Resolution CM/ResDH(2018)371
Execution of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights
171 cases against Ukraine
(Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 3 October 2018
at the 1326th meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies)
The Committee of Ministers, under the terms of Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, which provides that the Committee supervises the execution of final judgments of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter “the Convention” and “the Court”),
Having regard to the final judgments transmitted by the Court to the Committee in these cases (see Appendix) and to the violations established mainly on account of excessive length of civil proceedings as well as the lack of effective remedy in this respect (violations of Articles 6, paragraph 1 and 13);
Recalling the respondent State’s obligation, under Article 46, paragraph 1, of the Convention, to abide by all final judgments in cases to which it has been a party and that this obligation entails, over and above the payment of any sums awarded by the Court, the adoption by the authorities of the respondent State, where required:
- of individual measures to put an end to violations established and erase their consequences so as to achieve as far as possible restitutio in integrum; and
- of general measures preventing similar violations;
Having invited the government of the respondent State to inform the Committee of the measures taken to comply with the above-mentioned obligation;
Having examined the information provided by the government indicating the individual measures adopted in order to give effect to the judgments including the information provided regarding the payment of the just satisfaction awarded by the Court and the state of domestic proceedings (see Annex I to the document DH-DD(2018)760);
Considering that the question of individual measures has therefore been resolved in these cases, given that the domestic proceedings have been terminated and that all required individual measures have also been taken in respect of the other violations found by the Court; noting in that respect that the internal judgment debts were paid to the applicants in the cases of Chukhas and Shulga;
Recalling that the question of general measures required in response to the shortcomings found by the Court in these judgments continues to be examined within the framework of the Svetlana Naumenko group of cases and that the closure of these cases therefore in no way prejudges the Committee’s evaluation of the general measures in relation to the excessive length of civil proceedings and the lack of an effective domestic remedy in this respect;
Noting also that questions related to the non-enforcement or delayed enforcement of domestic judicial decisions, mostly delivered against the State and State-owned or controlled entities, and to the lack of an effective remedy in this respect, raised by the Chukhas and Shulga cases, are being examined by the Committee in the context of the supervision of the Zhovner / Yuriy Nikolayevich Ivanov group of cases;
DECLARES that it has exercised its functions under Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention in the cases listed below as regards the individual measures and
DECIDES to close the examination thereof.
Appendix: List of cases
Application No.
Case
Judgment of
Final on
10347/07
STARYGIN
13/10/2011
13/10/2011
10437/02
KUKHARCHUK
10/08/2006
10/11/2006
10569/03
BARSKIY
05/07/2007
05/10/2007
10636/05
KOVALEV
21/12/2010
21/12/2010
1071/08
PONOMARENKO
06/10/2011
06/10/2011
10792/04
NESTEROVA
28/05/2009
28/08/2009
11084/03
KOZLOV
12/07/2007
12/10/2007
11208/03
KOLOMOYETS
15/07/2010
15/10/2010
11447/04
LOSHENKO
11/12/2008
11/03/2009
11471/08
SHPILKO
19/04/2012
19/04/2012
12347/02
LASTOVKA
06/09/2007
06/12/2007
12355/06
VIKULOVA
21/04/2011
21/04/2011
1278/06
TKACHENKO
04/04/2013
04/04/2013
12803/02
OGURTSOVA
01/02/2007
23/05/2007
13242/02
KONOVALOV
18/10/2007
18/01/2008
14018/08
MANGADASH AND OTHERS
14/06/2012
14/06/2012
14089/03
NIKONENKO
29/05/2008
29/08/2008
14403/04
SHEPELEVA
15/10/2009
15/01/2010
14518/07
KRAVETS
10/01/2013
10/01/2013
15045/05
ASMOLOV
21/04/2011
21/04/2011
15935/06
KLIMENKO
17/02/2011
17/02/2011
16443/07
KALYUZHNA
07/04/2011
07/04/2011
1661/04
BENDRYT
10/12/2009
10/03/2010
16652/04
SHULGA
02/12/2010
02/12/2010
16901/03
SIREDZHUK
21/01/2016
21/04/2016
17026/05
GITSKAYLO
14/02/2008
14/05/2008
17059/07
VOLCHKOVA
22/09/2011
22/09/2011
17156/05
PALAMARCHUK
21/10/2010
21/10/2010
17185/02
FEDINA
02/09/2010
02/12/2010
17446/06
VOLOVIK
24/02/2011
24/02/2011
17674/05
CHUBAKOVA
18/02/2010
18/05/2010
17842/08
PALAMARCHUK
24/11/2011
24/11/2011
17945/02
N.B.
03/04/2008
03/07/2008
18010/04
KUSHNARENKO
13/11/2008
05/06/2009
18255/05
NEKHANCHENKO
28/10/2010
28/10/2010
183/06
MITAKIY
19/02/2009
05/06/2009
18345/03
LEBEDEVA
20/12/2007
20/03/2008
18389/03
MIKHAYLENKO
15/05/2008
15/08/2008
18508/07
SHAPOVALOVA
22/09/2011
22/09/2011
1853/08
FEDOROVA
12/05/2011
12/05/2011
18608/05
FPK GROSS, OOO
16/02/2012
16/02/2012
1866/04
BURYAK
19/02/2009
19/05/2009
18951/04
MAYSTER
09/12/2010
09/12/2010
18957/03
RUDYSH
15/11/2007
31/03/2008
19142/03
YAKYMENKO
29/05/2008
29/08/2008
20165/04
ROSTUNOVA
18/02/2010
28/06/2010
20330/03
PETRENKO
12/06/2008
12/09/2008
20339/03
BLIDCHENKO
29/11/2007
29/02/2008
20746/05
FEDORCHUK
15/11/2007
15/02/2008
20856/05
MAKHONKO
13/10/2011
13/10/2011
21047/02
KISELYOVA
22/11/2007
22/02/2008
21263/04
VOISHCHEV
19/02/2009
19/05/2009
21798/05
KADUK
20/01/2011
20/01/2011
21922/07
DEMENOVA
15/03/2012
15/03/2012
21939/05
MKRTCHYAN
20/05/2010
20/08/2010
22149/05
VOYT
08/04/2010
08/07/2010
22431/02
BAGLAY
08/11/2005
08/02/2006
2248/06
BLINOVA
26/04/2012
26/04/2012
22580/04
BELOUS
08/04/2010
08/07/2010
22581/04
CHEPYZHNA
11/12/2008
11/03/2009
22775/03
FANDRALYUK
31/01/2008
30/04/2008
23747/05
SHEPTITSKAYA AND SHEPTITSKIY
03/03/2011
03/03/2011
23786/02
KRASNOSHAPKA
30/11/2006
28/02/2007
23853/02
KARNAUSHENKO
30/11/2006
28/02/2007
23926/02
SILIN
13/07/2006
13/10/2006
24131/03
CHUYAN
15/11/2007
15/02/2008
2414/06
KUTSENKO(No. 2)
03/02/2011
03/02/2011
24429/03
SOLOMAKHIN
15/03/2012
24/09/2012
24436/06
VARLAMOVA
19/04/2012
19/04/2012
24685/07
AVRAMENKO
03/03/2011
03/03/2011
24857/07
MARCHENKO
10/02/2011
10/02/2011
24959/06
MARUTSENKO
31/05/2011
31/05/2011
25681/03
PANCHENKO
05/07/2007
05/10/2007
25713/06
MITSEVY
16/02/2012
16/02/2012
26675/07
BYKOV
16/04/2009
16/07/2009
26864/03
VASHCHENKO
26/06/2008
26/09/2008
26976/06
MUSIYENKO
20/01/2011
20/01/2011
27234/04
BRATCHENKO
18/11/2010
18/11/2010
27341/05
TVERDOKHLEBOV
19/11/2009
19/02/2010
27685/04
PRASOV
03/03/2011
03/03/2011
27820/04
KOSTYCHEV
08/04/2010
08/07/2010
28297/08
KHAZHEVSKIY
19/04/2012
19/04/2012
28325/04
MURDUGOVA
02/02/2012
02/02/2012
28660/04
SOKOLOVSKIY
13/01/2011
13/01/2011
28746/03
VYROVYY
12/07/2007
12/10/2007
29025/05
YAKUBOVYCH
30/07/2009
30/10/2009
29843/04
DEMIDOVA
02/12/2010
02/12/2010
30741/08
LARIONOV
10/11/2011
10/11/2011
30853/04
SHAPOSHNIKOV
08/04/2010
04/10/2010
30972/07
KRAT
21/12/2010
21/12/2010
311/03
SOLOMATINA
29/05/2008
29/08/2008
31105/02
SHINKARENKO
07/06/2007
24/09/2007
31406/03
GAVRILYAK
03/04/2008
03/07/2008
31572/03
YEROSHKINA
18/06/2009
18/09/2009
31780/02
PANTELEEVA
05/07/2007
10/12/2007
32038/04
LYUTOV
11/12/2008
11/03/2009
32849/05
PAPAZOVA AND OTHERS
15/03/2012
15/03/2012
33697/04
PREKRASNYY
18/02/2010
18/05/2010
33983/02
ARTEMENKO
07/06/2007
07/09/2007
34332/03
PUSTOVIT
18/11/2010
18/11/2010
34545/05
BESTIYANETS
04/10/2012
04/10/2012
35176/08
PAVLIV
20/01/2011
20/01/2011
35187/04
MYKULYN
18/02/2010
18/05/2010
3572/03
TSYKHANOVSKYY
06/09/2007
31/03/2008
35909/06
TROFIMOVA AND ZYLKOVA
15/03/2012
15/03/2012
36002/08
OLKHOVIKOVA
25/11/2010
25/11/2010
36223/06
LITVINOVA
28/10/2010
28/10/2010
36283/02
KIRICHENKO AND BELINSKIY
15/05/2008
15/08/2008
3638/04
SHASTKIV AND VALITSKA
30/07/2009
30/10/2009
36545/02
MOROZ AND OTHERS
21/12/2006
21/03/2007
36619/05
KRYZHANIVSKYY
12/01/2012
12/01/2012
36655/02
SMIRNOVA
08/11/2005
08/02/2006
36758/08
OMELYANENKO
22/09/2011
22/09/2011
36949/02
PAVLOVSKA
03/07/2008
03/10/2008
37138/04
KOBCHENKO
21/12/2010
21/12/2010
37246/04
GURYNENKO
18/02/2010
18/05/2010
37500/04
BUBLYK
18/06/2009
18/09/2009
377/02
MENSHAKOVA
08/04/2010
04/10/2010
38711/06
SLYADNYEVA
26/07/2012
26/07/2012
38753/06
SUBOT
21/12/2010
21/12/2010
39028/04
KHALAK
18/02/2010
18/05/2010
39161/02
GOLOVKO
01/02/2007
01/05/2007
39404/02
MUKHIN
19/10/2006
19/01/2007
39763/02
TERENTYEV
29/05/2008
29/08/2008
39855/04
UDOVIK
18/02/2010
18/05/2010
39878/05
ONOPKO
02/02/2012
02/02/2012
39946/03
INKOVTSOVA
26/07/2007
26/10/2007
4078/03
CHUKHAS
12/07/2007
12/10/2007
41286/04
VORONENKOV
19/02/2009
19/05/2009
42207/04
YAVORSKA
15/11/2007
15/02/2008
43482/02
MAKARENKO
01/02/2007
01/05/2007
43799/05
YEFREMOV
16/12/2010
16/12/2010
4430/04
SEBOVA
30/07/2009
30/10/2009
44654/06
PETROV AND OTHERS
08/12/2011
08/12/2011
44674/05
LOBATSKA
05/04/2012
05/04/2012
45846/05
GUTKA
08/04/2010
08/07/2010
47305/06
SKOROKHOD
29/09/2011
29/09/2011
48874/06
RUDYCH
10/02/2011
10/02/2011
49009/07
SOKOR
09/12/2010
09/12/2010
49430/99
STRANNIKOV
03/05/2005
03/08/2005
50138/07
ANDRENKO
20/01/2011
20/01/2011
5050/07
SHCHUROV
06/10/2011
06/10/2011
5144/06
REVUNETS
17/02/2011
17/02/2011
5211/05
MALANCHUK AND VAVRENYUK
18/02/2010
18/05/2010
53249/07
KRYUKOV(VI)
21/12/2010
21/12/2010
53443/07
CHERNYSH
24/11/2011
24/11/2011
55326/07
SOBOLEV
22/09/2011
22/09/2011
5547/07
SURDINA
20/12/2011
20/12/2011
55865/07
SVERCHKOV AND SVERCHKOVA
10/11/2011
10/11/2011
55870/00
EFIMENKO
18/07/2006
11/12/2006
56918/00
LESHCHENKO AND TOLYUPA
08/11/2005
08/02/2006
595/08
ZHUZHA
06/10/2011
06/10/2011
61679/00
DULSKIY
01/06/2006
01/09/2006
6261/04
LAZARUK
19/11/2009
19/02/2010
6508/05
SLANKO
15/07/2010
15/10/2010
6713/07
ZHELEZNOVA
21/04/2011
21/04/2011
6717/07
ZHELEZNOVA(No 2)
21/04/2011
21/04/2011
68762/01
NATALIYA SHEVCHENKO
15/05/2008
15/08/2008
70767/01
PAVLYULYNETS
06/09/2005
06/12/2005
72551/01
TELIGA AND OTHERS
21/12/2006
21/03/2007
7411/05
SHAPOVAL
08/04/2010
08/07/2010
7536/05
KOLESNIKOVA
03/03/2011
03/03/2011
7575/05
RUSNAKOVA
20/01/2011
20/01/2011
7867/06
GONCHAROV
10/12/2009
10/05/2010
8503/05
KHURAVA
08/04/2010
08/07/2010
8944/07
KISELYOVA
10/02/2011
10/02/2011
9025/03
PILIPEY
18/06/2009
06/11/2009
9476/06
SEMENYUK
20/01/2011
20/01/2011
9510/03
LESINA
19/06/2008
01/12/2008
9616/03
SVISTUN
21/06/2007
21/09/2007
9755/03
DOLGIKH
28/06/2007
28/09/2007
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy