Resolution CM/ResDH(2018)353
Execution of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights
162 cases against Italy
(Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 20 September 2018
at the 1324th meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies)
The Committee of Ministers, under the terms of former Article 32 and those of Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (hereinafter “the Convention”),
Having regard to its decisions adopted under former Article 32 of the Convention and to the final judgments transmitted by the Court to the Committee in these cases and the violations established of Article 6, paragraph 1, of the Convention on account of the excessive length of criminal proceedings;
Recalling the respondent State’s obligation, under Article 46, paragraph 1, of the Convention, to abide by all final judgments in cases to which it has been a party and that this obligation entails, over and above the payment of any sums awarded by the Court, the adoption by the authorities of the respondent State, where required:
- of individual measures to put an end to violations established and erase their consequences so as to achieve as far as possible restitutio in integrum; and
- of general measures preventing similar violations;
Having invited the government of the respondent State to inform the Committee of the measures taken to comply with the above-mentioned obligation;
Having noted the information provided regarding the payment of the just satisfaction awarded by the Court or the Committee (see document DH-DD(2018)700);
Considering that the individual measures have therefore been resolved, given that steps have been taken to accelerate the proceedings which were still pending at the time the Committee adopted its decisions under former Article 32 or the judgments of the European Court became final;
Recalling that the general measures required in response to the shortcomings found by the Court in the present judgments will continue to be examined within the framework of the case of Ledonne (No. 1) v. Italy, (Application No. 35742/97) and that the closure of the cases listed below in no way prejudges the Committee’s evaluation of the general measures in relation to the excessive length of criminal proceedings;
DECLARES that it has exercised its functions under Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention in these cases as regards the individual measures and
DECIDES to close the examination of these cases.
Appendix list of cases
Application
Case
Judgment of
Final on
ART. 32 :
IR or CM decision
38414/97
LEDONNE (No. 2)
12/05/1999
12/08/1999
-
21807/93
A. AND A.F. AND A.R.
-
-
DH(97)176
27141/95
A.A.Q.
-
-
DH(98)128
26774/95
A.D.
-
-
DH(98)208
21068/92
A.M. III
-
-
DH(97)366
23356/94
A.R. II
-
-
DH(98)47
21873/93
ACHILLI
-
-
DH(98)91
33454/96
ALBÉ
-
-
DH(99)421
31230/96
ANTONINO ARCONTE
-
-
DH(99)102
29530/95
ANTONIO ROSSI
-
-
DH(98)459
22873/93
ARCONTE
-
-
DH(98)48
44970/98
ARGANESE
26/04/2001
26/07/2001
-
20854/92
ARICHETTA
-
-
DH(97)108
45856/99
BACIGALUPI
16/11/2000
16/02/2001
-
24920/94
BALLESTRA
-
-
DH(98)268
38576/97
BARATTELLI
04/07/2002
04/10/2002
-
27584/95
BERTELLI
-
-
DH(99)325
41863/98
BOLDRIN
04/07/2002
04/10/2002
-
24909/94
BONOMO
-
-
DH(99)228
25541/94
BORTOLUSSI
-
-
DH(97)554
27952/95
BRUNO
-
-
DH(97)175
44976/98
C.P.
26/04/2001
26/07/2001
-
27473/95
CALISTRI
-
-
DH(97)180
39997/98
CANCELLIERI
26/04/2001
26/07/2001
-
16752/90
CAPOCCIA
-
-
Decision [1]
25265/94
CARBONE
-
-
DH(96)211
42600/98
CARBONE BIAGIO
04/07/2002
04/10/2002
-
41275/98
CARMELA GUARINO
26/04/2001
05/09/2001
-
37249/97
CASADEI
04/07/2002
04/10/2002
-
37137/97
CASSANDRA
-
-
DH(99)207
38878/97
CIACCI
01/03/2001
01/06/2001
-
35303/97
CICERONE E., S., S. AND D.
-
-
DH(98)453
29654/96
CICINO AND OTHERS
-
-
DH(97)467
27240/95
CILIONE
-
-
DH(99)326
33950/96
COLA
-
-
DH(99)422
45857/99
COMELLA AND OTHERS
09/11/2000
09/02/2001
-
46970/99
CONTARDI
28/03/2002
28/06/2002
-
42210/98
CORSI ANDREA
04//07/2002
04/10/2002
-
39140/98
CORSO AND FACCHETTI
-
-
DH(99)525
24854/94
COSER
-
-
DH(97)292
39714/98
DAVINELLI
26/04/2001
26/07/2001
-
33969/96
DE BLASIIS
14/12/1999
04/04/2000
-
26843/95
DE LUCA GIANNI
-
-
DH(96)661
23968/94
DE SANTIS
-
-
DH(98)269
35300/97
DE SIMONE AND 6 OTHERS
13/05/1998
13/08/1998
DH(98)454
35991/97
DEL FEDERICO
04/07/2002
04/10/2002
-
42351/98
DEL GIUDICE
01/03/2001
05/09/2001
-
41513/98
DI DONATO AND 3 OTHERS
26/04/2001
26/07/2001
-
35285/97
DI PRISCO AND CAPPON
-
-
DH(98)455
33153/96
DI TRAPANI AND CRESCIMANNO
-
-
DH(98)123
42619/98
DI VUONO
04/07/2002
04/10/2002
-
29077/95
E.M.
-
-
DH(99)229
16549/90
EMMANUELE
21/02/1995
21/05/1995
Decision[2]
35000/97
F. F.
-
-
DH(99)423
30577/96
F., A. M., M. G. AND P. P. S.
-
-
DH(97)531
40457/98
F.C.
26/04/2001
26/07/2001
-
43621/98
F.M.
28/11/2002
28/02/2003
-
45267/99
F.R. AND OTHERS
26/07/2001
26/10/2001
-
31009/96
FABRIZI
-
-
DH(99)327
37263/97
FALCONE
04/07/2002
04/10/2002
-
34203/96
FERRARIN
26/04/2001
05/09/2001
-
28166/95
FORTE II
-
-
DH(98)49
35207/97
FRANCESCO AGGIATO
26/04/2001
26/07/2001
-
28591/95
FRISALDI
-
-
DH(98)270
26415/95
FUSCO
26/02/1996
26/05/1996
DH(96)556
17043/90
G. AND A.G., AND M.C.
-
-
Decision[3]
35554/97
G. S.
-
-
DH(99)425
41603/98
G.B.Z. AND L.Z. AND S.Z.
14/12/1999
11/02/2000
-
28664/95
G.C. V
-
-
DH(98)456
28666/95
G.N. IV
-
-
DH(98)50
22120/93
G.P III
-
-
DH(97)465
33605/96
G.P. V
-
-
DH(99)424
37752/97
GELLI *
19/10/1999
31/01/2000
-
28594/95
GHIGNONI
-
-
DH(99)104
41094/98
GIANNANGELI *
05/07/2001
05/10/2001
-
33789/96
GIGANTE E. AND N.
-
-
DH(98)192
18138/91
GINER
-
-
DH(95)444
36057/97
GIUNCHIGLIA
-
-
DH(99)426
27963/95
GRANDE AND OTHERS
-
-
DH(97)181
32646/96
GUERRESI
24/04/2001
24/04/2001
-
40458/98
IALONGO
26/04/2001
26/07/2001
-
40662/98
IARROBINO AND DE NISCO
26/04/2001
26/07/2001
-
45260/99
ICOLARO
26/04/2001
26/07/2001
-
28963/95
ISNARDI GIUSEPPE II
-
-
DH(97)659
27540/95
JOSEPH BRINCAT II
-
-
DH(99)103
23570/94
L.C. AND P.A.
-
-
DH(97)464
22870/93
L.G
-
-
DH(97)294
33377/96
L.Z
-
-
DH(99)328
28721/95
LELLI G., L. AND L.
-
-
DH(97)555
20543/92
LUPO
-
-
DH(96)107
35943/97
M. R. VI
-
-
DH(99)100
29508/95
M.B.
-
-
DH(99)329
26833/95
M.C. V
-
-
DH(96)662
22901/93
M.C. VI
-
-
DH(97)466
27169/95
M.Z.
-
-
DH(97)77
24904/94
MAGGIANI
-
-
DH(97)660
41206/98
MANGASCIA’
01/03/2001
05/09/2001
-
37702/97
MARCHETTI
14/12/1999
14/03/2000
-
37156/97
MARE’
-
-
DH(99)208
45063/98
MARI
17/10/2000
17/01/2001
-
44517/98
MARI AND MANGINI
01/03/2001
01/06/2001
-
41893/98
MARTINEZ
26/07/2001
26/10/2001
-
45789/99
MASSIMO PUGLIESE
28/11/2002
28/02/2003
-
43635/98
MATERA
26/04/2001
26/07/2001
-
43350/98
MAURANO
26/04/2001
26/07/2001
-
23306/94
MILIONI GUERRIERO AND MANSUETI
-
-
DH(97)661
51652/99
MOLEK
11/12/2001
11/03/2002
-
30605/96
MONGIARDO
-
-
DH(98)457
28167/95
MONI
-
-
DH(98)51
32045/96
MORELLI
-
-
DH(99)105
28903/95
MOTALLI
-
-
DH(98)280
47681/99
MOTTA no3
26/04/2001
05/09/2001
-
44173/98
MUCCIACCIARO
04/07/2002
04/10/2002
-
25124/94
NATIVI, LORIGA, PITTALIS, ORECCHIONI, MELIAU AND PRUNAS
-
-
DH(97)662
41424/98
NUVOLI
16/05/2002
16/08/2002
-
44943/98
ORLANDI
01/03/2001
01/06/2001
-
35905/97
ORLANDO
-
-
DH(99)101
37144/97
P. A. I
-
-
DH(99)209
18755/91
P.B. III
-
-
DH(96)109
45269/99
P.G.F.
05/07/2001
05/10/2001
-
37507/97
PALMIGIANO
11/01/2000
11/04/2000
-
38127/97
PALMISANO
-
-
DH(99)312
42287/98
PASCAZI
04/07/2002
04/10/2002
-
29898/96
PATANÉ
01/03/2001
01/06/2001
-
30132/96
PEPE
27/04/2000
27/07/2000
-
36733/97
PERILLI
-
-
DH(99)427
24170/94
PESCE
-
-
DH(97)468
23310/94
POIDIMANI
-
-
DH(97)173
44454/98
PORCELLI
25/10/2001
25/01/2002
-
35007/97
PROFETA (LPP)
-
-
DH(99)428
29881/96
PUCCIO
-
-
DH(98)458
36626/97
R. P.
-
-
DH(99)210
43915/98
ROCCI
04/07/2002
04/10/2002
-
33510/96
ROMANIELLO
-
-
DH(98)266
44531/98
RONGONI
25/10/2001
25/01/2002
-
40693/98
ROTELLINI AND BARNABEI
26/04/2001
26/07/2001
-
39118/98
S. G.
-
-
DH(99)526
26042/94
S.C. II
-
-
DH(97)78
45480/99
S.G., S.M. AND P.C.
26/04/2001
26/07/2001
-
36719/97
SACCOMANNO
12/05/1999
12/08/1999
-
21567/93
SALERNO
-
-
DH(97)174
45854/99
SAVINO
09/11/2000
04/04/2001
-
43536/98
SCHIAPPACASSE
26/04/2001
26/07/2001
-
46512/99
SPARANO
21/11/2000
21/02/2001
-
34232/96
SPARTI
-
-
DH(98)267
40231/98
SPINELLO
04/07/2002
30/01/2003
04/10/2002
30/04/2003
-
32728/96
SPISSU
-
-
DH(99)330
34081/96
STARACE
27/04/2000
27/07/2000
-
33749/96
SURACI A. AND A.
-
-
DH(99)331
45858/99
TESCONI
09/11/2000
09/02/2001
-
45264/99
TOMMASO PALUMBO
26/04/2001
26/07/2001
-
26433/95
TORRI
01/07/1997
01/07/1997
-
42291/98
TUMBARELLO AND TITONE
04/07/2002
04/10/2002
-
26806/95
U.O. I
-
-
DH(98)52
26781/95
U.O. II
-
-
DH(98)129
26782/95
U.O. III
-
-
DH(98)130
33691/96
V.B. III
-
-
DH(99)332
23147/93
VAGGELLI LUPI
-
-
DH(96)245
28839/95
VIEZZER
-
-
DH(98)271
43199/98
VISINTIN
01/03/2001
20/06/2001
-
29510/95
VOCCA
-
-
DH(98)460
31461/96
ZAIA
-
-
DH(2000)21
[1] Decision adopted under former Article 32 at the 546th meeting (October 1995) (DH).
[2] Decision adopted under former Article 32 at the 542nd meeting (September 1995) (DH).
[3] Decision adopted under former Article 32 at the 534th meeting (April 1995) (DH).
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy