Resolution CM/ResDH(2018)455
Execution of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights
136 cases against Russian Federation (from the Kalashnikov group –see list in appendix )
(Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 12 December 2018
at the 1332nd meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies)
The Committee of Ministers, under the terms of Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, which provides that the Committee supervises the execution of final judgments of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter “the Convention” and “the Court”,
Having regard to the final judgments transmitted by the Court to the Committee in these cases and to the violations established mainly on account of poor conditions of detention in detention facilities under the authority of the Ministries of Justice and of the Interior, the lack of adequate medical care and the lack of an effective domestic remedy in both respects (violations of Articles 3 and 13);
Recalling the respondent State’s obligation, under Article 46, paragraph 1, of the Convention, to abide by all final judgments in cases to which it has been a party and that this obligation entails, over and above the payment of any sums awarded by the Court, the adoption by the authorities of the respondent State, where required:
- of individual measures to put an end to violations established and erase their consequences so as to achieve as far as possible restitutio in integrum; and
- of general measures preventing similar violations;
Having invited the government of the respondent State to inform the Committee of the measures taken to comply with the above-mentioned obligation;
Having examined the information provided by the government indicating the individual measures adopted to give effect to the judgments including the information provided regarding the payment of the just satisfaction awarded by the Court;
Considering that the question of individual measures has been resolved, given that the applicants have either been released or passed away, and that all necessary individual measures have also been taken in respect of the other violations found by the Court;
Recalling that the question of the general measures required in response to the shortcomings found by the Court in the present judgments continues to be examined within the framework of the Kalashnikov group (Application No. 47095/99) and that the closure of these cases therefore in no way prejudges the Committee’s evaluation of the general measures in relation to poor conditions of detention and the lack of effective domestic remedies;
Recalling also that the general measures required in response to the other violations found in some of these cases are or were examined by the Committee in the cases or groups of Klyakhin, Kamaliyevy, Ponushkov, Kosheleva, Krivonosov, Guliyev, Vlasov, Gizzatova, Tarariyeva, Svinarenko and Slyadnev, Smirnov, Khudobin and Salmanov;
DECLARES that it has exercised its functions under Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention in these cases as regards the individual measures and
DECIDES to close the examination of these cases.
Appendix: List of cases
No.
Application No.
Case
Judgment of
Final on
1439/06
A.B.
14/10/2010
14/01/2011
61531/14
AFANASYEV
24/11/2016
24/11/2016
37463/04
AKHMETOV
01/04/2010
04/10/2010
33929/03
ALEKSANDR LEONIDOVICH IVANOV
23/09/2010
11/04/2011
15217/07
ALEKSANDR MAKAROV
12/03/2009
14/09/2009
14797/02
ALEKSANDR MATVEYEV
08/07/2010
08/10/2010
46468/06
ALEKSANYAN
22/12/2008
05/06/2009
205/02
ANDREY FROLOV
29/03/2007
24/09/2007
43174/10
ANDREY GORBUNOV
05/02/2013
05/05/2013
66252/14
ANDREY LAVROV
01/03/2016
01/06/2016
1750/03
ANDREYEVSKIY
29/01/2009
06/07/2009
25462/09
ASYANOV
09/10/2012
09/01/2013
67253/01
BABUSHKIN
18/10/2007
18/01/2008
37810/03
BAGEL
15/11/2007
15/02/2008
36932/02
BAKHMUTSKIY
25/06/2009
25/09/2009
106/02
BENEDIKTOV
10/05/2007
24/09/2007
57502/12
BOGOMOLOV
30/10/2014
30/10/2014
921/03
BORDIKOV
08/10/2009
08/01/2010
12543/09
BORISOV
13/03/2012
13/06/2012
66583/11
BUDANOV
09/01/2014
02/06/2014
17679/03
BUZHINAYEV
15/10/2009
15/01/2010
68337/01
BUZYCHKIN
14/10/2008
14/01/2009
39420/03
BYCHKOV
05/03/2009
05/06/2009
32719/09
CHERNYKH
24/11/2016
24/11/2016
20641/04
CHUDUN
21/06/2011
28/11/2011
4176/03
DANILIN
16/09/2010
16/12/2010
41461/10
DIRDIZOV
27/11/2012
27/02/2013
4265/06
DMITRIY ROZHIN
23/10/2012
23/01/2013
30268/03
DMITRIY SAZONOV
01/03/2012
01/06/2012
66231/14
DMITRIYEV
06/12/2016
06/12/2016
1066/05
DOROGAYKIN
10/02/2011
10/05/2011
66802/01
DOROKHOV
14/02/2008
14/05/2008
44187/04
E. A.
23/05/2013
23/08/2013
43710/07
FETISOV AND OTHERS
17/01/2012
04/06/2012
42526/07
G.
21/06/2016
21/09/2016
41550/02
GADAMAURI AND KADYRBEKOV
05/07/2011
28/11/2011
52431/07
GAVRILOVA
18/10/2016
18/10/2016
1900/04
GELD
27/03/2012
27/06/2012
3242/03
GLADKIY
21/12/2010
20/06/2011
52058/99
GORODNITCHEV
24/05/2007
12/11/2007
38711/03
GOROSHCHENYA
22/04/2010
04/10/2010
30983/02
GRISHIN
15/11/2007
02/06/2008
8217/04
GUBIN
17/06/2010
17/09/2010
36941/02
GUBKIN
23/04/2009
23/07/2009
67413/01
GULTYAYEVA
01/04/2010
01/07/2010
41828/10
GURENKO
05/02/2013
05/05/2013
34000/02
IGOR IVANOV
07/06/2007
30/01/2008
28505/09
ISTRATOV
16/10/2014
16/10/2014
30575/08
IVKO
15/12/2015
02/05/2016
54427/08
IZMUTDIN ISAYEV
29/10/2015
29/10/2015
26073/09
KARBYSHEV
13/03/2014
13/03/2014
32917/13
KHALVASH
15/12/2015
02/05/2016
5829/04
KHODORKOVSKIY
31/05/2011
28/11/2011
59696/00
KHUDOBIN
26/10/2006
26/01/2007
54436/14
KLIMOV
04/10/2016
30/01/2017
54996/07
KLYUKIN
17/10/2013
17/02/2014
2052/08
KOKOSHKINA
28/05/2009
06/11/2009
26436/05
KOLUNOV
09/10/2012
09/01/2013
12987/15
KONDRULIN
20/09/2016
30/01/2017
67086/01
KOROBOV AND OTHERS
27/03/2008
27/06/2008
24677/10
KORYAK
13/11/2012
13/02/2013
69535/01
KOSITSYN
12/05/2010
12/08/2010
7782/04
KOVALEVA
02/12/2010
02/03/2011
33099/08
KOZHOKAR
16/12/2010
20/06/2011
4963/06
KURUSHIN
15/10/2015
15/10/2015
13182/04
KUTEPOV
05/12/2013
14/04/2014
62208/00
LABZOV
16/06/2005
16/09/2005
25664/05
LIND
06/12/2007
02/06/2008
32863/13
LITVINOV
22/03/2016
22/06/2016
12008/03
LUTOKHIN
08/04/2010
08/07/2010
8589/08
M.S.
10/07/2014
10/10/2014
52526/07
MAKSHAKOV
24/05/2016
24/08/2016
6954/02
MALTABAR AND MALTABAR
29/01/2009
29/04/2009
71578/11
MALYUGIN
13/03/2014
13/03/2014
26676/06
MANULIN
11/04/2013
11/07/2013
14850/03
MATYUSH
09/12/2008
09/03/2009
63378/00
MAYZIT
20/01/2005
06/07/2005
35421/05
MECHENKOV
07/02/2008
07/07/2008
34044/08
MELA
23/10/2014
23/01/2015
52697/99
MIKADZE
07/06/2007
12/11/2007
38758/05
MOROZOV
12/11/2015
12/02/2016
3267/03
MOSKALYUK
14/01/2010
14/04/2010
6521/07
MYSIN
16/10/2014
16/10/2014
13591/05
NAZAROV
26/11/2009
26/02/2010
66823/12
NIZOV
02/05/2017
02/05/2017
58530/08
NOGIN
15/01/2015
01/06/2015
66460/01
NOVOSELOV
02/06/2005
02/09/2005
50149/11
OLEG ZHURAVLEV
10/07/2014
10/07/2014 (rectified on 23/09/2014)
9807/02
OVCHINNIKOV
17/06/2010
17/09/2010
8741/15
PASHKEVICH
13/12/2016
13/12/2016
30112/04
PETRENKO
20/01/2011
20/04/2011
52873/11
PETROV
06/07/2017
06/07/2017
3933/12
PISKUNOV
04/10/2016
04/01/2017
34393/03
PITALEV
30/07/2009
30/10/2009
1606/02
POPOV AND VOROBYEV
23/04/2009
23/07/2009
13579/09
RAZVYAZKIN
03/07/2012
03/10/2012
56027/10
RESHETNYAK
08/01/2013
08/04/2013
59443/12
REZNIK AND GUZEYEVA
04/10/2016
04/10/2016
4532/04
ROMOKHOV
16/12/2010
20/06/2011
17564/06
SADRETDINOV
24/05/2016
24/08/2016
15492/09
SAKHVADZE
10/01/2012
09/07/2012
15591/03
SELEZNEV
26/06/2008
01/12/2008
2689/12
SEMIKHVOSTOV
06/02/2014
07/07/2014
5993/08
SERGEY BABUSHKIN
28/11/2013,
16/10/2014
28/02/2014,
16/01/2015
33023/07
SERGEY VASILYEV
17/10/2013
17/01/2014
23939/02
SHCHERBAKOV
17/06/2010
17/09/2010
34959/07
SHCHERBAKOV (No. 2)
24/10/2013
24/01/2014
23691/06
SHTEYN (STEIN)
18/06/2009
18/09/2009
25432/05
SKACHKOV
07/10/2010
07/01/2011
918/02
SOLOVYEVY
24/04/2012
24/07/2012
63955/00
SUKHOVOY
27/03/2008
27/06/2008
33761/05
TERESHCHENKO
05/06/2014
05/09/2014
25604/06
TOMAYLY
17/09/2015
17/09/2015
78774/13
TOPEKHIN
10/05/2016
17/10/2016
36898/03
TREPASHKIN
19/07/2007
19/10/2007
28333/13
TSELOVALNIK
08/10/2015
08/01/2016
56097/07
TYCHKO
11/06/2015
11/09/2015
10641/09
USHAKOV
25/10/2011
25/01/2012
20326/04
VADIM KOVALEV
10/05/2011
10/08/2011
19936/04
VALERIY LOPATA
30/10/2012
30/01/2013
16264/05
VASILIY VASILYEV
19/02/2013
19/05/2013
49106/09
VASILYADI
22/11/2016
22/11/2016
2974/05
VASYUKOV
05/04/2011
15/09/2011
24202/05
VELIYEV
24/06/2010
24/09/2010
53120/08
VIDISH
15/03/2016
15/06/2016
27122/10
VINOGRADOV
07/03/2017
07/03/2017
21503/04
VLADIMIR KOZLOV
20/05/2010
20/08/2010
7772/04
VLADIMIR KRIVONOSOV
15/07/2010
22/11/2010
45196/04
VOLCHKOV
14/10/2010
14/01/2011
33302/08
VOROBYEV
16/10/2014
16/10/2014
18813/06
VYATKIN
11/04/2013
11/07/2013
591/07
YEPISHIN
27/06/2013
27/09/2013
41833/04
YEVGENIY ALEKSEYENKO
27/01/2011
27/04/2011
22405/04
YEVGENIY BOGDANOV
26/02/2015
26/05/2015
37858/08
ZENKOV
30/04/2014
30/07/2014
35297/05
ZENTSOV AND OTHERS
23/10/2012
23/01/2013
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy