Resolution CM/ResDH(2017)138
Execution of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights
Belvedere Alberghiera S.R.L group against Italy
(Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 10 May 2017 at the 1286th meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies)
The Committee of Ministers, under the terms of Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, which provides that the Committee supervises the execution of final judgments of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter “the Convention” and “the Court”),
Having regard to the final judgments (see list in Appendix) transmitted by the Court to the Committee in these cases and to the violations of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 established on account of the inadequate guarantees to secure the lawfulness of emergency expropriations by local authorities and excessively restrictive compensation rules since the 1990s ("indirect expropriation");
Recalling the respondent State’s obligation, under Article 46, paragraph 1, of the Convention, to abide by all final judgments in cases to which it has been a party and that this obligation entails, over and above the payment of any sums awarded by the Court, the adoption by the authorities of the respondent State, where required:
- of individual measures to put an end to violations established and erase their consequences so as to achieve as far as possible restitutio in integrum; and
- of general measures preventing similar violations;
Having invited the government of the respondent State to inform the Committee of the measures taken to comply with the above-mentioned obligation;
Having examined the action report provided by the government indicating the measures adopted in order to give effect to the judgments including the information provided regarding the payment of the just satisfaction awarded by the Court (see document DH-DD(2017)304);
Recalling that in 12 cases concerning the same general problem, not included in the Appendix, the Committee continues to examine the issue of the payment of the just satisfaction awarded by the Court;
Having satisfied itself that all the measures required by Article 46, paragraph 1, have been adopted,
DECLARES that it has exercised its functions under Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention in the cases listed in Appendix and
DECIDES to close the examination thereof.
Appendix – list of cases
Application n°
Case
Judgment of
Final on
31524/96
BELVEDERE ALBERGHIERA S.R.L.
30/05/2000
30/10/2003
30/08/2000
30/01/2004
41040/98
ACCIARDI AND CAMPAGNA
19/05/2005
03/05/2007
12/10/2005
Friendly settlement
33312/03
BENENATI AND SCILLAMÀ
04/02/2014
04/02/2014
71603/01
LAURA BINOTTI
13/10/2005
29/07/2010
13/01/2006
29/10/2010
63632/00
CARLA BINOTTI
17/11/2005
29/07/2010
17/02/2006
29/10/2010
60890/00
BORGHESI
22/05/2012
22/08/2012
20236/02
CAPONE
06/12/2005
07/06/2007
06/03/2006
Friendly settlement
62592/00
CAPONE No.2
15/07/2005
22/07/2008
30/11/2005
22/10/2008
24638/94
CARBONARA AND VENTURA
30/05/2000
11/12/2003
30/05/2000
11/12/2003
63861/00
CARLETTA
15/07/2005
05/06/2012
30/11/2005
05/09/2012
37178/02
CASOLARO CAMMILLETTI
14/06/2011
14/09/2011
21457/04
CEGLIA
19/10/2006
29/07/2010
19/01/2007
29/10/2010
63620/00
CHIRO’ AND 3 OTHERS No. 1
11/10/2005
27/07/2010
11/01/2006
27/10/2010
65137/01
CHIRO’ AND 3 OTHERS No. 2
11/10/2005
27/07/2010
11/01/2006
27/10/2010
67196/01
CHIRO’ AND 3 OTHERS No. 4
11/10/2005
27/07/2010
11/01/2006
27/10/2010
67197/01
CHIRO’ AND 3 OTHERS No. 5
11/10/2005
27/07/2010
11/01/2006
27/10/2010
63296/00
COLACRAI No. 1
13/10/2005
29/07/2010
13/01/2006
29/10/2010
63868/00
COLACRAI No. 2
15/07/2005
05/06/2012
30/11/2005
05/09/2012
63633/00
COLAZZO
13/10/2005
05/06/2012
13/01/2006
05/09/2012
14828/02
CROCI AND OTHERS
21/09/2006
24/07/2012
21/12/2006
24/10/2012
16220/03
CUCINOTTA
10/07/2012
10/07/2012
26010/04
D’ASTA
16/12/2014
16/12/2014
68852/01
DE ANGELIS AND OTHERS
21/12/2006
19/10/2010
21/03/2007
19/01/2011
65278/01
DE CATERINA AND OTHERS
28/06/2011
28/09/2011
24294/03
DE GREGORIO
18/12/2012
18/12/2012
41248/04
DE NIGRIS No. 1
05/10/2006
14/12/2010
05/01/2007
14/03/2011
71175/01
DE PASQUALE
13/10/2005
17/01/2008
13/01/2006
17/04/2008
176/04
DE SCISCIO
20/04/2006
29/07/2010
20/07/2006
29/10/2010
72795/01
DE STEFANO AND OTHERS
14/06/2011
14/09/2011
19403/03
DEDDA AND FRAGASSI
21/09/2006
12/04/2011
21/12/2006
12/07/2011
44897/98
DI COLA
15/12/2005
18/05/2010
15/03/2006
18/08/2010
73575/01
DI PIETRO
02/11/2006
26/06/2012
02/02/2007
19/11/2012
64111/00
DOMINICI
15/11/2005
07/06/2007
15/02/2006
Friendly settlement
63242/00
DONATI
15/07/2005
15/11/2012
30/11/2005
08/07/2013
65272/01
DORA CHIRÒ
11/10/2005
27/07/2010
11/01/2006
27/10/2010
71310/01
EMANUELE CALANDRA AND OTHERS
26/10/2006
19/10/2010
26/01/2007
19/01/2011
19734/92
F.S.
Interim Resolution DH(98)209 of 10/07/98[1]
-
75259/01
FARINA
17/05/2011
17/08/2011
65165/01
FERRARA
08/11/2012
08/11/2012
63864/00
FIORE
13/10/2005
29/07/2010
13/01/2006
29/10/2010
67794/01
FIORELLO
17/05/2011
17/08/2011
9119/03
GENOVESE AND OTHERS
02/02/2006
01/02/2011
03/07/2006
01/05/2011
16041/02
GIACOBBE AND OTHERS
15/12/2005
01/02/2011
15/03/2006
01/05/2011
69878/01
GIANAZZA
05/10/2006
14/10/2008
05/01/2007
Friendly settlement
35941/03
GIANNI AND OTHERS
30/03/2006
31/05/2007
30/06/2006
Friendly settlement
1780/04
GIANNITTO
28/01/2014
28/01/2014
36228/02
GIANQUITTI AND OTHERS
22/01/2013
22/01/2013
60124/00
GRAVINA
15/11/2005
27/07/2010
15/02/2006
27/10/2010
58858/00
GUISO-GALLISAY
08/12/2005
22/12/2009
08/03/2006
Grand Chamber
67992/01
IANDOLI
14/06/2011
14/09/2011
35638/03
IMMOBILIARE CERRO S.A.S.
23/02/2006
05/06/2012
23/05/2006
05/09/2012
162/04
RITA IPPOLITI
16/11/2006
19/10/2010
16/02/2007
19/01/2011
12263/05
IPPOLITI
26/10/2006
26/03/2007
62876/00
ISTITUTO DIOCESANO PER IL SOSTENTAMENTO DEL CLEROAND
17/11/2005
09/10/2007
17/02/2006
Friendly settlement
13396/03
IULIANO AND OTHERS
14/12/2006
19/06/2012
14/03/2007
19/09/2012
20935/03
IZZO
02/03/2006
19/10/2010
02/06/2006
19/01/2011
58119/00
LA ROSA AND ALBA No. 1
11/10/2005
27/07/2010
11/01/2006
27/10/2010
58386/00
LA ROSA AND ALBA No. 3
15/11/2005
27/07/2010
15/02/2006
27/10/2010
63238/00
LA ROSA AND ALBA No. 4
13/10/2005
05/06/2012
13/01/2006
05/09/2012
63239/00
LA ROSA AND ALBA No. 5
11/07/2006
27/07/2010
11/10/2006
27/10/2010
63240/00
LA ROSA AND 3 OTHERS No. 6
15/07/2005
29/07/2010
30/11/2005
29/10/2010
63241/00
LA ROSA AND ALBA No. 7
17/11/2005
29/07/2010
17/02/2006
29/10/2010
63285/00
LA ROSA AND ALBA No. 8
15/07/2005
05/06/2012
15/10/2005
05/09/2012
10022/02
LABBRUZZO
05/10/2006
05/05/2009
05/01/2007
Friendly settlement
56578/00
LANTERI
15/11/2005
29/01/2013
15/02/2006
29/04/2013
12912/04
LO BUE AND OTHERS
13/07/2006
29/07/2010
13/10/2006
29/10/2010
66394/01
ROSARIO LOMBARDI
15/11/2012
15/11/2012
14130/02
MACRÌ AND OTHERS
12/07/2011
12/10/2011
997/05
MAIORANO AND SERAFINI
25/11/2014
25/11/2014
38591/06
MANGO
05/05/2015
05/05/2015
63866/00
MASELLI
13/10/2005
29/07/2010
13/01/2006
29/10/2010
24887/03
MASELLI
18/12/2012
18/12/2012
61211/00
MASELLI No. 2
11/07/2006
27/07/2010
11/10/2006
27/10/2010
43663/98
MASON AND OTHERS
17/05/2005
12/10/2005
35174/03
MATTHIAS AND OTHERS
02/11/2006
17/07/2012
02/02/2007
17/10/2012
9512/04
MESSENI NEMAGNA AND OTHERS
05/10/2006
19/06/2012
05/01/2007
19/09/2012
77156/01
MILAZZO
02/11/2006
26/06/2012
02/02/2007
26/09/2012
69269/01
MOREA
25/01/2007
29/04/2008
25/04/2007
Friendly settlement
14817/02
MUSELLA AND ESPOSITO
22/01/2013
22/01/2013
64264/01
NOTARNICOLA
05/10/2006
12/04/2011
05/01/2007
12/07/2011
6015/05
PAGNOZZI
04/02/2014
04/02/2014
1537/04
PASCUCCI
14/01/2014
14/01/2014
36818/97
PASCULLI
17/05/2005
04/12/2007
12/10/2005
02/06/2008
15348/03
PERRELLA No. 2
02/11/2006
27/03/2008
02/02/2007
Friendly settlement
69907/01
PRENNA AND OTHERS
09/02/2006
19/06/2012
09/05/2006
19/09/2012
67785/01
QUATTRONE
11/01/2007
01/02/2011
11/04/2007
01/05/2011
63869/00
RIVERA AND DI BONAVENTURA
14/06/2011
14/09/2011
2911/05
ROSSI AND VARIALE
03/06/2014
03/06/2014
24891/03
RUBORTONE
05/02/2013
05/02/2013
24892/03
RUBORTONE AND CARUSO
05/02/2013
05/02/2013
14231/05
RUSSO
05/05/2015
05/05/2015
65141/01
SANTINELLI AND OTHERS
17/05/2011
17/08/2011
70818/01
SCALA
18/12/2012
18/12/2012
14793/02
SCIAROTTA AND OTHERS
12/01/2006
19/10/2010
12/04/2006
19/01/2011
43662/98
SCORDINO No. 3
17/05/2005
06/03/2007
12/10/2005
09/07/2007
67790/01
SCOZZARI AND OTHERS
15/12/2005
19/10/2010
15/03/2006
19/01/2011
67198/01
SERRAO
13/10/2005
13/01/2006
77822/01
SERRILLI
06/12/2005
17/07/2008
06/03/2006
17/10/2008
77823/01+
SERRILLI AND OTHERS
17/11/2005
17/01/2007
17/02/2006
17/04/2008
16508/05
SOTIRA
08/01/2009
08/04/2009
32843/03
STEA AND OTHERS
12/03/2013
12/03/2013
25106/03
TRAPANI LOMBARDO AND OTHERS
16/11/2006
09/10/2012
16/02/2007
09/01/2013
213/04
UCCI
22/06/2006
17/02/2011
22/09/2006
17/05/2011
62984/00
UGUCCIONI
18/12/2012
18/12/2012
1717/03
VELOCCI
18/03/2008
21/04/2009
18/06/2008
Friendly settlement
24814/03
VENTURA
22/01/2013
22/01/2013
12894/04
ZAFFUTO AND OTHERS
13/07/2006
29/07/2010
13/10/2006
29/10/2010
[1] Under former Article 32 of the European Convention.
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy