FIFTH SECTION
CASE OF FEYA, MPP AND OTHERS v. UKRAINE
(Application no. 27617/06 and 126 other applications)
JUDGMENT
STRASBOURG
21 February 2013
This judgment is final. It may be subject to editorial revision.
In the case of Feya, MPP and Others v. Ukraine,
The European Court of Human Rights (Fifth Section), sitting as a Committee composed of:
Boštjan M. Zupančič, President,
Ann Power-Forde,
Helena Jäderblom, judges,
and Stephen Phillips, Deputy Section Registrar,
Having deliberated in private on 29 January 2013,
Having noted that the underlying legal issue in the applications is already the subject of well-established case-law of the Court (see Yuriy Nikolayevich Ivanov v. Ukraine, no. 40450/04, 15 October 2009),
Delivers the following judgment, which was adopted on that date:
PROCEDURE
1. The case originated in 127 applications against Ukraine lodged with the Court under Article 34 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (“the Convention”) by Ukrainian and Russian nationals and companies based in Ukraine, whose details are specified in the appended tables.
2. The applicants in applications nos. 46250/08, 22257/10 and 36266/10 died. The applications were pursued in their name by the persons of the required standing, their relatives or heirs to their estate.
3. The Ukrainian Government (“the Government”) were represented by their Agent, Mr Nazar Kulchytskyy.
4. The applications, which mainly concern the issues of lengthy failure to enforce domestic decisions given in the applicants’ favour, were communicated to the Government on various dates.
5. On various dates the Government submitted to the Court a number of unilateral declarations aimed at resolving the non-enforcement issues. The Government requested the Court to strike the applications concerned out of the list of cases pursuant to Article 37 § 1 (c) of the Convention on the basis of the declarations. The Court examined the declarations and decided to reject the Government’s request.
6. The Russian Government, having been informed of their right to intervene in the proceedings in respect of the applicants in applications nos. 35071/10 and 53963/10 (Article 36 § 1 of the Convention and Rule 44 of the Rules of Court), indicated that they did not wish to exercise that right.
THE FACTS
THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE
7. On the dates set out in the appended tables domestic courts and commissions on labour disputes delivered judgments and decisions according to which the applicants were entitled to various pecuniary amounts or to have certain actions taken in their favour. The decisions became final and enforceable. However, the applicants were unable to obtain the enforcement of the decisions in due time because of State’s failure to comply with these decisions.
8. Some of the applicants also made submissions concerning factual and legal matters unrelated to the above non-enforcement issues.
THE LAW
I. JOINDER OF THE APPLICATIONS
9. In view of the similarity of the applications in terms of the principal legal issue raised, the Court finds it appropriate to join them.
II. THE STANDING OF THE APPLICANTS IN APPLICATIONS Nos. 46250/08, 22257/10 AND 36266/10
10. The Court considers that the applicants’ heirs or next-of-kin in the applications nos. 46250/08, 22257/10 and 36266/10 (see paragraph 2 above) have standing to continue the proceedings in the applicants’ stead (see, among other authorities, Mironov v. Ukraine, no. 19916/04, § 12, 14 December 2006).
III. ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLES 6 AND 13 OF THE CONVENTION AND OF ARTICLE 1 OF PROTOCOL No. 1
11. The applicants complained about the lengthy non-enforcement of the decisions given in their favour and about the lack of effective domestic remedies in respect of those complaints. They relied on, expressly or in substance, Articles 6 and 13 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1.
12. The Court notes that the applicants’ above complaints are not manifestly ill-founded within the meaning of Article 35 § 3 (a) of the Convention. It further notes that they are not inadmissible on any other grounds. They must therefore be declared admissible.
13. The Court finds that the decisions in the applicants’ favour were not enforced in due time, for which the State authorities were responsible.
14. Having regard to its well-established case-law on the subject (see Yuriy Nikolayevich Ivanov, cited above, §§ 56-58 and 66-70), the Court finds that there has been a violation of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 on account of the prolonged non-enforcement of the decisions in the applicants’ favour. It also considers that there has been a violation of Article 13 of the Convention in that the applicants did not have an effective domestic remedy to redress the damage created by such non-enforcement.
IV. OTHER ALLEGED VIOLATIONS OF THE CONVENTION
15. Some of the applicants raised other complaints under the Convention which the Court has carefully examined. In the light of all the material in its possession, and in so far as the matters complained of are within its competence, the Court finds that they do not disclose any appearance of a violation of the rights and freedoms set out in the Convention or its Protocols.
16. It follows that those complaints are manifestly ill-founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 (a) and 4 of the Convention.
V. APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 41 OF THE CONVENTION
17. Article 41 of the Convention provides:
“If the Court finds that there has been a violation of the Convention or the Protocols thereto, and if the internal law of the High Contracting Party concerned allows only partial reparation to be made, the Court shall, if necessary, afford just satisfaction to the injured party.”
18. In the present case, bearing in mind its previous decision on the matter (see Kharuk and Others v. Ukraine [Committee], no. 703/05 and 115 other applications, § 25, 26 July 2012), the Court considers it reasonable and equitable to award amounts of EUR 3,000 jointly to the applicants in applications nos. 32178/09 and 50804/09, and in the remainder of the applications it awards 3,000 euros (EUR) to each applicant in the applications which concern non‑enforcement delays exceeding three years (the applications tabulated in Appendix 1) and EUR 1,500 to each applicant in the other applications (the applications tabulated in Appendix 2). These sums are to cover any pecuniary and non-pecuniary damage, as well as costs and expenses.
19. The Court further notes that the respondent State has an outstanding obligation to enforce the decisions which remain enforceable.
20. The Court considers it appropriate that the default interest rate should be based on the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank, to which should be added three percentage points.
FOR THESE REASONS, THE COURT UNANIMOUSLY
1. Decides to join the applications;
2. Declares the applicants’ complaints under Article 6 § 1 and Article 13 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 about the lengthy non-enforcement of the decisions given in their favour and about the lack of effective domestic remedies in respect of those complaints admissible and the remainder of the applications inadmissible;
3. Holds that there has been a violation of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1;
4. Holds that there has been a violation of Article 13 of the Convention;
5. Holds
(a) that the respondent State is to enforce the domestic decisions in the applicants’ favour which remain enforceable and is to pay, within three months, EUR 3,000 (three thousand euros) jointly to the applicants in applications nos. 32178/09 and 50804/09, EUR 3,000 (three thousand euros) to each applicant or his or her estate in the applications tabulated in Appendix 1 and EUR 1,500 (one thousand five hundred euros) to each applicant or his or her estate in the applications tabulated in Appendix 2 in respect of pecuniary and non-pecuniary damage, and costs and expenses, plus any tax that may be chargeable to the applicants on the above amounts which are to be converted into the national currency at the rate applicable at the date of settlement;
(b) that from the expiry of the above-mentioned three months until settlement simple interest shall be payable on the above amounts at a rate equal to the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank during the default period plus three percentage points.
Done in English, and notified in writing on 21 February 2013, pursuant to Rule 77 §§ 2 and 3 of the Rules of Court.
Stephen PhillipsBoštjan M. Zupančič
Deputy RegistrarPresident
APPENDIX 1
(non-enforcement delays more than three years)
No.
Application
no. and date of introduction
Applicant’s name
date of birth (if known)
Relevant domestic decisions
27617/06
19/06/200
FEYA, MPP
1) Snizhne Court, 26/01/2004
2) Snizhne Court, 26/01/2004
3) Donetsk Regional Commercial Court, 14/10/2004
4) Donetsk Regional Commercial Court, 12/11/2004
44628/06
27/10/2006
SHLYAKHOVE REMONTNO-BUDIVELNE UPRAVLINNYA 33, VAT
1) Kharkiv Regional Commercial Court, 15/10/2003
2) Kharkiv Regional Commercial Court, 15/10/2003
3) Kharkiv Regional Commercial Court, 19/08/2004
47368/06
09/11/2006
Mykola Yevgeniyovych SEMZENIS
15/05/1967
1) Kotovsk Court, 25/07/2005
2) Kotovsk Court, 03/03/2005
21136/07
07/05/2007
Natalya Timofeyevna BEREZKINA
24/12/1959
Eduard Vladislavovich BEREZKIN
14/05/1986
1) Zhovtnevyy District Court of Lugansk, 12/09/2001
2) Zhovtnevyy District Court of Lugansk, 13/12/2004
26935/07
18/06/2007
Valeriy Yegorovich SUBBOTIN
04/02/1950
1) Torez Court, 28/07/2000
2) Torez Court, 02/07/2001
3) Torez Court, 05/11/2003
4) Torez Court, 15/08/2005
30251/07
31/05/2007
SNABMASHOBSBYT, PP
Lugansk Regional Commercial Court, 02/03/2001
43621/07
26/09/2007
Nikolay Yemelyanovich MALOVICHKO
05/12/1944
Tsentralno-Misky District Court of Makiyivka, 20/05/2002
49573/07
03/11/2007
Ryurik Petrovich RODICHEV
26/02/1937
Krasnyy Luch Court, 24/07/2003
35243/08
04/07/2008
CHERNIGIVTORGBUD, VAT
Chernigiv Regional Commercial Court, 03/02/2004
40933/08
22/07/2008
CHERNIGIVTORGBUD, VAT
Chernigiv Regional Commercial Court, 05/07/2007
46250/08
31/07/2008
Aleksandr Georgiyevich LUPONOSOV
26/06/1951
Tsentralno-Mistskyy District Court of Makiyivka, 22/09/2006
53963/08
18/10/2008
Vladlen Yuryevich DMITRIYEV
23/12/1956
Primorskyy District Court of Odesa, 29/05/2007
55114/08
03/11/2008
VYROBNYCHA FIRMA ASTEYS, TOV
Kyiv City Commercial Court, 03/11/2005
4519/09
11/12/2008
Viktor Vladimirovich SHPAK
04/08/1950
Krasnyy Luch Court, 04/05/2005
12629/09
23/02/2009
Ivan Ivanovich DENISOV
10/05/1945
Igor Ivanovich DENISOV
05/06/1977
Applicant 1:
1) Kerch Court, 29/07/2004
2) Kerch Court, 19/07/2005
Applicant 2:
1) Kerch Court, 06/08/2004
2) Kerch Court, 19/07/2005
17384/09
10/02/2009
Volodymyr Mykolayovych PAVLENKO
04/03/1973
Korolovskyy District Court of Zhytomyr, 13/09/2007, as amended by the Zhytomyr Regional Court of Appeal on 29/11/2007
20888/09
02/04/2009
Andrey Andreyevich BRYANTSEV
25/09/1953
Yevpatoriya Court of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, 04/08/2006
22588/09
07/04/2009
Stanislav Yuryevich POPOVICH
22/10/1954
Tsentralno-Miskyy Court of Gorlivka, 11/03/2004
29900/09
22/05/2009
Aleksandr Nikolayevich LOKHMATOV
26/08/1960
1) Kerch Court of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, 03/09/2004
2) Kerch Court of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, 14/12/2004
29904/09
20/05/2009
Boris Fedorovich SOLODKIY
30/04/1955
Babushkinskyy District Court of Dnipropetrovsk, 05/05/2006
30355/09
12/05/2009
Aleksandr Vladimirovich VOVK
29/06/1964
Selydove Court, 30/11/2005
30807/09
29/05/2009
Mykola Stepanovych KHOBOT
15/09/1950
Feodosiya Court of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, 16/10/2006
31440/09
25/05/2009
Aleksandr Ivanovich VASILYEV
13/03/1957
1) Oleksandriya Court of Kirovograd Region, 07/08/2006
2) Oleksandriya Court of Kirovograd Region, 17/11/2006
31815/09
03/04/2009
Dmitriy Anatolyevich KLYAKHIN
08/10/1965
1) Labour Disputes Commission of Avtosklo, State Enterprise, 14/05/1998
2) Kostyantynivka Court of the Donetsk Region, 30/01/2001
31959/09
08/06/2009
Oleksandr Mykolayovych DRACHENKO
23/08/1964
Oleksandriya Court of the Kirovograd Region, 31/07/2008
32061/09
05/06/2009
Grygoriy Oleksandrovych OBUSHCHAK
14/02/1960
Zamostyanskyy District Court of Vinnytsya, 15/11/2006
32178/09
05/06/2009
Vadym Oleksandrovych MOLCHANOV
25/10/1937
Kateryna Vasylivna MOLCHANOVA
10/12/1937
Kherson Regional Court of Appeal, 07/12/2006
33252/09
05/06/2009
Vitaliy Nikolayevich VOLKOBOY
16/06/1954
1) Kostyantynivka Court, 21/08/2006
2) Labour Disputes Commission of the Avtosklo, State Enterprise, 12/03/2001
33390/09
05/06/2009
Alla Andreyevna OMELCHENKO
22/09/1941
Kostyantynivka Court, 14/03/2003
35661/09
23/06/2009
Vasyl Ivanovych VERZHYKOVSKYY
22/10/1924
Shepetivka Court, 28/11/2007
38664/09
07/07/2009
Volodymyr Mykhaylovych SHALAYEV
08/08/1949
1) Oleksandriya Court, 20/03/2008 As Amended by the Dnipropetrovsk Regional Administrative Court of Appeal on 04/12/2008
2) Oleksandriya Court, 19/05/2008
39734/09
02/06/2009
Vitaliy Yevgenyevich SAMOFALOV
16/07/1979
Krasnyy Luch Court, 14/06/2007
40678/09
20/07/2009
Vera Alekseyevna KITCHENKO
21/09/1947
Vyshgorod Court, 21/04/2008
41045/09
21/07/2009
Aleksandr Mikhaylovich STUPAKOV
16/08/1941
Krasnyy Luch Court, 25/06/2007
42857/09
27/07/2009
Stanislava Eduardivna FURSOVA
04/01/1954
Krasnyy Luch Court, 27/05/2005
43017/09
27/07/2009
Yuriy Alekseyevich FURSOV
21/02/1949
1) Krasnyy Luch Court, 06/06/2005
2) Krasnyy Luch Court, 28/04/2006
45905/09
12/08/2009
Volodymyr Semenovych VERESHCHAKA
20/08/1946
1) Oleksandriya Court, 28/01/2008 as amended by the Dnipropetrovsk Administrative Court of Appeal,
25/09/2008
2) Oleksandriya Court, 11/04/2008 as amended by the Dnipropetrovsk Administrative Court of Appeal,
10/12/2008
3) Oleksandriya Court, 10/07/2008 as amended by the Dnipropetrovsk Administrative Court of Appeal,
23/04/2009, quashed by the Higher Administrative Court on 30/11/2012
46475/09
17/08/2009
Igor Olegovich BUTENIN
06/09/1972
Zamostyanskyy District Court of Vinnytsya, 05/03/2007
47329/09
20/08/2009
Yevgeniy Nikolayevich MATSKIY
16/07/1971
Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 31/01/2008
48647/09
26/08/2009
Galyna Mykhaylivna BRZHEZITSKA
27/08/1958
Mukacheve Court, 13/11/2006
50168/09
25/08/2009
Gennadiy Grigoryevich SERENKO
29/12/1966
Berdyansk Court, 16/01/2006
50804/09
07/09/2009
Aleksandra Zakharovna ZHUKOVA
29/06/1945
Dmitriy Vladimirovich ZHUKOV
30/08/1968
Dzerzhinskyy District Court of Kharkiv, 11/10/2004
53644/09
27/09/2009
Volodymyr Ivanovych SPINOV
29/11/1953
Kalininskyy District Court of Donetsk, 14/06/2006
54647/09
28/09/2009
Sergiy Yakovlevych TORGAN
19/10/1971
Malynovskyy District Court of Odesa, 20/06/2008
54747/09
28/09/2009
Sergiy Mykolayovych PODGURSKYY
15/06/1976
Malynovskyy District Court of Odesa, 20/06/2008
58907/09
27/10/2009
Veletyna Ivanivna NAZARCHUK
16/05/1954
Volodarka Court, 16/10/2006
1284/10
11/12/2009
Anatoliy Mykolayovych SHERSHUN
1955
1) Tetiyiv Court, 07/12/2007
2) Tetiyiv Court, 07/03/2008
1299/10
24/12/2009
SKLADNI SPLAVY, PP
Commercial Court of Kyiv, 16/10/2007
1301/10
21/12/2009
Sergey Nikolayevich LYUBENKIY
16/12/1977
Zamostyanskyy District Court of Vinnytsya, 05/03/2007
2495/10
31/12/2009
Venera Ilmar- Voldemarivna MAROCHKYNA
04/09/1962
1) Krasnyy Luch Court, 13/05/2005
2) Krasnyy Luch Court, 03/06/2008
2946/10
04/12/2009
Maya Vasylivna
MRACHEK
10/05/1944
Komsomolskyy District Court of Kherson, 06/06/2008
3073/10
05/01/2010
Viktor Vasylyovych KOPYLTSIV
01/03/1963
Kolomyya Court, 25/06/2004
3191/10
25/12/2009
Volodymyr Vikentiyovych KHARITONOV
04/09/1963
Kolomyya Court, 22/02/2005
3275/10
12/01/2010
Larysa Sergiyivna KASHPRUK
18/03/1972
Kalynivka Court, 31/01/2007
4412/10
06/01/2010
Lyudmila Vladimirovna SIDENKO
13/02/1965
Kupyansk Court, 13/03/2008
4524/10
06/01/2010
Viktor Anatolyevich TKACHEV
12/04/1959
Labour Disputes Commission the Kupyanskyy Lyvarnyy Zavod, 01/11/2001
4541/10
06/01/2010
Yuriy Nikolayevich KARDASH
21/05/1963
Kupyansk Court, 20/01/2007
4743/10
06/01/2010
Valentina Alekseyevna BURYAK
17/07/1952
Kupyansk Court, 01/10/2007
6128/10
22/01/2010
Vira Volodymyrivna BAGNO
11/11/1959
Dubno Court, 11/01/2007
9452/10
09/02/2010
Alla Mykolayivna SHEVCHUK
22/03/1963
1) Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 12/12/2007
2) Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 14/05//2009
9642/10
09/02/2010
Nina Oleksandrivna KALENCHENKO
unspecified
Pecherskyy District Court of Kyiv, 02/04/2008
9650/10
09/02/2010
Valentyn Rostyslavovych SHROL
01/07/1964
Pecherskyy District Court of Kyiv, 02/04/2008
9699/10
09/02/2010
Liliya Ivanivna KASYANENKO
26/12/1952
Pecherskyy District Court, 02/04/2008
9705/10
09/02/2010
Svitlana Anatoliyivna GOLUB
24/03/1964
Pecherskyy District Court of Kyiv, 02/04/2008
9711/10
08/02/2010
Olga Mykolayivna KAPICHON
06/11/1965
Pecherskyy District Court of Kyiv, 02/04/2008
9720/10
08/02/2010
Oleksandr Ivanovych SLIPCHENKO
31/10/1965
Pecherskyy District Court of Kyiv, 02/04/2008
10008/10
08/02/2010
Oleksiy Mykolayovych DANILOV
28/03/1953
Pecherskyy District Court of Kyiv, 02/04/2008
10016/10
08/02/2010
Mykhaylo Anatoliyovych POLISHCHUK
20/11/1961
Pecherskyy District Court of Kyiv, 02/04/2008
10023/10
08/02/2010
Ruslana Viktorivna BEREZOVENKO
unspecified
Pecherskyy District Court of Kyiv, 02/04/2008
10034/10
08/02/2010
Anatoliy Ivanovych OREL
16/12/1958
Pecherskyy District Court of Kyiv, 02/04/2008
10118/10
08/02/2010
Valentyna Ivanivna KHEYFITS
06/02/1953
Kupyansk Court, 27/09/2001
10124/10
04/02/2010
Vera Vladimirovna GODIYAK
09/01/1958
Krasnyy Luch Court, 18/07/2005
10126/10
03/02/2010
Mykola Mykhaylovych MOSHKIVSKYY
10/10/1970
Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 28/04/2009
10171/10
09/02/2010
Oleg Volodymyrovych IGNATYUK
11/01/1966
Pecherskyy District Court of Kyiv, 02/04/2008
10278/10
08/02/2010
Mykola Grygorovych AVRAMENKO
05/10/1957
Pecherskyy District Court of Kyiv, 02/04/2008
10302/10
08/02/2010
Volodymyr Mykolayovych CHERKASOV
25/03/1959
Pecherskyy District Court of Kyiv, 02/04/2008
10411/10
09/02/2010
Rayisa Mykolayivna GAYDAY
26/03/1955
Pecherskyy District Court of Kyiv, 02/04/2008
10453/10
05/02/2010
Irina Yevgenyevna KRASEVICH
20/03/1955
Labour Disputes Commission of the State Company "Techbudsklo", 18/04/2002
10575/10
09/02/2010
Oleksandr Ivanovych VLASENKO
05/11/1974
Court’s order of the Kyivskyy District Court of Poltava, 30/03/2009
10598/10
05/02/2010
Volodymyr Ivanovych MALTSEV
17/08/1938
Darnytskyy District Court of Kyiv, 15/12/2006
11480/10
08/02/2010
Nataliya Semenivna VOROBYOVA
12/03/1954
Pecherskyy District Court of Kyiv, 02/04/2008
11641/10
11/02/2010
Nikolay Ivanovich KANDAUROV
unspecified
Pervomaysk Court of the Lugansk Region, 08/05/2002
11721/10
10/02/2010
Lidiya Fedorivna SAMKO
13/12/1953
Kharkiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 02/12/2008
11837/10
17/02/2010
Valeriy Yevgeniyovych PANKOV
13/05/1956
Fastiv Court, 20/11/2007
12328/10
19/02/2010
FPK GROSS OOO
Donetsk Regional Commercial Court, 11/04/2005
12338/10
24/02/2010
Oleksandr SENCHYLO
01/12/1949
Kyiv City Court of Appeal, 27/09/2007
13643/10
10/02/2010
Volodymyr Yevgenovych SMYRNOV
23/11/1978
Commercial Court of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, 25/03/2008
13673/10
23/02/2010
Grygoriy Vasylyovych TABACHUK
03/07/1962
Zamostyanskyy District Court of Vinnytsya, 22/12/2006
14611/10
02/03/2010
Grygoriy Yakovych KOVROVSKYY
01/08/1955
1) Vyshgorod Court, 25/02/2008
2) Vyshgorod Court, 27/02/2009
3) Vyshgorod Court, 26/05/2009
14912/10
03/03/2010
Igor Mykolayovych SOLOMOYCHENKO
21/07/1956
Pecherskyy District Court of Kyiv, 15/12/2004 (as amended by the Kyiv Court of Appeal, 14/03/2005)
17874/10
19/03/2010
Sergiy Volodymyrovych STRYZHAK
02/06/1956
Novi Sanzhary Court, 18/10/2007
18112/10
10/03/2010
Igor Anatoliyovych LIPANOV
22/07/1962
1) Korolyovskyy District Court of Zhytomyr, 17/10/2007
2) Bogunskyy District Court of Zhytomyr, 15/01/2010
3) Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 10/12/2008
18276/10
16/03/2010
Viktor Ivanovych YAREMCHUK
10/07/1961
Berezan Court, 19/02/2008
20170/10
23/03/2010
Yuriy Mykolayovych STRYZHAK
04/05/1962
Kryukivskyy District Court of Kremenchuk, 17/09/2008
20448/10
29/03/2010
FIRMA DILAYN, PP
Lugansk Regional Commercial Court, 12/12/2000
20511/10
23/11/2009
Oleksandr Ivanovych POBEREZHNYY
18/09/1971
1) Court’s order of the Kolomyya Court, 16/03/2007
2) Court’s Order of the Kolomyya Court, 15/06/2007
21733/10
30/03/2010
Nikolay Ivanovich TISHCHENKO
25/03/1958
Leninskyy District Court of Sevastopol, 07/08/2008
22024/10
12/03/2010
Yuriy Yevgenyevich KRASNOKUTSKIY
20/03/1949
Krasnyy Luch Court, 30/03/2009
22257/10
02/04/2010
Ivan Yefimovich MAKSYUK
1932
Krasnyy Luch Court, 15/06/2007
22336/10
02/04/2010
Yelena Yakovlevna BENDA
29/12/1965
1) Krasnyy Luch Court, 20/08/2008
2) Krasnyy Luch Court, 29/10/2008
22493/10
27/03/2010
Oleksandra Fedorivna SHAGA
04/12/1951
Novozavodskyy District Court of Chernigiv, 17/12/2007
23629/10
20/04/2010
Tetyana Mykolayivna DIDYK
11/02/1961
Zamostyanskyy District Court of Vinnytsya, 11/12/2006
24443/10
20/04/2010
Lyudmyla Pavlivna MANKIVSKA
21/08/1962
Zamostyanskyy District Court of Vinnytsya, 30/11/2006
25298/10
23/04/2010
Lyubov Fedorivna SYDORENKO
17/06/1948
1) Krasnyy Liman Court, 21/08/1999
2) Krasnyy Liman Court, 17/08/1999
25989/10
20/04/2010
Igor LYSAK
13/01/1947
Lychakisvkyy District Court of Lviv, 07/11/2007
26673/10
19/04/2010
Fedir Frolovych FIRSOV
20/09/1941
Mukachevo Court, 01/11/2006
30056/10
17/05/2010
Galyna Stepanivna YAKOVYSHYNA
27/03/1932
Lviv Administrative Court of Appeal, 05/08/2008
30631/10
20/05/2010
Tamara Mykolayivna MANDRYKA
27/11/1941
1) Labour Disputes Commission of the Khimprom, Pervomayskyy State Enterprise, 11/12/2007
2) Pervomayskyy Court, 06/05/2008
33325/10
07/06/2010
Volodymyr Valeriyovych KRAL
unspecified
Golosiyivskyy District Court of Kyiv, 02/06/2005
33691/10
02/06/2010
Svitlana Ivanivna DYGAS
21/07/1965
Zamostyanskyy District Court of Vinnytsya, 27/03/2007
35071/10
03/06/2010
Anastasiya Semenovna DIKAREVA
31/10/1934 (Russian)
Severodonetsk Court, 15/04/2009
35124/10
31/05/2010
Viktor Semenovych MOVCHAN
29/07/1937
1) Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 02/04/2009
2) Kyiv Circuit Administrative Court, 15/10/2008
36266/10
16/06/2010
Mykola Andriyovych NESOLYONYY
14/08/1922
Lugansk Circuit Administrative Court, 07/05/2009
42839/10
17/07/2010
Yefim Mikhaylovich TIMOSHENKO
17/05/1926
Krasnoarmiysk Court, 20/02/2009
45624/10
27/07/2010
Ivan Pavlovych BUSHUYEV
12/02/1923
Leninskyy District Court of Lugansk, 04/12/2009
45785/10
31/07/2010
Larisa Viktorovna VYSOTSKAYA
04/02/1960
1) Kerch Court, 28/02/2003
2) Kerch Court, 05/05/2005
49215/10
09/08/2010
Pavlo Vasylyovych GELYUNENKO
23/06/1966
Bila Tserkva Court, 19/05/2009
53963/10
10/09/2010
Olga Pavlivna PASHATSKA
12/02/1956 (Russian)
Higher Administrative Court, 08/10/2008
60317/10
07/10/2010
Kateryna Avksentiyivna KUYTUKLU
23/12/1953
1) Pokrovske Court, 02/02/2009
2) Pokrovske Court, 02/02/2009
61768/10
07/10/2010
FEYA, MPP
1) Donetsk Regional Commercial Court, 24/05/2007
2) Donetsk Regional Commercial Court, 18/02/2008
66873/10
05/11/2010
Nina Petrivna MOZGOVA
19/01/1947
1) Svitlovodsk Court, 15/08/2005
2) Svitlovodsk Court, 31/07/2006
3) Svitlovodsk Court, 20/07/2007
68454/10
11/11/2010
Oleksandr Kostyantynovych SHEVCHENKO
11/02/1957
1) Oleksandriya Court, 14/11/2007
2) Oleksandriya Court, 04/11/2008
3) Oleksandriya Court, 04/11/2008
69251/10
18/11/2010
Nina Ivanivna PINUS
16/04/1957
1) Svitlovodsk Court, 20/12/2007
2) Svitlovodsk Court, 26/08/2009
70834/10
25/11/2010
Grigoriy Yefimovich LIZOGUB
13/04/1933
Lugansk Circuit Administrative Court, 02/02/2009
71290/10
19/11/2010
Lidiya Petrivna CHUNYKHINA
01/01/1954
Shostka Court, 13/05/2008
APPENDIX 2
(non-enforcement delays less than three years)
No.
Application
no. and date of introduction
Applicant’s name
date of birth (if known)
Relevant domestic decisions
42136/09
23/07/2009
Volodymyr Yakovych GOLOTA
12/07/1953
Shakhtarsk Court, 07/12/2007
71588/10
27/11/2010
Oleksiy Illlich LOPATIN
24/03/1917
Rayisa Mykhaylivna KORZHOVA
30/03/1921
Khmelnytskyy Circuit Administrative Court, 17/10/2008 (award given to each of the applicants)
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy