Published on 18 December 2023
SECOND SECTION
Application no. 31954/21
Nuri BERBER against Türkiye
and 199 other applications
(see list appended)
communicated on 12 December 2023
STATEMENT OF FACTS
1. A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix.The circumstances of the case
2. The applications mainly concern the applicants’ conviction for membership of an armed terrorist organisation described by the Turkish authorities as the “Fetullahist Terror Organisation/Parallel State Structure” (Fetullahçı Terör Örgütü / Paralel Devlet Yapılanması, hereinafter referred to as “the FETÖ/PDY”), considered by the authorities to be behind the coup attempt that took place in Türkiye on 15 July 2016.
3. According to the information submitted by the applicants, the convictions were based, inter alia, on the applicants’ alleged use of the encrypted messaging application “ByLock”, which the domestic courts held was used exclusively by FETÖ/PDY members and which therefore constituted sufficient evidence to prove on its own that a person had been part of the FETÖ/PDY’s hierarchical structure.
4. The broader domestic background and context to the present applications was set out by the Grand Chamber in the case of Yüksel Yalçınkaya v. Türkiye ([GC], no. 15669/20, §§ 10-22 and 108-40, 26 September 2023).Relevant domestic law and practice
5. A description of the relevant domestic law and practice can be found in Yüksel Yalçınkaya (cited above, §§ 141-193).
COMPLAINTS
6. The applicants mainly complained that their trial and conviction for membership of the FETÖ/PDY had violated the principle of no punishment without law under Article 7 of the Convention and/or the right to a fair trial under Article 6 § 1.
QUESTIONS TO THE PARTIES
Since the issues raised by the present applications are already the subject of well-established case-law of the Court (see Yüksel Yalçınkaya v. Türkiye [GC], no. 15669/20, §§ 237-356, 26 September 2023), the Court does not put any questions to the parties or require any observations on these applications. However, if they so wish, the Government may submit observations on the complaints set out in the appended table, to the extent that they refer essentially to the factual aspects of the applications and not to preliminary objections or legal issues already decided by the Court in Yüksel Yalçınkaya (cited above) or other similar cases against Türkiye.
APPENDIX
List of applications raising complaints under Article 7 (no punishment without law) and/or Article 6 § 1 of the Convention (right to a fair trial)
(conviction for membership of the FETÖ/PDY based, inter alia, on the applicants’ alleged use of the encrypted messaging application “ByLock”)
No.
Application no.
Case name
Lodged on
Applicant
Year of Birth
Place of Residence
Nationality
Represented by
31954/21
Berber v. Türkiye
07/06/2021
Nuri BERBER
1984
Uşak
Turkish
Müleyke ÇEVİK
53509/19
Turan v. Türkiye
27/09/2019
Mustafa TURAN
1984
Elazığ
Turkish
Adnan DEMİR
60688/19
Kadıoğlu v. Türkiye
07/11/2019
İsmail KADIOĞLU
1979
Giresun
Turkish
Elif CİVELEKOĞLU
911/20
Karadağ v. Türkiye
09/12/2019
Ahmet KARADAĞ
1975
Edirne
Turkish
Ayşegül BEDELCİ KARADAĞ
1595/20
Demirhan v. Türkiye
21/12/2019
Metin DEMİRHAN
1976
Kütahya
Turkish
Münise DEMİRHAN
8383/20
Karabaş v. Türkiye
05/02/2020
Muhittin KARABAŞ
1982
Adıyaman
Turkish
Murat CENGİZ
14901/20
Kayasaroğlu v. Türkiye
17/03/2020
Ümit KAYASAROĞLU
1987
Ankara
Turkish
Neda BUYRUKÇU
15189/20
Güvenç v. Türkiye
05/03/2020
Onur GÜVENÇ
1995
Tokat
Turkish
Nuriye Beyza BİLGEN GÜÇ
19842/20
Aldı v. Türkiye
11/05/2020
Bahtiyar ALDI
1983
Aydın
Turkish
Hakkı ÇELİK
21508/20
Bulmuş v. Türkiye
18/03/2020
Hacı Mehmet BULMUŞ
1975
Kayseri
Turkish
Ömer DELİGEZER
21832/20
Özen v. Türkiye
27/05/2020
İbrahim ÖZEN
1983
Ağrı
Turkish
Timur DEMİR
22218/20
Tetik v. Türkiye
12/05/2020
Şinasi Sedat TETİK
1976
Ankara
Turkish
Burak ÇOLAK
23433/20
Büyükçakır v. Türkiye
20/05/2020
Mustafa BÜYÜKÇAKIR
1962
Balıkesir
Turkish
Fatih BÜYÜKÇAKIR
23934/20
Berk v. Türkiye
03/06/2020
Hacı Hakan BERK
1968
Malatya
Turkish
Tuna BERK
25553/20
Taş v. Türkiye
05/06/2020
Seyfi Ali TAŞ
1978
Niğde
Turkish
Yasin ÇALIM
25577/20
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
17/06/2020
Sait YILMAZ
1981
Kocaeli
Turkish
Cahit ÇİFTÇİ
28067/20
Demirci v. Türkiye
17/06/2020
İbrahim DEMİRCİ
1980
Kırşehir
Turkish
Rukiye COŞGUN
30528/20
Benli v. Türkiye
04/06/2020
Esat Faruk BENLİ
1970
Konya
Turkish
Hülya BENLİ
32506/20
Topaloğlu v. Türkiye
29/07/2020
Mahmut TOPALOĞLU
1979
Kocaeli
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
32701/20
Yulcu v. Türkiye
21/07/2020
Cesim YULCU
1991
Patnos
Turkish
M. Sani BİNGÖLBALLI
34065/20
Durak v. Türkiye
05/08/2020
Turan DURAK
1986
Kahramamaraş
Turkish
Murat CENGİZ
35839/20
Çin v. Türkiye
27/07/2020
Murat ÇİN
1979
Burdur
Turkish
Ayşe ÇİN
36249/20
Toprak v. Türkiye
06/08/2020
Recep TOPRAK
1975
Muğla
Turkish
Sinan DAĞ
38114/20
Akkavak v. Türkiye
19/08/2020
Hasan Hüseyin AKKAVAK
1986
Erzincan
Turkish
Sezai DEMİRBİLEK
41163/20
Kalkan v. Türkiye
09/09/2020
İsmail KALKAN
1958
Kütahya
Turkish
Rıdvan ÇAKIR
41238/20
Mercan v. Türkiye
28/07/2020
Bayram Ali MERCAN
1988
Adana
Turkish
Selçuk ÇIĞŞAR
41355/20
Karabacak v. Türkiye
26/08/2020
Ali Osman KARABACAK
1981
Balıkesir
Turkish
Nuriye Beyza BİLGEN GÜÇ
42342/20
Çetinbaş v. Türkiye
18/09/2020
Ömer ÇETİNBAŞ
1992
Denizli
Turkish
Hanifi BAYRI
42766/20
Cinbaş v. Türkiye
16/09/2020
Emel CİNBAŞ
1965
Isparta
Turkish
Hümeyra Refia CİNBAŞ
43101/20
Gökce v. Türkiye
09/09/2020
Hasan GÖKCE
1973
İzmir
Turkish
Halil ÇETİN
43140/20
Demir v. Türkiye
12/08/2020
Enes DEMİR
1992
İzmir
Turkish
Metin DEMİR
43516/20
Bayram v. Türkiye
08/09/2020
Hamza BAYRAM
1985
Şanlıurfa
Turkish
Aysel BAYRAM
47233/20
Erdem v. Türkiye
15/10/2020
Bayram ERDEM
1971
Malatya
Turkish
Nalan ERDEM
49577/20
Kesgin v. Türkiye
19/10/2020
İzzet KESGİN
1968
Manisa
Turkish
Adem BEDİR
49581/20
Medeni v. Türkiye
19/10/2020
Erdoğan MEDENİ
1986
Çanakkale
Turkish
Adnan ERDOĞAN
51525/20
Terkeşli v. Türkiye
04/11/2020
Ramazan TERKEŞLİ
1973
Diyarbakır
Turkish
Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAŞİN
51919/20
İnci v. Türkiye
12/11/2020
Muhammed Fethullah İNCİ
1997
Balıkesir
Turkish
Nuriye Beyza BİLGEN GÜÇ
52188/20
Akdoğan v. Türkiye
13/11/2020
Mehmet Emin AKDOĞAN
1981
Ağrı
Turkish
Arzu BEYAZIT
54375/20
Minareci v. Türkiye
23/11/2020
Yusuf MİNARECİ
1967
Uşak
Turkish
Ahmet Emre CEYLAN
54385/20
Yavuz v. Türkiye
20/11/2020
Safa YAVUZ
1973
Diyarbakır
Turkish
Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAŞİN
55132/20
Söylemez v. Türkiye
20/11/2020
Ahmet SÖYLEMEZ
1972
Karaman
Turkish
Cihat ÇITIR
1126/21
Dişçi v. Türkiye
10/12/2020
İbrahim DİŞÇİ
1960
Uşak
Turkish
Yasemin Müşerref BOZKURT
2979/21
Cengiz v. Türkiye
06/01/2021
Ferhat CENGİZ
1977
Sinop
Turkish
Tuğba CENGİZ
3274/21
Evirgen v. Türkiye
06/01/2021
Mehmet Çetin EVİRGEN
1986
Kütahya
Turkish
Rıdvan ÇAKIR
3727/21
Demirci v. Türkiye
29/12/2020
Eyüp DEMİRCİ
1977
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Ahmet ÇOBANOĞLU
4660/21
Arslan v. Türkiye
15/01/2021
Mehmet ARSLAN
1971
Malatya
Turkish
İzettin DEMİR
4675/21
Kara v. Türkiye
15/01/2021
Ali KARA
1988
Elazığ
Turkish
İzettin DEMİR
5181/21
Kalaycı v. Türkiye
19/01/2021
Mustafa KALAYCI
1983
Kütahya
Turkish
Rıdvan ÇAKIR
5204/21
Yıldız v. Türkiye
13/01/2021
Volkan YILDIZ
1991
Turkish
Doğan BEKİROĞLU
6663/21
Çeçen v. Türkiye
07/01/2021
Hamdi ÇEÇEN
1970
Niğde
Turkish
Adem ÇEÇEN
6681/21
Örküt v. Türkiye
06/01/2021
Hüseyin ÖRKÜT
1973
Manisa
Turkish
Rukiye COŞGUN
6978/21
Çınar v. Türkiye
18/01/2021
Gökhan ÇINAR
1990
Aydın
Turkish
Ali ÇINAR
7782/21
Kesmenoğlu v. Türkiye
22/01/2021
Mustafa KESMENOĞLU
1987
Kilis
Turkish
Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAŞİN
8682/21
Biçer v. Türkiye
12/01/2021
Muammer BİÇER
1975
İzmir
Turkish
Ciğdem BİÇER
8735/21
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
14/01/2021
Ali Rıza YILMAZ
1973
Kocaeli
Turkish
Cahit ÇİFTÇİ
8750/21
Öztürk v. Türkiye
02/02/2021
Fatih ÖZTÜRK
1983
Yozgat
Turkish
Fatih Nadi DOĞAN
9770/21
Bıçakcıgil v. Türkiye
10/02/2021
Sümeyye Saadet BIÇAKCIGİL
1994
Sivas
Turkish
Mualla ERCAN
10453/21
Fidan v. Türkiye
05/02/2021
Şaban FİDAN
1993
Van
Turkish
Ramazan DUMAN
11080/21
Arslan v. Türkiye
19/02/2021
Bekir ARSLAN
1987
Osmaniye
Turkish
Hanifi BAYRI
11615/21
Şanlı v. Türkiye
10/02/2021
Hüsnü ŞANLI
1983
Istanbul
Turkish
Sadrettin DEMİREL
12088/21
Duysak v. Türkiye
21/12/2020
Raşit DUYSAK
1962
Manisa
Turkish
Hatice DUYSAK
12121/21
Şerifoğlu v. Türkiye
17/02/2021
Yusuf ŞERİFOĞLU
1977
Kayseri
Turkish
Gökmen DÖNER
13753/21
Tekin v. Türkiye
26/02/2021
Fatih TEKİN
1987
Van
Turkish
İdris ERÇETİN
14028/21
Yalçınkaya v. Türkiye
26/02/2021
Çelebi Batuhan YALÇINKAYA
1985
Giresun
Turkish
Elif CİVELEKOĞLU
14506/21
Eraslan v. Türkiye
03/03/2021
Zülfü ERASLAN
1985
Kütahya
Turkish
Hesna ERASLAN
14970/21
Dağhan v. Türkiye
05/01/2021
Rıza DAĞHAN
1989
Van
Turkish
İdris ERÇETİN
16355/21
Aydın v. Türkiye
04/03/2021
Mustafa AYDIN
1971
İzmir
Turkish
Adnan ERDOĞAN
16380/21
Aksu v. Türkiye
02/03/2021
İbrahim AKSU
1979
Samsun
Turkish
Ahmet ÇAVUŞ
16416/21
Uğurlu v. Türkiye
05/03/2021
Burak UĞURLU
1985
Elazığ
Turkish
Hacer Perihan DEMİREL
16624/21
Timur v. Türkiye
24/03/2021
Orhan TİMUR
1984
Adana
Turkish
İzzettin ÇİÇEK
17609/21
Akkaş v. Türkiye
26/03/2021
Musa Fatih AKKAŞ
1989
Aksaray
Turkish
Fatih DÖNMEZ
18258/21
Kuluç v. Türkiye
18/03/2021
Yılmaz KULUÇ
1979
Diyarbakır
Turkish
Sinan DAĞ
18617/21
Çiftçi v. Türkiye
22/03/2021
Mesut ÇİFTÇİ
1987
Aksaray
Turkish
Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAŞİN
18967/21
Çelik v. Türkiye
07/04/2021
Ekrem ÇELİK
1991
Şırnak
Turkish
Gizay DULKADİR
19173/21
Demir v. Türkiye
01/04/2021
Muhammet DEMİR
1985
Konya
Turkish
Mustafa DEMİRCAN
19326/21
Şireli v. Türkiye
02/04/2021
Mehmet Cihad ŞİRELİ
1974
Adana
Turkish
Büşra DİNÇER
20847/21
Ekici v. Türkiye
09/04/2021
Nihat EKİCİ
1973
Diyarbakır
Turkish
Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAŞİN
20928/21
Ateş v. Türkiye
13/04/2021
Mehmet Sait ATEŞ
1982
Diyarbakır
Turkish
Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAŞİN
21686/21
Akbulut v. Türkiye
12/04/2021
Yunus Emre AKBULUT
1993
Samsun
Turkish
Nur Efşan ÇİL
21973/21
Aygören v. Türkiye
15/04/2021
Burak Şahin AYGÖREN
1985
Istanbul
Turkish
Abdullah DOĞAN
22387/21
Karabacak v. Türkiye
20/04/2021
Nabi KARABACAK
1963
Diyarbakır
Turkish
Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAŞİN
22430/21
Çalbıyık v. Türkiye
26/04/2021
Halil İbrahim ÇALBIYIK
1988
Çorum
Turkish
Rümeysa DENİZ
22520/21
Sarı v. Türkiye
22/04/2021
Leyla SARI
1983
Erzurum
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
22649/21
Sarı v. Türkiye
22/04/2021
Siracettin SARI
1982
Elazığ
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
23862/21
Çevik v. Türkiye
16/04/2021
Muhammed Said ÇEVİK
1993
Diyarbakır
Turkish
Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAŞİN
24500/21
Çevik v. Türkiye
05/05/2021
Ayten ÇEVİK
1978
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
24537/21
Arpacı v. Türkiye
21/04/2021
Necmi ARPACI
1974
Ordu
Turkish
Şükran ER ŞAHİN
24622/21
Baloğlu v. Türkiye
07/05/2021
Remziye BALOĞLU
1978
İzmit
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
25488/21
Benli v. Türkiye
29/04/2021
Hasan BENLİ
1973
Diyarbakır
Turkish
Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAŞİN
25774/21
Altıkat v. Türkiye
07/05/2021
Ebubekir ALTIKAT
Ankara
Turkish
Hanifi BAYRI
26049/21
Kocaağa v. Türkiye
17/05/2021
Hüseyin KOCAAĞA
1980
Antalya
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
28215/21
Özdemir v. Türkiye
27/05/2021
Mahmut ÖZDEMİR
1986
Ankara
Turkish
Burhan DEMİRCİ
29632/21
Bilal v. Türkiye
21/05/2021
İsmail BİLAL
1983
Manisa
Turkish
Öznur BİLAL
29991/21
Şahin v. Türkiye
10/06/2021
Ferdi ŞAHİN
1988
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
30097/21
Ceylan v. Türkiye
07/06/2021
Mehmet CEYLAN
1975
Şanlıurfa
Turkish
Gülten CEYLAN
30645/21
Miran v. Türkiye
25/05/2021
Celal MİRAN
1986
Diyarbakır
Turkish
Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAŞİN
30656/21
Kırıcı v. Türkiye
03/06/2021
Kevser KIRICI
1991
Kilis
Turkish
Harun ÇOKGÜNGÖR
31597/21
Genç v. Türkiye
14/06/2021
Serkan GENÇ
1977
Manisa
Turkish
Oğuzhan DAŞDEMİR
31738/21
Emer v. Türkiye
14/06/2021
Sezer EMER
1986
Istanbul
Turkish
Gökçen DEMİRHAN ALPAĞUT
33536/21
Bilgiç v. Türkiye
15/06/2021
Hüseyin BİLGİÇ
1974
Isparta
Turkish
Serpil BİLGİÇ
34125/21
Ergüneş v. Türkiye
25/05/2021
Rüştü Harun ERGÜNEŞ
1977
İzmir
Turkish
Zeynep CANBELDEK YURTÇİÇEK
36716/21
Akdeniz v. Türkiye
16/07/2021
Mahmut AKDENİZ
1978
Osmaniye
Turkish
Coşkun Çağlar DURAN
37009/21
Koç v. Türkiye
14/07/2021
Ümit KOÇ
1971
Manisa
Turkish
Remzi DEMİRKOL
37400/21
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
09/07/2021
Sabri YILMAZ
1974
Erzurum
Turkish
Merve DOĞAN
37989/21
Gökçen v. Türkiye
26/07/2021
Sümeyra GÖKÇEN
1993
İzmir
Turkish
Veysel ÇELİK
40398/21
Dural v. Türkiye
02/08/2021
Ali DURAL
1979
Konya
Turkish
Sefanur BOZGÖZ
40821/21
Bayraktar v. Türkiye
11/08/2021
Hasan BAYRAKTAR
1987
Denizli
Turkish
Fatma Nur BAYRAKTAR
42462/21
Gönen v. Türkiye
13/08/2021
Yusuf GÖNEN
1989
Kayseri
Turkish
Ömer DELİGEZER
42606/21
Biçer v. Türkiye
23/08/2021
Yakup BİÇER
1987
Antalya
Turkish
Muhammet DEMİREL
43799/21
Deli v. Türkiye
31/08/2021
Adem DELİ
1985
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
44064/21
Aydın v. Türkiye
27/08/2021
İbrahim AYDIN
1975
Kocaeli
Turkish
Cahit ÇİFTÇİ
50027/21
Güneş v. Türkiye
05/10/2021
Mustafa GÜNEŞ
1977
Isparta
Turkish
Tarık ÇAĞLAYAN
50178/21
Sümer v. Türkiye
08/10/2021
Adem SÜMER
1986
Ankara
Turkish
Gizay DULKADİR
50649/21
Kurak v. Türkiye
21/09/2021
Nurevşan KURAK
1994
Malatya
Turkish
Gülsüm EKİNCİ
51706/21
Yavuz v. Türkiye
15/10/2021
Bayram YAVUZ
1981
Bursa
Turkish
Mehmet CEBECİ
51800/21
Demiralay v. Türkiye
04/10/2021
Mehmet DEMİRALAY
1980
Isparta
Turkish
Atilla ELMA
52155/21
Aksu v. Türkiye
20/10/2021
Süleyman AKSU
1978
Kayseri
Turkish
Lalenur ÇELİK
52393/21
Kızıl v. Türkiye
19/10/2021
Ercan KIZIL
1978
Ankara
Turkish
Naciye Refia ÇOKER
53906/21
Algül v. Türkiye
01/11/2021
Cengiz ALGÜL
1985
Bingöl
Turkish
Faruk BEDLEK
54681/21
Yıldız v. Türkiye
01/11/2021
Engin YILDIZ
1983
Istanbul
Turkish
Yunus ELMAS
55305/21
Pilavlı v. Türkiye
02/11/2021
Derviş PİLAVLI
1980
Ankara
Turkish
Zülfinaz DURSUN
55340/21
Şimşek v. Türkiye
11/11/2021
Mehmet ŞİMŞEK
1979
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
55742/21
Kandemir v. Türkiye
15/11/2021
Hakan KANDEMİR
1985
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
Muhammed Sabit CAN
57061/21
Kaçire v. Türkiye
05/11/2021
İlhan KAÇİRE
1970
Diyarbakır
Turkish
Lezgin Ahmet BAYBAŞİN
58116/21
Kılıç v. Türkiye
24/11/2021
Faruk KILIÇ
1971
Ankara
Turkish
Regaip DEMİR
58160/21
Dinçel v. Türkiye
25/11/2021
Muhammed DİNÇEL
1977
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
Özlem DİNÇEL
58284/21
Yıldırım v. Türkiye
26/11/2021
İlhami YILDIRIM
1972
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
59184/21
Bilgehan v. Türkiye
29/11/2021
Recep BİLGEHAN
1964
Balıkesir
Turkish
Furkan BURHAN
59423/21
Özden v. Türkiye
23/11/2021
Faruk ÖZDEN
1981
Ankara
Turkish
Fatih DÖNMEZ
59821/21
Ömercikoğlu v. Türkiye
30/11/2021
Muhammed Sinan ÖMERCİKOĞLU
1979
Ordu
Turkish
Erşan CANSEVEN
60946/21
Acar v. Türkiye
07/12/2021
Ramazan ACAR
1975
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
Abdullah DOĞAN
1259/22
Tanrıöver v. Türkiye
17/12/2021
Recep TANRIÖVER
1990
Istanbul
Turkish
Kazım DEMİR
1473/22
Danış v. Türkiye
28/12/2021
Esin DANIŞ
1972
Antalya
Turkish
Sümeyra ÇELİK AKINCI
4355/22
Erdem v. Türkiye
07/01/2022
İdris ERDEM
1984
Manisa
Turkish
Bengül BERBER
6394/22
Bilgin v. Türkiye
27/01/2022
Mehmet Mustafa BİLGİN
1971
Mersin
Turkish
Ali Asaf BİLGİN
7028/22
Demirci v. Türkiye
30/12/2021
Recep DEMİRCİ
1990
Kocaeli
Turkish
Burhan DEMİRCİ
8199/22
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
27/01/2022
İrfan YILMAZ
1979
Istanbul
Turkish
Ahmet DALDABAN
8630/22
Moran v. Türkiye
09/02/2022
Rukiye MORAN
1978
Kayseri
Turkish
Burak ÇAĞ
8937/22
Demirci v. Türkiye
09/02/2022
Hakkı DEMİRCİ
1971
Karabük
Turkish
Nihal DEMİRCİ
9677/22
Pir v. Türkiye
08/02/2022
Recep PİR
1975
Gaziantep
Turkish
Zahide BOZKUŞ
11031/22
Dağlarbaş v. Türkiye
11/02/2022
Ersin DAĞLARBAŞ
1969
Muğla
Turkish
Nezahat DAĞLARBAŞ
14126/22
Dikici v. Türkiye
03/03/2022
Burhan DİKİCİ
1974
Bursa
Turkish
Ahmet Can DEMİRCİ
14286/22
Akbulut v. Türkiye
09/03/2022
Murat AKBULUT
1978
Kütahya
Turkish
Muhammed ÇAPRAK
14790/22
Akcan v. Türkiye
15/03/2022
İdris AKCAN
1981
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
14918/22
Çalışkan v. Türkiye
16/03/2022
Serdar ÇALIŞKAN
1987
Istanbul
Turkish
Burak ÇAĞ
15403/22
Baysal v. Türkiye
16/03/2022
Ali İhsan BAYSAL
1965
Balıkesir
Turkish
Yeşim BAYSAL
16607/22
Ürek v. Türkiye
29/03/2022
Ramazan ÜREK
1986
Antalya
Turkish
Muhammet DEMİREL
16929/22
Akaslan v. Türkiye
23/03/2022
Yasin AKASLAN
1978
Kırşehir
Turkish
Muhammet Uğur DEMİRKAN
17609/22
Can v. Türkiye
21/03/2022
Bahadır CAN
1975
Eskişehir
Turkish
Olcay DÜNDAR
18161/22
Levent v. Türkiye
05/04/2022
Ahmet LEVENT
1986
Niğde
Turkish
Ersan CANSEVER
18247/22
Üveyik v. Türkiye
29/03/2022
Zekeriya ÜVEYİK
1976
Niğde
Turkish
Adem ÇEÇEN
18861/22
Özköklü v. Türkiye
08/04/2022
Ramazan ÖZKÖKLÜ
1980
Kocaeli
Turkish
Yasin DANGIR
18897/22
Tezcan v. Türkiye
01/04/2022
Ali TEZCAN
1980
Istanbul
Turkish
Süveyda BAYTAK
19850/22
Bakırcı v. Türkiye
06/04/2022
İzzet BAKIRCI
1987
Malatya
Turkish
Yusuf EKİNCİ
20060/22
Madanoğlu v. Türkiye
15/04/2022
Mehmet MADANOĞLU
1958
Istanbul
Turkish
Salim DİNÇ
20943/22
Baş v. Türkiye
04/04/2022
Yalçın BAŞ
1979
Turkish
Özgün DİNÇ
22536/22
Demir v. Türkiye
19/04/2022
Mehmet DEMİR
1970
Malatya
Turkish
Enes DEMİR
22787/22
Kocaman v. Türkiye
05/05/2022
Ömer Faruk KOCAMAN
1981
Mersin
Turkish
Burhan DEMİRCİ
22808/22
Tepe v. Türkiye
21/04/2022
Halil TEPE
1984
Nevşehir
Turkish
Ebru EKİCİ
24236/22
Ataş v. Türkiye
25/04/2022
Şenel ATAŞ
1985
Kocaeli
Turkish
Cahit ÇİFTÇİ
24877/22
Töre v. Türkiye
29/04/2022
Rahmi TÖRE
1976
Elazığ
Turkish
Mustafa Selami EKİCİ
24940/22
Ünal v. Türkiye
05/05/2022
Ramazan ÜNAL
1973
Samsun
Turkish
Zeliha DERVİŞOĞLU
25882/22
Aytaş v. Türkiye
29/04/2022
Kaya Mehmet AYTAŞ
1971
Samsun
Turkish
Zeliha DERVİŞOĞLU
26862/22
Yalçın v. Türkiye
20/05/2022
Rahmetullah YALÇIN
1975
Antalya
Turkish
Muhammet DEMİREL
27983/22
Güngör v. Türkiye
24/05/2022
Ferhat GÜNGÖR
1983
Adana
Turkish
Büşra DİNÇER
34981/22
Kaynar v. Türkiye
09/06/2022
Salih KAYNAR
1974
Nevşehir
Turkish
Ebru EKİCİ
37255/22
Tosuner v. Türkiye
03/06/2022
Ebru TOSUNER
1988
Kayseri
Turkish
Ömer DELİGEZER
37272/22
Çavga v. Türkiye
28/06/2022
Semiha ÇAVGA
1989
Samsun
Turkish
Zeliha DERVİŞOĞLU
40375/22
Tekin v. Türkiye
02/08/2022
Muharrem TEKİN
1974
Balıkesir
Turkish
Refik Cağlar DİLBER
40942/22
Alış v. Türkiye
16/07/2022
Ahmet ALIŞ
1977
Samsun
Turkish
Zeliha DERVİŞOĞLU
42500/22
Korkmaz v. Türkiye
15/08/2022
Adem KORKMAZ
1976
Ordu
Turkish
Ayşe DURMUŞ
42766/22
Akgün v. Türkiye
10/08/2022
Murat AKGÜN
1981
Antalya
Turkish
Muhammet DEMİREL
42917/22
Doğan v. Türkiye
12/08/2022
Melek DOĞAN
1977
Mersin
Turkish
Erşan CANSEVEN
43844/22
Demir v. Türkiye
26/08/2022
Engin DEMİR
1975
Konya
Turkish
Kevser DEMİR
43980/22
Söylemez v. Türkiye
29/08/2022
Mahmut SÖYLEMEZ
1974
Şanlıurfa
Turkish
Hacer Perihan DEMİREL
44822/22
Afşar v. Türkiye
13/09/2022
Erkan AFŞAR
1975
Kayseri
Turkish
Merve DOĞAN
45459/22
Maral v. Türkiye
09/09/2022
Reyhan MARAL
1993
Istanbul
Turkish
Ayşe DURMUŞ
46566/22
Dangır v. Türkiye
26/09/2022
Yasin DANGIR
1992
Istanbul
Turkish
Kadir DANGIR
48187/22
Işık v. Türkiye
26/09/2022
Kenan IŞIK
1973
Hatay
Turkish
Tamer DEMİRCİ
48658/22
Çatkaya v. Türkiye
05/10/2022
Remzi ÇATKAYA
1985
Kars
Turkish
Erol ÇATKAYA
48831/22
Arslan v. Türkiye
05/10/2022
Yasemin ARSLAN
1989
Antalya
Turkish
Muhammet DEMİREL
49482/22
Şenel v. Türkiye
04/10/2022
Niyazi ŞENEL
1975
Aksaray
Turkish
Ayşe DURMUŞ
50213/22
Huylu v. Türkiye
10/10/2022
Gazi HUYLU
1965
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Merve DOĞAN
50309/22
Gürpınar v. Türkiye
19/10/2022
Yakup GÜRPINAR
1983
Edirne
Turkish
Burhan DEMİRCİ
51725/22
Aydın v. Türkiye
24/10/2022
Tarık AYDIN
1980
Elazığ
Turkish
İzettin DEMİR
52080/22
Köksalan v. Türkiye
05/11/2022
Salih KÖKSALAN
1980
Balıkesir
Turkish
Melih DİNÇ
52265/22
Dönmez v. Türkiye
26/10/2022
Dilek DÖNMEZ
1974
İzmir
Turkish
Zeynep Betül DÖNMEZ
53134/22
Akcan v. Türkiye
03/11/2022
Soner AKCAN
1985
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Mehmet ÇARMAN
53416/22
Yıldırım v. Türkiye
01/11/2022
Bünyamin YILDIRIM
1981
Ankara
Turkish
Fatih DÖNMEZ
53506/22
Doğan v. Türkiye
31/10/2022
Şerafettin DOĞAN
1983
Istanbul
Turkish
Abdülmenaf DOĞAN
54816/22
Yüzden v. Türkiye
16/11/2022
Yusuf YÜZDEN
1982
Bursa
Turkish
Adem DÜZGÜN
55079/22
Aydın v. Türkiye
10/11/2022
Serdar AYDIN
1982
Kütahya
Turkish
Ahmet Can DEMİRCİ
55527/22
Dede v. Türkiye
23/11/2022
Burak DEDE
1992
Balıkesir
Turkish
Melih DİNÇ
57616/22
Koç v. Türkiye
28/11/2022
Mahmut KOÇ
1985
Samsun
Turkish
Zeliha DERVİŞOĞLU
2683/23
Çolakoğlu v. Türkiye
03/01/2023
Serkan ÇOLAKOĞLU
1992
Kayseri
Turkish
Muhammet Uğur DEMİRKAN
3200/23
Güder v. Türkiye
29/12/2022
İcri GÜDER
1974
Sakarya
Turkish
Bekir DÖNMEZ
12625/23
Uslu v. Türkiye
10/02/2023
Hasan USLU
1976
Ankara
Turkish
Burhan DEMİRCİ
12891/23
Gökçe v. Türkiye
10/03/2023
Cem GÖKÇE
1987
Turkish
Gizay DULKADİR
12979/23
Gürler v. Türkiye
08/03/2023
Selami GÜRLER
1979
Kırıkkale
Turkish
Erşan CANSEVEN
21046/23
Gedikci v. Türkiye
10/05/2023
Süleyman GEDİKCİ
1976
Konya
Turkish
Burhan DEMİRCİ
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy