Resolution CM/ResDH(2017)422
Execution of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights
253 cases against Hungary
(Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 7 December 2017
at the 1302nd meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies)
The Committee of Ministers, under the terms of Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, which provides that the Committee supervises the execution of final judgments of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter “the Convention” and “the Court”),
Having regard to the final judgments transmitted by the Court to the Committee in these cases and to the violations established concerning the excessive length of civil and criminal proceedings and the lack of an effective remedy in this respect (violations of Articles 6 and 13);
Recalling the respondent State’s obligation, under Article 46, paragraph 1, of the Convention, to abide by all final judgments in cases to which it has been a party and that this obligation entails, over and above the payment of any sums awarded by the Court, the adoption by the authorities of the respondent State, where required:
-of individual measures to put an end to violations established and erase their consequences so as to achieve as far as possible restitutio in integrum; and
-of general measures preventing similar violations;
Having invited the government of the respondent State to inform the Committee of the measures taken to comply with the above-mentioned obligation;
Having noted the information provided regarding the payment of the just satisfaction awarded by the Court and the state of the proceedings which were still pending at domestic level at the time the Court rendered its judgment (see documents DH-DD(2017)220, DH-DD(2015)1377);
Considering that the individual measures have been resolved, given that the domestic proceedings in these cases have been terminated;
Recalling that the general measures required to respond to the shortcomings established by the Court in the present judgments continue to be examined within the framework of the pilot judgment in the case of Gazsó (Application No. 48322/12) and the other cases belonging to this group and that the closure of the cases listed below in no way prejudges the Committee’s evaluation of the general measures in relation to the excessive length of civil and criminal proceedings and the lack of an effective remedy in this respect,
DECLARES that it has exercised its functions under Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention in these cases and
DECIDES to close the examination thereof.
Appendix
Cases of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations
Application
Case
Judgment of
Final on
36186/97
TÍMÁR
25/02/2003
09/07/2003
36124/10
ABBAS
25/03/2014
25/03/2014
12089/07
ÁGNES KOVÁCS
24/09/2013
24/09/2013
8034/07
AGROLA TRADE KFT.
08/10/2013
08/10/2013
18328/03
AJZERT
07/11/2006
26/03/2007
45311/05
BAKONYI
03/05/2007
12/11/2007
44880/08
BAKSA
11/06/2013
11/06/2013
1107/04
BALOGH
27/11/2007
27/02/2008
52664/07
BARANYI AND OTHERS
09/10/2012
09/10/2012
44413/05
BARATI
11/01/2011
11/01/2011
40465/04
BARNA
09/10/2007
09/01/2008
40431/04
BARNA
23/10/2007
23/01/2008
35364/09
BARNA No. 2
25/03/2014
25/06/2014
8226/07
BARTAL
27/07/2010
27/07/2010
33486/07
BARTHA
25/03/2014
25/06/2014
9269/08
BELÉNYESI
30/03/2010
30/06/2010
4578/03
BENCZE
31/10/2006
12/02/2007
17596/12
BENKŐ AND SOÓSNÉ BENKŐ
08/07/2014
08/10/2014
14276/04
BERGMANN
27/03/2008
27/06/2008
15652/04
BÍRÓ
18/07/2006
18/10/2006
46206/07
BODNAR
15/11/2012
15/11/2012
81099/12
BODOR
25/03/2014
25/03/2014
14962/03
BÖRCSÖK BODOR
03/10/2006
12/02/2007
44885/04
BORODY
20/11/2007
20/02/2008
48150/11
BÖRZSÖNYI
22/10/2013
22/10/2013
14996/05
CSABAINÉ GYŐRI
27/03/2008
27/06/2008
57525/12
CSABUDA
22/04/2014
22/04/2014
25749/10
CSÁK
15/10/2015
15/10/2015
40293/06
CSANICS
01/03/2011
01/03/2011
53834/07
CSERJÉS AND OTHERS
15/11/2012
15/11/2012
33255/02
CSÍK
11/04/2006
13/09/2006
49905/06
CSORBA
06/12/2011
06/12/2011
34418/04
CSŐSZ
29/01/2008
29/04/2008
13290/05
CZIFRA
24/03/2009
06/07/2009
38636/06
CZIGANYIK
01/03/2011
01/03/2011
26242/04
CZMARKÓ
09/10/2007
31/03/2008
71096/01
DALA
05/10/2004
05/01/2005
43198/11
DÉRY
01/10/2015
01/10/2015
59562/00
EARL
20/01/2004
20/04/2004
5194/07
ECOPREVENT KFT
07/10/2008
07/01/2009
36343/03
EMESZ
31/10/2006
12/02/2007
32069/05
EÖSÖLY
24/02/2009
24/05/2009
63153/10
FARAGÓ AND OTHERS
22/10/2013
22/10/2013
4968/10
FARKAS
23/06/2015
23/06/2015
4564/03
FODOR
23/05/2006
18/07/2006
30799/04
FONYÓDI
07/10/2008
05/05/2009
38042/06
FÜRY
27/07/2010
27/07/2010
33723/06
GAVRIS
15/03/2011
15/03/2011
23364/03
GERGELY
31/10/2006
26/03/2007
17628/04
GLÖCKLER AND OTHERS
05/02/2008
05/05/2008
20014/04+
GŐGÖS
27/03/2008
27/06/2008
28323/04
GOTTHÁRD-GÁZ KFT
05/06/2007
05/09/2007
47018/10
GRESPIK
22/04/2014
22/04/2014
36999/08
GUEST ZRT
11/06/2013
11/06/2013
53943/07
GUTMAN
08/11/2012
08/11/2012
15258/06
GYÁRFÁS AND HUNAUDIT KFT
27/07/2010
27/07/2010
32990/09
GYULA VARGA
22/01/2013
22/01/2013
20915/07
GYULÁNÉ KOCSIS
08/11/2012
08/11/2012
34344/07
GYULANE SZABO
08/02/2010
08/02/2010
35569/05
HATALA
30/11/2010
30/11/2010
9254/07
HEGYI
14/06/2011
14/06/2011
30077/03
HÉLIOPLÁN KFT
03/05/2007
12/11/2007
39382/06
HESZ
30/11/2010
28/02/2011
5482/05
HIDVÉGI
14/10/2008
14/01/2009
25709/04
HILTI
09/10/2007
09/01/2008
45407/05
HORVÁTH AND OTHERS
24/11/2009
17/05/2011
24/02/2010
17/08/2011
47902/08
ILONA KOVÁCS
17/02/2015
17/02/2015
13647/04
IMMOBILIA BAU KFT
09/10/2007
10/12/2007
35000/07
ISTVÁN KOCSIS
22/10/2013
22/10/2013
121/11
ISTVÁN NAGY
15/10/2015
15/10/2015
40109/03
JACZKÓ
18/07/2006
18/10/2006
25279/06
JÁHNY
03/06/2014
03/06/2014
6841/07
JANOS TOTH
20/10/2011
20/10/2011
19689/05
JÁNOSI
29/09/2009
29/12/2009
11440/02
JÁVOR AND OTHERS
23/05/2006
23/10/2006
30081/02
KALLÓ
11/04/2006
11/07/2006
32783/03
KALMÁR
03/10/2006
03/01/2007
16073/07
KALMÁR ZOLTÁNNÉ
27/07/2010
27/07/2010
4417/02
KÁLNÁSI G. AND G.
27/09/2005
15/02/2006
53421/11
KANDA
26/04/2016
26/04/2016
458/03
KÁNTOR
22/11/2005
22/02/2006
37494/02
KARÁCSONYI
18/04/2006
18/07/2006
75116/01
KARALYOS AND HUBER[1]
06/04/2004
06/07/2004
26859/05
KARAVÁN CITY BT.
20/10/2009
20/01/2010
6444/02+
KÁRMÁN
22/11/2005
22/02/2006
58887/00
KÁROLY
02/12/2003
24/03/2004
13318/02
KÁRPÁTI
06/12/2005
06/03/2006
61568/00
KASTNER
29/06/2004
29/09/2004
20075/05
KATONA
24/03/2009
24/06/2009
16033/06
KELEMEN
14/06/2011
14/06/2011
73413/01
KELLNER
28/09/2004
28/12/2004
47355/99
KERÉKGYÁRTÓ
16/12/2003
24/03/2004
14966/03
KESZTHELYI
25/04/2006
25/07/2006
66232/10
KINCSES
27/01/2015
01/06/2015
7097/11
KIS AND BOZA
22/04/2014
22/04/2014
31754/04
KISS
29/01/2008
29/04/2008
15670/04
KISS ÁRON
09/12/2008
09/03/2009
2462/03
KOCSIS
11/04/2006
11/07/2006
39138/05
KOKAVECZ
15/06/2010
15/09/2010
12192/06
KOKAVECZ No. II
20/10/2011
20/10/2011
15509/05
KOLLÁTH
27/11/2007
27/02/2008
4825/02
KORGA
06/12/2005
12/04/2006
7680/05
KORONCZAI
10/06/2008
10/09/2008
9271/07
KOTELES
15/03/2011
15/03/2011
37492/02
KOVAČ
18/04/2006
13/09/2006
54457/00
KOVÁCS
16/12/2003
07/07/2004
23435/03
KOVÁCS
23/10/2007
23/01/2008
67660/01
KOVÁCS TAMÁS
28/09/2004
28/12/2004
25454/06
KOVACSICS AND AUTÓMOBIL KFT.
20/10/2011
20/10/2011
12941/05
KREISZ
03/04/2007
03/07/2007
23992/02
KRISTÓF
11/04/2006
11/07/2006
22434/08
KULCSÁR
25/03/2014
25/03/2014
42260/05
KUSTÁR
08/01/2009
08/04/2009
4853/02
KÚTFALVY
05/10/2004
05/01/2005
60459/12
KVACSKAY
22/04/2014
22/04/2014
54730/12
L’TRADING AND INVEST LINES KFT
09/06/2015
09/06/2015
54289/09
LAKAT
25/03/2014
25/03/2014
35701/05
LAKATOS JANOS
11/01/2011
11/01/2011
48689/10
LAMBERTNÉ BÁRSONY
25/03/2014
25/03/2014
33807/07
LANTOS
01/03/2011
01/03/2011
41571/07
LÁSZLÓ KÁROLY
09/10/2012
09/10/2012
41063/07
LASZLO MOLNAR
15/03/2011
15/03/2011
44319/11
LÁZÁR
01/10/2015
01/10/2015
34567/08
LENGYEL
18/12/2012
18/12/2012
43657/98
LÉVAI AND NAGY
08/04/2003
24/09/2003
62730/00
LOVÁSZ
20/01/2004
20/04/2004
442/03
MAGYAR (No. 2)
04/04/2006
04/07/2006
13323/02
MAJERCSIK
20/12/2005
12/04/2006
11005/08
MÁRTON
22/01/2013
22/01/2013
47070/10
MÁTRAINÉ TÖRŐ
11/03/2014
11/03/2014
66020/01
MÁTYÁS
28/09/2004
28/12/2004
33654/06
MÁTYUS
22/07/2008
22/10/2008
25648/06
MENYHÁRT
22/07/2008
22/10/2008
33552/05
MENYHÁRT MÁRIA
27/10/2009
27/01/2010
23559/09
MÉSZÁROS
12/03/2013
12/03/2013
21317/05
MÉSZÁROS
21/10/2008
21/01/2009
30330/02
MEZEI
08/11/2005
08/02/2006
7909/05
MEZEY
14/10/2008
26/01/2009
5503/02
MEZÖTÚR-TISZAZUGI VIZGAZDÁLKODÁSI TÁRSULAT
26/07/2005
26/10/2005
30901/06
MIKLÓSNÉ KANYÓ
08/11/2012
08/11/2012
40360/04
MIKÓ
27/05/2008
27/08/2008
55539/00
MILITARU
12/11/2003
12/02/2004
4395/02
MÓDER
05/10/2004
05/01/2005
22592/02
MOLNÁR
05/10/2004
05/01/2005
3261/05
MRÚZ
14/10/2008
06/04/2009
31802/04
MUITY
17/07/2008
17/10/2008
62930/12
MÜLLER
08/10/2013
08/10/2013
24710/11
MULTIPROJEKT KFT
15/03/2016
15/03/2016
16477/13
NAGY
22/04/2014
22/04/2014
61530/00
NAGY AND OTHERS
14/09/2004
02/02/2005
20743/07
NAGY GÉZÁNÉ
27/07/2010
27/07/2010
61/03
NEBUSOVÁ
10/10/2006
10/01/2007
41030/10
NECKOV
22/04/2014
22/04/2014
60650/11
NEMESNÉ FONYÓDI
01/10/2015
01/10/2015
3840/05
NÉMETH LAJOS
21/10/2008
21/01/2009
30211/05
NÉMETH LÁSZLÓ
09/12/2008
09/03/2009
52724/99+
NYÍRŐ AND TAKÁCS
21/10/2003
11/11/2003
15481/05
ORAVECZ
27/10/2009
27/01/2010
44726/04
PALLOS
30/10/2007
30/01/2008
41453/05
PÁTKOVÁ
24/03/2009
24/06/2009
1936/10
PATYI
15/10/2015
15/10/2015
18699/11
PEÁGICS
15/10/2015
15/10/2015
20280/04
PEÁK
01/07/2008
01/12/2008
6690/02
PEPSZOLG KFT (V.A.)
27/02/2007
09/07/2007
13204/11
PINTÉR
15/10/2015
15/10/2015
73369/01
RAJNAI
26/10/2004
26/01/2005
40478/10
RAKSSÁNYI
25/03/2014
25/03/2014
10501/03
RATALICS
11/04/2006
11/07/2006
65058/01
RENOVIT ÉPÍTŐIPARI KFT
28/09/2004
28/12/2004
5417/06
RÉVÉSZ
29/06/2010
21/07/2010
22671/04
RÓZSA
29/01/2008
29/04/2008
31069/11
SÁNDOR
12/03/2013
12/03/2013
9077/05+
SÁNDOR
17/07/2008
17/10/2008
62552/10
SÁRA ANNA KOVÁCS
25/03/2014
25/03/2014
1056/05
SASSNÉ SÁRI
04/03/2008
04/06/2008
25073/05
SCHWARTZ
03/11/2009
03/02/2010
37501/06
SEFCSUK
09/12/2008
09/03/2009
59094/00
SESZTAKOV
16/12/2003
16/03/2004
53844/00
SIKÓ
04/11/2003
04/02/2004
42961/98
SIMKÓ
08/04/2003
08/07/2003
54602/11
SINDELY
12/01/2016
12/01/2016
3925/05
SINKÓ
02/06/2009
02/09/2009
7060/05
SIPOS
07/10/2008
07/01/2009
44822/04
SIRKÓ AND OTHERS
05/02/2008
05/05/2008
9286/04
STERBEK
22/07/2008
22/10/2008
34254/10
SZABÓ
22/04/2014
22/04/2014
37470/06
SZABÓ BÉLA
09/12/2008
09/03/2009
59056/00
SZAKÁLY
25/05/2004
25/08/2004
38329/04
SZEBELLÉDI
21/06/2007
21/09/2007
4153/10
SZÉCHENYI
18/02/2014
18/02/2014
1233/06
SZÉCHENYI
20/10/2011
20/10/2011
38904/05
SZÉKELY
20/10/2009
20/01/2010
19558/09
SZENTESI
12/06/2012
12/06/2012
77669/12
SZEPES
11/06/2013
11/06/2013
28441/02
SZIKORA
22/11/2005
22/02/2006
73376/01
SZILÁGYI
05/04/2005
12/10/2005
17623/04
SZILVÁSSY
01/04/2008
01/07/2008
16348/02
SZOBOSZLAY
22/11/2005
12/04/2006
22736/04
SZŐKE
05/02/2008
05/05/2008
16407/05
SZTERGÁR
22/07/2008
22/10/2008
25848/06
TAMÁSI AND OTHERS
21/04/2009
21/07/2009
12935/05
TEMESVÁRI
07/10/2008
07/01/2009
44746/04
TÓT[2]
05/02/2008
07/07/2008
14099/12
TÓTH
26/05/2015
26/05/2015
22657/04
TÓTH
23/10/2007
23/01/2008
60297/00
TÓTH
30/03/2004
07/07/2004
35701/04
TÓTH, MAGYAR AND TÓTHNÉ
06/12/2005
06/03/2006
46218/09
TURUL KFT.
18/02/2014
18/02/2014
60214/13
URBÁN
15/10/2015
15/10/2015
32744/10
VALVOLA KFT.
22/10/2013
22/10/2013
31172/07
VÁRALJAI
15/06/2010
15/09/2010
14338/03
VARGA
28/03/2006
13/09/2006
27618/10
VARGÁNÉ FEKETE
08/10/2013
08/10/2013
14282/04
VÁRNAI
23/10/2007
31/03/2008
57966/00
VASS
25/11/2003
24/03/2004
39073/02
VONDRATSEK
11/04/2006
11/07/2006
13711/09
WALCH
25/03/2014
25/03/2014
8982/10
WARE
25/03/2014
25/03/2014
36739/05
WOLFGÉHER AND TURULA
03/11/2009
03/02/2010
11213/03
ZAVECZKY
25/04/2006
25/07/2006
66019/01
ZICHY GALÉRIA
05/04/2005
05/07/2005
44936/07
ZSOLNAY
22/01/2013
22/01/2013
b. Cases of length of criminal proceedings
Application
Case
Judgment of
Final on
55220/00
CSANÁDI
09/03/2004
09/06/2004
15482/05
AUPEK
08/01/2009
08/04/2009
27970/12
BALÁZS AND OTHERS
17/02/2015
17/02/2015
35729/12
BARTA AND DRAJKÓ
17/12/2013
17/03/2014
31162/09
BERKI
26/05/2015
26/05/2015
16412/05
BODON
30/10/2007
30/01/2008
31181/07
BODOR
14/06/2011
14/06/2011
16054/06
BORSÓDY AND OTHERS
20/01/2009
20/04/2009
60992/12
BRUNNER
22/04/2014
22/04/2014
65833/09
CSERNY
18/02/2014
18/02/2014
23123/07
CZIMBALEK
24/09/2013
24/09/2013
3373/11
DOMOKI
17/02/2015
17/02/2015
33275/08
FERENCSIK
22/01/2013
22/01/2013
24485/07
GARZÓ
24/09/2013
24/09/2013
64385/12
HAVAS
13/11/2014
13/11/2014
30361/12
JÁNOS DÁNIEL SZABÓ
17/02/2015
17/02/2015
31692/06
KALMÁR AND LORENCZ
07/10/2008
07/01/2009
26958/04
KÁLOVITS
30/10/2007
30/01/2008
8174/05
KOVÁCS LAJOS
17/07/2008
01/12/2008
37778/04
KULCSÁR
24/01/2008
24/04/2008
42542/04
MÁRTA
29/04/2008
29/07/2008
9429/10
MÁTÉ
22/10/2013
22/10/2013
14308/07
MEDGYES AND RUSZ
08/06/2010
08/09/2010
6437/02
NAGY
20/12/2005
20/03/2006
72262/12
NAGY
21/10/2014
21/10/2014
38891/06
NAGY GYŐZŐ
30/03/2010
30/06/2010
45392/05
NEU
03/11/2009
1/12/2009
54244/10
PALÁSTI
22/04/2014
22/04/2014
40354/04
SÁRKÖZI
27/11/2007
27/02/2008
66177/11
UDVARDY
01/10/2015
01/10/2015
21225/10
NAGY
26/01/2016
26/01/2016
[1] This application was lodged against Greece and Hungary but the Court declared inadmissible the complaints in respect of Greece.
[2] This case was lodged against Hungary and Italy but the European Court declared inadmissible the complaint against Italy.
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy