THIRD SECTION
CASE OF TYUTINA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
(Applications nos. 3380/10 and 33725/10)
JUDGMENT
STRASBOURG
13 February 2018
This judgment is final but it may be subject to editorial revision.
In the case of Tyutina and Others v. Russia,
The European Court of Human Rights (Third Section), sitting as a Committee composed of:
Luis López Guerra, President,
Dmitry Dedov,
Jolien Schukking, judges,
and Fatoş Aracı, Deputy Section Registrar,
Having deliberated in private on 23 January 2018,
Delivers the following judgment, which was adopted on that date:
PROCEDURE
1. The case originated in two applications (nos. 3380/10 and 33725/10) against the Russian Federation lodged with the Court under Article 34 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (“the Convention”) by 135 Russian nationals on 8 December 2009 and 25 May 2010. The applicants were represented by Mr A. A. Shestakov, a lawyer practising in Kotlas.
2. The Russian Government (“the Government”) were represented initially by Mr G. Matyushkin, the Representative of the Russian Federation to the European Court of Human Rights, and then by his successor in that office, Mr M. Galperin.
3. On 30 August and 29 September 2016 the applications were communicated to the Government.
THE FACTS
I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE
4. The list of applicants is set out in the appended tables.
A. Judgments in the applicants’ favour
5. On the dates indicated in the appended tables the applicants obtained monetary court awards against the Municipal Unitary Enterprise Passenger Transport Company of Kotlas (MUP Kotlas Passazhirskoye avtotransportnoye predpriyatiye – муниципальное предприятие муниципального образования Котлас «Пассажирское автотранспортное предприятие»).
6. Some of the judgments in the applicants’ favour have been partly enforced during the insolvency proceedings in respect of the company (see paragraphs 7-10 below), while others remained unenforced to date.
B. Available information on the debtor company
7. The company was incorporated as a municipal unitary enterprise. It was set up by the municipality of Kotlas. The company provided transport services in the town. It had “the right of economic control” (право хозяйственного ведения) over the assets allocated to it.
8. As submitted by the applicants, the prices for the transport services in the town of Kotlas were regulated by the Administration of Arkhangelsk region.
9. On 28 September 2007 insolvency proceedings started in respect of the company.
10. On 18 September 2012 the company was declared insolvent and subsequently liquidated.
II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW
11. The domestic provisions relevant to cases on the legal status of State and municipal unitary enterprises with the right of economic control are summarised in Liseytseva and Maslov v. Russia (nos. 39483/05 and 40527/10, §§ 54-127, 9 October 2014), and Samsonov v. Russia ((dec.) no. 2880/10, 18 September 2014).
THE LAW
I. JOINDER OF THE APPLICATIONS
12. Having regard to the similar subject matter of the applications, the Court finds it appropriate to examine them jointly in a single judgment (Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court).
II. LOCUS STANDI
13. The Court takes note of the death of the following applicants: Mr Vladimir Yegorovich Zavyalov, Mr Aleksey Ivanovich Shpolvind, Mr Nikolay Yevgenyevich Shcherbinin, Mr Valentin Feodosyevich Vasendin, Mr Andrey Nikolayevich Belykh, and Mr Yuriy Aleksandrovich Vishnyakov. The Court further takes note of the wish of Ms Tamara Vladimirovna Zavyalova, Ms Lyudmila Gotlibovna Shpolvind, Mr Valentin Vasilyevich Borozdin, Mr Aleksey Valentinovich Vasendin, Ms Tatyana Arkadyevna Belykh, as well as Ms Nadezhda Pavlovna Vishnyakova, Mr Aleksandr Yuryevich Vishnyakov, and Mr Eduard Yuryevich Vishnyakov to pursue the proceedings in their late relatives’ stead.
14. The Court reiterates that where an applicant dies during the examination of a case his or her heirs may in principle pursue the application on his or her behalf (see Ječius v. Lithuania, no. 34578/97, § 41, ECHR 2000-IX). Furthermore, in some cases concerning non-enforcement of court judgments and length of proceedings, the Court recognised the right of the relatives of the deceased applicant to pursue the application (see Shiryayeva v. Russia, no. 21417/04, §§ 8-9, 13 July 2006 concerning the non-enforcement, and Horváthová v. Slovakia, no. 74456/01, § 26, 17 May 2005, in the context of the length of proceedings).
15. The Court notes that the rights at stake in the present case are very similar to those at the heart of the cases referred to above. Nothing suggests that the rights the applicants sought to protect through the Convention mechanism were eminently personal and non-transferable (see Malhous v. the Czech Republic [GC], no. 33071/96, § 1, 12 July 2001).
16. The Court has previously established that it is for the heir who wishes to pursue the proceedings before the Court to substantiate his or her standing to do so (see Belskiy v. Russia (dec.), no. 23593/03, 26 November 2009, and Streltsov and other “Novocherkassk military pensioners”cases v. Russia, nos. 8549/06 and 86 others, 29 July 2010). In the present case all the above listed relatives of the deceased applicants (except Mr Aleksey Valentinovich Vasendin) submitted succession certificates confirming their acceptance of the late applicants’ succession. Mr Vasendin did not submit any document of that kind.
17. In respect of Mr Yuriy Aleksandrovich Vishnyakov, the Court notes that he had died before lodging the complaint before the Court. The Court further notes that the Government accepted that Mr Vishnyakov’s heirs could pursue the proceedings in their late relative’s stead.
18. Therefore, the Court considers that Ms Tamara Vladimirovna Zavyalova, Ms Lyudmila Gotlibovna Shpolvind, Mr Valentin Vasilyevich Borozdin, Ms Tatyana Arkadyevna Belykh, Ms Nadezhda Pavlovna Vishnyakova, Mr Aleksandr Yuryevich Vishnyakov, and Mr Eduard Yuryevich Vishnyakov have a legitimate interest in pursuing the complaints in their late relatives’ stead.
19. In the view of the above, the Court finds that the above-mentioned heirs have standing to pursue their late relatives’ complaints. At the same time, the Court is not satisfied that Mr Aleksey Valentinovich Vasendin has the standing to pursue the complaint lodged by his late relative. Thus, it considers that it is no longer justified to continue the examination of the application in respect of Mr Valentin Feodosyevich Vasendin and concludes pursuant to Article 37 § 1 (c) of the Convention that the application in this part should be struck out of its list of cases.
III. ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 6 § 1 OF THE CONVENTION AND OF ARTICLE 1 OF PROTOCOL No. 1 TO THE CONVENTION
20. The applicants complained of the non-enforcement of domestic decisions given in their favour. They relied on Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention, which read as follows:
Article 6 § 1
“In the determination of his civil rights and obligations ... everyone is entitled to a fair ... hearing ... by [a] ... tribunal ...”
Article 1 of Protocol No. 1
“Every natural or legal person is entitled to the peaceful enjoyment of his possessions. No one shall be deprived of his possessions except in the public interest and subject to the conditions provided for by law and by the general principles of international law.
The preceding provisions shall not, however, in any way impair the right of a State to enforce such laws as it deems necessary to control the use of property in accordance with the general interest or to secure the payment of taxes or other contributions or penalties.”
21. The Government submitted that the liquidation of the company was not caused by the actions of the owner of its assets, i.e. the municipality. They further argued that the company had been a commercial enterprise that had operated independently of the authorities. They, therefore, submitted that its debts were not attributable to the State.
22. The applicant maintained that the debtor company was a State-run enterprise controlled by the State, which was responsible for its debts. In particular, the applicant submitted that the company was the only provider of transport services in the town of Kotlas, and that the rates for transport services in that municipality were regulated by the regional authorities.
A. Admissibility
23. The Court has held that the existing legal framework in Russia does not provide unitary enterprises with a degree of institutional and operational independence that would absolve the State from responsibility under the Convention for the debts of such companies (see Liseytseva and Maslov, cited above, §§ 193-204). In order to determine the issue of State responsibility for the debts of unitary enterprises the Court must examine whether and how the extensive powers of control provided for in domestic law were actually exercised by the authorities in the present case.
24. The Court notes that the debtor company was set up for providing transport services. In Liseytseva and Maslov (cited above, § 215) the Court admitted that, in the absence of further information such activity could be regarded purely commercial, as suggested by the Government.
25. The Court observes that the Government submitted that the company had been one of many transport companies working in the Arkhangelsk region and had not performed any public function. The applicant argued, in reply, that the company had a vital function for the population of Kotlas as it was the only provider of transport services in that town, and submitted that the rates for its services were subject to regulation by the regional authorities (see paragraph 22 above) (see Liseytseva and Maslov, cited above, §§ 208-14).The Government did not contest that information. Moreover, in several previous applications concerning similar domestic judgments in respect of the same enterprise the Court has found that the company did not enjoy sufficient institutional and operational independence from the authorities (see Mamedov and Others v. Russia [Committee], nos. 16264/09 and 6 others, § 7, 16 February 2017).
26. In the light of the above, the Court finds that the company did not enjoy sufficient institutional and operational independence from the authorities and dismisses the Government ratione personae objection. Accordingly, the municipality, and hence the State, is to be held responsible under the Convention for the debts owed by the transport company to the applicant in accordance with the final judgments in their favour. The Court therefore declares the complaints admissible.
B. Merits
27. The Court notes that it is not disputed between the parties that the judgments in the applicants’ favour either have remained unenforced or have been enforced in part (see the appended tables for the overall length of enforcement).
28. The Court has established above that the State is responsible under the Convention for the debts owed by the respondent company (see paragraph 26 above). By failing to comply with the judgments the national authorities prevented the applicants from receiving the money they could reasonably have expected to receive. The Court has found a violation of Article 6 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention in respect of issues similar to those in the present cases (see Liseytseva and Maslov, cited above, §§ 208-24).
29. Accordingly, there has been a violation of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention on account of the non-enforcement of the final and binding judgments in the applicants’ favour.
IV. APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 41 OF THE CONVENTION
30. Article 41 of the Convention provides:
“If the Court finds that there has been a violation of the Convention or the Protocols thereto, and if the internal law of the High Contracting Party concerned allows only partial reparation to be made, the Court shall, if necessary, afford just satisfaction to the injured party.”
31. Most of the applicants claimed the outstanding court awards in their favour (see the appended tables) in respect of pecuniary damage.
32. In respect of non-pecuniary damage each applicant claimed 2,000 euros.
33. The Government contested these claims reiterating their position that the State was not liable for the debts of the company, and, therefore, the applicants’ rights were not violated.
34. Regard being had to the documents in its possession and to its case‑law (see, in particular, Voronkov v. Russia, no. 39678/03, §§ 68-69, 30 July 2015), the Court considers it reasonable to award the sums indicated in the appended tables.
35. In the application no. 33725/10 Ms Olga Maksimovna Letovaltseva, Ms Dina Alekseyevna Mamontova, Ms Irina Aleksandrovna Mamontova, Ms Tatyana Pavlinovna Smirnova, Mr Andrey Igorevich Tyukavin made no claims in respect of pecuniary damage. Accordingly, the Court makes no award under this head as regards these applicants.
36. The Court considers it appropriate that the default interest rate should be based on the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank, to which should be added three percentage points.
FOR THESE REASONS, THE COURT, UNANIMOUSLY,
1. Decides to join the applications;
2. Holds, in respect of application no. 3380/10, that Ms T. V. Zavyalova, Ms L. G. Shpolvind, Mr V. V. Borozdin, Ms T. A. Belykh, Ms N. P. Vishnyakova, Mr A. Yu. Vishnyakov, and Mr E. Yu. Vishnyakov have standing to continue proceedings in Mr V. Ye. Zavyalov’s, Mr A. I. Shpolvind’s, Mr N. Ye. Shcherbinin’s, Mr A. N. Belykh, and Mr Yu. A. Vishnyakov’s stead, and Mr A. V. Vasendin has no standing to continue proceedings in Mr V. F. Vasendin’s stead;
3. Decides to strike the application no. 3380/10 in the part related to complaints of the deceased Mr V. F. Vasendin out of its list of cases in accordance with the Article 37 § 1 (c) of the Convention;
4. Declares the applications in the remaining parts admissible;
5. Holds that there has been a violation of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention;
6. Holds
(a) that the respondent State is to pay the applicants or their legal heirs indicated in the appended tables, within three months, the amounts indicated in the appended tables, to be converted into the currency of the respondent State at the rate applicable at the date of settlement;
(b) that from the expiry of the above-mentioned three months until settlement simple interest shall be payable on the above amounts at a rate equal to the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank during the default period plus three percentage points.
7. Dismisses the remainder of the applicants’ claim for just satisfaction.
Done in English, and notified in writing on 13 February 2018, pursuant to Rule 77 §§ 2 and 3 of the Rules of Court.
Fatoş AracıLuis López Guerra
Deputy RegistrarPresident
APPENDIX I
(Application no. 3380/10, lodged on 8 December 2009)
No.
Applicant’s name
Date of birth
Judgment by
Date of judgment
Final on
Amount awarded (in euros)
Length of enforcement proceedings
Amount awarded for pecuniary damage per applicant/
household (in euros)
Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage and costs and expenses per applicant/
household (in euros)[1]
Natalya Serafimovna TYUTINA
28/09/1961
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
21/01/2008
01/02/2008
3,884
Pending
More than
8 years, 7 months
2,895
2,000
Larisa Vasilyevna ALEKSEYESHCHEVA
25/04/1964
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
17/01/2008
29/01/2008
3,243
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 3 days
2,419
2,000
Viktoriya Viliyevna ALEKSEYEVA
13/07/1971
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
25/03/2008
07/04/2008
1,554
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 25 days
1,554
2,000
Sergey Vasilyevich ARTEMENKO
03/09/1955
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
12/12/2007
22/02/2008
6,423
Pending
More than 8 years, 6 months, 9 days
4,781
2,000
Leonid Nikolayevich BABIKOV
21/03/1956
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
14/01/2008
25/01/2008
7,057
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 7 days
5,252
2,000
Valentina Yuryevna BATOVSKAYA
04/02/1965
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
23/01/2008
08/02/2008
6,331
Pending
More than 8 years, 6 months, 23 days
4,903
2,000
Andrey Nikolayevich BELYKH
25/12/1962
(died on 13/07/2017)
Legal heir: Tatyana Arkadyevna BELYKH
20/01/1966
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
19/12/2007
09/01/2008
4,156
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 23 days
3,097
2,000
Viktor Izosimovich BELYKH
28/05/1956
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
03/03/2008
14/03/2008
8,415
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 19 days
6,260
2,000
Galina Mikhaylovna BERGEVA
26/05/1961
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
16/01/2008
29/01/2008
5,528
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 3 days
4,116
2,000
Tatyana Petrovna BUBNOVA
17/10/1961
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
27/03/2008
08/04/2008
5,109
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 24 days
3,805
2,000
Vasiliy Aleksandrovich CHEKMAREV
29/08/1952
Justice of the Peace of the 3rd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
21/03/2008
01/04/2008
10,861
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 1 day
8,444
2,000
Lidiya Pavlovna CHERNYKH
13/06/1953
Justice of the Peace of the 1st court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
25/03/2008
07/04/2008
4,384
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 25 days
3,267
2,000
Sergey Dmitriyevich DRUZHININ
06/06/1950
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
17/01/2008
29/01/2008
7,720
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 3 days
5,744
2,000
Nikolay Aleksandrovich DUDNIKOV
24/01/1955
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
11/01/2008
03/03/2008
7,711
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 30 days
5,737
2,000
Lyudmila Vasilyevna DUMCHEVA
06/06/1957
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
31/03/2008
11/04/2008
4,695
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 21 days
3,498
2,000
Aleftina Vasilyevna FEDOTOVA
07/07/1949
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
16/01/2008
29/01/2008
4,235
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 3 days
3,156
2,000
Sergey Aleftinovich GANICHEV
05/11/1964
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
19/12/2007
09/01/2008
6,902
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 23 days
5,137
2,000
Veniamin Anatolyevich GOLOKHVASTOV
04/12/1954
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
18/02/2008
29/02/2008
6,056
Pending
More than 8 years, 6 months, 3 days
4.481
2,000
Valentina Fedorovna GOLOVINA
19/09/1948
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
31/03/2008
11/04/2008
4,330
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 21 days
3,226
2,000
Yanina Vintso GOLOVINA
07/10/1948
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
27/03/2008
08/04/2008
5,039
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 24 days
3,753
2,000
Ivan Pavlovich GOSTEV
09/06/1958
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
18/04/2008
29/04/2008
10,527
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 3 days
7,828
2,000
Vladimir Nikolayevich GURYEV
23/04/1962
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
25/12/2007
10/01/2008
6,924
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 22 days
5,153
2,000
Anatoliy Kuzmich GUZIYENKO
20/02/1946
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
03/03/2008
14/03/2008
3,322
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 19 days
2,478
2,000
Valentina Nikolayevna GUZIYENKO
29/10/1955
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
03/03/2008
14/03/2008
5,522
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 19 days
4,112
2,000
Anatoliy Ivanovich KHOKHLOV
26/03/1951
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
19/02/2008
03/03/2008
7,601
Pending
More than8 years, 5 months, 30 days
5,656
2,000
Nikolay Aleksandrovich KHOLOPOV
23/12/1952
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
12/02/2008
26/02/2008
8,911
Pending
More than 8 years, 6 months, 5 days
6,628
2,000
Vasiliy Petrovich KHUDYAKOV
06/09/1936
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
18/02/2008
29/02/2008
6,288
Pending
More than 8 years, 6 months, 3 days
4,680
2,000
Vasiliy Yakovlevich KIRDYASHOV
05/12/1951
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
26/03/2008
08/04/2008
10,568
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 24 days
7,855
2,000
Sergey Vasilyevich KOKSHAROV
31/05/1963
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
19/02/2008
03/03/2008
9,608
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 30 days
7,146
2,000
Nadezhda Gennadyevna KOKSHAROVA
02/03/1968
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
19/02/2008
03/03/2008
4,801
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 30 days
3,576
2,000
Lyudmila Vyacheslavovna KOMYAKOVA
06/12/1950
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
04/03/2008
17/03/2008
4,490
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 16 days
3,345
2,000
Leonid Nikolayevich KONEV
24/10/1946
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
19/02/2008
03/03/2008
7,170
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 30 days
5,335
2,000
Lyudmila Aleksandrovna KONONOVA
24/01/1960
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
26/03/2008
08/04/2008
2,020
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 24 days
1,541
2,000
Pavel Mikhaylovich KOREPIN
15/04/1963
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
18/12/2007
29/12/2007
6,966
Pending
More than 8 years, 8 months, 4 days
5,184
2,000
Valeriy Aleksandrovich KOZLOV
11/01/1953
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
21/01/2008
01/02/2008
9,193
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months
6,838
2,000
Evgeniy Leonidovich KRASUTSKIY
09/06/1971
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
27/03/2008
08/04/2008
8,668
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 24 days
6,448
2,000
Aleksandr Fedoseyevich KRETSUL
15/02/1947
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
18/02/2008
29/02/2008
6,990
Pending
More than 8 years, 6 months, 2 days
5,202
2,000
Anatoliy Nikolayevich KULIZHNIKOV
11/03/1959
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
27/03/2008
08/04/2008
8,086
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 24 days
6,016
2,000
Aleksandr Grigoryevich KUZNETSOV
20/10/1930
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
18/02/2008
29/02/2008
5,764
Pending
More than 8 years, 6 months, 3 days
4,291
2,000
Svetlana Ivanovna KUZNETSOVA
10/10/1963
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
29/02/2008
20/03/2008
4,862
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 13 days
3,755
2,000
Nikolay Vladimirovich LAZAREV
16/02/1944
Justice of the Peace of the 3rd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
21/03/2008
01/04/2008
4,939
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 1 day
3,679
2,000
Aleksandr Nikolayevich LOGINOV
26/11/1956
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
28/04/2008
12/05/2008
6,622
Pending
More than 8 years, 3 months, 20 days
4,928
2,000
Nikolay Aleksandrovich LOGINOV
19/02/1962
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
15/01/2008
26/01/2008
7,270
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 6 days
4,918
2,000
Tatyana Yuryevna LOMAKINA
13/12/1962
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
04/03/2008
17/03/2008
6,735
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 16 days
5,012
2,000
Sergey Dmitriyevich LUTSENKO
08/08/1962
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
17/01/2008
29/01/2008
7,396
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 3 days
5,503
2,000
Tamara Nikolayevna LYSTSEVA
28/06/1953
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
26/03/2008
08/04/2008
2,956
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 24 days
2,206
2,000
Nikolay Gavrilovich MAKHIN
19/05/1957
Justice of the Peace of the 3rd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
21/03/2008
01/04/2008
9,450
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 1 day
7,028
2,000
Ruslan Nikolayevich MAKHIN
05/05/1982
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
04/03/2008
17/03/2008
7,608
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 16 days
5,640
2,000
Olga Valentinovna MALYSHKINA
30/12/1969
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
15/01/2008
28/01/2008
4,590
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 4 days
3,420
2,000
Galina Nikolayevna MAMCHUR
10/03/1957
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
26/03/2008
11/04/2008
5,699
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 21 days
4,244
2,000
Valentina Vladimirovna MENSHAKOVA
08/06/1968
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
04/03/2008
17/03/2008
3,915
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 16 days
2,918
2,000
Natalya Yuryevna MESYATSYNA
18/06/1968
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
16/01/2008
29/01/2008
5,053
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 3 days
3,763
2,000
Nikolay Timofeyevich MIKHAYLOV
17/12/1956
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
27/03/2008
08/04/2008
8,450
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 24 days
6,286
2,000
Klara Anatolyevna MOTCHANAYA
27/01/1940
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
27/03/2008
08/04/2008
4,236
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 24 days
3,157
2,000
Vladimir Mikhaylovich MUSONOV
21/01/1953
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
27/12/2007
10/01/2008
7,466
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 22 days
5,555
2,000
Yuliya Vladimirovna NALIVAYKO
24/02/1974
Justice of the Peace of the 1st court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
25/03/2008
10/04/2008
4,010
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 22 days
2,989
2,000
Vladimir Vasilyevich NERADOVSKIY
08/05/1953
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
19/02/2008
03/03/2008
6,818
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 30 days
5,074
2,000
Svetlana Nikolayevna NURKANOVA
13/01/1961
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
25/03/2008
10/04/2008
5,913
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 22 days
4,402
2,000
Lyudmila Vladimirovna OSIPOVA
08/10/1952
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
20/02/2008
02/03/2008
6,236
Pending
More than 8 years, 6 months
4,642
2,000
Viktor Mikhaylovich OZHEGOV
23/05/1976
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
27/03/2008
08/04/2008
6,190
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 24 days
4,608
2,000
Sergey Vladimirovich PANTELEYEV
12/03/1964
Justice of the Peace of the 1st court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
24/03/2008
04/04/2008
10,986
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 28 days
8,169
2,000
Nina Nikolayevna PAUTOVA
27/03/1958
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
04/03/2008
17/03/2008
4,705
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 16 days
3,505
2,000
Valeriy Ivanovich PONIKAROVSKIY
17/09/1957
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
04/03/2008
17/03/2008
6,933
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 16 days
5,159
2,000
Andrey Gennadyevich POSELSKIY
23/11/1967
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
27/12/2007
10/01/2008
4,155
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 22 days
3,091
2,000
Nikolay Nikolaevich PROSHUTINSKIY
14/04/1954
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
17/12/2007
28/12/2007
7,640
Pending
More than 8 years, 8 months, 5 days
5,685
2,000
Vladimir Anatolyevich RAZDOBURDIN
06/04/1951
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
20/02/2008
04/03/2008
5,899
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 29 days
4,392
2,000
Aleksandr Alekseyevich SHAVERIN
23/10/1960
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
26/12/2007
10/01/2008
6,644
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 22 days
4,945
2,000
Vladimir Borisovich SHCHELKUNOV
01/07/1950
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
21/01/2008
01/02/2008
8,687
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months
6,462
2,000
Nikolay Yevgenyevich SHCHERBININ
26/11/1952
(died on 06/03/2013)
Legal heir:
Valentin Vasilyevich BOROZDIN
27/08/1974
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
19/02/2008
03/03/2008
6,460
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 30 days
4,780
2,000
Lyudmila Vitalyevna SHMELEVA
10/04/1959
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
26/03/2008
08/04/2008
4,886
Pending
More than 8 years, 24 days
3,639
2,000
Aleksey Ivanovich SHPOLVIND
29/08/1950 (died on 14/10/2010)
Legal heir:
Lyudmila Gotlibovna
SHPOLVIND
20/06/1951
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
18/02/2008
29/02/2008
6,900
Pending
More than 8 years, 6 months, 2 days
5,106
2,000
Vyacheslav Yuryevich SIDORIN
19/08/1972
Justice of the Peace of the 1st court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
24/03/2008
04/04/2008
3,934
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 28 days
2,932
2,000
Lyubov Andreyevna SIDORINA
22/06/1953
Justice of the Peace of the 3rd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
21/03/2008
01/04/2008
4,730
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 1 day
3,529
2,000
Yemelyan Tarasovich SIROMA
05/01/1949
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
18/01/2008
29/01/2008
7,688
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 3 days
5,720
2,000
Aleftina Gennadyevna SIZYUKHINA
14/09/1954
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
15/01/2008
26/01/2008
5,674
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 6 days
4,225
2,000
Dina Alekseyevna SLEPUKHINA
08/06/1940
Justice of the Peace of the 1st court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
24/03/2008
04/04/2008
4,250
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 28 days
3,167
2,000
Tatyana Mikhaylovna SLOTINA
10/06/1951
Justice of the Peace of the 1st court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
24/03/2008
04/04/2008
4,656
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 28 days
3,469
2,000
Vyacheslav Alekseyevich SOGUTOVSKIY
25/02/1948
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
11/01/2008
22/01/2008
7,381
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 10 days
5,492
2,000
Alina Nikolayevna STEPINA
15/08/1948
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
14/01/2008
25/01/2008
3,076
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 7 days
2,295
2,000
Aleksandr Vasilyevich SUKHANOV
06/08/1959
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
04/04/2008
15/04/2008
4,481
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 17 days
3,338
2,000
Yuriy Anatolyevich SUKHNEV
19/08/1946
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
26/03/2008
07/04/2008
5,753
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 25 days
4,283
2,000
Aleksandr Ivanovich SVIRIDA
10/09/1961
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
04/03/2008
17/03/2008
9,173
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 16 days
6,823
2,000
Galina Nikolayevna TALYKH
01/07/1949
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
26/03/2008
08/04/2008
709
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 24 days
531
2,000
Nadezhda Aleksandrovna TATARSKAYA
12/08/1952
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
03/03/2008
14/03/2008
4,607
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 19 days
3,432
2,000
Pavel Valentinovich TATARSKIY
04/11/1954
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
03/03/2008
14/03/2008
10,103
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 19 days
7,513
2,000
Vasiliy Arsenyevich TEREBIKHIN
15/06/1949
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
27/03/2008
08/04/2008
8,215
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 24 days
6,112
2,000
Aleksandr Grigoryevich TISHCHENKO
08/07/1985
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
21/03/2008
01/04/2008
3,756
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 1 day
2,800
2,000
Grigoriy Grigoryevich TISHCHENKO
18/11/1956
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
27/03/2008
08/04/2008
5,377
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 24 days
4,004
2,000
Aleksandr Vasilyevich TORITSYN
14/09/1959
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
15/01/2008
26/01/2008
7,692
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 6 days
5,723
2,000
Aleksandr Anatolyevich TRIFANOV
09/08/1963
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
26/12/2007
10/01/2008
8,200
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 22 days
6,071
2,000
Andrey Leonidovich TRINKO
01/05/1969
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
11/01/2008
22/01/2008
9,153
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 10 days
6,808
2,000
Nikolay Valeryanovich TYUSHOV
28/11/1963
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
26/03/2008
08/04/2008
7,771
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 24 days
5,782
2,000
Sergey Yuryevich TYUTIN
13/05/1963
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
22/01/2008
01/02/2008
6,364
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months
4,737
2,000
Yuliya Sergeyevna VOLOVA[2]
02/02/1987
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
21/01/2008
01/02/2008
2,823
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months
2,107
2,000
Vitaliy Anatolyevich USHAKOV
31/07/1966
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
13/02/2008
25/02/2008
3,766
Pending
More than 8 years, 6 months, 6 days
2,808
2,000
Lyudmila Yevgenyevna VARGANOVA
21/06/1951
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
27/03/2008
08/04/2008
5,417
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 24 days
4,034
2,000
Aleksey Valentinovich VASENDIN
08/05/1978
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
12/12/2007
25/12/2007
8,074
Pending
More than 8 years, 8 months, 8 days
6,007
2,000
Valentin Feodosyevich VASENDIN
19/01/1946 (died on 17/11/2014)
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
12/12/2007
25/12/2007
8,688
Pending
More than 8 years, 8 months, 8 days
Strike out
Strike out
Galina Ivanovna VASENEVA
05/08/1957
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
18/02/2008
29/02/2008
4,551
Pending
More than 8 years, 6 months, 3 days
3,391
2,000
Lyudmila Albertovna VASILYEVA
14/02/1956
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
19/02/2008
03/03/2008
6,290
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 30 days
4,682
2,000
Nikolay Aleksandrovich VERESHCHAGIN
09/03/1961
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
11/12/2007
24/12/2007
9,590
Pending
More than 8 years, 8 months, 9 days
9,590
2,000
Yuriy Matveyevich VERKHOLANTSEV
20/01/1944
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
27/03/2008
08/04/2008
3,330
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 24 days
2,484
2,000
Nadezhda Arkadyevna VERKHOVTSEVA
21/08/1959
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
27/03/2008
08/04/2008
5,422
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 24 days
4,037
2,000
Svetlana Sergeyevna VERSHININA
25/10/1975
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
15/01/2008
28/01/2008
4,367
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 4 days
3,254
2,000
Vyacheslav Anatolyevich VINOGRADOV
20/06/1958
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
24/01/2008
05/02/2008
9,048
Pending
More than 8 years, 6 months, 26 days
6,696
2,000
Yuriy Aleksandrovich VISHNYAKOV
06/02/1949 (died on 09/05/2008)
Legal heirs:
Nadezhda Pavlovna VISHNYAKOVA
06/02/1949
Aleksandr Yuryevich VISHNYAKOV
21/08/1986
Eduard Yuryevich VISHNYAKOV
06/01/1972
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
19/02/2008
03/03/2008
7,167
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 30 days
1,768 to each legal heir
2,000 jointly to all legal heirs
Svetlana Nikolaevna YUDANOVA
10/02/1973
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
14/01/2008
25/01/2008
4,917
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 7 days
3,693
2,000
Vladimir Egorovich ZAVYALOV
04/03/1945 (died on 25/02/2012)
Legal heir:
Tamara Vladimirovna ZAVYALOVA
06/02/1951
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
19/02/2008
03/03/2008
7,043
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 30 days
5,212
2,000
Irina Anatolyevna ZIMIREVA
09/01/1973
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
03/03/2008
14/03/2008
4,321
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 19 days
3,198
2,000
Sergey Arkadyevich ZOBOV
19/03/1959
Justice of the Peace of the 1st court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
24/03/2008
04/04/2008
6,506
Pending
More than 8 years, 4 months, 28 days
4,814
2,000
APPENDIX II
(Application no. 33725/10, lodged on 25 May 2010)
No.
Applicant’s name
Date of birth
Judgment by
Date of judgment
Final on
Amount awarded (in euros)
Length of enforcement proceedings
Amount awarded for pecuniary damage per applicant/
household (in euros)
Amount awarded for non-pecuniary damage and costs and expenses per applicant/
household (in euros)[3]
Valentina Vasilyevna MESYATSINA
20/06/1952
Justice of the Peace of the 1st court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
25/03/2008
10/04/2008
4,829
Pending
More than
8 years, 6 months, 21 days
3,852
2,000
Nikolay Pavlinovich GUBIN
22/12/1952
Justice of the Peace of the 3rd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
21/03/2008
01/04/2008
9,132
Pending
More than
8 years, 6 months
6,831
2,000
Valeriy Borisovich KOKORIN
10/02/1955
Justice of the Peace of the 3rd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
21/03/2008
01/04/2008
3,947
Pending
More than 8 years, 6 months
2,953
2,000
Sergey Yuryevich KORELIN
18/12/1963
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
31/03/2008
11/04/2008
8,040
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 21 days
6,014
2,000
Olga Maksimovna LETOVALTSEVA
08/11/1971
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
09/01/2008
20/01/2008
4,962
Pending
More than 8 years, 8 months, 12 days
n/a
2,000
Yevgeniy Afanasyevich LYSTSEV
07/08/1954
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
04/03/2008
17/03/2008
8,778
Pending
More than 8 years, 6 months, 15 days
6,567
2,000
Dina Alekseyevna MAMONTOVA
12/02/1950
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
26/03/2008
08/04/2008
2,940
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 24 days
n/a
2,000
Irina Aleksandrovna MAMONTOVA
05/07/1970
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
28/03/2008
09/04/2008
5,443
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 23 days
n/a
2,000
Aleksandr Anatolyevich MARCHEVSKIY
08/06/1962
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
04/03/2008
17/03/2008
6,979
Pending
More than 8 years, 6 months, 15 days
5,220
2,000
Galina Savvatiyevna MELENTYEVA
28/10/1959
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
26/03/2008
08/04/2008
4,825
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 24 days
3,610
2,000
Pavel Aleksandrovich NEFEDOV
24/08/1959
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
04/03/2008
17/03/2008
8,026
Pending
More than 8 years, 6 months, 15 days
6,004
2,000
Tatyana Borisovna OPARINA
18/11/1964
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
26/03/2008
08/04/2008
4,970
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 24 days
3,718
2,000
Svetlana Gennadyevna ORLOVA
05/12/1949
Justice of the Peace of the 3rd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
21/03/2008
02/04/2008
6,195
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 30 days
4,634
2,000
Konstantin Anatolyevich PAVLOV
07/02/1970
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
27/03/2008
08/04/2008
6,446
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 24 days
4,822
2,000
Mikhail Vladimirovich PILKO
12/11/1958
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
26/03/2008
08/04/2008
7,503
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 24 days
5,612
2,000
Lyubov Izosimovna PLETENEVA
14/02/1949
Justice of the Peace of the 1st court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
24/03/2008
04/04/2008
5,106
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 28 days
3,820
2,000
Tatyana Vladimirovna PLETENEVA
21/04/1981
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
26/03/2008
08/04/2008
2,191
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 24 days
1,639
2,000
Sergey Vadimovich SHILOVSKIY
16/03/1961
Justice of the Peace of the 1st court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
24/03/2008
04/04/2008
8,063
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 28 days
6,031
2,000
Tatyana Pavlinovna SMIRNOVA
07/06/1963
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
04/03/2008
17/03/2008
3,794
Pending
More than 8 years, 6 months, 15 days
n/a
2,000
Ivan Soligovich TOPSOKHALOV
10/08/1954
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
11/04/2008
22/04/2008
5,176
Pending
More than 8 years, 5 months, 10 days
3,947
2,000
Andrey Igorevich TYUKAVIN
21/11/1972
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
09/01/2008
21/01/2008
5,726
Pending
More than 8 years, 8 months, 11 days
n/a
2,000
Anatoliy Vitalyevich USTYUZHANINOV
18/08/1955
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
17/01/2008
29/01/2008
8,392
Pending
More than 8 years, 8 months, 3 days
6,208
2,000
Vladimir Anatolyevich YASHIN
17/03/1957
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
12/02/2008
26/02/2008
8,201
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 5 days
6,107
2,000
Vladimir Aleksandrovich ZENOVSKIY
08/11/1950
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
03/03/2008
18/03/2008
12,109
Pending
More than 8 years, 6 months, 14 days
9,058
2,000
Valentin Nikolayevich ZHUZHGIN
30/07/1953
Justice of the Peace of the 2nd court circuit of the town of Kotlas of the Arkhangelsk Region
24/01/2008
05/02/2008
7,766
Pending
More than 8 years, 7 months, 26 days
5,745
2,000
[1]. Plus any tax that may be chargeable to the applicants.
[2]. During the proceedings, the applicant’s last name changed from Tyutina to Volova.
[3]. Plus any tax that may be chargeable to the applicants.
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy