Resolution CM/ResDH(2016)332
Execution of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights
196 cases against Turkey (see list appended)
(Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 9 November 2016
at the 1270th meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies)
The Committee of Ministers, under the terms of Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, which provides that the Committee supervises the execution of final judgments of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter “the Convention” and “the Court”),
Having regard to the final judgments transmitted by the Court to the Committee in these cases and to the violations established;
Recalling that the violations of the Convention found by the Court in these cases primarily concern the right to liberty and security within the context of detention on remand; other violations concern:
- the continued detention of the applicant following a release order issued (violation of Article 5 § 1) in the case of Tandoğan (9244/02) (this issue was examined under the Hamşioğlu group of cases (see Final Resolution CM/ResDH(2014)123);
- the excessive length of criminal proceedings (violations of article 6 § 1) in 110 cases and the lack of an effective remedy in this respect (violations of article 13) in 20 cases (these issues were examined under the Ormancı and Others group of cases (see Final Resolution CM/ResDH(2014)298);
- the lack of independence and impartiality of the State security courts (violations of Article 6) in the cases of Demirel (39324/98), Sevgin and Ince (46262/99), Temel and Taşkin (40159/98) (this issue was examined under the Gençel and Çıraklar groups of cases (see Final Resolutions CM/ResDH(2013)256 and ResDH(99)555) respectively);
- the violation of the right to adversarial proceedings and equality of arms, on account of the authorities’ failure to communicate to the applicants the prosecutors’ opinion before the Court of Cassation (violation of Article 6 § 1) (this issue was examined under the Göç group of cases (see Final Resolution CM/ResDH(2011)307));
- the absence of legal assistance in police custody (violations of Article 6 § 3(c)) in the cases of Dil (2611/09), Doğan and Kalın (1651/05), Feti Ateş and Others (28827/04) (this issue is being examined under the Salduz (36391/02) group of cases);
- the violation of the applicant’s right to be presumed innocent until proved guilty (violation of Art 6 § 2) in the case of Urfi Cetinkaya (19866/04) (this issue is being examined under the Dicle and Sadak case (48621/07));
- the violation of the applicant’s right to respect for his private life on account of unjustified interference by the prison authorities with his correspondence (violation of Article 8) in Fethullah Akpulat (22077/03) (this issue is being examined under the Tamer group (6289/02));
Recalling the respondent State’s obligation, under Article 46, paragraph 1, of the Convention, to abide by all final judgments in cases to which it has been a party and that this obligation entails, over and above the payment of any sums awarded by the Court, the adoption by the authorities of the respondent State, where required:
- of individual measures to put an end to violations established and erase their consequences so as to achieve as far as possible restitutio in integrum; and
- of general measures preventing similar violations;
Having invited the government of the respondent State to inform the Committee of the measures taken to comply with the above-mentioned obligation;
Having examined the action report provided by the government indicating the measures adopted in order to give effect to the judgments including the information provided regarding the payment of the just satisfaction awarded by the Court (see document DH-DD(2016)1176);
Having noted that the applications in these cases were lodged with the Court between 16 December 1996 and 5 July 2012 and that none of the applicants are currently being detained on remand;
Having satisfied itself that all the measures required by Article 46, paragraph 1, have been adopted,
DECLARES that it has exercised its functions under Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention in these cases and
DECIDES to close the examination thereof.
Appendix: List of the cases
Application
Case
Judgment of
Final on
39324/98
DEMIREL
28/01/2003
28/04/2003
10512/02
ABDULLAH YILMAZ
22/07/2008
22/10/2008
19332/04
ABAY
01/12/2009
01/03/2010
17681/04
ABDO
26/01/2010
26/04/2010
28069/07
ABDULKERIM KAYA
05/01/2010
05/04/2010
31595/07
ABDULSİTAR AKGÜL
25/06/2013
25/09/2013
15234/05
AÇAN AND OTHERS
13/05/2014
13/05/2014
61442/00+
ACUNBAY
31/05/2005
31/08/2005
38372/06+
ADIYAMAN AND ERMAN
26/10/2010
26/01/2011
77331/01
AĞDAŞ ÇETIN
19/09/2006
19/12/2006
23480/06
AKALIN
23/11/2010
23/02/2011
8076/08
AKAN AND ÇELİK
25/11/2014
25/11/2014
35561/06
AKPOLAT
08/01/2009
08/04/2009
6178/04
AKYAZ
07/07/2009
07/10/2009
23438/02
AKYOL
20/09/2007
20/12/2007
483/02
ALGUR AND OTHERS
20/11/2007
20/02/2008
24597/08
ALİ RIZA KAPLAN
13/11/2014
13/02/2015
34396/05+
ALP AND OTHERS
07/12/2010
07/03/2011
73038/01
ALTIN HIYASETTIN
24/05/2005
24/08/2005
31610/08
ALTINOK
29/11/2011
29/02/2012
44319/04
ARAZ
20/05/2010
20/08/2010
33746/02
ARI AND ŞEN
02/10/2007
02/01/2008
7933/05
ATEŞ MIZRAP
26/01/2010
26/04/2010
7987/07
ATSIZ AND OTHERS
23/06/2009
23/09/2009
30441/08+
AYDOGAN AND OTHERS
08/02/2011
08/05/2011
43550/04
AYGÜL
16/06/2009
16/09/2009
29287/02
AYHAN AND OTHERS
14/10/2008
14/01/2009
20259/06
AYTIMUR
20/05/2010
20/08/2010
43256/04
BAĞRIYANIK
05/06/2007
05/09/2007
35257/04
BAHÇELI
06/10/2009
06/01/2010
495/02
BALTACI
18/07/2006
18/10/2006
26170/03
BARIŞ
31/03/2009
30/06/2009
74337/01
BAŞTIMAR AND OTHERS
05/12/2006
05/03/2007
26896/02
BAYAM
31/07/2007
31/10/2007
28053/10
BİLAL DOĞAN
27/11/2012
27/02/2013
8610/02
BILGIN ÖZDEN
14/06/2007
14/09/2007
26891/02
BOYRAZ
20/05/2008
20/08/2008
18623/03
CAHIT DEMIREL
07/07/2009
07/10/2009
16777/06+
CAN AND GÜMÜŞ
31/03/2009
30/06/2009
7940/05
ÇARKÇI
26/06/2007
10/12/2007
26808/08
CATAL
17/04/2012
17/07/2012
37912/04
ÇAYAN BILGIN
08/12/2009
08/03/2010
45490/05
CELIK AND ABATAY
29/11/2011
29/02/2012
6670/10
ÇELİK ÖZGÜR
17/0232015
17/0232015
41746/04
ÇEVEN
24/11/2009
24/02/2010
8140/08
CEVIZ
17/07/2012
17/10/2012
14899/03
ÇIÇEKLER
22/12/2005
22/03/2006
16963/07
ÇIĞDEM
21/04/2009
21/07/2009
45977/99
ÇOBANOĞLU AND BUDAK
30/01/2007
30/04/2007
42138/07+
DEMIR AND İPEK
26/01/2010
26/04/2010
77845/01
DERECI
24/05/2005
24/08/2005
2611/09
DİL
24/09/2013
24/09/2013
66066/09
DİNÇ AND ÇAKIR
09/07/2013
09/10/2013
28551/06
DINÇ ERHAN
20/05/2010
20/08/2010
61443/00
DINLER
31/05/2005
31/08/2005
1651/05
DOGAN AND KALIN
21/12/2010
21/03/2011
54625/09
DURMUŞ AND TANŞANCIK
31/07/2012
31/07/2012
17765/02
DURSUN
03/05/2007
03/08/2007
57963/00
DUYUM
27/03/2007
09/07/2007
47280/09
EKİCİ
05/03/2013
05/03/2013
18992/03
ELĞAY
20/01/2009
20/04/2009
6194/04
ENGIN
13/10/2009
13/01/2010
41810/06+
ERCAN KARTAL
29/03/2011
29/03/2011
73359/10
ERGEZEN
08/04/2014
08/07/2014
13176/05
ERKAN İNAN
23/02/2010
23/05/2010
32008/05
ETEM KARAGÖZ
15/09/2009
15/12/2009
42956/09
EVLİYAOĞLU
05/03/2013
05/03/2013
22077/03
FETHULLAH AKPULAT
15/02/2011
15/05/2011
34759/04+
FETI ATES AND OTHERS
21/12/2010
21/03/2011
28827/04
FETI ATEŞ
10/06/2008
10/09/2008
28074/08
FİLİZ
04/03/2014
04/06/2014
37291/04
FIRAT
30/06/2009
30/09/2009
21292/07
GAMZE ULUDAĞ
10/12/2013
10/03/2014
22478/06+
GEDIK
20/05/2010
20/08/2010
71517/01
GEZICI AND İPEK
10/11/2005
10/02/2006
51839/99
GÖKÇE AND DEMIREL
22/06/2006
22/09/2006
6257/02
GÜZEL (ZEYBEK)
20/11/2007
20/02/2008
28485/03
HABIP ÇIFTÇI
23/09/2008
23/12/2008
18378/02
HANBAYAT
17/07/2007
17/10/2007
58398/00
HASAN CEYLAN
23/05/2006
23/08/2006
44027/09
HASDEMIR
22/05/2012
22/05/2012
43918/08
HATICE DUMAN
22/05/2012
22/05/2012
15048/09
HEBAT ASLAN AND FİRAS ASLAN
28/10/2014
28/01/2015
19637/05+
İNAN AND OTHERS
13/10/2009
13/01/2010
58231/09
İSMAİL YILMAZ
24/09/2013
24/09/2013
32420/03
KAÇAR MURAT
03/05/2007
03/08/2007
43648/05
KAÇMAZ
02/02/2010
02/05/2010
16779/02
KALAY
22/09/2005
22/12/2005
43654/05
KALAYLI
11/10/2011
11/01/2011
24917/04
KAMA
10/06/2008
10/09/2008
20648/02
KAMIL ÖCALAN
12/12/2006
12/03/2007
7328/03
KAPAR
03/05/2007
03/08/2007
5701/02
KARAGÖZ GÖNÜL
20/10/2005
20/01/2006
76991/01
KARAKAŞ
13/06/2006
13/09/2006
11468/02
KARATAY AND OTHERS
15/02/2007
15/05/2007
40994/98
KATAR AND OTHERS
18/04/2006
18/07/2006
7263/04
KESIKKULAK
08/01/2009
08/04/2009
61440/00
KIMRAN
05/04/2005
05/07/2005
34683/07+
KINAY İSMAIL AND KINAY ŞEYHMUS
02/02/2010
02/05/2010
30689/05
KIRLANGIÇ
25/09/2012
25/12/2012
10262/04
KÖKLÜ
14/10/2008
14/01/2009
74321/01
KOŞTI AND OTHERS
03/05/2007
03/08/2007
56493/07
KÜRÜM
26/01/2010
26/04/2010
41433/06+
KUTLAR AND OCAKLI
01/02/2011
01/05/2011
17403/10
KUZU AND ABAY
08/10/2013
08/10/2013
70026/10
LEVENT BEKTAŞ
16/06/2015
19/10/2015
33104/04
MUSTAFA TOSUN
18/11/2008
18/02/2009
6840/08
MAHMUT OZ
03/07/2012
03/10/2012
33631/04
MAHMUT YAMAN
20/01/2009
20/04/2009
42296/07
MEHMET ALI ÇELIK
27/01/2009
27/04/2009
58405/10
MEHMET ALİ POLAT
21/01/2014
21/01/2014
9603/07+
MEHMET GARIP ÖZER AND OTHERS
05/01/2010
05/04/2010
61908/00
MEHMET GÜNEŞ
21/09/2006
21/12/2006
54614/07
MEHMET MANSUR DEMİR
24/07/2012
24/07/2012
4018/07+
MEHMET ÖZCAN AND OTHERS
26/10/2010
11/04/2011
48545/99
MEHMET ŞAH ÇELIK
24/07/2007
24/10/2007
47043/99
MEHMET YAVUZ
24/07/2007
24/10/2007
7605/05
MÜCEK
16/07/2009
16/10/2009
2623/04
MÜDET KÖMÜRCÜ
23/09/2008
23/12/2008
5346/03
MÜNIRE DEMIREL
20/05/2008
20/08/2008
47359/09
MURAT AKTAŞ
24/09/2013
24/09/2013
60225/11
MURAT ÖZDEMİR
15/04/2014
15/07/2014
35065/97
N.M.
25/10/2005
25/01/2006
69812/11
NAMAZ AND ŞENOĞLU
11/06/2012
11/06/2012
2694/06
NİHAT ATEŞ
22/10/2013
22/10/2013
59860/10
ÖNER AKTAŞ
29/10/2013
29/01/2014
9462/05+
ORMAN AND OTHERS
07/12/2010
07/03/2011
61441/00
ÖZDEMIR SADEGÜL
02/08/2005
02/11/2005
23601/10
OZKAN TURGUT
22/05/2012
22/08/2012
13017/02
PAKKAN
31/10/2006
31/01/2007
4233/03
PEHLIVAN
09/12/2008
09/03/2009
61446/00
POLAT ALI HIDIR
05/04/2005
05/07/2005
40593/04
POLAT CENGIZ
11/12/2007
11/03/2008
9572/05
RAHMAN
15/02/2011
15/05/2011
30911/04
REMZI AYDIN
20/02/2007
20/05/2007
24267/07
RİFAT DEMİR
04/06/2013
04/09/2013
28489/04
RÜZGAR HASAN
27/05/2008
27/08/2008
44324/09
SABAHATTİN ALKAN
22/10/2013
22/10/2013
4220/02+
SADIKOĞULLARI AND ERDEM
21/10/2008
21/01/2009
45465/04
SAĞNAT
13/10/2009
13/01/2010
29361/07
ŞAHAP DOĞAN
27/05/2010
27/08/2010
28807/05
SAHIN ZEKI
22/02/2011
22/05/2011
1947/09
SARAR
27/03/2012
27/03/2012
1966/07+
ŞAYIK AND OTHERS
08/12/2009
08/03/2010
9961/08
ŞEKERCİ
01/07/2014
01/07/2014
46262/99
SEVGIN AND INCE
20/09/2005
20/12/2005
7540/07+
SEVIM AND OTHERS
05/01/2010
05/04/2010
4020/07+
ŞINEĞU AND OTHERS
13/10/2009
13/01/2010
27561/02
SOLMAZ
16/01/2007
16/04/2007
34623/03
SOLMAZ CAHIT
14/06/2007
14/09/2007
74657/01
SOYLU
18/12/2007
02/06/2008
19985/04
STOICA
29/11/2011
29/02/2012
48846/07+
SUDAN AND OTHERS
05/04/2011
05/04/2011
38283/04
SÜLEYMANOĞLU
29/01/2013
29/04/2013
1508/08
SUUT AYDIN
24/09/2013
24/09/2013
25324/02
TACIROĞLU
02/02/2006
02/05/2006
1636/02
TAMAMBOĞA AND GÜL
29/11/2007
29/02/2008
28150/03
TAMCAN
12/06/2007
12/09/2007
235/02
TAMER AND OTHERS
22/06/2006
11/12/2006
9244/02
TANDOĞAN
20/09/2007
20/12/2007
18711/02
TARAK.
08/04/2008
28/09/2008
21179/02
TAŞ SABRI
20/09/2005
25/04/2006
20/12/2005
25/07/2006
23623/10
TASCI AND DEMIR
03/05/2012
03/08/2012
33153/04
TEKIN
17/01/2012
17/01/2012
42554/98+
TEKIN AND BALTAŞ
07/02/2006
07/05/2006
40159/98
TEMEL AND TAŞKIN
30/06/2005
30/09/2005
16185/06
TOKMAK
16/02/2010
16/05/2010
13244/02
TÖRE No. 2
11/07/2006
11/10/2006
11855/04
TÜM OKAN
17/06/2008
17/09/2008
2422/06+
TUNCE AND OTHERS
13/10/2009
13/01/2010
11798/03
TUTAR İSKENDER
10/10/2006
10/01/2007
1968/07+
UGUR ŞEYHMUS AND OTHERS
19/10/2010
11/04/2011
49651/06
UGUR
24/01/2012
24/04/2012
29545/06+
ULU AND OTHERS
07/12/2010
07/03/2011
10317/03
ÜMIT IŞIK
16/03/2010
16/06/2010
24801/05
ÜNAY
22/09/2009
22/12/2009
19866/04
ÜRFİ ÇETİNKAYA
23/07/2013
09/12/2013
40555/04
ÜTEBAY.
17/07/2008
17/10/2008
7945/05
UYANIK AND KABADAYI
22/09/2009
22/12/2009
18078/02
VAYIÇ
20/06/2006
20/09/2006
43824/07
VELI ÖZDEMIR
23/06/2009
23/09/2009
23639/10
YAKAR
22/05/2012
22/08/2012
11339/03
YAKIŞAN
06/03/2007
06/06/2007
15041/03
YALÇIN
19/02/2008
19/05/2008
2723/07
YALÇIN ABDULLAH
21/04/2009
21/07/2009
53214/09
YAŞAR ERİŞ
28/05/2012
28/05/2012
62581/12
YAYĞIN
03/02/2015
03/02/2015
21521/06+
YER AND GUNGOR
07/12/2010
07/03/2011
41481/05
YEŞILMEN AND OTHERS
16/02/2010
16/05/2010
15649/05
YEŞILYURT
23/02/2010
23/05/2010
20827/08
YIĞITDOĞAN
16/03/2010
16/06/2010
46048/06
YILDIZ ERCÜMENT
10/06/2008
10/09/2008
23706/07+
YOLDAS AND OTHERS
15/03/2011
15/03/2011
31152/04
YÜCEL No. 2
08/04/2008
08/07/2008
12439/03
YURT
20/02/2007
20/05/2007
1515/04
ZEHI DOĞAN
02/02/2010
02/05/2010
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy