BVGE 2010/7 - Abteilung I - Amts- und Rechtshilfe - Amtshilfe. Auslegung völkerrechtlicher Verträge im...

Amtshilfe 2010/7
STAATSVERTRAGSRECHT —
ACCORDS INTERNATIONAUX —
ACCORDI INTERNAZIONALI
0.1 Internationales Recht im Allgemeinen
Droit international public général
Diritto internazionale pubblico generale
7
HFMH:
4HF
78@
+EG8
*4F>
BE68
@GF; 
IB@

4AH4E

9@?45821 A?813A:3 BX871>>1/4@85/41> *1>@>Q31 598831915:1: A:0
B;: ;A:3?-.7;991: 59 1?;:01>1: &1/4@?/4->-7@1>
31:1>1881> *1>?@Q:053A:3?B1>15:.->A:31: *;>-A??1@FA:31: 01>
9@?45821 5: '@1A1>?@>-2?-/41: 59 *1>4Q8@:5? '/4C15F)' >A:0
?-@FA>@158
>@
 * >@

22 +51:1> L.1>15:7;991: B;9 
!-5 
Z.1> 0-? &1/4@ 01> *1>@>Q31 :-/42;831:0 *& >@
 .?

A:0
>@
 .7;991: B;9 
#7@;.1>  FC5?/41: 01> '/4C15F1
>5?/41: 5031:;??1:?/4-2@ A:0 01: *1>15:53@1: '@--@1: B;: 91>57-
FA> *1>9150A:3 01> ;A:3 -A2 019 1.51@ 01> '@1A1>:
B;9
5:7;991:
:-/42;831:0
)'
 '@141: 2Z> 051 '/4C15F B1>.5:085/41 BX871>>1/4@85/41 ";>91: 5:
+501>?A/4 FA15:-:01> ?; 5?@ 051?1> B;>-. -A2 019 +131 01>
A?813A:3 -8?0-:: A:@1> 1-/4@A:3 01> BX871>>1/4@85/41 ";>
91:451>->/451 ;01> -:01>1> ;885?5;:?>1318A:31: -A2FA8X?1:
>?@ 0-? ?5/4 -A? 051?1> 8Q>A:3 1>31.1:01 &1?A8@-@ 5?@ :-/4
>@

*
9-??31.1:0


 A?813A:3?>1318: 01> *& 
 51?1 318@1: -A/4 2Z> 0-?
)' C;.15 051 59  ?18.?@ 1:@4-8@1:1: A?813A:3?
BVGE / ATAF / DTAF 85
2010/7 Amtshilfe
>1318: A:0 13>522?.1?@599A:31: 01: -8831915:1: A?813A:3?
>1318:
01>
*&
B;>3141:


 1:1>1881 *1>?@Q:053A:3?B1>15:.->A:31: ?;31:-::@ ;:?A8@-
@5;:?B1>15:.->A:31: ?5:0 FA8Q??53 0Z>21: .1?@141:01  -.1>
C101> 1>3Q:F1: :;/4 -.Q:01>: 
 *1>8Q??@ 15:1 ;:?A8
@-@5;:?B1>15:.->A:3 01: 0A>/4 0-?  BX871>>1/4@85/4 31?1@F
@1: &-491: ?; C5>0 ?51 :5/4@ FA 15:19 *1>@>-3 01> 0-? .1?@1
41:01 .7;991: -.Q:01>: 7-:: '51 .815.@ -.1> 15: !5@@18 01>
A?813A:3

 

 19Q?? >@
 .?
)' 815?@1@ 051 '/4C15F 01: )' 5:
'@1A1>?@>-2?-/41: 9@?45821 .15 H
1@>A3?01857@1: A:0 01>3815
/41:
I 

 1> 13>522 C5>0 59 $>;@;7;88 FA9 )'
0125:51>@ 

 A:0 

 > A92-??@ -8? .1@>Z31>5?/41? *1>
4-8@1: :1.?@ 019 '@1A1>.1@>A3 59 '5::1 B;: >@
  .FC
>@
 '@ -A/4 01: C15@1>3141:01: .3-.1.1@>A3 :-/4
>@

.?
 *'@>& -95@ ?1@F@ 051 1CQ4>A:3 B;: 9@?45821
?@1@? .1?;:01>1 !-/41:?/4-2@1: :5221 ;01> 15: 1531:@85/41? Z
31:31.QA01 B;>-A? 15:1 H
15:2-/41 Z31
I 1>2Z88@ 0-? >385?@
18191:@ :5/4@ 

 A/4 .8;??1? *1>?/4C1531: ;4:1 61385/41
,A?-@F4-:08A:3 B1>9-3 715: .1@>Z31>5?/41? *1>4-8@1: FA .1
3>Z:01: 

 5:1 *1>?@Q:053A:3?B1>15:.->A:3 051 (-@
4-:08A:31: 2Z> -9@?458212Q453 1>78Q>@ 051 ?5/4 59 "5/4@15:
>15/41: 15:1? ;>9A8->? 1>?/4X&-491:
B;:
>@

)'



:@>-501 -095:5?@>-@5B1 :@1>S@-@5;: 01 @>-5@S? 5:@1>:-@5;:-AD 1:
3S:S>-8 1@ 01 /;:B1:@5;:? 01 0;A.81 59@5/A851> "-@A>1
6A>505=A1 01? ;@;/;81? 0-//;>0 N /->-/@R>1 3S:S>-8 ;:05@5;:? 01
81:@>-501 -095:5?@>-@5B1 1: 9-@5R>1 01 0>;5@
/-0>1
01?
>18-@5;:?
'A5??1)'
>>U@
01
5:/5>@
 ?@ >@

?? ;:B1:@5;: 01 *51::1 0A 
9-5  ?A> 81
0>;5@ 01? @>-5@S? /5-R? * >@
 -8

1@ ->@
 ;:B1:@5;: 0A

;/@;.>1  1:@>1 8- ;:2S0S>-@5;: ?A5??1 1@ 81? @-@?):5? 09S
>5=A1 1: BA1 0SB5@1> 81? 0;A.81? 591 059
81
>1B1:A
/5-R?
)'
 ;>?=A1 01? :;>91? 01 0>;5@ 5:@1>:-@5;:-8 85-:@ 8- 'A5??1 ?;:@ 1:
/;:@>-05/@5;: 81? A:1? -B1/ 81? -A@>1? 58 /;:B51:@ 01 >S?;A0>1 /1
/;:285@ 1: -E-:@ >1/;A>? 1: 1951> 851A N 85:@1>S@-@5;: 1@ 1:
?A5@1 1: >1?->/451 01? :;>91? 1: 0>;5@ 5:@1>:-
@5;:-8 ;A 0-A@>1? >R381? 01 /;:285@ '1A8 81 >S?A8@-@ >1??;>@-:@ 01
86 BVGE / ATAF / DTAF
Amtshilfe 2010/7
/1@@1 /8->525/-@5;: 1?@ 0S@1>95:-:@ -A ?1:? 01 8->@

?@ /;:
?50

 &R381? 05:@1>S@-@5;: 01 8- * /;:?50
 1881?/5 ?;:@ -A??5
B-8-.81? 8- )' @;A@12;5? 81? >R381? 05:@1>S@-@5;: 1@
81? 0S25:5@5;:? /;:@1:A1? 0-:? 8-  591:@ 81? >R381? 3S:S>-81?
05:@1>S@-@5;:
01
8-
*
/;:?50

 1? ;@;/;81? 0-//;>0 N /->-/@R>1 3S:S>-8 05@? ;@;/;81? 01:
@1:@1 ?A> /;:?A8@-@5;: ?;:@ -095??5.81? 9-5? :1 0;5B1:@ @;A@12;5?
:5 /;9 :5 9;05251> 81?  1D5?@-:@1? /;:?50
 '5 A:
;@;/;81 01:@1:@1 ?A> /;:?A8@-@5;: ?;>@ 0A /-0>1 01 0>;5@ 5:@1>
:-@5;:-8 25DS 8-  58 :1 01B51:@ 0 9;05251> 81 @>-5@S 1D5?@-:@ 8 0191A>1 @;A@12;5? A: ;A@58 05:@1>
S@-@5;:
/;:?50
 

 : B1>@A 01 8->@
 -8
)' 8- 'A5??1 -//;>01 -AD )'
?;: 1:@>-501 -095:5?@>-@5B1 1: 9-@5R>1 01 0>;5@
81? /-? 01 H
2>-A01? 1@ 0S85@? ?19.8-.81?
I /;:?50

 1@@1
:;@5;: 1?@ 0S25:51 0-:? 81 ;@;/;81 01 8- )' /;:?50


1@ /;:?50

 1@ 1:38;.1 /;991 -@@5@A01 2>-A0A81A?1 ;A@>1
8A?-31 01 2-AD ?18;: 8->@
  1@ 8- 2>-A01 25?/-81 ?18;:
8->@
  8- 2>-A01 25?/-81 G 31 G 01 8->@

-8

$ 1:@>-501 -095:5?@>-@5B1 S?A? 01?
9-/45:-@5;:? ?@525/1? ;A A: BS>5@-.81 S0525/1 01
91:?;:31? A: H
?59195@R>1
0-?@A/1 /;:?50

 1 9U91 8- ?59-A@>1 -/@1 ?A1 :1 ?A225@ A:1 -@@5@A01
2>-A0A81A?1 /;:?50

 ): ;@;/;81 0-//;>0 =A5 0S?53:1
/;991 ?A?/11 8;.61@ 01:@>-501 -095:5?@>-@5B1 01?
2-5@? ;A -/@1? ?1 >S?A9-:@ N 8;95??5;: 01 @>-:?91@@>1 A: 2;>
9A8-5>1 ?;>@ /;:?S=A1:@ 0A /-0>1 01 8->@
 )' /;:
?50


BVGE / ATAF / DTAF 87
2010/7 Amtshilfe
??5?@1:F- -995:5?@>-@5B- :@1>1@-F5;:1 05 @>-@@-@5 5:@1>:-F5;:-85
5: 31:1>-81 1 05 /;:B1:F5;:5 05 0;@5/;8->1
"-@A>- 35A>505/- 05 -//;>05 -95/41B;85 31:1>-85 ;:05F5;:5 8-
/;:/1??5;:1 0188-??5?@1:F- -995:5?@>-@5B- :18 05>5@@; :188-9.5@;
01881
>18-F5;:5
'B5FF1>-)'
'1:@1:F-
05
5:/5>@
 ;?@ >@

?133 ;:B1:F5;:1 05 *51::- 018 
9-335;
 ?A8 05>5@@; 015 @>-@@-@5 =A5 05 ?13A5@; * >@
 /
1
->@
 ;:B1:F5;:1 018 
;@@;.>1  @>- 8- ;:2101>-F5;:1 'B5FF1
>- 1 385 '@-@5 ):5@5 091>5/- 1B5@->1 81 0;9-@1>5-
05
591005@;
=A5
05
?13A5@;
)'
 "18 /-?; 5: /A5 01881 :;>91 05 05>5@@; 5:@1>:-F5;:-81 B5:/;8-:@5
8- 'B5FF1>- ?5 @>;B5:; 5: /;:@>-005F5;:1 @>- 8;>; R :1/1??->5;
>5?;8B1>1 @-81 /;:@>-005F5;:1 5::-:F5@A@@; 91FF; 01885:@1>
1@-F5;:1 10 5: ?13A5@; 5: ;??1>B-:F- 0188- 31>->/45- 01881 :;>
91 05 05>5@@; 5:@1>:-F5;:-81 ; 05 -8@>1 :;>91 05 /;885?5;:1 ';8; 58
>5?A8@-@; 05 @-81 /45->591:@; R 01@1>95:-:@1 -5 ?1:?5 0188->@

;?@
/;:?50

 &13;81 05 5:@1>1@-F5;:1 0188- * /;:?50
 ??1 B-83;:; -:
/41 8- )' @A@@-B5- 81 >13;81 05:@1>1@-F5;:1 1 81 0125
:5F5;:5 1B5?@1 0-88- ?@1??-  1B-83;:; ?A881 >13;81 31:1>-85
05:@1>1@-F5;:1
0188-
*
/;:?50

 //;>05 -95/41B;85 31:1>-85 /;?5001@@5 -//;>05 ?A /;:?A8@-F5;:1
?;:; -991??5 9- :;: 01B;:; :S /;91 :S 9;0525/->1 81
 1?5?@1:@5 /;:?50
 "18 /-?; 5: /A5 A: -//;>0; ?A /;:?A8
@-F5;:1 1?/- 0-8 =A-0>; 018 05>5@@; 5:@1>:-F5;:-81 ?@-.585@; 0-88-
 1??; :;: 05B1:@- A: @>-@@-@; /41 1 8- /;:B1:
F5;:1 1?5?@1:@1 ??; >1?@- V A: 91FF; 05 5:@1>1@-F5;:1 /;:
?50
 

 '1/;:0; 8->@
 /- 2;>:5?/1 -385 )'
-??5?@1:F- -995:5?@>-@5B- :18 05>5@@; H
@>A221 1 0185@@5 -:-8;345
I /;:?50

 %A1?@- :;F5;:1 R 0125
:5@- :18 ;@;/;88; 0188- )' /;:?50

 1 /;:?50

 ?
?- 5:/8A01 =A-81 /;9@-91:@; 2>-A0;81:@; ;8@>1 -88- 2>;01 25?
/-81 -5 ?1:?5 0188->@
  1 ->@
  -:/41 8- @>A22-
5: 9-@1>5- 05 @-??1 @

/
/;:/1??5;:1 0188-??5?@1:F- -995:5?@>-@5B- 1?A?191 8A@585FF; 05 9-//45:-F5;:5 @5/;8->5 05 ->@525F5 ;1
05 A: /-?@188; 05 91:F;3:1 A:- H
?191-
85FF- 818191:@; 0188-?@AF5- /;:?50

 "1991:; 8- ?1905??59A8-F5;:1 ?1:F- -8/A: -@@; ?A1 R ?A225/51:@1 -
88 BVGE / ATAF / DTAF
Amtshilfe 2010/7
/;?@5@A5>1 A: /;9@-91:@; 2>-A0;81:@; /;:?50

 ): -/
/;>0; -95/41B;81 /41 5:/8A01 :18 /-9?@1:F- -995:5?@>-@5B- 01385 -@@5 /41 ?5 8595@-:; -88- :;: 1
?1:@-F5;:1 05 A: 2;>9A8->5; 1?/1 =A5:05 0-8 =A-0>; 0188->@

)'
/;:?50

@ 5>B@@8A IB@ 
H:HFG  MJ
4 l58E 8
@GF;IBA @8E4 58GE8998A7 +)  8
EG
 A46;9B?:8A7 5>B@
@8A  I8EC9?
!EB@@8A IB@ 
%>GB58E 
MJ
)G44G8A IBA @8E4 MHE ,8E@885B@@8A )( 

 A46;9B?:8A7
+)
8+AG8E 8EH9HA: 4H9 74F 5>B@@8A  E4A
>B@@8AFFG8H8E58;iE78 AG8EA4? (8I8AH8 )8EI
4@

H:HFG  8I8EJ4?GHA: )*, 8E () 8EFH6;G8 H@ 8E4HF:458 IBA A9BE@4G
A8A l58E 4@8E4A

4AH4E  HA7 78@

8M8@58E  7:HA: B78E 8>BAG8A ;4GG8A 7IBA 8*B6;G8E:8F8??F6;49G8A
JHE78A 8GEB998A J4E8A !BAG8A 9lE J8?6;8 78F
J4E HA7  ABEE8>G @
@8AF 78F =8J84AHF 4??8
8Ml:8
7@ 
)8CG8@58E  8E?
77
7B@@8A  :8A4AAG8A !4G8:BE9;4?G8F
8E9BE78E?4F IBE?
4@ 
$BI8@58E  A BVGE / ATAF / DTAF 89
2010/7 Amtshilfe
 :8?4A:G8 7BA>E8G8A 4?? F8MH
?8
4F
HA78FI8EJ4?GHA:F:8E
Aus den Erwägungen:
 8@^FF EG
 78E HA78FI8E94FFHA: 78E )6;J8
8EE86;G 4AMHJ8A78A #4FF:858A7 F
A
58M HA7 )G^A78A :HG:8;88EE86;G?6;8A ,8EGE^:8 FBA78EA 74F :8F4@G8 :8F8GMG8 HA7 A8E
E86;G @8EE86;G??HA:8A  

  
 YVO HANGARTNER )G 4??8E !B@@8AG4E
MHE )6;J8
9B?:8A7 )G 4??8E !B@@8AG4E2 $
 MH EG
 , %78E @
E8A -BEG8A #4FF:858A7 FHA: IBA &4E?4@8AG
HA7 ,B?> HA7 4??8A94??F :4E J
IB@ HA78FE4G 45:8F6;?BFF8A8A ,8EGE^:8   5
 
6 JEAN-
FRANÇOIS AUBERT/PASCAL MAHON &8G
7cE4?8 78 ?4 BA9c7cE4G
 $
 MH EG

, ANDREAS AUER/GIORGIO MALINVERNI/MICHEL HOTTELIER EB
G
HA78FI8E94FFHA: 78E )6;J8
$
 MH EG
 , ANNE BENOIT ,8EF HA8 ;
A4G
(86;G  12  )


99 
9 77
78E ;4EG4 78E ,8E8
78A
#8AF6;8AE86;G8A

 H6; ,i?>8EE86;G EG
 , @4FF:858A7 8AGFCE86;8A7 F8
G8A9l??HA:
;i;8EE4A:EG
 , HA7 $
 MH EG
 , EG
 , 8AG;^?G 58>8G8 MJ
)6;J88EE86;GF !4AA 78E !BA9?G
A>8EE86;G?
MHEl6>:8:E
  
 846;G8G J8E78A 74E9
90 BVGE / ATAF / DTAF
Amtshilfe 2010/7
BA9BE@8E 4A7
;45HA: IBA ,i?>8EE86;G I:? HANGARTNER )G 4??8E !B@@8AG4E $

MH EG
 , 4F ,8E;^?GA
94??F 8EE86;GF
IBE ?^E8A J^E8
8F 7B6; ?B:
JlE78 88EE86;G 58M
7
EG

,
J
 8Ml:?8EE86;G?$BE@8A FG8;G 7
J8E78A BE7AHA: HA7 @lFF8A 74;8E IBA 4??8A )G44GFBE:4A8A 5846;G8G J8E78A
4AFG4GG M4;??BF8E 8?8:FG8??8A HA78F4@G 9lE HFG
 I8Ei998AG?
 HA7    

5 #
J8E78A 78EI8EGE4:?
FBA78EA 58;4?G8A G8E 4?F Ii?>8EE86;G?88EE86;G?MHE AJ8A7HA: ROBERT WALDBURGER FG8H8EHA:F45>B@@8A
78F:8EB@@8A
78E (86;GFCE86;HA: 78E i6;FG:8E
XFG8EE88
HFG8EE86;G?
EHA7?4:8A #8G;B78A HA7 !E
 @
E8A 
C8?58FG8H8EHA:F45>B@@8A 78E HA78FE8CH5? 8HGF6;?4A7 4H9 78@
85B@@8A HA7 ,8E@i:8A !B@@8AG4E 4H9 78E
EHA7?4:8 78E #HFG8E45>B@@8A 
H9? #lA6;8A  $
 MH

 4G8EE86;G?F8A 78F
78F &H5?4G
IB@ 
HA58

5F

&H5? ,8EGE^:8 IBA 58F6;E^A>G8E *E4:J8
FB?6;8 MH I8EFG8;8A F
(8:
(,% )(  MHGE8998A I:? THOMAS SÄGESSER (8:,8EJ4?GHA:FBE:4A
BVGE / ATAF / DTAF 91
2010/7 Amtshilfe
(,% +@ 458E HA:8A :8:8Al58E 78@ CEI4G8A (86;GFHAG8EJBE98A8A 8AG94?G8A MH >iAA8A 5874E9 8F FB B78E 4A78EF
4H6; 9lE Ii?>8EE86;G?4G
8@8G8EE86;G
IB@ 
CE 074FF 788EE86;G?
?4G


 
?4A78FE86;G?4G
8
88EE86;G?B78E 58E8
G8E FBJ78EE86;G?
58E 4H6; 8EE86;GF :G4?8 E86;GFFG44G?
&9?iAA8A 4IBA 8AG5
GE4:?:8E1 &2

)

99


 (8:8?HA:F:8:8AFG4A7 78F ,i?>8EE86;GF
MJ
KÄLIN/ASTRID EPINEY/MARTINA CARONI/JÖRG KÜNZLI ,i?>8EE86;G 
9l;EHA: 
H9? 8EA  )
  JB58>8EE86;GF
 5F
 78F )G4GHGF 78F AG8EA4G
IB@ 
HA >B78EE86;G?(8:8?A l58E 74F ,8EGE4:FE86;G 58EH;8A 4H9 8JB;A;8
B@@8A IB@ 

#4,8EGE^:8 )(  A46;9B?:8A7 ,(! 9lE 7
B7
 
6 FPAUL MÜLLER/LUZIUS WILDHABER &E4K8EE86;GF

H9? 8EA
 )

9 @8EE86;G?GE4: :8EE86;G HAG8EFG8;8A78 4HF7El6>?>BA>?H78AG8 4A7?HA: MHFG4A78 :8>B@@8A8 -MJ88EE86;GFFH5=8>G8A
F
I8EC9?
J8E78A KÄLIN/EPINEY/CARONI/KÜNZLI 4
4
% )
 DANIEL THÜRER/BINH
TRUONG/FELIX SCHWENDIMANN )G
4??8E !B@@8AG4E MHE )6;J8
HA78FI8E94FFHA: 
H9? 0lE92 BVGE / ATAF / DTAF
Amtshilfe 2010/7
HG46;G8A 78F  IB@ 
4AH4E  I8Ei998AG?

0@4? HA7 4H6; A46;
;8EEF6;8A78E "8;E8 MH EG
 5F
 FG
4 ,(! @4FF:85?
E86;G?8HA9G    

5 #
G8G8EE86;G 78F  HA7 78F  78F  &
IB@ 
HAB@@8AG4EL BA G;8  ,
"8,(! ANDREAS R. ZIEGLER 8EE86;G 8EA 
)
 PHILIPPE GAUTIER
6BAI8AG
4EG
7
ElFF8?

$

9
MH
EG

,(!
 
 EG
 ,(! FG4GHB78E:8JB;A;8
E86;G Q 78A EHA7F4GM 74FF 8

F
EG
 ,(! >4AA F
B998AF8
EG
 ,(! Q A
$


  5
 
6 ,i?>8EE86;G?
G8G HA:846;G8G 8EE86;G?GHA:8A 88EE86;G 584AFCEH6;G 45FB?HG8 8?GHA: 878E
,8EGE4:F5EH6; FG8??G 88EE86;GFI8E?8GMHA: 74E 9lE J8?6;8 78E ;4A
78?A78 )G44G Ii?>8EE86;G?
BAI8AG
)6;J8
HÄFELIN/WALTER HALLER/HELEN KELLER )6;J8
FG44GFE86;G 
H9? 0lEACHERMANN 8E ,BEE4A: 78F ,i?>8EE86;GF
6;8E@4AA 4A



99 
KÄLIN/EPINEY/CARONI/KÜNZLI 4
4
% )
 H9 J8?6;8 -8
;
A46;>B@@8A @HFF J8EE86;G A8E
E86;G I8EJ8G 4H9 74F "4A78FE86;G HANGARTNER
)G
4??8E !B@@8AG4E $
 MH EG
 , THOMAS COTTIER/MAYA HERTIG
4F ,i?>8EE86;G
>HA:8A
K
BVGE / ATAF / DTAF 93
2010/7 Amtshilfe
- IBA EG
 ,(! 8EF6;iC9G
F
(86;G 58EH9G H@ F8EE86;G?74@8

7EB

7 ElFF8? 
$

9
MH
EG

,(!

8FG8;8A MJ
FG8;8A78 ,8EGE^:8 l58E 78AF8?58A 8:8AFG4A7 4?FB l58E 7@
7
FB FG8??G EG

,(! 7&9?
EG

,(! FELIPE PAOLILLO
"8F 6BAI8AG
C4E 4EG
7 ElFF8?  $
 HA7  MH EG

,(! EG


,(! E8:8?G 9B?:?IBA 4H98

5F

  HA7  ,(! FG8??8A 7
AJ8A7HA: J8AA 78
;458A VILLIGER ,
,(! PAOLILLO
4
4
%
$

9
MH
EG


,(!

5F
 ,(!  

 

 Q 9E8
:8A HAG8E8iAA8A 7@8AG?
8FG4??8A l5E
F6;?BFF8A8A ,8EGE4:F IBE:8;8A 74FF 7
G8A ,8EGE4:F 7
HA58El;EG ?4FF8A 58M
74FF 8
8?
4HF7El6>?
?^FFG 58FG 5F
 ,(! 74FF 7
?8?
;^?G EG

5F

,(! 9lE ,8EGE^:8 MJ
G8
9El;8E8 ,8EGE4: AHE FBJ8
,8EGE4:
I8E8

9
MH
EG


,(!
94 BVGE / ATAF / DTAF
Amtshilfe 2010/7
 8EE86;G?6;8A ,8EGE^:8 HAG8EFG8;8A 78A HF?8:HA:FE8:8?A IBA EG


99 ,(!
8EG8A HF?8:HA:F@8G;B78A >B78E:8JB;A
;8
 
6 7BAI8AG

99 MH EG

 ,(! $

MH EG

 ,(! HA7 $

MH EG


,(! HA7 J8E78A FBJ88E:8JB;A
;84AAG F
M8
COTTIER/RENÉ MATTEOTTI 4F 5>B@@8A l58E 8MJ
)G44G8A IBA @8E4 IB@ 
H:HFG  EHA7?4:8A HA7
?8
58E86;G 1)2  )


99 )


FRANK ENGELEN AG8ECE8G4G
*E84G
 JEAN-MARC
RIVIER "
78 7EB

99 
9 @

E8:8? IBA EG

 5F
 ,(! F
8FG
78F ,8EGE4:F *E8H HA7 ?4H58A FBJ?8@8AG8 F
!?8
B@@8AG4

7 ElFF8?  $
 MH EG


,(! MARK E. VILLIGER EG 4A7
 B9 G;8 ,
G;8 "4J B9 *E84G
(
9lE 8BE: (8FF MH@ 
85HEGFG4: 4@ 
4AH4E  1A46;9B?:8A7
EG
99
 VILLIGER ,
MH EG

 ,(! ENGELEN 4
4
% )

99 )
 RIVIER 4
4
%
)
 WÜGER 4
4
% )
 7E8FF4G8A 7

)G44G8A B78E %E:4A
6BAGE47

,(!
 8A HF:4A:FCHA>G 78E HF?8:HA: 5GE4:? ,(!
VILLIGER ,
MH EG

 ,(! VILLIGER EG)


 XAVIER OBERSON &Ec6

H9?
8EA  $

 8EE86;G?
AHE F8B@@8A F8?5FG :89HA78A ;4G HARALD
BVGE / ATAF / DTAF 95
2010/7 Amtshilfe
SCHAUMBURG AG8EA4G
FG8H8EHA:FE86;G 
H9? !i?A  $
 ENGELEN 4
4
% )

VOGEL 4
4
% $
 MH 

GHA: MH
8 78F ,8E
GE4:F HA7 :8@^FF *E8H HA7 ?4H58A MH 8EH4 HA7  MH 
 RIVIER 4
4
%
)

9 SCHAUMBURG 4
4
% $

9 ,BE58;4?G8A 5?8A46; EG

 5F
 ,(! 8?4E @4A
F A
58FBA78E8A )
$
 HA7 
99 MH EG

 ,(! MH@ 4AM8A I:? 4H6; ENGELEN 4
4
%
)

9
 0 78F ,8EGE4:F FG8 J8?6;8
7?RIVIER 4
4
% )

9 4H6; MH@ B?:8A78A VILLIGER ,I8AG
 ,(! VILLIGER, EG EG

 ,(!
FCE 8
,8EGE4:F 8AGAB@@8A J8E78A >4AA 4??:8@8
VILLIGER ,
MH EG

 JB58B@@8A

>B@@8A MHE ,8E@8B@@8A
MHE 8>^@C9HA: IBA )G8H8E58GEH: HAG8EF6;87HA: 58B@@8A  74IBA 74FF 00J86> 78F 5>B@@8AF 7OBERSON 4
4
% $


9 4H6; MH@ B?:8A78A $J8E78A >4AA
E58
@iAA8A :8@^FF EG

 ,(! 8EFG ;8E
4A:8MB:8A J8E78A H@ 7 ,(!
8E:858A78 878HGHA: MH 58FG^GEG

 ,(! 7B78E 8?A ?^FFG 58M
E

99

9 RIVIER 4
4
% )
 VILLIGER ,
EG

 ,(!; VILLIGER, EG JAN WOUTERS/MAARTEN VIDAL
$BA*4K *E84G
96 BVGE / ATAF / DTAF
Amtshilfe 2010/7
H:?
)


99

@ ??:8@8
74FF 74El58E 8
 ,(! A??B:iAA8 7
:HA: A46; *E8H HA7 ?4H58A :4E4AGVILLIGER EG SOREL 4
4
% $
 HA7 

99 MH EG


,(! %5 74
4
% )

 H6; 58
:8@^FF 0 78F ,8EGE4:F J
?G 
G8E8AGJ?HA: B78E :4E 8
HF?8:HA: F8

9
,(! A
EG VOGEL 4
4
% $
 MH 
8
?
$
 MH EG

 ,(! RIVIER 4
4
% )
 JOHN F. AVERY JONES *4K
*E84G
#4

99
 ENGELEN 4
4
% )

1@
RENÉ MATTEOTTI T
*E84GL );BCC
)6;J8
AG8EA4GGB58E  0lE0
78F FB :8A4AAG8A T
*E84GL );BCCB@
@8AFE86;G?iAAG8A MH@
6BAGE4 I8E54 4HF:8?8:G J8E78A J8AA 7
:8:8A *E8H HA7 ?4H58A I8EFGBFF8A78F HAI8EAlA9GJE:85A
 A Y58E8
?
EHA7F4GM I8EC9?
6;8A IBA )C88?Ml:8A 9E8GE4:?VILLIGER ,
)

 4H6; MH@ B?:8A78A 
5846;G8G 4H6; 74F ,8E5BG 78F I8A
(86;GF@

8@^FF EG

 5F
 ,(!
F6;?
BVGE / ATAF / DTAF 97
2010/7 Amtshilfe
74EHAG8E MH I8EFG8;8A
 5F
 ,(! 789
,
 ,(! SOREL 4
4
% $
 HA7


99 MH EG

 ,(! OBERSON 4
4
% $

 RIVIER 4
4
% )

4H6; MH@ B?:8A78A 8E 8:E
EG

 5F
 ,(! G F
78E8 J878E 4H9 7
BE@ 78E IBE58E8
,(! 4HFF6;?>iAA8A I:? 

 AB6; 4H9 ?8@8AG8 4HFF8E;4?5 78F *8KG8F EG


5F

,(! 789
A4AAG8E T
6BAG8KG8 8KG8EA8
U :?8?8:HA: MH 58El6>F
MH EG

 ,(! SOREL 4
4
% $

99 MH EG

 ,(! F 8K
FB@8
 5F
 HA7
,(! SOREL
4
4
%
$

MH
EG


,(!
 EG


5F
 ,(! E8:8?G 7
MJ8
=878E )CE46;8
IBEF
FG
5F

,(! FG4GH,8E@HGHA: 74FF 78 78F ,8EGE4:F
7
99 
99 lE 7,(! F8?5FG J8?6;8 8EE86;G?:HA: 5874E9 ?8:G EG
 ,(! 7
,


,(!

  F8EE86;G?
5F
 FG
4 ,(! Q :8@^FF 78A HF?8:HA:FE8:8?A 78E ,(! 4HFMH?8:8A
4AFG4GG 4??8E +EG8  IB@ 
$BI8@58E 
I8Ei998AG?
 @
E8E8:8?A ,i?>8E:8JB;A;8B7
 >iAA8A 7(8:8?A 4H6; 9lE 5>B@@8A 4A:8J8A78G J8E78A J8?6;8 IBE A>E49G
GE8G8A 78E ,(! 45:8F6;?BFF8A JHE78A    
 
6 58M;HA:FJ8
GE8THOMAS PERROT BHAGEL )HEI8LF ;4CG8E  E4A68
#4

99


I:?
4H6;



98 BVGE / ATAF / DTAF
Amtshilfe 2010/7

FG
HF?8:HA: :8@^FF EG


99 ,(! IBE   5  

4 +EG878F 8E 
  IB@ 
$BI8@58E  I8Ei998AG?
 

 ENGELEN 4
4
% )

99 RIVIER 4
4
% )

SCHAUMBURG 4
4
% $
 8E
E86;G?FC86

, 
 
 8;?8A FB?6;8 I8EGE4:?:HA:FE8:8?A HA7 8:EG 4H9 7
99
,(! 45MHFG8??8A HA7 A46; #4FF:458 78E 74E
HF?8:HA:FE8:8?A
5>B@@8AF58FGB@@8A Q "
J878E 4HF7El6>?7
MHM5 58FG^G
4 MARKUS
REICH 4F ,8EFG^A7
FG8H8EHA:F45>B@@8A 78E )6;J8
 $HE 458E @8E;
;^H9B@@8A78A FH5F
J8A78G8A 8:E
4 +EG88E 
  IB@ 
$BI8@58E  I8Ei998AG?



 8FG8;8A B@@8A 78E %E:4A
G?HA: %#
1IBE?
HA:8A
0lE# HA7 F8
 8B@@8A PETER LOCHER 
74F

H9? 8EA  )


OBERSON 4
4
% $
 RIVIER 4
4
% )

9 WALDBURGER HF
?8:HA: )

9 +EG8  IB@ 
$BI8@58E 
I8Ei998AG?
 HA7
 +EG83  IB@ 
#4
 $E
 
 458
F8

99 ,(! JACQUES
SASSEVILLE BHEG 86
BAI8AG
@FG8E74@  )

99  VOGEL 4
4
% $
 MH 
BVGE / ATAF / DTAF 99
2010/7 Amtshilfe
AGFCE86;8A7 >4AA 8GJ4 8
874E9F94?? Q I8EGE4:F4HGBAB@ :8@^FF 78A (8:8?A 78E EG


99 ,(!
4HF:8?8:G HA7 >iAA8A F8F
?F
4?F 8E:^AM8A78  ,(! 778HGHA: 7STEFAN OESTERHELT/MAURUS WINZAP 5>B@@8AF@
*E8H;^A78E  )


99 
9 @
HEF>B@@
 IB@

#^EM 
I:? 4H6; 

 A:8F8AGFCE86;8A78A !B@@8AG4EF A^@?
:?8 J878E 9lE 7#
4H6; >8HA: MH 8EM$
5 MH 
REICH/ROBERT WALDBURGER (86;GFCE86;HA:

9
 
84H6;
9lE
74F
+)
 EG
 +) E8:8?G HAG8E 78@ *
I8E94;E8A
U 7E8
"8;A8E 1EF:2 BCC8?58FG8H8EHA:F45>B@@8A 78E HA78FE8CH5?
8HGF6;?4A7 4H9 78@ 85B@@8A HA7
,8E@i:8A !B@@8AG4E 4H9 78E EHA7?4:8 78E #HFG8E45>B@@8A

H9? #lA6;8A  $

MH EG
 8
HA7  +) :8E8:8?G8A
>4AA 8
,8EGE4:FFG44G8F B78E 58
9l;E8A B78E 9l;E8A JlE78A 7B@@8A A58F6;478G 78E A46; 78@
(86;GF@
HAG8E5E8
F
IBE?
)4GM


+) :8E8:8?G8 7E
78E 58
BCC8?58FG8H8EHA: B@@8A A58;4A78?G
F

MH
EG


100 BVGE / ATAF / DTAF
Amtshilfe 2010/7
 ?F 8
)4GM

HA7  +) 7,8EGE4:FFG44G8A 58@l;8A )6;J8
?8:HA: B78E AJ8A7HA: 78F 5>B@@8AF 8AGFG8;8A

"8;E8 HA7
I8E94;E8A
U 58M8G 4?F T
HF?8
:HA:FI8E8
%#HFG8E>B@@8AG4E2 HA7 $

99 MH EG
 ROLF LAND
4AF ? E4AM -4FF8E@8L8E #58FG8H8EHA:F45>B@@8A 8HGF6;?4A7)6;J8
$

99 MH EG

,8E8
M8

EG
 5F

FG
9 +) A8AAG 7
HF7EH6>F 8KC?
7BAFH?GiAA8A MHFG^A7iAA8A :8@^FF EG
 5F

+) MHE 8E58
I8E>8;E8A 8E HF7EH6> T
MHFG^A7
)6;J8GBE 78E 
58IB??@^6;G 5F
 FG
9 +) FG^A78
(,% HF 78@ 4??:8@8
)8?5FG84GGHE 78E
HA78FI8EJ4?GHA: 45?8
EG

 (,% 9
J4?GHA:F8
7
MiAA8A
I:?
SÄGESSER
4
4
%
$


99
MH
EG

(,%
 8E (86;GF6;4E4>G8E 78E4EG
54EHA:8A
Ii?>8EE86;G??^E8A B5 8
EHA: MJ
88EE86;G?
4H6; MADELEINE SIMONEK &EB5?8@98?78E 4HF 78@ ,8E;^?GA
58FG8H8EHA:F45>B@@8A HA7 ,8EFG^A7
FG44G?
)

99 
@
74G4AA 4H9 75>B@@8A HG46;G8A 78F  IB@ 
4AH4E  I8Ei998AG?
,& 
0BVGE / ATAF / DTAF 101
2010/7 Amtshilfe
HA7 &9?
EG

 5F
 ,(! >?4E8A -BEG?4HG8 FBJB;? 58Ml:?:HA:FI8E8

4AH4E 
MJ
8C4EG@8AG B9 G;8 *E84FHEL 78E +) 58GE8998A7 7EG
 +) 4?F 4H6; ;B@@8AF  A
E4:8 
84G
>8EE86;G?B@@8AF I:?
4H6; REICH 4
4
% )
 SIMONEK 4
4
% )
 
9 17M
9 WALTER BOSS 4F ,8EFG^A7F6;J8B@@8A

 HA7 LOCHER 4
4
%
)

 J8?6;8 =87B6; 78A +AG8EF6;
:8A8E8??8A ,8EFG^A7
Y5EGE
4
4
%
)


99
@

A 78E "8;E8 H@FGE
E8??8A ,8EFG^A7
!BAFH?G4G4AA LEHNER 4
4
% $
 MH
EG



G


 $46; ;8EEF6;8A78E F6;J8iAA8A 77
J878E 8E:^AM8A AB6; 45^A78EA B78E A8H8 (86;G8 B78E &9?
E8A OBERSON 4
4
% $
 RIVIER 4
4
% )

 I:? 4H6; DANIEL
HUFSCHMID T
*4K 9E4H7 4A7 G;8 ?8
U Q 5HA: 78F 4A>:8;8G8A
:8@^FF +)
 DANIEL HOLENSTEIN
)6;J84HF>lA9G8 4A 78A 4HF?^A7HF
 )

99 
9 @
H. BOSS *;8 #HGH4? :E88@8AG &EB687HE8 HA78E G;8 )J
*4K4G


G


 A 78E "8
78E 749lE FGE
 45^A78EA 7lE98 4??8A94??F 4A78E8E #8
4
4
% )


9 J8?6;8
102 BVGE / ATAF / DTAF
Amtshilfe 2010/7
78
!BAFH?G4G
>B@@8AF
U IBE?78A &4FF4:8A 78F 74MH:8;iEB??F MH ;4?G8A -
:8FCE8A:G J
,8EGE4: 78E 74F 58FG8;8A78 5>B@@8A ^A78EG HA7 74@
,8EGE4: Q
5F

,(! 78@ 9El;8E8A IBE:8;G I:?


 H6;
J8?6;8A B@@8A
U F8GMG l58E?4CCG 5?8458E
 5F


FG
4 ,(! 
:HA:FI8E88EE86;G
MH:8J
 
786>G F
7
GE
58
>B@@8A AEB;8A B78E 74F ,BE?
#i:?8
7
:8?8:G8 )46;I8E;4?G EB@
@8A :85BG8A8 (86;GF9B?:8 45:8?8
&El9HA: HAG8E?^:8A 77FBJB;? 4A 74F 5>B@@8A 4?F 4H6; 4A 74F =8J8:85HA78A 7iAA8 J878E 74F :8?G8A78
5>B@@8AFE86;G AB6; 74F
4
4
%
$


MH
EG

0H@ MJ8GE
(86;GFCE86;HA: J8?6;8 4H6; 9lE 8
E8FF8 8EE86;G?!BAFH?G4G?:8;4?G8A 78E4EG

5F

FG
4 ,(! HA7 FGlA78A FB 4H9 78E :?878E 0HF4@@8A;4A: JOHN F. AVERY JONES *;8 E8?4G
@HGH4? 4:E88@8AG CEB687HE8 4A7
)
 H9 :?8
Y5HA:
U
 5F

FG
5 ,(! J
FH?G4G
FG8??8 AHE FB?4A:8 8
BVGE / ATAF / DTAF 103
2010/7 Amtshilfe
F
LOUKOTA 4F
HF?8:HA: )G8H8E HA7 -



99 
F6;8

#^EM
 MH@  XFG8EE88iAA8
T
7HE6; 8
EHA: B78E FBAFG 58JG8 Q P
Y5HA:
R 78E A;4?G 8B@
@8AFE8:8?HA: :8^A78EG J8E78A
U MICHAEL LANG AG8EA4G
F6;49GF5E8E 78HGF6;8 HA78F9
5F

78F 5>B@@8AF IB@ 
H:HFG  MJ
E 8HGF6;?4A7 MHE ,8E
@8
>B@@8A HA7 IB@ ,8E@i:8A )( 
 58GE8998A78A AGF6;8HAG8E 8MH:A4;@8 4H9 EG

 5F

FG
4 HA7 5 ,(! 4HF:89l;EG 8
:8A8E8??8 ,8EFG^A7iAA8 9lE 7B@@8AF4HF?8
:HA: 5878HGF4@ F8
>B@@8AFJBEG?4HG MHJ
78
R 9lE 74F P
EB@@8AFI8EFG^A7A
+EG8 5 66 
F6;8
?4A78 98FG;iAAG8A
AHA9G 4HF?8:8A HA7 7458,8EGE4: ^A78EA +EG8
4AH4E

 ( 
Erwägungen 4–6 im Volltext vgl. 

 4EFG8??HA:
78E
9lE
78A
IBE?
 !?^EHA: 78F ,8E;^?GA
HA7 HF?8:HA: 78EF8?58A F 8E:IBE:85E46;G8 )46;I8E;4?G 8
+) 1F4@G &EBGB>B??2 MH 58HEG8B@@8A  74E
:8?8:G8A !BAFG8??4G
F &El9HA: B5 74F BA>E8G8A @GF;G8A 4?F T
8GEH:F78?G8 HA7 78E:?8
+) HA7 0B??F MH@ )G44GFI8EGE4: 58GE46;G8G J8E78A
>4AA 4F ,8E I8EA84A
7104 BVGE / ATAF / DTAF