03/05/2006
08/06/2006
21/06/2006
Articles 6 and 10, Article 2 of Protocol No. 1
27868/06
Deniz
v. Turkey
praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
ban from prison work shops and sports activities for 45 days
26/04/2006
24/05/2006
27/06/2006
Articles 6, 7, 10 and 14
28219/06
Karaaslan
v. Turkey
praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
a) ban from prison work shops and sports activities for 45 days
b) 11 days’ solitary confinement
a)
09/05/2006
b)
26/03/2007
a)
08/06/2006
b)
15/05/2007
04/07/2006
Article 9
29341/06
Şanak
v. Turkey
a) launching a hunger strike for three days to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
b) praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
a) ban from certain activities for 3 months
b) ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
a)
22/02/2006
b)
16/03/2006
a)
14/04/2006
b)
25/04/2006
08/06/2006
Article 6
36444/06
Taşdemir
v. Turkey
praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
ban from prison work shops and sports activities for 45 days
09/05/2006
08/06/2006
14/08/2006
Articles 6, 7, 9 and 10
38377/06
Günay
v. Turkey
a) launching a hunger strike for three days to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
b) chanting illegal slogans
c) launching a hunger strike for three days to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
d) praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
a) ban from social activities for 1 month
b) ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
c) ban from social activities for 3 months
d) ban from social activities for 2 months
a)
20/02/2006
b)
22/08/2006
c)
08/09/2006
d)
03/10/2006
a)
03/04/2006
b)
01/11/2006
c)
30/10/2006
d)
27/11/2006
a)
11/09/2006
b)
18/12/2006
c)
18/12/2006
d)
18/12/2006
Articles 3, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 and 14
40349/06
Coşkun
v. Turkey
launching a hunger strike for two days to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from social activities for 2 months and ban from corres-pondence for 2 months
18/09/2006
18/10/2006
14/11/2006
Articles 3, 6, 7, 10, 13 and 14
43491/06
Özdemir
v. Turkey
launching a hunger strike
ban from corres-pondence for 2 months
26/12/2005
07/04/2006
06/10/2006
Articles 6, 8, 13, 14, 17 and 18
47401/06
Gedik v. Turkey
launching a hunger strike for two days to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from certain activities for 2 months and ban from corres-pondence for 2 months
18/09/2006
18/10/2006
14/11/2006
Articles 3, 6, 7, 10, 13, 14
47453/06
Demir
v. Turkey
launching a hunger strike for two days to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from certain activities for 2 months
18/09/2006
18/10/2006
14/11/2006
Articles 3, 6 and 13
561/07
Tekdemir
v. Turkey
a) writing a letter to the prison administration to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
b) writing letters to the public prosecutor, Ministry of Justice, and Ministry of Health
a) ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
b) ban from participating in prison work shops for 1 month
a)
18/09/2006
b)
19/03/2007
a)
09/10/2006
b)
09/05/2007
a)
22/12/2006
b)
06/07/2007
a)
Articles 3, 6, 7, 8 and 10
b)
Articles 3, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 10
562/07
Okçul
v. Turkey
a) writing a letter to the prison administration to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
b) writing letters to the public prosecutor, Ministry of Justice, and Ministry of Health
a) ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
b) ban from participating in prison work shops for 1 month
a)
18/09/2006
b)
19/03/2007
a)
09/10/2006
b)
09/05/2007
a)
22/12/2006
b)
04/07/2007
a)
Articles 3, 6, 7, 8 and 10
b)
Articles 3, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 10
565/07
Vural
v. Turkey
writing a letter to the prison administration to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
18/09/2006
09/10/2006
22/12/2006
Articles 3, 6, 7, 8 and 10
608/07
Edemen
v. Turkey
writing a letter to the prison administration to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
18/09/2006
09/10/2006
19/12/2006
Articles 3, 6, 7, 8 and 10
627/07
Emek
v. Turkey
writing a letter to the prison administration to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
18/09/2006
09/10/2006
19/12/2006
Articles 3, 6, 7, 8 and 10
1316/07
Özer
v. Turkey
writing a letter to the prison administration to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
18/09/2006
09/10/2006
19/12/2006
Articles 3, 6, 7, 8 and 10
1318/07
Tuneli
v. Turkey
writing a letter to the prison administration to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
18/09/2006
9/10/2006
19/12/2006
Articles 3, 6, 7, 8 and 10
1324/07
Sır
v. Turkey
writing a letter to the prison administration to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
18/09/2006
09/10/2006
27/12/2006
Articles 3, 6, 7, 8 and 10
1344/07
Yurtsever
v. Turkey
a) chanting slogans
b) launching a hunger strike
c) chanting slogans
d) launching a hunger strike
a) ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
b) ban from social activities for 3 months
c) ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
d) ban from certain activities for 3 months
a)
09/05/2006
b)
08/09/2006
c)
13/03/2007
d)
09/03/2007
a)
20/09/2006
b)
30/10/2006
c)
09/05/2007
d)
28/05/2007
a)
18/12/2006
b)
18/12/2006
c)
22/06/2007
d)
22/06/2007
Articles 6, 8 and 14
2752/07
Erol Yılmaz
v. Turkey (no. 1)
launching a hunger strike to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from social activities for 3 months
08/09/2006
30/10/2006
04/01/2007
Article 6
3492/07
Özer
v. Turkey
writing a letter to the prison administration to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
18/09/2006
09/10/2006
19/12/2006
Articles 3, 6, 7, 8 and 10
3937/07
Yamalak
v. Turkey (no. 2)
chanting slogans
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
09/05/2006
20/09/2006
18/12/2006
Articles 6, 8 and 14
4072/07
Bakır
v. Turkey
a) launching a hunger strike
b) writing a petition to the
public prosecutor in support of Öcalan
a) ban from corres-pondence for 2 months
b) ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
a)
18/09/2006
b)
25/09/2006
a)
18/10/2006
b)
13/12/2006
10/01/2007
Articles 3, 6, 7, 10 and 13
5987/07
Tatar
v. Turkey
launching a hunger strike to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from corres-pondence for 2 months
18/09/2006
18/10/2006
25/01/2007
Articles 6 and 10
6426/07
Yamalak
v. Turkey (no. 4)
launching a hunger strike to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from social activities for 3 months
08/09/2006
30/10/2006
18/12/2007
Articles 6,8 and 10
6433/07
Murat Arslan
v. Turkey (no. 2)
launching a hunger strike to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from corres-pondence for 2 months
18/09/2006
18/10/2006
04/01/2007
Articles 6, 13 and 14
6434/07
Murat Arslan
v. Turkey (no. 3)
refusing to meet visitors to protest against the detention conditions of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 1 month
25/09/2006
13/12/2006
10/01/2007
Articles 6, 13 and 14
6946/07
Gedik
v. Turkey (no. 5)
writing a petition to the
public prosecutor in support of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 1 month
Date unspeci-fied number 2006/215
13/12/2006
07/01/2007
Articles 3, 5, 8, 10, 13 and 14
6953/07
Erol Yılmaz
v. Turkey (no. 2)
chanting illegal slogans
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
09/05/2006
20/09/2006
04/01/2007
Article 6
6965/07
Çelik
v. Turkey (no. 1)
a) launching a hunger strike
b) refusing to meet visitors
c) writing a petition to the
public prosecutor in support of Öcalan
d) launching a hunger strike
a) ban from corres-pondence for 2 months
b) ban from receiving visitors for 1 month
c) ban from receiving visitors for 1 month
d) ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
a)
18/09/2006
b)
25/09/2006
c)
05/10/2006
d)
03/04/2007
a)
18/10/2006
b)
13/12/2006
c)
30/12/2006
d)
16/05/2007
For a), b) and c):
19/01/2007
and for d): 05/07/2007
Article 6
7858/07
Yaşa
v. Turkey
a) launching a hunger strike
b) writing letters to the public prosecutor, Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Health
a) ban from certain activities for 1 month
b) ban from prison work shops for 1 month
a)
05/09/2006
b)
19/03/2007
a)
09/10/2006
b)
09/05/2007
a)
07/02/2007
b)
07/07/2007
a)
Articles 3 and 6
b)
Articles 3, 5, 6, 8 and 10
8719/07
Aydınalp
v. Turkey
refusing to meet visitors
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
25/09/2006
13/12/2006
30/01/2007
Articles 3, 6 and 13
9939/07
Demir
v. Turkey (no. 2)
refusing to meet visitors
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
25/09/2006
13/12/2006
30/01/2007
Articles 3, 6 and 13
9966/07
Gedik
v. Turkey (no. 6)
refusing to meet visitors
ban from receiving visitors for 1 month
25/09/2006
13/12/2006
30/01/2007
Articles 8 and 10
11490/07
Danış
v. Turkey (no. 2)
launching a hunger strike
ban from corres-pondence for 2 months
18/09/2006
18/10/2006
08/02/2007
Articles 3, 6, 7, 10, 13 and 14
11491/07
Danış
v. Turkey (no. 3)
refusing to meet visitors
ban from receiving visitors for 1 month
25/09/2006
13/12/2006
08/02/2007
Articles 3, 6, 7, 10, 13 and 14
11888/07
Kaytan
v. Turkey (no. 2)
refusing to meet visitors
ban from receiving visitors for 1 month
25/09/2006
13/12/2006
10/01/2007
Articles 6, 13 and 14
11984/07
Tunç
v. Turkey
launching a hunger strike
ban from corres-pondence for 2 months
18/09/2006
07/11/2006
20/02/2007
Articles 3, 6, 7 and 14
12307/07
Kaytan
v. Turkey (no. 3)
launching a hunger strike
ban from corres-pondence for 2 months
18/09/2006
18/10/2006
10/01/2007
Articles 6, 13 and 14
12308/07
Kaytan
v. Turkey (no. 4)
writing a petition to the public prosecutor in support of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 1 month
05/10/2006
13/12/2006
08/02/2007
Articles 3, 6, 7, 10 and 13
13040/07
Tatar
v. Turkey
refusing to meet visitors
ban from receiving visitors for 1 month
25/09/2006
13/12/2006
15/02/2007
Articles 6, 10 and 13
14392/07
Çelebi
v. Turkey (no. 2)
refusing to meet visitors
ban from receiving visitors for 1 month
25/09/2006
13/12/2006
10/01/2007
Articles 6, 13 and 14
14581/07
Aydınalp
v. Turkey (no. 3)
writing a petition to the public prosecutor in support of Öcalan
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
05/10/2006
13/12/2006
21/02/2007
Articles 3, 6 and 13
16483/07
Bekik
v. Turkey
launching a hunger strike
ban from certain activities for 2 months
18/09/2006
18/10/2006
03/04/2007
Articles 6, 9 and 10
16486/07
Bekik
v. Turkey (no. 2)
writing a petition to the public prosecutor in support of Öcalan
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
05/10/2006
13/12/2006
03/04/2007
Articles 6, 9 and 10
16488/07
Bekik
v. Turkey (no. 4)
refusing to meet visitors
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
25/09/2006
13/12/2006
03/04/2007
Articles 6, 9 and 10
20893/07
Akbaba
v. Turkey (no. 2)
launching a hunger strike
ban from corres-pondence for 2 months
18/09/2006
18/10/2006
08/02/2007
Articles 3, 6, 7, 10, 13 and 14
20895/07
Akbaba
v. Turkey (no. 3)
refusing to meet visitors
ban from receiving visitors for 1 month
25/09/2006
13/12/2006
08/02/2007
Articles 3, 6, 7, 10, 13 and 14
20896/07
Akbaba
v. Turkey (no. 4)
writing a petition to the public prosecutor in support of Öcalan
ban from receiving visitors for 1 month
05/10/2006
13/12/2006
08/02/2007
Articles 3, 6, 7, 10, 13 and 14
21386/07
Kort
v. Turkey
a) refusal to use infirmary
b) chanting slogans
a) ban from sports activities and work shops for 2 months
b) ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
a)
16/03/2007
b)
12/04/2007
a)
09/04/2007
b)
03/05/2007
17/05/2007
Articles 6, 9 and 10
21387/07
Narin
v. Turkey
a) refusal to use infirmary
b) launching a hunger strike
c) chanting slogans
a) ban from sports activities and work shops for 2 months
b) ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
c) ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
a)
16/03/2007
b)
05/04/2007
c)
12/04/2007
a)
09/04/2007
b)
25/04/2007
c)
02/05/2007
17/05/2007
Articles 6, 9 and 10
21388/07
Balin
v. Turkey
a) launching a hunger strike
b)chanting slogans
c) refusal to use infirmary
a) ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
b) ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
c) ban from sports activities and work shops for 2 months
a)
05/04/2007
b)
12/04/2007
c)
16/03/2007
a)
25/04/2007
b)
03/05/2007
c)
09/04/2007
17/05/2007
Articles 6, 9, 10 and 14
22760/07
Demir
v. Turkey
a) refusal to use infirmary
b) launching a hunger strike
c) chanting slogans
a) ban from sports activities and work shops for 2 months
b) ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
c) ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
a)
16/03/2007
b)
05/04/2007
c)
12/04/2007
a)
09/04/2007
b)
25/04/2007
c)
02/05/2007
16/05/2007
Articles 6, 9 and 10
23412/07
Bülbül
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the public prosecutor, the Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Healthy in support of Öcalan
ban from certain activities for 1 month
19/03/2007
09/05/2007
25/06/2007
Articles 3, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 10
23443/07
Benek
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the public prosecutor, the Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Healthy in support of Öcalan
ban from certain activities for 1 month
19/03/2007
09/05/2007
04/06/2007
Articles 3, 6, 7, 8 and 10
23457/07
Şimşek
v. Turkey
refusal to use infirmary
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
12/03/2007
24/04/2007
28/05/2007
Articles 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10
23890/07
Süncak
v. Turkey
writing a letter to the prison administration and in the letter praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
solitary confinement for 11 days
02/04/2007
17/05/2007
24/05/2007
Articles 6 and 10
24095/07
Yeter
v. Turkey
refusal to use infirmary
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
12/03/2007
24/04/2007
29/05/2007
Articles 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 and 14
24099/07
Keskin
v. Turkey
refusal to use infirmary
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
12/03/2007
24/04/2007
29/05/2007
Articles 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 and 14
24114/07
Şahin
v. Turkey
refusal to use infirmary
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
12/03/2007
24/04/2007
29/05/2007
Articles 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 and 14
24119/07
Adam
v. Turkey
writing a letter to the prison administration and in the letter praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
solitary confinement for 11 days
02/04/2007
18/05/2007
30/05/2007
Article 10
24125/07
Yıldırım
v. Turkey
refusal to use infirmary
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
12/03/2007
24/04/2007
29/05/2007
Articles 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 and 14
24455/07
Canpolat
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the public prosecutor, the Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Healthy in support of Öcalan
ban from certain activities for 1 month
19/03/2007
09/05/2007
01/06/2007
Articles 3, 5, 7, 8 and 10
24460/07
Benek and Others
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the public prosecutor, the Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Healthy in support of Öcalan
ban from certain activities for 1 month
19/03/2007
09/05/2007
04/06/2007
Articles 3, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 10
24799/07
Karaağar
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the public prosecutor, the Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Healthy in support of Öcalan
ban from certain activities for 1 month
19/03/2007
09/05/2007
01/06/2007
Articles 3, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 10
24802/07
Yaşa
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the public prosecutor, the Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Healthy in support of Öcalan
ban from certain activities for 1 month
19/03/2007
09/05/2007
01/06/2007
Articles 3, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 10
24900/07
Reşit and Others
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the public prosecutor, the Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Healthy in support of Öcalan
ban from certain activities for 1 month
19/03/2007
09/05/2007
04/06/2007
Articles 3, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 10
25172/07
Reşit
v. Turkey
refusal to use infirmary
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
12/03/2007
24/04/2007
06/06/2007
Articles 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 and 14
26228/07
Gerez
v. Turkey (no. 4)
writing a petition to the public prosecutor, the Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Healthy in support of Öcalan
ban from certain activities for 1 month
19/03/2007
09/05/2007
01/06/2007
Articles 3, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 10
26232/07
Öztop
v. Turkey
refusal to use infirmary
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
12/03/2007
24/04/2007
29/05/2007
Articles 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 and 14
26254/07
Kaya
v. Turkey (no. 5)
writing a petition to the public prosecutor, the Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Healthy in support of Öcalan
ban from certain activities for 1 month
19/03/2007
09/05/2007
01/06/2007
Articles 3, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 10
26256/07
Ekmez
v. Turkey (no. 2)
refusal to use infirmary
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
12/03/2007
24/04/2007
29/05/2007
Articles 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 and 14
27102/07
Öner
v. Turkey (no. 2)
refusal to use infirmary
ban from work shops and sports activities for 2 months
16/03/2007
09/04/2007
15/06/2007
Articles 3, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 and 13
29875/07
Aydemir
v. Turkey (no. 2)
writing a petition to the prison administration and in the letter praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
solitary confinement for 11 days
02/04/2007
17/05/2007
12/06/2007
Articles 6 and 10
30834/07
Kaplan
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the public prosecutor, Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Health in support of Öcalan
ban from certain activities for 1 month
19/03/2007
09/05/2007
07/07/2007
Articles 3, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 10
31262/07
Ölmez
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the public prosecutor, Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Health in support of Öcalan
ban from certain activities for 1 month
19/03/2007
09/05/2007
07/07/2007
Articles 3, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 10
31263/07
Oral
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the public prosecutor, Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Health in support of Öcalan
ban from certain activities for 1 month
19/03/2007
09/05/2007
07/07/2007
Articles 3, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 10
31265/07
Tokmakçı
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the public prosecutor, Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Health in support of Öcalan
ban from certain activities for 1 month
19/03/2007
09/05/2007
07/07/2007
Articles 3, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 10
31266/07
Sain
v. Turkey
refusal to use infirmary
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
Date unspeci-fied
24/04/2007
12/07/2007
Articles 2, 3, 5, 6, 9 and 10
31273/07
Tendik
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the public prosecutor, Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Health in support of Öcalan
ban from certain activities for 1 month
19/03/2007
09/05/2007
07/07/2007
Articles 3, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 10
31277/07
Oktar
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the public prosecutor, Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Health in support of Öcalan
ban from certain activities for 1 month
19/03/2007
09/05/2007
07/07/2007
Articles 3, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 10
31507/07
Yılmaz
v. Turkey (no. 3)
launching a hunger strike
solitary confinement for 11 days
20/03/2007
05/04/2007
19/06/2007
Article 6
35356/07
Salgar
v. Turkey
refusal to use infirmary
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
12/03/2007
24/04/2007
02/08/2007
Articles 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 and 14
36819/07
Tarım
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the public prosecutor, Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Health in support of Öcalan
ban from certain activities for 1 month
19/03/2007
09/05/2007
17/08/2007
Articles 3, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 10
41332/07
Emek
v. Turkey (no. 2)
writing a petition to the public prosecutor, Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Health in support of Öcalan
ban from certain activities for 1 month
19/03/2007
09/05/2007
07/07/2007
Articles 3, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 10
43401/07
Alkış
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the prison administration and praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
solitary confinement for 11 days
12/04/2007
22/05/2007
11/09/2007
Article 10
44421/07
Günay
v. Turkey (no. 3)
a) banging on the doors of the cells
b) launching a hunger strike
c) launching a hunger strike
a) ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
b) ban from sports activities and work shops for 3 months
c) ban from sports activities and work shops for 3 months
a)
13/03/2007
b)
20/03/2007
c)
18/05/2007
a)
09/05/2007
b)
28/05/2007
c)
23/07/2007
14/08/2007
Articles 3, 6 and 8
44426/07
Kaya
v. Turkey
writing petitions to several Ministries and refusing to use infirmary
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
19/03/2007
07/05/2007
25/09/2007
Articles 9 and 10
44656/07
Kuran v. Turkey (no.2)
writing a petition to the Minister of Justice and in the letters praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
ban from corres-pondence for 80 days
02/04/2007
08/05/2007
01/10/2007
Articles 6 and 10
45964/07
Bal
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the Prime Minister’s office and the Minister of Justice and in the letters praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
solitary confinement for 12 days
15/03/2007
06/04/2007
04/10/2007
Articles 5 and 10
51681/07
İnan and Others
v. Turkey
a) chanting slogans and banging on the doors of the cells
b)writing a letter to the public prosecutor and the Ministry of Justice
c) chanting slogans and resisting prison guards
d) chanting slogans
a) ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
b) ban from certain activities for 45 days
c) ban from receiving visitors for 1 month
d) ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
a)
25/05/2007
b)
03/09/2007
c)
30/10/2007
d)
30/10/2007
a)
26/07/2007
b)
07/11/2007
c)
24/12/2007
d)
30/01/2008
09/11/2007
Articles 6, 8 and 13
55546/07
Sürensoy and Others
v. Turkey
launching a hunger strike
ban from certain activities for 3 months
19/03/2007
28/05/2007
27/11/2007
Articles 6 and 13
56450/07
Yamalak and Others
v. Turkey
banging on the doors of the cells and chanting slogans
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
13/03/2007
09/05/2007
09/11/2007
Articles 6, 8, 9, 10 and 13
127/08
Yamalak and Others
v. Turkey
launching a hunger strike
ban from sports activities and work shops for 3 months
19/03/2007
28/05/2007
27/11/2007
Articles 6 and 10
9131/08
Özen
v. Turkey
praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
solitary confinement for 11 days
02/04/2007
30/05/2007
29/11/2007
Articles 6, 9 and 10
13727/08
Çetiner
v. Turkey
writing a letter to the Ministry of Justice in support of Öcalan
ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
12/12/2007
15/01/2008
07/02/2008
Articles 6, 7 and 8
13839/08
Tuncer
v. Turkey
chanting slogans
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
30/10/2007
31/01/2007
12/03/2008
Articles 3, 6 and 13
15772/08
Kuran
v. Turkey
praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
solitary confinement for 11 days
03/09/2007
23/10/2007
05/02/2008
Articles 10and 13
15996/08
Bal
v. Turkey
praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
solitary confinement for 11 days
03/09/2007
23/10/2007
20/03/2008
Articles 5 and 10
16240/08
Özbil
v. Turkey (no. 4)
resisting prison guards and chanting slogans
ban from receiving visitors for 2 months
30/10/2007
25/01/2008
15/02/2008
Articles 6, 8 and 13
17510/08
Özbil
v. Turkey (no. 5)
launching a hunger strike
ban from certain activities for 2 months
28/12/2007
29/02/2008
19/03/2008
Articles 6, 8 and 13
19623/08
Yiğit
v. Turkey (no. 4)
launching a hunger strike
ban from corres-pondence for 2 months
18/01/2008
08/02/2008
7/03/2008
Article 10
24444/08
Çelikkeser
v. Turkey
praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
solitary confinement for 11 days
18/12/2007
18/01/2008
14/05/2008
Articles 6, 7, 10 and 13
24449/08
Özalp
v. Turkey
praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
solitary confinement for 11 days
17/12/2007
22/01/2008
15/05/2008
Articles 6, 7, 10 and 13
24459/08
Musa
v. Turkey
launching a hunger strike and praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
solitary confinement for 11 days
07/02/2008
11/03/2008
16/05/2008
Articles 6, 7, 10 and 13
24476/08
Yıldırım
v. Turkey
praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
solitary confinement for 11 days
18/12/2008
18/01/2008
15/05/2008
Articles 6, 7, 10 and 13
26971/08
Tanış and Karaman
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the Ministry of Justice against the prison administration
ban from certain activities for 3 months
05/10/2007
02/01/2008
15/05/2008
Articles 6, 7 and 13
26986/08
Dolaz and Others
v. Turkey
launching a hunger strike
ban from certain activities for 3 months
29/08/2008
08/11/2008
06/05/2008
Articles 6 and 13
28070/08
Öztürk
v. Turkey
launching a hunger strike and praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
solitary confinement for 11 days
05/02/2008
17/03/2008
03/06/2008
Articles 6, 7, 9 and 10
28080/08
Özalp
v. Turkey
launching a hunger strike
deprivation of any paid work during 1 month
01/02/2008
03/04/2008
03/06/2008
Articles 6, 8, 9, 10 and 13
29723/08
Türkman
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the Ministry of Justice in support of Öcalan
Ban from corres-pondence for 1 month
26/12/2007
16/04/2008
04/06/2008
Articles 6, 8 and 10
31140/08
Topçu
v. Turkey (no. 3)
launching a hunger strike and praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
solitary confinement for 11 days
29/01/2008
05/05/2008
16/05/2008
Articles 6, 7, 9, 10 and 13
31625/08
Yaşar
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the Ministry of Justice against the prison administration
ban from certain activities for 3 months
05/10/2007
02/01/2008
16/06/2008
Articles 6, 7 and 13
31984/08
Tuncer
v. Turkey
resisting prison guards and chanting slogans
ban from receiving visitors for 1 month
30/10/2007
31/01/2007
22/05/2008
Articles 3, 6 and 8
32034/08
Uçucu
v. Turkey
resisting prison guards and chanting slogans
ban from receiving visitors for 1 month and solitary confinement for 15 days
03/01/2008
13/03/2008
17/06/2008
Articles 3, 6 and 13
32614/08
Eroğlu
v. Turkey
chanting slogans and banging on the doors
ban from receiving visits for 1 month
16/10/2007
26/12/2007
26/06/2008
Articles 3, 6, 10, 13, 14, 17 and 18
32616/08
Şen
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the Ministry of Justice against the prison administration
ban from certain activities for 3 months
05/10/2007
02/01/2008
26/06/2006
Articles 3, 6 and 13
33620/08
Ergezen
v. Turkey
writing a petition to the Ministry of Justice against the prison administration
ban from certain activities for 3 months
5/10/2007
2/01/2008
30/06/2008
Articles 6, 8, 9, 10, 13, 17, 18
36224/08
Baran
v. Turkey (no. 2)
pressing emergency buttons in the cell and refusing to participate in social activities, work shops in prison
ban from corres-pondence for 15 days
29/12/2004
26/01/2005
17/02/2005
Articles 6 and 8
41083/08
Akay
v. Turkey (no. 2)
launching a hunger strike
ban from receiving visitors for 15 days
31/05/2005
04/07/2005
17/10/2005
Article 6
41085/08
Akay
v. Turkey (no. 3)
praising the imprisoned leader of the PKK, by using the honorific “sayın”, meaning esteemed
ban from using common areas for 45 days
03/05/2006
08/06/2006
27/06/2006
Articles 6 and 10
B. Relevant domestic law and practice
A description of the relevant domestic law may be found in Gülmez v. Turkey, no. 16330/02, §§ 13-15, 20 May 2008 and Aydemir and others (dec.), nos. 9097/05, 9491/05, 9498/05, 9500/05, 9505/05 and 9509/05, 9 November 2010.
THE LAW
Given the similarity of the applications, as regards both fact and law, the Court deems it appropriate to join them.
The applicants mainly argued that they did not have a fair hearing during the disciplinary proceedings in question as the domestic courts had delivered their decisions on the basis of the case files and that they had been deprived of their right to defend themselves in person or through the assistance of a lawyer. In this respect, most of the applicants relied on Article 6 of the Convention. The remaining applicants, based on the same facts and raising the same complaint, merely cited Articles 2, 3, 5, 7, 9, 13, 14, 17, 18, and Article 2 of Protocol No. 1. The Court notes that although the applicants referred to different Articles of the Convention, they all complained about the unfairness of the disciplinary proceedings in dispute. It will thus examine these complaints under Article 6 of the Convention.
Furthermore, some of the applicants (as indicated in the table above), alleged a violation of Article 8 in respect of the ban on their right to correspondence and/or visiting rights, or a violation of Article 10, stating that the disciplinary sanctions imposed on them had violated their right to freedom of expression.
The Court notes that by Law no. 6008 of 22 July 2010, Section 6 of the Law on Enforcement Judges was amended so as to allow prisoners charged with disciplinary offences to defend themselves in person or through legal assistance. It further observes that the new law also provides a remedy for all those prisoners who had previously been charged with disciplinary offences to file a fresh objection with the Enforcement Judge concerning their previous sentences within six months following the adoption of this law. Such requests would be examined by the Enforcement Judge in the light of the new procedure.
The Court has already examined that remedy and found it effective in respect of complaints for applications concerning prison disciplinary sanctions. In particular, it considered that the new remedy was accessible and provided reasonable prospects of success (see, Aydemir and others, cited above). In assessing the effectiveness of the new remedy, the Court had regard to sample decisions submitted by the Government, according to which upon fresh objections, the Enforcement Judges had re-evaluated the evidence in the case file and annulled the disciplinary sanctions in dispute, clearing the respective prisoners of all consequences of the offence.
Considering that there are no exceptional circumstances capable of exempting the present applicants from the obligation to exhaust domestic remedies, the Court concludes that they should avail themselves of the new remedy offered by Law No. 6008 of 22 July 2010.
Therefore, the applications must be rejected under Article 35 §§ 1 and 4 of the Convention for non-exhaustion of domestic remedies.
For these reasons, the Court unanimously
Decides to join the applications;
Declares the applications inadmissible.
Stanley NaismithFrançoise Tulkens
RegistrarPresident
APPENDIX
Application no.
Name of Applicant
Date of birth
8498/05
Abdulkahar Aksoy
1963
8534/05
Soydan Akay
1974
9021/05
Celaleddin Cenap Araci
1964
9096/05
Nevzat Bahadır
1978
13442/05
Bayram Ekelik
1975
14030/05
Seyithan Kutlu
1960
24822/05
Ahmet Gerez
1965
40676/05
Ahmet Çakal
1953
43339/05
İzzettin Sayhan
1971
43655/05
Hatip Şek
1955
43681/05
Ahmet Yavuz
1966
43732/05
a) Ramazan Kıran
b) Ecevit Özgül
c) Musa Kaya
1966
1980
1973
43736/05
Ömer Okul
1971
43737/05
Abdulvahap Karatay
1976
45875/05
Turgut Koyuncu
1974
45876/05
Mehmet Nesih Sarıkaya
1971
1797/06
Nihat Yağız
1972
8763/06
Ebubekir Yulu
1966
8766/06
Cemal Mustafa
1961
8767/06
Yusuf Karataş
1971
8768/06
Erhan Kaya
1970
8769/06
Izzet Muhammet
(Syrian national)
1969
9047/06
Ramazan Nazlıer
1973
9123/06
Ali Haydar Çırak
1958
9509/06
Muzaffer Yılmaz
1972
9558/06
a) Murat Arslan
b) Esat Kaya
c) Ali İhsan Dost
1973
1969
1974
9575/06
a) Abdulhekim Eşiyok
b) Ahmet Şervan
1979
1975
9953/06
Cahit İlboğa
1973
9958/06
Fikret Güzelaydın
1963
10685/06
Serhat Öztürk
1969
10686/06
Cengiz Eker
1964
15919/06
Nusret Yıldız
1974
15921/06
Aliekber Oruç
1969
15922/06
Mehmet Zengeralp
1967
16249/06
Metin Yamalak
1980
17798/06
Nusret Kaya
1972
20990/06
a) Mehmet Çelik
b) Şabettin Yeşilmen
c) Bülent Sarıgül
1967
1971
1975
24619/06
Mehmet Yavuz
1967
27796/06
Hasan Alkış
1970
27868/06
Mehmet Zeki Deniz
1955
28219/06
Kenan Karaaslan
1966
29341/06
Musa Şanak
1964
36444/06
Mehmet Şirin Taşdemir
1969
38377/06
Abdullah Günay
1979
40349/06
Ali Ekber Coşkun
1974
43491/06
Veli Özdemir
1978
47401/06
Soncan Gedik
1967
47453/06
Turan Demir
1964
561/07
Abdulhamit Tekdemir
1980
562/07
Mustafa Okçul
1974
565/07
Cebrail Vural
1975
608/07
Mehmet Emin Edemen
1965
627/07
Kadir Emek
1971
1316/07
Şemsettin Özer
1968
1318/07
Ahmet Tuneli
1966
1324/07
Selim Sır
1972
1344/07
Canar Yurtsever
1982
2752/07
Erol Yılmaz
1977
3492/07
Enver Özer
1966
3937/07
Metin Yamalak
1980
4072/07
Vedat Bakır
1971
5987/07
Süleyman Tatar
1972
6426/07
Metin Yamalak
1980
6433/07
Murat Arslan
1976
6434/07
Murat Arslan
1976
6946/07
Soncan Gedik
1967
6953/07
Erol Yılmaz
1977
6965/07
Ali Murat Çelik
1968
7858/07
Fethi Yaşa
1966
8719/07
Engin Aydınalp
1971
9939/07
Turan Demir
1964
9966/07
Soncan Gedik
1967
11490/07
Mehmet Veysi Danış
1976
11491/07
Mehmet Veysi Danış
1976
11888/07
Hayati Kaytan
1968
11984/07
Osman Tunç
1972
12307/07
Hayati Kaytan
1968
12308/07
Hayati Kaytan
1968
13040/07
Süleyman Tatar
1970
14392/07
Mehmet Nur Çelebi
1974
14581/07
Engin Aydınalp
1971
16483/07
Recep Bekik
1969
16486/07
Recep Bekik
1969
16488/07
Recep Bekik
1969
20893/07
Lokman Akbaba
1974
20895/07
Lokman Akbaba
1974
20896/07
Lokman Akbaba
1974
21386/07
Seyithan Kort
1973
21387/07
Abdulvahap Narin
1971
21388/07
Ali Balin
1980
22760/07
Resul Demir
1974
23412/07
Sinan Bülbül
1973
23443/07
Ali Benek
1965
23457/07
Salih Şimşek
1978
23890/07
Yılmaz Süncak
1972
24095/07
Hüseyin Yeter
1981
24099/07
Yalçın Keskin
1970
24114/07
Mehmet Şahin
1970
24119/07
Mehmet Salih Adam
1967
24125/07
Şafi Yıldırım
1979
24455/07
Hacı Canpolat
1979
24460/07
a) Kazım Benek
b) Hamdin Işık
c) Ahmet Tuneli
d) Abdulkadir Tatlı
1973
1976
1966
1975
24799/07
Nizamettin Karaağar
1971
24802/07
Seyfettin Yaşa
1955
24900/07
a) Hasan Ahmet Reşit
b) Abdullah Babat
c) Mahmut Aslan
1978
1974
1976
25172/07
Muhammet Emir (Ibrahim) Reşit
(Syrian national)
1963
26228/07
Ahmet Gerez
1965
26232/07
Resul Öztop
1965
26254/07
Nusret Kaya
1972
26256/07
Nihat Ekmez
1968
27102/07
Mehmet Şerif Öner
1975
29875/07
Gültekin Aydemir
1973
30834/07
Kadir Kaplan
1974
31262/07
Eyüp Ölmez
1973
31263/07
Ahmet Oral
1968
31265/07
İlhan Tokmakçı
1972
31266/07
İzzettin Sain
1963
31273/07
Halit Tendik
1972
31277/07
Görgin Oktar
1973
31507/07
Cemal Yılmaz
1965
35356/07
İsmail Salgar
1964
36819/07
Nesip Tarım
1977
41332/07
Kadir Emek
1971
43401/07
Hasan Alkış
1970
44421/07
Abdullah Günay
1979
44426/07
Musa Kaya
1973
44656/07
Nurullah Kuran (no. 2)
1968
45964/07
Naif Bal
1972
51681/07
a) Barış İnan
b) Hasan Gülbahar
c) İbrahim Şahin
1973
1961
1975
55546/07
a) Hüseyin Sürensoy
b) Aydın Şaka
c) İbrahim
Ayan
1969
1980
1983
56450/07
a) Metin Yamalak
b) Erol Yılmaz
c) Senar Dolaz
d) Nesim Özkan
e) Aydın Şaka
f) Hüseyin Sürensoy
1980
1977
1976
1976
1980
1969
127/08
a) Metin Yamalak
b) Canar Yurtsever
c) Erol Yılmaz
1980
1982
1977
9131/08
Mehmet Nuri Özen
1976
13727/08
Serhat Çetiner
1972
13839/08
Tamer Tuncer
1971
15772/08
Nasrullah Kuran
1968
15996/08
Naif Bal
1972
16240/08
Sami Özbil
1977
17510/08
Sami Özbil
1977
19623/08
Kemal Yiğit
1982
24444/08
Zafer Çelikkeser
1979
24449/08
Nedim Özalp
1963
24459/08
Şeyhmus Musa
(Syrian national)
1974
24476/08
Abdurrahman Yıldırım
1974
26971/08
a) Mehmet Nuri Tanış
b) Ergün Karaman
1976
1975
26986/08
a) Senar Dolaz
b) Fesih Nardan
c) Nesim Özkan
d) Nezir Adıyaman
e) Abdullah Günay
f) Cengiz Atsız
g) Aydın Şaka
h) Adem Yüksekdağ
i) Hüseyin Sürensoy
j) Habip Çiftçi
k) Ergin Atabey
l) Metin Yamalak
m) Canar Yurtsever
n) Erol Yılmaz
o) Mehmet Ali Kaya
p) Suat Çalıskan
1976
1964
1973
1978
1979
1982
1980
1986
1969
1973
1973
1980
1982
1977
1976
1981
28070/08
Yüksel Öztürk
1972
28080/08
Resul Özalp
1978
29723/08
Sinan Türkman
1966
31140/08
Çeçan Topçu
1962
31625/08
Halis Yaşar
1976
31984/08
Mete Tuncer
1969
32034/08
Remzi Uçucu
1971
32614/08
Tayyar Eroğlu
1982
32616/08
Abdurrahim Şen
1971
33620/08
a) Mehmet Ergezen
b) Sıraç Çelik
c) İsmail Cengiz Oğurtan
d) Dalyan Alsaç
e) İshak Aybergüler
f) Cahit Yaşar
g) Ramazan Kaya
h) Mehmet Aladağ
i) İhsan Akbıyık
j) Abdullah Çolak
k) Veysi Dereli
l) Yunus Akbal
m) Ahmet Koç
n) Kenan Avcı
o) Faruk Yıldız
p) Oktay Kalaç
q) Mehmet Nart
r) Abdülhakim Kulik
s) İbrahim Kanat
t) Sami Dündar
u) Zafer Balcı
v) Bilal Önen
w) Cüneyt Yeşilyurt
1983
1981
1974
1984
1984
1979
1980
1974
1984
1969
1986
1982
1981
1980
1973
1974
1977
1988
1966
1980
1977
1981
1982
36224/08
İhsan Baran
1968
41083/08
Barış Akay
1977
41085/08
Barış Akay
1977
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy