Resolution CM/ResDH(2019)353
Execution of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights
95 cases against Turkey
(Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 11 December 2019
at the 1363rd meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies)
The Committee of Ministers, under the terms of Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, which provides that the Committee supervises the execution of final judgments of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter “the Convention” and “the Court”,
Having regard to the final judgments transmitted by the Court to the Committee in these cases and to the violations established on account of the non-enforcement or delayed enforcement of domestic judicial decisions, mostly delivered against entities owned or controlled by the State (violations of Article 6, paragraph 1, and of Article 1 of Protocol No.1);
Recalling that a number of cases also concern excessive length of judicial proceedings (violation of Article 6, paragraph 1) (this issue was examined under the Ormancı and Others group of cases (see CM/ResDH(2014)298));
Recalling the respondent State’s obligation, under Article 46, paragraph 1, of the Convention, to abide by all final judgments in cases to which it has been a party and that this obligation entails, over and above the payment of any sums awarded by the Court, the adoption by the authorities of the respondent State, where required:
- of individual measures to put an end to violations established and erase their consequences so as to achieve as far as possible restitutio in integrum; and
- of general measures preventing similar violations;
Having invited the government of the respondent State to inform the Committee of the measures taken to comply with the above-mentioned obligation;
Having examined the action report provided by the government indicating the individual measures adopted to give effect to the judgments including the information provided regarding the payment of the just satisfaction awarded by the Court (see document DH-DD(2019)1324);
Recalling that the question of general measures required in response to the shortcomings found by the Court in these judgments continues to be examined within the framework of the Ahmet Kilic (38473/02), Yerebasmaz (14710/03), Bozuyuk (3595/05), Akpınar (41246/98), Kranta (31277/03), Kaynak and Cokkalander (34445/08); Kizmaz (34461/08) cases; that moreover the latter two cases also require individual measures; and that the closure of the cases listed below therefore in no way prejudges the Committee’s continuing evaluation of the general measures required;
DECLARES that it has exercised its functions under Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention in the cases listed in Appendix as regards the individual measures and
DECIDES to close the examination of these cases.
Appendix: list of cases
Application
Case
Judgment of
Final on
34459/08
ABDULKADİR DEMİR
09/10/2012
09/10/2012
53329/08
ABDURRAHMAN YILDIRIM
13/12/2011
13/03/2012
27150/02
AK
31/07/2007
31/10/2007
6982/04
AKDÜZ AND OTHERS
22/09/2009
22/12/2009
34448/08
AKHAN
31/05/2012
31/08/2012
12146/02
AKINCI
08/04/2008
08/07/2008
42894/04+
ARAT AND OTHERS
13/01/2009
13/04/2009
35528/03
ARICI AND OTHERS
28/04/2009
28/07/2009
28270/02
ATEŞ HÜSEYIN AND ATEŞ MEHMET
13/10/2009
13/01/2010
5325/02+
AYGÜN AND OTHERS
20/11/2007
20/02/2008
35075/97
BABA
24/10/2006
24/01/2007
10457/08
BERTAN
03/11/2011
03/02/2012
34456/08
BEŞİRE ÖZER AND OTHERS
09/10/2012
09/10/2012
34458/08
BEŞİRE ÖZER AND OTHERS No. 2
09/10/2012
09/10/2012
41166/05
BILGIN AND ORSEL
13/12/2011
13/03/2012
14558/03
BUYRUK
08/04/2008
08/07/2008
34465/08
CEMİLE KALENDER
09/10/2012
09/10/2012
34468/08
ÇETİNKAYA AND OTHERS
09/10/2012
09/10/2012
74069/01+
ÇIÇEK AND ÖZTEMEL AND 6 OTHER CASES
03/05/2007
03/08/2007
2620/05
ÇOBAN AND OTHERS
24/01/2008
24/04/2008
35561/05
COSKUN AND OTHERS
13/12/2011
13/03/2012
28152/02
DEMIRHAN, GÖRSAV AND ÇELIK
05/06/2007
05/09/2007
77361/01
DILDAR
12/12/2006
12/03/2007
10435/08
DINCER AND OTHERS
03/11/2011
03/02/2012
14738/06
DOMANIC
13/12/2011
13/03/2012
22261/03
DURMAZ M. ALI
08/01/2009
08/04/2009
25952/03+
DÜZDEMIR AND GÜNER
27/05/2010
27/08/2010
28877/03
EKICI AND OTHERS
23/09/2008
23/12/2008
34466/08
EMİNE KALENDER AND OTHERS
09/10/2012
09/10/2012
34467/08
EMİNE KALENDER AND OTHERS No. 2
09/10/2012
09/10/2012
34449/08
ERDAL
09/10/2012
09/10/2012
1520/06
ERDEN OSMAN
26/10/2010
26/01/2011
4266/02
ERGIN AND OTHERS
30/11/2010
30/11/2010
34472/08
FATMA ÇOKKALENDER AND OTHERS
09/10/2012
09/10/2012
34455/08
FATMA ÖZER AND OTHERS
09/10/2012
09/10/2012
17597/03
FIRAT AND OTHERS
06/10/2009
06/01/2010
54223/08
GERÇEK AND OTHERS
13/12/2011
13/03/2012
53323/08
GEZEN
13/12/2011
13/03/2012
54227/08
GÖKÇE
13/12/2011
13/03/2012
33994/06+
GULER AND KEKEC
07/06/2011
07/09/2011
34450/08
GÜLİZAR ÇEVİK
31/05/2012
31/08/2012
3875/06
GULSOY
13/12/2011
13/03/2012
10458/08
GULTEKIN AND OTHERS
03/11/2011
03/02/2012
41150/05
GUMUS
13/12/2011
13/03/2012
29666/06
HALISE TUNCEL AND OTHERS
13/12/2011
13/03/2012
34453/08
İBRAHİM HALİL ÇETİNKAYA AND OTHERS
31/05/2012
31/08/2012
34463/08
İNANOĞLU AND AKHAN
09/10/2012
09/10/2012
34464/08
İNANOĞLU AND OTHERS
09/10/2012
09/10/2012
10450/08
İŞCAN
03/11/2011
03/02/2012
10434/08
ISIK AND OTHERS
03/11/2011
03/02/2012
38323/04
KAÇAR AND OTHERS
22/07/2008
22/10/2008
34470/08
KAHRAMAN ÇOKKALENDER AND OTHERS
09/10/2012
09/10/2012
34473/08
KAHRAMAN ÇOKKALENDER AND OTHERS No. 2
09/10/2012
09/10/2012
4562/08
KALIN AND BILGIN
03/11/2011
03/02/2012
29016/04
KAPLAN MEHMET
09/12/2008
09/03/2009
3224/05
KAPLAN MEHMET ALI AND OTHERS
16/12/2008
16/03/2009
34452/08
KARACA AND OTHERS
31/05/2012
31/08/2012
14886/05
KARACAN
08/06/2010
08/09/2010
54170/08
KAZANLAR
13/12/2011
13/03/2012
4397/08
KEMAL TURHAN
03/11/2011
03/02/2012
34474/08
KEZIBAN ÇOKKALENDER AND OTHERS
09/10/2012
09/10/2012
36424/06
KILIÇ KEMAL
13/01/2009
13/04/2009
34462/08
KIZMAZ AND KAYA
09/10/2012
09/10/2012
20313/03
KURT AND OTHERS
15/06/2010
15/09/2010
27817/04
KUŞ
08/07/2008
01/12/2008
13062/03
KUZU
17/01/2006
17/04/2006
14030/06
MESCI
13/12/2011
13/03/2012
10443/08
NACİ AKKUŞ AND NECMİ AKKUŞ
03/11/2011
03/02/2012
4387/08
NECATI EROL
03/11/2011
03/02/2012
14604/05+
OKTAŞ AND OTHERS
18/05/2010
18/08/2010
37243/05
ORAY
20/04/2010
20/07/2010
53339/08
OZKARA AND TELLI
13/12/2011
13/03/2012
31462/07
SAHIDE KORKMAZ
12/07/2011
12/07/2011
45559/04
ŞAHIN ABIDIN
18/12/2007
18/03/2008
6124/02
ŞAHIN MEHMET EMIN
24/03/2009
24/06/2009
11912/04
SAKARYA
20/05/2008
01/12/2008
34469/08
SALİHE ÇETİNKAYA AND OTHERS
09/10/2012
09/10/2012
54154/08
SAPMAZ
13/12/2011
13/03/2012
11098/04
SARIKAYA YAVUZ
13/01/2009
13/04/2009
34993/05
SAT
14/06/2011
14/09/2011
13090/04
SELÇUK MEHMET
10/06/2008
10/09/2008
4631/06
SENIRMAK
13/12/2011
13/03/2012
27402/03
SEVGILI
18/12/2007
18/03/2008
54250/08
TAKTAKOGLU
13/12/2011
13/03/2012
37054/03+
TOK AND OTHERS
20/11/2007
20/02/2008
14937/06
TOPEL
20/12/2011
20/03/2012
14935/06
TUNA
13/12/2011
13/03/2012
74405/01
TÜTÜNCÜ AND OTHERS
18/10/2005
18/01/2006
26664/05
UYGURER İNŞAAT SAN. TIC. LTD ŞTI
06/10/2009
06/01/2010
9923/05+
YAVUZ AND OTHERS
05/05/2009
05/08/2009
14295/05
YAVUZ NURTEN
20/05/2010
20/08/2010
10985/02+
YERLIKAYA
08/04/2008
08/07/2008
13721/04
YILDIZ VAIDE AND OTHERS
20/10/2009
20/01/2010
39994/04
YILMAZ M.
27/10/2009
27/01/2010
54173/08
ZERDALI AND OTHERS
13/12/2011
13/03/2012
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy