Resolution CM/ResDH(2018)230
Execution of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights
123 cases against the Russian Federation
(Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 7 June 2018 at the 1318th meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies)
The Committee of Ministers, under the terms of Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, which provides that the Committee supervises the execution of final judgments of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter “the Convention” and “the Court”),
Having regard to the final judgments transmitted by the Court to the Committee in these cases and to the violations established on account of various irregularities concerning pre-trial detention (violations of Article 5 of the Convention);
Having regard also to the violations established in some cases related to poor conditions of pre-trial detention, transport and confinement in a courthouse; length of criminal proceedings; unjustified in camera trials; breach of the presumption of innocence; unlawful composition of the court; and censorship of correspondence with the European Court (violations of Articles 3, 6, 8 13 and 34 of the Convention);
Recalling the respondent State’s obligation, under Article 46, paragraph 1, of the Convention, to abide by all final judgments in cases to which it has been a party and that this obligation entails, over and above the payment of any sums awarded by the Court, the adoption by the authorities of the respondent State, where required:
- of individual measures to put an end to violations established and erase their consequences so as to achieve as far as possible restitutio in integrum; and
- of general measures preventing similar violations;
Having invited the government of the respondent State to inform the Committee of the measures taken to comply with the above-mentioned obligation;
Having noted the information provided regarding the payment of the just satisfaction awarded by the Court;
Considering that the question of individual measures has been resolved, given that the applicants are no longer in pre-trial detention; that they no longer suffer the consequences of the violations established in respect of Articles 6 (length of proceedings), 8 and 34 of the Convention; and that the domestic law allows for the reopening of criminal proceedings found by the Court to have been unfair;
Recalling that the question of the general measures required in response to the shortcomings found by the Court in the present judgments as regards the irregularities related to pre-trial detention continues to be examined within the framework of the Klyakhin v. Russian Federation group of cases and that the closure of these cases therefore in no way prejudges the Committee’s evaluation of the general measures in the Klyakhin group;
Recalling also that the general measures required in response to the other violations found in some of these cases are or were examined by the Committee in the cases or groups Kalashnikov, Guliyev, Salmanov, Smirnova (Resolution CM/ResDH(2017)168), Belashev, Khuzhin and Others, Fedotova (Resolution CM/ResDH(2017)167) and Ponushkov;
DECLARES that it has exercised its functions under Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention in these cases as regards the individual measures and
DECIDES to close the examination of these cases.
Appendix: list of cases
Application
Case
Judgment of
Final on
9096/09
ABASHEV
27/06/2013
27/09/2013
10638/08
ALEKHIN
30/07/2009
30/10/2009
12993/05
ALEKSANDR DMITRIYEV
07/05/2015
07/08/2015
7087/04
ALEKSANDR NOVIKOV
11/07/2013
11/10/2013
48243/11
ALEKSANDR SHEVCHENKO
23/07/2015
14/12/2015
26764/06+
ALEKSANDROV AND OTHERS
24/11/2016
24/11/2016
10387/07+
ANTSIFEROV AND NOVIKOV
22/11/2016
22/11/2016
2737/04
AVDEYEV AND VERYAYEV
09/07/2009
09/10/2009
72967/01
BELEVITSKIY
01/03/2007
01/06/2007
22053/02
BELOV
03/07/2008
03/10/2008
1253/04+
BIRYUCHENKO AND OTHERS
11/12/2014
11/12/2014
31917/07
BOCHAROV
20/09/2016
20/09/2016
11214/07
BOYCHUK
13/12/2016
13/12/2016
1603/02
BROVCHENKO
18/12/2008
18/03/2009
8681/06
BULIN
29/03/2016
29/03/2016
4345/06
BURMAGA
20/09/2016
20/09/2016
7923/04
BUTUSOF
22/12/2009
22/03/2010
41472/06+
CHERNOYVAN AND OTHERS
20/09/2016
20/09/2016
17504/07
CHUPRIKOV
12/06/2014
12/09/2014
39655/10
DERGALEV
04/07/2017
04/07/2017
80015/12
DEVTEROV
19/07/2016
19/07/2016
11886/05
DOLGOVA
02/03/2006
03/07/2006
48929/08
DUBINSKIY
03/07/2014
03/10/2014
49689/10
DZHASYBAYEVA
22/11/2016
22/11/2016
25071/07
DZHAVADOV
08/11/2016
08/11/2016
1937/05
EDUARD SHABALIN
16/10/2014
16/01/2015
26386/02
FURSENKO
24/04/2008
24/07/2008
39249/03
G.O.
18/10/2011
18/01/2012
16120/07+
GORBATENKO AND SHEYDYAKOV
15/11/2016
15/11/2016
42940/06
GOVORUSHKO
25/10/2007
25/01/2008
14807/08
GRISHIN
24/07/2012
24/10/2012
67542/01
GUSEV
15/05/2008
15/08/2008
27193/02
IGNATOV
24/05/2007
24/08/2007
20756/04
ISAYEV
22/10/2009
22/01/2010
31691/10
ISTOMIN
15/10/2015
15/10/2015
54749/12
KALININ
19/02/2015
19/02/2015
37894/07
KASHPRUK
08/12/2015
08/12/2015
6847/02
KHUDOYOROV
08/11/2005
12/04/2006
11010/10
KISELEV
22/11/2016
22/11/2016
29985/05
KISLITSA
19/06/2012
19/09/2012
44925/06
KLEYN
05/01/2016
06/06/2016
34942/05
KOLKUTIN
12/07/2016
12/07/2016
2450/04
KONDRATYEV
09/04/2009
09/07/2009
41169/02
KONONOVICH
09/07/2009
09/10/2009
75039/01
KORCHUGANOVA
08/06/2006
08/09/2006
48416/09
KORKIN
12/11/2015
02/05/2016
1600/09
KOROLEVA
13/11/2012
13/02/2013
7955/07
KOSYANOV
22/11/2016
22/11/2016
13008/13+
KOVYAZIN AND OTHERS
17/09/2015
01/02/2016
49961/10
KRAVETS
24/11/2016
24/11/2016
13991/05
KRIKUNOV
04/12/2014
20/04/2015
40025/10
LAGUNOV
01/03/2016
01/03/2016
20571/04
LAMAZHYK
30/07/2009
30/10/2009
4493/04
LEBEDEV
25/10/2007
02/06/2008
44511/04
LOGVINENKO
17/06/2010
17/09/2010
3243/06
LOSEVSKIY AND OTHERS
16/10/2014
16/10/2014
60249/13
LYUBIMOV
11/10/2016
11/10/2016
6277/06
LYUBUSHKIN
22/10/2014
14/03/2016
5962/03
MAKARENKO
22/12/2009
28/06/2010
7064/05
MAMEDOVA
01/06/2006
23/10/2006
54929/09
MANDRYKIN
11/10/2016
11/10/2016
49848/10
MANEROV
05/01/2016
05/04/2016
9487/02
MEDVEDEV
15/07/2010
15/10/2010
33803/04
MIKHALCHUK
23/04/2015
23/07/2015
36911/02
MISHKETKUL AND OTHERS
24/05/2007
12/11/2007
9237/14
MYALICHEV
08/11/2016
08/11/2016
40288/06
NAIMDZHON YAKUBOV
12/11/2015
12/02/2016
55669/00
NAKHMANOVITCH
02/03/2006
02/06/2006
17614/08
NAZAROV
13/12/2016
13/12/2016
40573/08
NOVOKRESHCHIN
27/11/2014
27/11/2014
22631/04
OLYUNIN
19/04/2016
19/04/2016
45100/98
PANCHENKO
08/02/2005
08/05/2005
35878/08
PANOV
15/11/2016
15/11/2016
55299/07
PASTUKHOV AND YELAGIN
19/12/2013
19/03/2014
38726/05
PELEVIN
10/02/2011
10/05/2011
9994/06
PODDUBNYY AND BABKOV
26/06/2016
26/06/2016
4320/05
POLOVINKIN
25/11/2010
25/02/2011
28957/02
PSHEVECHERSKIY
24/05/2007
24/08/2007
61767/08
PYATKOV
13/11/2012
13/02/2013
47837/06
RAKHIMBERDIYEV
18/09/2014
18/12/2014
37311/08
ROMAN PETROV
15/12/2015
15/03/2016
23215/02
ROMANOVA
11/10/2011
08/03/2012
64140/00
ROZHKOV
19/07/2007
12/11/2007
30930/02
SAVENKOVA
04/03/2010
04/06/2010
41545/06
SEGEDA
19/12/2013
19/03/2014
1985/05+
SERGEY DENISOV AND OTHERS
19/04/2016
12/09/2016
3194/08
SERGEY MEDVEDEV
30/07/2009
30/10/2009
27335/13
SHALYA
13/11/2014
13/11/2014
7649/02
SHCHEGLYUK
14/12/2006
14/03/2007
2563/06
SHENOYEV
10/06/2010
10/09/2010
44815/10
SHEPEL
24/05/2016
24/05/2016
45373/05
SHIKUTA
11/04/2013
11/07/2013
65734/01
SHUKHARDIN
28/06/2007
28/09/2007
3947/03
SILIN
24/04/2008
24/07/2008
33123/08
SIZOV
15/03/2011
15/06/2011
28018/05
STRELETS
06/11/2012
06/02/2013
2366/07
SUSLOV
29/05/2012
29/08/2012
14824/02
SYCHEV
23/02/2010
23/05/2010
17628/03
SYNGAYEVSKIY
27/03/2012
27/06/2012
24649/10+
SYUSYURA AND OVECHKIN
21/07/2016
21/07/2016
14248/05
TREPASHKIN No. 2
16/12/2010
20/06/2011
5235/09
TSARENKO
03/03/2011
03/06/2011
16854/03
TSARKOV
16/07/2009
16/10/2009
38911/07
TUMANOV
11/10/2016
11/10/2016
19857/09
URMANOV
11/10/2016
11/10/2016
46871/07+
USHAKOV AND OTHERS
22/09/2016
22/09/2016
41716/08
VALERIY KOVALENKO
29/05/2012
29/08/2012
57541/09
VALERIY SAMOYLOV
24/01/2012
24/04/2012
2708/02
VLADIMIR SOLOVYEV
24/05/2007
12/11/2007
58104/14+
WALTER AND OTHERS
21/07/2016
21/07/2016
152/04
YEFIMENKO
12/02/2013
08/07/2013
36551/07
YELIZAROV
26/03/2009
26/06/2009
28020/05
YEVGENIY GUSEV
05/12/2013
05/03/2014
6479/05
YEVGENIY KUZMIN
03/05/2012
03/08/2012
7243/10+
YEVSTRATOV AND RUDAKOV
19/07/2016
19/07/2016
40258/03
YUDAYEV
15/01/2009
15/04/2009
48982/08
YURIY RUDAKOV
15/01/2015
15/04/2015
5453/08
YURIY YAKOVLEV
29/04/2010
29/07/2010
676/09
ZAKHAROV
11/10/2016
11/10/2016
42080/11
ZAVORIN
15/01/2015
15/01/2015
51445/09
ZHEREBIN
24/03/2016
12/09/2016
22965/06
ZHULIN
18/10/2016
18/10/2016
16262/05
ZUYEV
19/02/2013
19/05/2013
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy