FIRST SECTION
CASE OF RYABOV
and 151 other “Privileged pensioners” cases v. RUSSIA
(Applications nos. 4563/07, 19923/08, 29853/08, 35836/08, 37062/08, 37064/08, 37069/08, 37072/08, 37568/08, 37717/08, 38120/08, 38832/08, 39479/08, 39532/08, 39601/08, 40675/08, 40676/08, 40678/08, 41157/08, 41158/08, 41161/08, 41163/08, 41794/08, 41804/08, 41806/08, 41807/08, 41810/08, 41820/08, 41822/08, 41824/08, 41825/08, 41828/08, 41911/08, 41975/08, 41981/08, 42005/08, 42006/08, 44357/08, 44361/08, 44617/08, 45200/08, 45204/08, 45207/08, 45243/08, 45246/08, 45253/08, 45258/08, 45261/08, 45265/08, 45833/08, 45834/08, 46047/08, 46210/08, 46211/08, 46215/08, 46218/08, 46965/08, 46968/08, 47762/08, 47768/08, 47774/08, 47776/08, 47779/08, 47783/08, 47878/08, 48025/08, 48045/08, 48049/08, 48054/08, 48056/08, 48587/08, 48606/08, 48854/08, 48861/08, 48877/08, 48942/08, 48956/08, 49322/08, 49325/08, 49411/08, 49415/08, 49563/08, 51002/08, 52521/08, 52557/08, 52563/08, 52566/08, 53574/08, 53579/08, 53583/08, 53587/08, 53589/08, 53593/08, 53595/08, 53600/08, 53603/08, 53605/08, 53607/08, 53611/08, 53614/08, 53617/08, 53620/08, 53623/08, 53629/08, 53632/08, 54367/08, 54379/08, 54384/08, 54392/08, 54396/08, 54398/08, 54399/08, 54400/08, 54431/08, 54456/08, 54470/08, 54473/08, 54507/08, 54513/08, 54526/08, 54530/08, 54590/08, 54593/08, 54596/08, 54602/08, 54605/08, 54608/08, 56037/08, 56774/08, 56778/08, 56781/08, 56784/08, 56786/08, 56789/08, 56801/08, 56806/08, 56813/08, 56816/08, 56827/08, 56832/08, 56837/08, 58306/08, 58344/08, 59027/08, 59599/08, 59626/08, 59628/08, 59698/08, 59699/08, 59703/08, 60036/08, and 4507/09)
JUDGMENT
STRASBOURG
17 December 2009
FINAL
17/03/2010
This judgment will become final in the circumstances set out in Article 44 § 2 of the Convention. It may be subject to editorial revision.
In the case of Ryabov and 151 other “Privileged pensioners” cases v. Russia,
The European Court of Human Rights (First Section), sitting as a Chamber composed of:
Christos Rozakis, President,
Nina Vajić,
Anatoly Kovler,
Elisabeth Steiner,
Dean Spielmann,
Giorgio Malinverni,
George Nicolaou, judges,
and Søren Nielsen, Section Registrar,
Having deliberated in private on 26 November 2009,
Delivers the following judgment, which was adopted on that date:
PROCEDURE
1. The case originated in 152 applications (nos. 4563/07, 19923/08, 29853/08, 35836/08, 37062/08, 37064/08, 37069/08, 37072/08, 37568/08, 37717/08, 38120/08, 38832/08, 39479/08, 39532/08, 39601/08, 40675/08, 40676/08, 40678/08, 41157/08, 41158/08, 41161/08, 41163/08, 41794/08, 41804/08, 41806/08, 41807/08, 41810/08, 41820/08, 41822/08, 41824/08, 41825/08, 41828/08, 41911/08, 41975/08, 41981/08, 42005/08, 42006/08, 44357/08, 44361/08, 44617/08, 45200/08, 45204/08, 45207/08, 45243/08, 45246/08, 45253/08, 45258/08, 45261/08, 45265/08, 45833/08, 45834/08, 46047/08, 46210/08, 46211/08, 46215/08, 46218/08, 46965/08, 46968/08, 47762/08, 47768/08, 47774/08, 47776/08, 47779/08, 47783/08, 47878/08, 48025/08, 48045/08, 48049/08, 48054/08, 48056/08, 48587/08, 48606/08, 48854/08, 48861/08, 48877/08, 48942/08, 48956/08, 49322/08, 49325/08, 49411/08, 49415/08, 49563/08, 51002/08, 52521/08, 52557/08, 52563/08, 52566/08, 53574/08, 53579/08, 53583/08, 53587/08, 53589/08, 53593/08, 53595/08, 53600/08, 53603/08, 53605/08, 53607/08, 53611/08, 53614/08, 53617/08, 53620/08, 53623/08, 53629/08, 53632/08, 54367/08, 54379/08, 54384/08, 54392/08, 54396/08, 54398/08, 54399/08, 54400/08, 54431/08, 54456/08, 54470/08, 54473/08, 54507/08, 54513/08, 54526/08, 54530/08, 54590/08, 54593/08, 54596/08, 54602/08, 54605/08, 54608/08, 56037/08, 56774/08, 56778/08, 56781/08, 56784/08, 56786/08, 56789/08, 56801/08, 56806/08, 56813/08, 56816/08, 56827/08, 56832/08, 56837/08, 58306/08, 58344/08, 59027/08, 59599/08, 59626/08, 59628/08, 59698/08, 59699/08, 59703/08, 60036/08, and 4507/09) against the Russian Federation lodged with the Court under Article 34 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (“the Convention”) by 156 Russian citizens whose names and dates of birth are tabulated in the Annex (“the applicants”). The applications' dates of introduction are also tabulated in the Annex.
2. The applicants were represented, respectively, by Mr M. Antonov, Mr I. Fedotov, Mr V. Glukhov, Ms O. Gurova, Mr G. Migay, Mr. Y. Pakin, and Ms L. Yerokhina, consultants from the Moscow Region. The Russian Government (“the Government”) were represented by Mr G. Matyushkin, Representative of the Russian Federation at the European Court of Human Rights.
3. On 12 February 2009 the President of the First Section decided to give notice of the applications to the Government. It was also decided to examine the merits of the applications at the same time as their admissibility (Article 29 § 3). The Government objected to the joint examination of the admissibility and merits, but the Court rejected this objection.
THE FACTS[1]
4. The applicants are pensioners who live in the Moscow Region. Before retirement they used to work in hazardous industries. They had a dispute with a pension authority about the scope of their privileged pensions and appealed to the Region's district and town courts.
5. In September 2003–November 2006 the courts held for the applicants and ordered the pension authority to recalculate the pensions. The courts based their findings on the Law on Labour Pensions. These judgments became binding and were executed.
6. On the pension authority's request, in October 2007–June 2008 the district and town courts quashed their judgments due to discovery of new circumstances. The courts found, in particular, that the judgments had ignored the interpretation of the Law on Labour Pensions given by the Supreme Court in December 2005 and March 2007.
7. The applicants' cases were remitted for a rehearing and eventually dismissed.
THE LAW
I. JOINDER OF THE APPLICATIONS
8. As the applications are similar in terms of both fact and law, the Court decides to join them.
II. ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 6 § 1 OF THE CONVENTION AND OF ARTICLE 1 OF PROTOCOL No. 1
9. The applicants complained under Article 6 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 that the quashing of the binding judgments was unjustified. Insofar as relevant, these Articles read as follows:
Article 6 § 1
“In the determination of his civil rights and obligations ..., everyone is entitled to a fair ... hearing ... by [a] ... tribunal...”
Article 1 of Protocol No. 1
“Every natural or legal person is entitled to the peaceful enjoyment of his possessions. No one shall be deprived of his possessions except in the public interest and subject to the conditions provided for by law and by the general principles of international law.
The preceding provisions shall not, however, in any way impair the right of a State to enforce such laws as it deems necessary to control the use of property in accordance with the general interest or to secure the payment of taxes or other contributions or penalties.”
A. Admissibility
10. The Government argued that the applications were inadmissible. The Supreme Court's interpretations of the Law on Labour Pensions revealed fundamental errors in the district and town courts' reasoning, and hence those judgments had had to be quashed. The quashing had been legitimate, lawful, and compliant with the principle of legal certainty. The quashing was meant to ensure a uniform and coherent functioning of the State pension scheme and to protect the public purse from undue depletion.
11. The applicants argued that their applications were admissible. The quashing had been unjustified because the district and town courts did take into account the interpretation of 2005, and because the interpretation of 2007 had been given after the judgments. In any event, a legislative interpretation of laws might come only from a lawmaker, not from a court. Besides, the pension authority had missed the statutory time-limit for the quashing, and the courts had extended that limit without good reason.
12. The Court notes that the applications are not manifestly ill-founded within the meaning of Article 35 § 3 of the Convention. It further notes that they are not inadmissible on any other grounds. They must therefore be declared admissible.
B. Merits
13. The Court reiterates that for the sake of legal certainty implicitly required by Article 6, final judgments should generally be left intact. They may be disturbed only to correct fundamental defects (see Ryabykh v. Russia, no. 52854/99, §§ 51–52, ECHR 2003‑IX). Quashing of judgments because of newly-discovered circumstances is not by itself incompatible with this requirement, but the manner of its application may be (see Pravednaya v. Russia, no. 69529/01, §§ 27–34, 18 November 2004).
14. In the case at hand, the domestic courts justified the quashing with the Supreme Court's two interpretations of the Law on Labour Pensions.
As to the interpretation of 2005, the Court considers that differing judicial interpretations of a law represent a ground for an ordinary appeal, rather than a discovery warranting a quashing of a binding judgment (see Yerogova v. Russia, no. 77478/01, § 34, 19 June 2008).
As to the interpretation of 2007, the Court reiterates that newly-discovered circumstances are circumstances that exist during the trial, remain hidden from the court, and become known after trial. Since the interpretation of 2007 was posterior to the Town Court's judgments, it did not justify the quashing either (see Yerogova, cited above, § 33).
15. It follows that the quashing of the applicants' judgments was unjustified, and that there has, accordingly, been a violation of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1.
III. APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 41 OF THE CONVENTION
16. Article 41 of the Convention provides:
“If the Court finds that there has been a violation of the Convention or the Protocols thereto, and if the internal law of the High Contracting Party concerned allows only partial reparation to be made, the Court shall, if necessary, afford just satisfaction to the injured party.”
A. Damage, costs, and expenses
17. In respect of pecuniary damage, the applicants claimed sums ranging from 0 euros (EUR) to EUR 11,344. According to the applicants, these sums represented the difference between the pensions they had been receiving after the quashing and the pensions they would have received if there had been no quashing. The Government argued that this claim was excessive and unreasonable.
18. The Court rejects this claim in view of its speculative character (see Tarnopolskaya and Others v. Russia, nos. 11093/07, 14558/07, 19660/07, 30166/07, 46736/07, 52681/07, 52985/07, 10633/08, 10652/08, 12694/08, 15437/08, 16691/08, 19447/07, 19457/08, 20857/08, 20872/08, 22546/08, 25820/08, 25839/08, and 25845/08, § 51, 9 July 2009).
19. In respect of non-pecuniary damage, the applicants claimed sums ranging from EUR 2,000 to EUR 10,000. The Government contested this claim as ill-founded.
20. In respect of costs and expenses incurred before the Court, the applicants claimed sums ranging from EUR 0 to EUR 1,640. The Government noted that any possible award should cover only proven expenses.
21. The Court reiterates that it is an international judicial authority contingent on the consent of the States signatory to the Convention, and that its principal task is to secure the respect for human rights, rather than compensate applicants' losses minutely and exhaustively. Unlike in national jurisdictions, the emphasis of the Court's activity is on passing public judgments that set human-rights standards across Europe.
22. For this reason, in cases involving many similarly situated victims a unified approach may be called for. This approach will ensure that the applicants remain aggregated and that no disparity in the level of the awards will have a divisive effect on the applicants.
23. In view of the above, making its assessment on equitable and reasonable bases, the Court awards each applicant EUR 2,000 in respect of non-pecuniary damage, and costs and expenses.
B. Default interest
24. The Court considers it appropriate that the default interest should be based on the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank, to which should be added three percentage points.
FOR THESE REASONS, THE COURT UNANIMOUSLY
1. Decides to join the applications;
2. Declares the applications admissible;
3. Holds that there has been a violation of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1;
4. Holds
(a) that the respondent State is to pay each applicant, within three months from the date on which the judgment becomes final in accordance with Article 44 § 2 of the Convention, EUR 2,000 (two thousand euros), plus any tax that may be chargeable to the applicants, in respect of non-pecuniary damage, and costs and expenses, to be converted into Russian roubles at the rate applicable at the date of settlement;
(b) that from the expiry of the above-mentioned three months until settlement simple interest shall be payable on the above amount at a rate equal to the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank during the default period plus three percentage points;
5. Dismisses the remainder of the applicants' claims for just satisfaction.
Done in English, and notified in writing on 17 December 2009, pursuant to Rule 77 §§ 2 and 3 of the Rules of Court.
Søren NielsenChristos Rozakis
RegistrarPresiden
ANNEX
Application no.
Introduced on
Applicant
Born in
Court
Judgment of
Quashed on
4563/07
26/12/06
Ryabov Vladimir Pavlovich
1928
Elektrostal Town Court
01/06/06
22/11/07
19923/08
22/03/08
Zavedeyev Vladimir Nikolayevich
1938
Elektrostal Town Court
25/05/06
09/10/07
29853/08
25/05/08
Kochkolda Svetlana Pavlovna
1938
Korolyov Town Court
13/04/05
26/11/07
35836/08
24/06/08
Fedosova Olga Mikhaylovna
1949
Elektrostal Town Court
21/09/06
17/01/08
37062/08
17/06/08
Titova Tamara Nikolayevna
1950
Elektrostal Town Court
11/09/06
24/01/08
37064/08
17/06/08
Motorina Mariya Mikhaylovna
1931
Elektrostal Town Court
16/08/06
14/02/08
37069/08
19/06/08
Andronova Tamara Mikhaylovna
1928
Elektrostal Town Court
23/10/06
04/03/08
37072/08
25/06/08
Vasyunina Lyudmila Leontyevna
1948
Elektrostal Town Court
08/09/06
22/02/08
37568/08
01/07/08
Titov Yevgeniy Nikolayevich
1947
Elektrostal Town Court
11/09/06
24/01/08
37717/08
02/07/08
Knyazev Yuriy Anatolyevich
1952
Elektrostal Town Court
05/10/06
05/03/08
38120/08
16/07/08
Yevseyeva Nina Vasilyevna
1941
Elektrostal Town Court
18/09/06
25/03/08
38832/08
16/07/08
Usova Valentina Mikhaylovna
1945
Elektrostal Town Court
18/09/06
25/03/08
39479/08
19/07/08
Lazarenko Tatyana Mikhaylovna
1953
Elektrostal Town Court
15/09/06
31/03/08
39532/08
02/08/08
Khrisova Antonina Dmitriyevna
1957
Elektrostal Town Court
20/11/06
14/03/08
39601/08
02/08/08
Baranova Lyudmila Ivanovna
1955
Elektrostal Town Court
26/09/06
11/03/08
40675/08
18/07/08
Bovtalo Nikolay Ivanovich
1950
Elektrostal Town Court
20/10/06
23/01/08
40676/08
19/07/08
Shmakov Vladimir Dmitriyevich
1951
Elektrostal Town Court
06/10/06
22/02/08
40678/08
19/07/08
Shmakova Tatyana Aleksandrovna
1952
Elektrostal Town Court
06/10/06
22/02/08
41157/08
23/07/08
Shcherbakov Sergey Germanovich
1952
Elektrostal Town Court
21/09/06
12/02/08
41158/08
02/08/08
Bezikon Alla Vladimirovna
1958
Elektrostal Town Court
20/11/06
14/03/08
41161/08
28/07/08
Gorenshteyn Valentina Alekseyevna
1935
Elektrostal Town Court
23/10/06
04/04/08
41163/08
29/07/08
Yevseyeva Emiliya Fyodorovna
1939
Shchyolkovo Town Court
31/07/06
04/03/08
41794/08
04/07/08
Musorina Galina Ilyinichna
1939
Shchyolkovo Town Court
20/11/06
17/01/08
41804/08
27/06/08
Tishchenko Mikhail Kirillovich
1944
Shchyolkovo Town Court
13/10/06
12/02/08
41806/08
23/04/08
Sergeyenko Yuriy Mikhaylovich
1932
Elektrostal Town Court
25/05/06
27/11/07
41807/08
04/07/08
Levkina Lyubov Sergeyevna
1950
Shchyolkovo Town Court
21/11/06
14/01/08
41810/08
04/07/08
Rusin Vasiliy Pavlovich
1931
Elektrostal Town Court
19/09/06
07/02/08
41820/08
08/07/08
Popova Galina Ivanovna
1953
Noginsk Town Court
18/09/03
14/01/08
41822/08
09/07/08
Odina Olga Ivanovna
1951
Elektrostal Town Court
21/09/06
11/02/08
41824/08
09/07/08
Tikhomirov Viktor Feoktistovich
1946
Elektrostal Town Court
16/10/06
15/01/08
41825/08
09/07/08
Bulatova Galina Vasilyevna
1951
Elektrostal Town Court
21/09/06
24/03/08
Butskikh Amalia Efimovna
1930
Elektrostal Town Court
21/09/06
24/03/08
Chuvatkin Vladimir Yakovlevich
1925
Elektrostal Town Court
21/09/06
24/03/08
41828/08
09/07/08
Borisova Zinaida Nilovna
1925
Elektrostal Town Court
16/08/06
15/01/08
41911/08
09/08/08
Kharitonova Tatyana Valentinovna
1956
Elektrostal Town Court
12/10/06
26/03/08
41975/08
28/06/08
Ionova Svetlana Dmitriyevna
1951
Elektrostal Town Court
27/10/06
28/02/08
Application no.
Introduced on
Applicant
Born in
Court
Judgment of
Quashed on
41981/08
05/07/08
Smirnov Yuriy Aleksandrovich
1930
Elektrostal Town Court
23/10/06
18/03/08
42005/08
26/07/08
Sukonkina Galina Aleksandrovna
1938
Elektrostal Town Court
21/09/06
14/01/08
42006/08
26/07/08
Sukonkin German Alekseyevich
1934
Elektrostal Town Court
21/09/06
04/03/08
44357/08
28/08/08
Gunina Natalya Prokofyevna
1952
Elektrostal Town Court
03/10/06
13/03/08
44361/08
09/08/08
Anokhina Lyubov Ivanovna
1948
Shchyolkovo Town Court
22/09/06
04/03/08
44617/08
08/07/08
Arkhipova Aleksandra Anatolyevna
1937
Elektrostal Town Court
21/08/06
21/03/08
45200/08
22/08/08
Pichugina Yekaterina Pavlovna
1958
Elektrostal Town Court
28/06/06
31/03/08
45204/08
21/08/08
Parshenkova Olga Viktorovna
1959
Elektrostal Town Court
18/09/06
25/03/08
Kuzmina Yevdokiya Pavlovna
1945
Elektrostal Town Court
18/09/06
25/03/08
45207/08
22/08/08
Zelova Praskovya Sergeyevna
1927
Elektrostal Town Court
09/10/06
27/02/08
45243/08
22/08/08
Semencheva Nadezhda Anatolyevna
1954
Elektrostal Town Court
05/10/06
10/04/08
45246/08
21/08/08
Chaykova Galina Grigoriyevna
1947
Elektrostal Town Court
15/09/06
26/03/08
45253/08
05/08/08
Bugreyeva Yelena Stepanovna
1930
Elektrostal Town Court
07/11/06
27/03/08
45258/08
15/08/08
Mikhaylova Tamara Ivanovna
1957
Elektrostal Town Court
03/10/06
13/03/08
45261/08
15/08/08
Inkina Tamara Aleksandrovna
1949
Elektrostal Town Court
11/10/06
31/03/08
45265/08
16/08/08
Rakova Natalya Sergeyevna
1951
Elektrostal Town Court
28/09/06
19/02/08
45833/08
01/08/08
Myachin Sergey Fyodorovich
1953
Elektrostal Town Court
04/10/06
28/03/08
45834/08
17/07/08
Khokhlova Valentina Mikhaylovna
1929
Elektrostal Town Court
16/11/06
26/03/08
46047/08
19/08/08
Starchukova Zinaida Ivanovna
1933
Shchyolkovo Town Court
13/11/06
11/03/08
46210/08
30/08/08
Fakhrtdinov Aleksandr Gayasovich
1945
Voskresensk Town Court
14/04/05
09/04/08
46211/08
03/09/08
Roslyakova Svetlana Aleksandrovna
1939
Voskresensk Town Court
20/06/05
06/03/08
46215/08
30/08/08
Romanov Yevgeniy Petrovich
1954
Elektrostal Town Court
03/10/06
13/03/08
46218/08
30/08/08
Roslyakova Yelena Aleksandrovna
1952
Voskresensk Town Court
04/04/06
11/04/08
46965/08
14/08/08
Antonov Mikhail Alekseevich
1953
Elektrostal Town Court
21/11/06
25/03/08
46968/08
02/09/08
Savinova Valentina Maksimovna
1941
Elektrostal Town Court
27/10/06
25/03/08
47762/08
16/09/08
Dubanova Tatyana Sergeyevna
1948
Elektrostal Town Court
23/10/06
26/03/08
47768/08
22/09/08
Pershin Viktor Ivanovich
1956
Elektrostal Town Court
09/11/06
19/02/08
47774/08
05/09/08
Tyuvayev Nikolay Vasilyevich
1952
Elektrostal Town Court
23/10/06
26/03/08
47776/08
05/09/08
Fedotova Galina Aleksandrovna
1951
Voskresensk Town Court
25/04/05
20/02/08
47779/08
13/09/08
Poloskov Viktor Leonidovich
1925
Elektrostal Town Court
30/10/06
31/03/08
47783/08
06/09/08
Romanova Nadezhda Viktorovna
1929
Voskresensk Town Court
19/05/05
12/03/08
47878/08
14/08/08
Zenina Valentina Nikityevna
1940
Elektrostal Town Court
17/10/06
27/03/08
48025/08
25/08/08
Pavlova Tatyana Anatolyevna
1953
Elektrostal Town Court
21/09/06
21/03/08
48045/08
22/08/08
Krayushkina Lyubov Aleksandrovna
1947
Elektrostal Town Court
27/10/06
28/02/08
48049/08
22/08/08
Perevitskaya Marina Vladislavovna
1953
Elektrostal Town Court
27/10/06
28/02/08
48054/08
23/08/08
Gusarova Maria Efimovna
1933
Elektrostal Town Court
14/08/06
03/03/08
48056/08
22/08/08
Krasilnikova Rimma Nikolayevna
1949
Elektrostal Town Court
27/09/06
20/03/08
48587/08
16/09/08
Shamova Galina Vasilyevna
1951
Elektrostal Town Court
23/10/06
02/04/08
48606/08
16/09/08
Denis Valentina Fedorovna
1948
Elektrostal Town Court
09/11/06
02/04/08
48854/08
07/09/08
Samsonov Valentin Nikolayevich
1946
Elektrostal Town Court
20/11/06
20/03/08
48861/08
07/09/08
Ogurtsova Antonina Ivanovna
1929
Elektrostal Town Court
23/10/06
27/03/08
Application no.
Introduced on
Applicant
Born in
Court
Judgment of
Quashed on
48877/08
20/09/08
Kazina Tatyana Konstantinovna
1949
Elektrostal Town Court
21/08/06
21/03/08
48942/08
12/09/08
Bryunina Tatyana Germanovna
1949
Elektrostal Town Court
13/10/06
13/03/08
48956/08
16/09/08
Sapunov Vladimir Ignatyevich
1939
Elektrostal Town Court
20/11/06
28/03/08
49322/08
19/09/08
Saprykin Igor Nikolayevich
1950
Elektrostal Town Court
30/10/06
27/03/08
49325/08
19/09/08
Ivanova Nina Nikolayevna
1951
Elektrostal Town Court
30/10/06
20/03/08
49411/08
22/09/08
Galochkina Irina Lvovna
1959
Elektrostal Town Court
15/09/06
26/03/08
49415/08
22/09/08
Goncharenko Viktor Grigoryevich
1948
Elektrostal Town Court
15/09/06
26/03/08
49563/08
16/09/08
Trimasova Nina Vasilyevna
1934
Elektrostal Town Court
21/09/06
25/03/08
51002/08
02/10/08
Kolosovskaya Lyudmila Vasilyeva
1929
Elektrostal Town Court
25/10/06
07/06/08
52521/08
22/09/08
Lukina Galina Pavlovna
1956
Elektrostal Town Court
15/09/06
26/03/08
52557/08
30/08/08
Feofanov Anatoliy Leonidovich
1947
Voskresensk Town Court
26/04/05
17/03/08
52563/08
27/08/08
Mosina Natalya Nikolayevna
1952
Elektrostal Town Court
23/10/06
26/03/08
52566/08
21/08/08
Kovyrshina Larisa Vasilyevna
1959
Elektrostal Town Court
14/09/06
26/03/08
53574/08
14/08/08
Igonin Oleg Vasilyevich
1946
Elektrostal Town Court
30/10/06
26/03/08
53579/08
03/09/08
Larkova Raisa Zakharovna
1947
Voskresensk Town Court
04/07/05
06/03/08
53583/08
08/09/09
Mitichev Yevgeniy Vasilyevich
1955
Voskresensk Town Court
21/03/06
12/03/08
53587/08
21/08/08
Petrova Lyudmila Vasilyevna
1930
Elektrostal Town Court
21/09/06
21/03/08
53589/08
22/08/08
Yefimova Zoya Fedorovna
1946
Elektrostal Town Court
04/10/06
26/03/08
53593/08
23/07/08
Zavyalova Kseniya Petrovna
1935
Elektrostal Town Court
25/09/06
24/01/08
53595/08
26/07/08
Solomatin Mikhail Pavlovich
1925
Elektrostal Town Court
20/11/06
17/03/08
53600/08
09/07/08
Volchukova Mariya Ivanovna
1932
Elektrostal Town Court
31/07/06
24/01/08
53603/08
18/09/08
Tulyakova Olga Viktorovna
1955
Elektrostal Town Court
18/10/06
26/03/08
53605/08
05/09/08
Rukityanskaya Nina Mikhaylovna
1945
Elektrostal Town Court
27/10/06
27/03/08
53607/08
05/09/08
Rukityanskiy Vladimir Dmitriyevich
1941
Elektrostal Town Court
27/10/06
02/04/08
53611/08
20/08/08
Kukuy Irina Stepanovna
1935
Elektrostal Town Court
09/11/06
02/04/08
53614/08
19/08/08
Starkova Mariya Vasilyevna
1932
Elektrostal Town Court
12/10/06
21/02/08
53617/08
13/08/08
Bogatov Akim Fedorovich
1928
Elektrostal Town Court
12/10/06
27/03/08
53620/08
20/06/08
Alferova Nadezhda Mikhaylovna
1956
Elektrostal Town Court
13/09/06
11/02/08
53623/08
02/09/08
Nazina Yuliya Pavlovna
1929
Elektrostal Town Court
09/11/06
25/03/08
53629/08
13/08/08
Bondar Anatoliy Ivanovich
1929
Elektrostal Town Court
10/11/06
13/03/08
53632/08
24/09/08
Romanova Galina Dmitriyevna
1952
Elektrostal Town Court
27/10/06
25/03/08
54367/08
09/08/08
Khusyainova Rauza Safovna
1950
Shchyolkovo Town Court
21/08/06
04/03/08
54379/08
11/08/08
Dent Yuriy Semenovich
1937
Shchyolkovo Town Court
17/11/06
15/02/08
54384/08
22/07/08
Mokrinskaya Marina Nikolayevna
1959
Elektrostal Town Court
20/10/06
23/01/08
54392/08
18/08/08
Kuznetsova Aleksandra Petrovna
unknown
Elektrostal Town Court
06/10/06
22/02/08
54396/08
54396/08
Panfilova Olga Georgiyevna
1954
Voskresensk Town Court
12/07/05
28/02/08
54398/08
04/07/08
Subbotina Tatyana Vasilyevna
1950
Shchyolkovo Town Court
13/11/06
09/01/08
54399/08
03/07/08
Andrianova Antonina Aleksandrovna
1937
Elektrostal Town Court
17/10/06
27/03/08
54400/08
03/07/08
Kvasova Olga Yuryevna
1958
Elektrostal Town Court
09/11/06
19/02/08
54431/08
19/09/08
Musinov Viktor Nikolayevich
1947
Elektrostal Town Court
13/10/06
13/03/08
54456/08
05/06/08
Romantsova Mariya Yakovlevna
1939
Elektrostal Town Court
19/09/06
11/03/08
Application no.
Introduced on
Applicant
Born in
Court
Judgment of
Quashed on
54470/08
12/08/08
Khlopova Tatyana Nikolayevna
1950
Elektrostal Town Court
06/10/08
28/02/08
54473/08
22/07/08
Lyalkina Galina Ivanovna
1924
Elektrostal Town Court
17/11/06
28/03/08
54507/08
24/06/08
Obyedkova Tamara Mikhaylovna
1951
Elektrostal Town Court
16/08/06
23/01/08
54513/08
13/08/08
Khakimova Zaynyad
1927
Elektrostal Town Court
28/09/06
21/02/08
54526/08
12/08/08
Zaytseva Valentina Leonidovna
1947
Elektrostal Town Court
12/10/06
19/03/08
54530/08
08/08/08
Chelnokova Lyudmila Yakovlevna
1941
Elektrostal Town Court
05/10/06
10/04/08
54590/08
31/07/08
Shatilov Dmitriy Mikhaylovich
1952
Elektrostal Town Court
09/10/06
02/04/08
54593/08
13/08/08
Yefimenko Vladimir Aleksandrovich
1946
Elektrostal Town Court
15/10/06
26/03/08
54596/08
13/08/08
Fedorova Valentina Nikolayevna
1934
Elektrostal Town Court
18/10/06
27/03/08
54602/08
29/07/08
Solomatina Rimma Mikhaylovna
1930
Elektrostal Town Court
21/11/06
19/03/08
54605/08
29/07/08
Klimov Viktor Yegorovich
1941
Elektrostal Town Court
30/10/06
02/04/08
54608/08
18/07/08
Dubovitskaya Nina Ivanovna
1938
Elektrostal Town Court
29/09/06
28/02/08
56037/08
21/10/08
Musatova Galina Ivanovna
1960
Voskresensk Town Court
12/09/06
22/04/08
56774/08
06/10/08
Pusep Viktor Vasilyevich
1952
Voskresensk Town Court
24/05/05
08/04/08
56778/08
06/09/08
Sidorova Tatyana Petrovna
1954
Elektrostal Town Court
19/10/06
20/03/08
56781/08
30/08/08
Romanova Tatyana Semenovna
1954
Elektrostal Town Court
03/10/06
13/03/08
56784/08
04/09/08
Zotova Tamara Yuryevna
1951
Voskresensk Town Court
10/08/06
04/03/08
56786/08
12/09/08
Chernikov Aleksey Grigoryevich
1955
Voskresensk Town Court
06/03/06
12/03/08
56789/08
09/09/08
Yamshchikova Lidiya Andriyanovna
1946
Elektrostal Town Court
18/10/06
26/03/08
56801/08
03/09/08
Sidorova Nadezhda Petrovna
1927
Elektrostal Town Court
20/11/06
28/03/08
56806/08
05/09/08
Tyuvayeva Nadezhda Vasilyevna
1954
Elektrostal Town Court
23/10/06
28/03/08
56813/08
03/09/08
Chernetskaya Polina Vasilyevna
1928
Elektrostal Town Court
16/08/06
14/03/08
56816/08
14/08/08
Chernomurov Yuriy Nikolayevich
1952
Elektrostal Town Court
13/09/06
18/02/08
56827/08
10/09/08
Tsybenko Liya Borisovna
1957
Elektrostal Town Court
15/11/06
03/04/08
56832/08
02/10/08
Kashtanova Tatyana Vladimirovna
1947
Elektrostal Town Court
25/10/06
07/06/08
56837/08
25/09/08
Yeliseyeva Galina Vasilyevna
1948
Elektrostal Town Court
05/10/06
10/04/08
58306/08
17/10/08
Akatova Lidiya Alekseyevna
1927
Elektrostal Town Court
31/07/06
31/03/08
58344/08
29/04/08
Vaskina Valentina Nikolayevna
1946
Elektrostal Town Court
31/05/06
06/11/07
59027/08
08/10/08
Gurova Olga Ivanovna
1956
Elektrostal Town Court
21/11/06
07/06/08
59599/08
25/09/08
Rogatin Vyacheslav Aleksandrovich
1955
Voskresensk Town Court
11/05/06
03/04/08
59626/08
30/08/08
Moskalenko Vladimir Vasilyevich
1948
Voskresensk Town Court
16/02/06
05/03/08
59628/08
01/09/08
Bulekov Pavel Fyodorovich
1930
Voskresensk Town Court
18/04/06
03/03/08
59698/08
16/08/08
Krylov Yuriy Vladimirovich
1949
Elektrostal Town Court
21/09/06
11/03/08
59699/08
20/09/08
Fomichev Nikolay Petrovich
1929
Voskresensk Town Court
05/08/05
26/03/08
59703/08
08/10/08
Sharova Larisa Vasilyevna
1947
Elektrostal Town Court
20/10/06
27/03/08
60036/08
22/11/08
Ivanova Nadezhda Vladimirovna
1955
Elektrostal Town Court
25/10/06
10/06/08
4507/09
19/11/08
Bakhireva Natalya Dmitriyevna
1956
Elektrostal Town Court
26/10/06
07/06/08
[1].Factual details concerning individual applications are given in the Annex.
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy