Published on 29 April 2024
SECOND SECTION
Application no. 47025/22
Muhammet ÇİNİCİ against Türkiye
and 199 other applications
(see list appended)
communicated on 16 April 2024
STATEMENT OF FACTS
1. A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix.
The circumstances of the case2. The applications mainly concern the applicants’ conviction for membership of an armed terrorist organisation described by the Turkish authorities as the “Fetullahist Terror Organisation/Parallel State Structure” (Fetullahçı Terör Örgütü / Paralel Devlet Yapılanması, hereinafter referred to as “the FETÖ/PDY”), considered by the authorities to be behind the coup attempt that took place in Türkiye on 15 July 2016.
3. According to the information submitted by the applicants, the convictions were based, inter alia, on their alleged use of the encrypted messaging application “ByLock”, which the domestic courts held was used exclusively by FETÖ/PDY members and which therefore constituted sufficient evidence to prove on its own that a person had been part of the FETÖ/PDY’s hierarchical structure.
4. The broader domestic background and context to the present applications was set out by the Grand Chamber in the case of Yüksel Yalçınkaya v. Türkiye ([GC], no. 15669/20, §§ 10-22 and 108-40, 26 September 2023).
Relevant domestic law and practice5. A description of the relevant domestic law and practice can be found in Yüksel Yalçınkaya (cited above, §§ 141-93).
COMPLAINTS
6. The applicants mainly complained that their trial and conviction for membership of the FETÖ/PDY had violated the principle of no punishment without law under Article 7 of the Convention and/or the right to a fair trial under Article 6 § 1.
QUESTIONS TO THE PARTIES
Since the issues raised by the present applications are already the subject of well-established case-law of the Court (see Yüksel Yalçınkaya v. Türkiye [GC], no. 15669/20, §§ 237-356, 26 September 2023), the Court does not put any questions to the parties or require any observations on these applications. However, if they so wish, the Government may submit observations on the complaints set out in the appended table, to the extent that they refer essentially to the factual aspects of the applications and not to preliminary objections or legal issues already decided by the Court in Yüksel Yalçınkaya (cited above) or other similar cases against Türkiye.
APPENDIX
List of applications raising complaints under Article 7 (no punishment without law) and/or Article 6 § 1 of the Convention (right to a fair trial) (conviction for membership of the FETÖ/PDY based, inter alia, on the applicants’ alleged use of the encrypted messaging application “ByLock”):
No.
Application no.
Case name
Lodged on
Applicant
Year of Birth
Place of Residence
Nationality
Represented by
1.
47025/22
Çinici v. Türkiye
28/02/2022
Muhammet ÇİNİCİ
1987
Manisa
Turkish
Fatma ÇİNİCİ
2.
47102/22
Özsözen v. Türkiye
26/09/2022
Tamer Alpay ÖZSÖZEN
1977
Samsun
Turkish
Yakup GÖNEN
3.
47168/22
Tomar v. Türkiye
13/09/2022
Hasan Duran TOMAR
1976
Çorum
Turkish
Memnune Melike AKYILDIZ
4.
47215/22
Bayram v. Türkiye
20/09/2022
Kazım BAYRAM
1976
Giresun
Turkish
Elif CİVELEKOĞLU
5.
47265/22
Demir v. Türkiye
19/09/2022
Mehmet DEMİR
1975
Düzce
Turkish
İlyas TEKİN
6.
47294/22
Tuskan v. Türkiye
01/09/2022
Mehmet TUSKAN
1968
Adana
Turkish
Remziye ARSLAN KAYA
7.
47502/22
Öztürk v. Türkiye
07/09/2022
Eyüp ÖZTÜRK
1973
Kayseri
Turkish
Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
8.
47515/22
Kotan v. Türkiye
14/09/2022
Ümit KOTAN
1976
Samsun
Turkish
Zeliha DERVİŞOĞLU
9.
47542/22
Temel v. Türkiye
07/10/2022
Mehmet Emin TEMEL
1986
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
10.
47549/22
Kayabaş v. Türkiye
05/10/2022
Selman KAYABAŞ
1986
Muğla
Turkish
Eda KAYABAŞ
11.
47596/22
Binboğa v. Türkiye
28/09/2022
Halime BİNBOĞA
1986
İzmir
Turkish
Yavuz Selim ÇELİK
12.
47774/22
Sözen v. Türkiye
29/09/2022
Yaşar SÖZEN
1980
Samsun
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
13.
47891/22
Fatma v. Türkiye
23/09/2022
Aydın FATMA
1988
Turkish
Akın DEMİR
14.
47952/22
Arslan v. Türkiye
07/09/2022
Yılmaz ARSLAN
1978
Ankara
Turkish
Rümeysa DENİZ
15.
47979/22
Vurdem v. Türkiye
03/10/2022
Ümit Erkan VURDEM
1968
Kayseri
Turkish
Yasemin Berna ASLANBAY
16.
48005/22
Aldır v. Türkiye
03/10/2022
İsmail ALDIR
1978
Sivas
Turkish
Tolgahan KAŞKAYA
17.
48127/22
Sezer v. Türkiye
26/09/2022
Yüksel SEZER
1968
Ankara
Turkish
Fatih DÖNMEZ
18.
48139/22
Demirel v. Türkiye
30/09/2022
Mustafa DEMİREL
1987
Antalya
Turkish
Başak KARATAŞ
19.
48168/22
Şanda v. Türkiye
05/10/2022
Uğur ŞANDA
1987
Ankara
Turkish
Nesibe YOLCU
20.
48186/22
Kuzan v. Türkiye
30/09/2022
Ertuğrul KUZAN
1984
Istanbul
Turkish
Fatma ALBAYRAK
21.
48311/22
Kılıç v. Türkiye
03/10/2022
Mehmet KILIÇ
1987
Osmaniye
Turkish
Mehmet Ali KAYA
22.
48337/22
Diler v. Türkiye
25/09/2022
Metin DİLER
1971
Erzurum
Turkish
Kadir ÖZTÜRK
23.
48358/22
Kaya v. Türkiye
03/10/2022
Aydın KAYA
1980
Ankara
Turkish
Kadir ÖZTÜRK
24.
48389/22
Mecit v. Türkiye
04/10/2022
Hamit MECİT
1972
Malatya
Turkish
Kadir ÖZTÜRK
25.
48507/22
Kaçmaz v. Türkiye
22/09/2022
Fahri KAÇMAZ
1983
Samsun
Turkish
Zeliha DERVİŞOĞLU
26.
48528/22
Koca v. Türkiye
10/10/2022
Tuba KOCA
1987
Jørpeland (Norway)
Turkish
Ekrem KAYA
27.
48660/22
Boduroğlu v. Türkiye
10/10/2022
Özkan BODUROĞLU
1984
Kastamonu
Turkish
Şeyma ALKAN
28.
48904/22
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
07/10/2022
Aydın YILMAZ
1979
Ankara
Turkish
Ertuğrul ALKILIÇ
29.
49119/22
Deniz v. Türkiye
06/10/2022
Muhammed Emin DENİZ
1991
Gaziantep
Turkish
Murat CENGİZ
30.
49329/22
İşçi v. Türkiye
13/10/2022
Mehmet İŞÇİ
1983
Kars
Turkish
İsmail DOĞAN
31.
49347/22
Mimaroğlu v. Türkiye
19/09/2022
Esra MİMAROĞLU
1984
Hatay
Turkish
Abdülgani MİMAROĞLU
32.
49577/22
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
05/10/2022
Murat YILMAZ
1985
Denizli
Turkish
Ali KAVALLI
33.
49611/22
Palabıyık v. Türkiye
12/10/2022
Ozan PALABIYIK
1984
Ankara
Turkish
Burak ÇOLAK
34.
49820/22
İşçi v. Türkiye
14/10/2022
Reşat İŞÇİ
1973
Turkish
Mustafa ÖZTÜRK
35.
50019/22
Tobi v. Türkiye
05/10/2022
Kadir TOBİ
1987
Turkish
Muhammet DEMİREL
36.
50058/22
Öztürk v. Türkiye
10/10/2022
Yakup ÖZTÜRK
1992
Karaman
Turkish
Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
37.
50220/22
Çelik v. Türkiye
11/10/2022
Zeynep ÇELİK
1977
Manisa
Turkish
Mustafa ASLAN
38.
50335/22
Karaoğlu v. Türkiye
22/10/2022
Gülay KARAOĞLU
1972
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
Mehmet MİRZA
39.
50456/22
Özel v. Türkiye
14/10/2022
Sabiha ÖZEL
1975
Gaziantep
Turkish
Önder ALKURT
40.
50570/22
Lale v. Türkiye
13/10/2022
Melih LALE
1987
Mersin
Turkish
Osman ALANBAY
41.
50653/22
Akça v. Türkiye
21/10/2022
Musa AKÇA
1964
Ankara
Turkish
Şeyma ALKAN
42.
51117/22
Konukman v. Türkiye
12/10/2022
Tuğrul KONUKMAN
1985
Hatay
Turkish
Bilal ÇÖRTÜK
43.
51144/22
Demir v. Türkiye
24/10/2022
Önder DEMİR
1969
Osmaniye
Turkish
Emine Hatice DEMİR
44.
51313/22
Demir v. Türkiye
21/10/2022
Mehmet DEMİR
1987
Adana
Turkish
Belma KAYRAN
45.
51375/22
Eroğlu v. Türkiye
10/10/2022
Ömer Faruk EROĞLU
1981
Kocaeli
Turkish
İlyas TEKİN
46.
51483/22
Ecemiş v. Türkiye
02/11/2022
Mustafa ECEMİŞ
1982
Ankara
Turkish
Kemal ÇETİNKAYA
47.
51612/22
Metin v. Türkiye
13/10/2022
Yakup METİN
1977
Ankara
Turkish
Saadet METİN
48.
51632/22
Özbay v. Türkiye
25/10/2022
Atilla ÖZBAY
1974
Yozgat
Turkish
Memnune Melike AKYILDIZ
49.
51882/22
Yazıcı v. Türkiye
27/10/2022
Yavuz YAZICI
1987
Karabük
Turkish
Kadir ÖZTÜRK
50.
51906/22
Karadenizli v. Türkiye
27/10/2022
Erkan KARADENİZLİ
1977
Eskişehir
Turkish
Kadir ÖZTÜRK
51.
52097/22
Elgin v. Türkiye
31/10/2022
Şule ELGİN
1987
Elazığ
Turkish
Bekir ALBAY
52.
52193/22
Bahadır v. Türkiye
01/11/2022
Şehide BAHADIR
1986
Manisa
Turkish
Emine Özge ARSLAN
53.
52225/22
Tomar v. Türkiye
21/10/2022
Mesut TOMAR
1980
Giresun
Turkish
Elif CİVELEKOĞLU
54.
52450/22
Sağlam v. Türkiye
26/10/2022
Harun SAĞLAM
1995
Antalya
Turkish
Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
55.
52653/22
Dinç v. Türkiye
01/11/2022
Ersin DİNÇ
1980
Trabzon
Turkish
Muhammed Nuh POLAT
56.
52795/22
Aksoy v. Türkiye
28/10/2022
Safiye AKSOY
1981
Kayseri
Turkish
Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
57.
52885/22
Bayri v. Türkiye
07/11/2022
Ahmet Cevat BAYRİ
1968
Ankara
Turkish
Fatih DÖNMEZ
58.
52975/22
Kılıç v. Türkiye
02/11/2022
Kürşat KILIÇ
1985
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Ali DİNSEVER
59.
53103/22
Doğan v. Türkiye
04/11/2022
Adem DOĞAN
1992
Osmaniye
Turkish
Mehmet Ali KAYA
60.
53199/22
Ağırbaş v. Türkiye
10/11/2022
Ahmet AĞIRBAŞ
1991
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
61.
53331/22
Demir v. Türkiye
09/11/2022
Kadir DEMİR
1997
İzmir
Turkish
Veli ÇELİK
62.
53409/22
Kara v. Türkiye
02/11/2022
Yunus Emre KARA
1991
Sakarya
Turkish
Emrullah POLAT
63.
53431/22
Ülker v. Türkiye
11/11/2022
Osman ÜLKER
1976
München (Germany)
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
64.
53439/22
Ünal v. Türkiye
02/11/2022
Cengiz ÜNAL
1976
Sakarya
Turkish
Emrullah POLAT
65.
53463/22
Demirel v. Türkiye
09/11/2022
Bekir DEMİREL
1973
Düzce
Turkish
Fatih DÖNMEZ
66.
53590/22
Kaba v. Türkiye
04/11/2022
Ercan KABA
1986
Kocaeli
Turkish
Hakan KARAKUŞ
67.
53805/22
Yiğit v. Türkiye
04/11/2022
Mustafa YİĞİT
1981
Kayseri
Turkish
Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
68.
53809/22
Yalçın v. Türkiye
04/11/2022
Davut YALÇIN
1988
Ağrı
Turkish
Mehmet Fatih KAYA
69.
53898/22
Akpınar v. Türkiye
11/11/2022
İmdat AKPINAR
1970
Niğde
Turkish
Fatih DÖNMEZ
70.
53916/22
Yiğitoğlu v. Türkiye
12/11/2022
Adem YİĞİTOĞLU
1962
Isparta
Turkish
Ebubekir DEMİÇ
71.
53950/22
Demirel v. Türkiye
16/11/2022
İshak DEMİREL
1993
Konya
Turkish
Kadir ÖZTÜRK
72.
53998/22
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
15/11/2022
Mehmet YILMAZ
1970
İzmir
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
73.
54047/22
Ebeş v. Türkiye
16/11/2022
Sultan Murat EBEŞ
1987
Ankara
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
74.
54049/22
Çam v. Türkiye
16/11/2022
İbrahim ÇAM
1980
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
75.
54077/22
Erdoğan v. Türkiye
19/10/2022
Sadık Erdal ERDOĞAN
1978
Malatya
Turkish
Ahmet PEKTAŞ
76.
54081/22
Duran v. Türkiye
16/11/2022
Furkan Fatih DURAN
1989
Nevşehir
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
77.
54084/22
Çulha v. Türkiye
16/11/2022
Burak ÇULHA
1998
Denizli
Turkish
Nazlı MERT
78.
54089/22
Öztürk v. Türkiye
16/11/2022
Üneys Özcan ÖZTÜRK
1958
Denizli
Turkish
Nazlı MERT
79.
54092/22
Gür v. Türkiye
16/11/2022
Cansu GÜR
1989
Denizli
Turkish
Nazlı MERT
80.
54221/22
Yıkılmaz v. Türkiye
19/11/2022
Hasan YIKILMAZ
1969
Bursa
Turkish
Muhammed Ali DEMİRCİ
81.
54310/22
Şen v. Türkiye
16/11/2022
Havvanur ŞEN
1992
Antalya
Turkish
Nazlı MERT
82.
54315/22
Savaş v. Türkiye
16/11/2022
Aliye SAVAŞ
1992
Antalya
Turkish
Nazlı MERT
83.
54382/22
Ayata v. Türkiye
14/11/2022
Tahir AYATA
1970
Kayseri
Turkish
Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
84.
54437/22
Kaya v. Türkiye
17/11/2022
Dilek KAYA
1976
Kırıkkale
Turkish
Merve Elif GÜRACAR
85.
54438/22
Vurmaz v. Türkiye
14/11/2022
Fatih VURMAZ
1984
Malatya
Turkish
İsa KARGIN
86.
54460/22
Kırlıoğlu v. Türkiye
09/11/2022
Suat KIRLIOĞLU
1975
Burdur
Turkish
Muhammed Sabit CAN
87.
54509/22
Pala v. Türkiye
07/11/2022
Osman PALA
1988
Manisa
Turkish
Akkız KARDEŞLER
88.
54527/22
Bayram v. Türkiye
01/11/2022
Hasan Hüseyin BAYRAM
1960
Giresun
Turkish
Elif CİVELEKOĞLU
89.
54543/22
Süt v. Türkiye
08/11/2022
Hadis SÜT
1984
Bolu
Turkish
Adem DÜZGÜN
90.
54620/22
Demir v. Türkiye
14/11/2022
Tacettin DEMİR
1992
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Halil ŞAHİN
91.
54683/22
Tunçkol v. Türkiye
14/11/2022
Oğuzhan TUNÇKOL
1988
Osmaniye
Turkish
Ömer YÜZGEÇ
92.
54851/22
Gürbudak v. Türkiye
21/11/2022
Nevin GÜRBUDAK
1983
Burdur
Turkish
Ahmet KESKİN
93.
54867/22
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
15/11/2022
Ünal YILMAZ
1977
Batman
Turkish
Sinan DAĞ
94.
54889/22
Çabalak v. Türkiye
09/11/2022
Arif ÇABALAK
1979
Hatay
Turkish
Dudu ERTUNÇ
95.
54940/22
Çelik v. Türkiye
09/11/2022
Tevhit ÇELİK
1987
Istanbul
Turkish
Mesut ÖZTÜRK
96.
54942/22
Atilla v. Türkiye
16/11/2022
Halil İbrahim ATİLLA
1982
Karaman
Turkish
Adem DÜZGÜN
97.
55086/22
Tuna v. Türkiye
15/11/2022
Meryem Serap TUNA
1978
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Muhammed Murat POYRAZ
98.
55173/22
Delikanlı v. Türkiye
14/11/2022
Tuba DELİKANLI
1979
İzmir
Turkish
Okan ERGÜN
99.
55272/22
Öncü v. Türkiye
22/11/2022
Nebahat ÖNCÜ
1987
Mersin
Turkish
Abdulselam DURAN
100.
55300/22
Demirbaş v. Türkiye
22/11/2022
Hasan DEMİRBAŞ
1979
Ankara
Turkish
Adnan ZEYBEK
101.
55335/22
Arıkan v. Türkiye
21/11/2022
Murat ARIKAN
1987
Gallen (Switzerland)
Turkish
Meliha Gülsüm ŞAHİN SOYTÜRK
102.
55422/22
Arslan v. Türkiye
18/11/2022
Mehmet ARSLAN
1966
Kocaeli
Turkish
Yüksel GENÇ
103.
55459/22
Güçlü v. Türkiye
25/11/2022
Uğur GÜÇLÜ
1978
Ankara
Turkish
Şeyma ALKAN
104.
55479/22
Bayat v. Türkiye
15/11/2022
Abdulkadir BAYAT
1971
Malatya
Turkish
Sinan DAĞ
105.
55494/22
İmir v. Türkiye
14/11/2022
Hüseyin İMİR
1990
Düzce
Turkish
Cüneyt GÜLBAŞ
106.
55501/22
Metin v. Türkiye
24/11/2022
Mehmet METİN
1980
İzmir
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
107.
55576/22
Gülbay v. Türkiye
23/11/2022
Kenan GÜLBAY
1975
Eskişehir
Turkish
Tülay GÜLBAY
108.
55591/22
Alpaslan v. Türkiye
25/11/2022
Ercan ALPASLAN
1986
Samsun
Turkish
Ekrem KAYA
109.
55613/22
Aytek Şen v. Türkiye
28/11/2022
Medine AYTEK ŞEN
1984
Ankara
Turkish
Kübra GÜLAÇTI
110.
55929/22
Yıldırım v. Türkiye
24/11/2022
İsmail YILDIRIM
1985
Kayseri
Turkish
Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
111.
56046/22
Gün v. Türkiye
26/11/2022
Ramazan GÜN
1985
Konya
Turkish
Leyla MESUTOĞLU
112.
56223/22
Güney v. Türkiye
18/11/2022
Muhammed Fatih GÜNEY
1987
Konya
Turkish
Burcu AKTAŞ EFE
113.
56282/22
Kurtoğlu v. Türkiye
22/11/2022
Akif KURTOĞLU
1983
Bolu
Turkish
Adem DÜZGÜN
114.
56345/22
Ertuğral v. Türkiye
15/11/2022
Havva Nur ERTUĞRAL
1985
Çanakkale
Turkish
Figen AKDOĞAN
115.
56372/22
Çağlayan v. Türkiye
24/11/2022
Abidin ÇAĞLAYAN
1980
Antalya
Turkish
Ebubekir RENK
116.
56462/22
Ulucan v. Türkiye
28/11/2022
Kemal Turhan ULUCAN
1989
Konya
Turkish
Bilal DAĞLI
117.
56463/22
Dirier v. Türkiye
29/11/2022
Emine DİRİER
1979
Kilis
Turkish
Ebru EKİCİ
118.
56469/22
Çelik v. Türkiye
28/11/2022
Rıfkı ÇELİK
1979
Konya
Turkish
Bilal DAĞLI
119.
56753/22
Karabina v. Türkiye
21/10/2022
Yusuf KARABİNA
1974
Istanbul
Turkish
Muhammet İkbal DOĞANÇAY
120.
56853/22
Ceyhan v. Türkiye
22/11/2022
Hakan CEYHAN
1978
Kütahya
Turkish
Zeynep Bilge CEYHAN
121.
57014/22
Güler v. Türkiye
03/12/2022
Ahmet GÜLER
1973
Antalya
Turkish
Ahmet KESKİN
122.
57132/22
Keskin v. Türkiye
01/12/2022
Şeyma KESKİN
1992
Bingöl
Turkish
Naim GÜÇDEN
123.
57137/22
Ciğerci v. Türkiye
29/11/2022
Zafer CİĞERCİ
1979
Kayseri
Turkish
Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
124.
57395/22
Polat v. Türkiye
28/11/2022
Harun POLAT
1986
Erzincan
Turkish
Sümeyra Nur POLAT
125.
57429/22
Türk v. Türkiye
25/11/2022
İsmail TÜRK
1973
Ankara
Turkish
Didem Gizem ERGİN
126.
13/23
Uzun v. Türkiye
06/12/2022
Mehmet UZUN
1989
Konya
Turkish
Sibel KELEŞ
127.
15/23
Kurnaz v. Türkiye
01/12/2022
Yaşar KURNAZ
1982
Yozgat
Turkish
Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
128.
37/23
İlhan v. Türkiye
02/12/2022
Mehmet Akif İLHAN
1988
VAN
Turkish
Mehmet Ali KAYA
129.
344/23
Doğan v. Türkiye
13/12/2022
Selami DOĞAN
1971
Tokat
Turkish
Sümeyye DOĞAN
130.
716/23
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
15/12/2022
Sevda YILMAZ
1980
Antalya
Turkish
Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
131.
717/23
Elgün v. Türkiye
15/12/2022
Ali Ramazan ELGÜN
1973
Kayseri
Turkish
Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
132.
796/23
Tunçyürek v. Türkiye
23/12/2022
Hasan TUNÇYÜREK
1983
Isparta
Turkish
Orçun MUŞLU
133.
803/23
Çelik v. Türkiye
14/12/2022
Mustafa ÇELİK
1967
Denizli
Turkish
Sümeyra ÇELIK AKINCI
134.
992/23
Arslan v. Türkiye
08/12/2022
Kürşad ARSLAN
1984
Ankara
Turkish
Zehra ARSLAN ALKAÇ
135.
1117/23
Kurtuldu v. Türkiye
06/12/2022
Sefa KURTULDU
1986
Sakarya
Turkish
Mehmet Ali KAYA
136.
1213/23
Turaç v. Türkiye
22/12/2022
Metin TURAÇ
1987
Antalya
Turkish
Yavuz Selim ÇELİK
137.
1980/23
Şahin v. Türkiye
15/12/2022
Şenol ŞAHİN
1975
Hatay
Turkish
Dudu ERTUNÇ
138.
2039/23
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
08/12/2022
Murat YILMAZ
1983
Kocaeli
Turkish
Ahmet Can DEMİRCİ
139.
2051/23
Tüysüz v. Türkiye
21/12/2022
Erol TÜYSÜZ
1973
Kocaeli
Turkish
Yakup GÖNEN
140.
2402/23
Kala v. Türkiye
01/12/2022
Osman KALA
1980
Hatay
Turkish
Dudu ERTUNÇ
141.
2420/23
Güler v. Türkiye
23/12/2022
İbrahim GÜLER
1971
Çanakkale
Turkish
Hatice ÇİLOĞLU
142.
2638/23
Toklu v. Türkiye
16/12/2022
Süleyman TOKLU
1973
Turkish
Halil ÇETİN
143.
2924/23
Işık v. Türkiye
23/12/2022
Mehmet IŞIK
1985
Adıyaman
Turkish
Kadir ÖZTÜRK
144.
2959/23
Özler v. Türkiye
28/12/2022
Ömer ÖZLER
1981
Erzurum
Turkish
Ali KAVALLI
145.
3389/23
Özdemir v. Türkiye
26/12/2022
Mehmet ÖZDEMİR
1979
Aydın
Turkish
Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
146.
4085/23
Çakıroğlu v. Türkiye
09/01/2023
Aynur ÇAKIROĞLU
1990
Samsun
Turkish
Ekrem KAYA
147.
4126/23
Ulus v. Türkiye
27/12/2022
Ünal ULUS
1976
Samsun
Turkish
Latife Nazlı GÜVEN
148.
4423/23
Bahadır v. Türkiye
26/12/2022
Mehmet BAHADIR
1988
Manisa
Turkish
Mehmet ARSLAN
149.
4645/23
Güngör v. Türkiye
27/12/2022
Yasin GÜNGÖR
1978
İzmir
Turkish
Ümmü GÜNGÖR
150.
5044/23
Önder v. Türkiye
19/01/2023
Musa ÖNDER
1972
Kayseri
Turkish
Fatih GÜNDÜZ
151.
5053/23
Gündüz v. Türkiye
19/01/2023
Vehbi GÜNDÜZ
1982
Kocaeli
Turkish
Fatih GÜNDÜZ
152.
5062/23
Demirkan v. Türkiye
14/01/2023
Ahmet DEMİRKAN
1972
Samsun
Turkish
Ekrem KAYA
153.
5097/23
Zengindemir v. Türkiye
17/01/2023
Mesut ZENGİNDEMİR
1970
Kırıkkale
Turkish
Muhammet Uğur DEMİRKAN
154.
5131/23
Çakır v. Türkiye
13/01/2023
Mustafa ÇAKIR
1982
Antalya
Turkish
Celil ZURNACI
155.
5227/23
Karakaya v. Türkiye
16/01/2023
Abdulkadir KARAKAYA
1986
Erzurum
Turkish
Erdem ALP
156.
5284/23
Mansız v. Türkiye
12/01/2023
Mustafa MANSIZ
1987
Gaziantep
Turkish
Dudu ERTUNÇ
157.
5293/23
Yıldız v. Türkiye
16/01/2023
Uğur YILDIZ
1982
Samsun
Turkish
Ekrem KAYA
158.
5336/23
Aksoy v. Türkiye
11/01/2023
Yakup AKSOY
1979
Ankara
Turkish
Sinan DAĞ
159.
7156/23
Baki v. Türkiye
28/01/2023
Yasin BAKİ
1975
Ordu
Turkish
Ekrem KAYA
160.
7756/23
Alyavuz v. Türkiye
27/01/2023
Osman ALYAVUZ
1972
Samsun
Turkish
Ekrem KAYA
161.
7778/23
Takım v. Türkiye
20/01/2023
Abdulsamet TAKIM
1992
Erzurum
Turkish
Elif CİVELEKOĞLU
162.
8441/23
Kazan v. Türkiye
04/02/2023
Burcu KAZAN
1989
Amasya
Turkish
Ekrem KAYA
163.
9133/23
Durukan v. Türkiye
08/02/2023
Niyazi DURUKAN
1955
Denizli
Turkish
Hayrettin ARABACI
164.
9355/23
Yıldırım v. Türkiye
13/02/2023
Ayhan YILDIRIM
1977
Ankara
Turkish
Burak ÇOLAK
165.
9778/23
Özcan v. Türkiye
28/02/2023
Burhan ÖZCAN
1970
Tekirdağ
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
166.
9824/23
Sirkecioğlu v. Türkiye
28/02/2023
İlyas SİRKECİOĞLU
1985
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
167.
12304/23
Başaran v. Türkiye
10/03/2023
Hamdi BAŞARAN
1980
Ankara
Turkish
Ahmet Can DEMİRCİ
168.
12533/23
Acar v. Türkiye
07/02/2023
Serap ACAR
1990
Turkish
Adnan ERDOĞAN
169.
12827/23
Çevikel v. Türkiye
09/03/2023
Ersin ÇEVİKEL
1975
Kocaeli
Turkish
İlyas TEKİN
170.
12995/23
Dündar v. Türkiye
14/03/2023
Fatih DÜNDAR
1983
Gaziantep
Turkish
171.
13273/23
Avşar v. Türkiye
16/03/2023
Güllü AVŞAR
1990
Ankara
Turkish
Burak ÇOLAK
172.
13363/23
Doğan v. Türkiye
24/03/2023
Mustafa DOĞAN
1980
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
173.
13768/23
Aktı v. Türkiye
14/03/2023
Songül AKTI
1992
Turkish
Halil ÇETİN
174.
13825/23
Tuğral v. Türkiye
14/03/2023
Elif TUĞRAL
1988
İzmir
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
175.
13829/23
Caymaz v. Türkiye
14/03/2023
Şerife CAYMAZ
1989
Konya
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
176.
13834/23
Özdemir v. Türkiye
14/03/2023
Ayşe ÖZDEMİR
1995
Manisa
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
177.
13836/23
Karakoyun v. Türkiye
14/03/2023
Osman KARAKOYUN
1977
Turkish
Halil ÇETİN
178.
13855/23
Korkmaz v. Türkiye
14/03/2023
İlhan KORKMAZ
1971
Turkish
Halil ÇETİN
179.
14239/23
Aydın v. Türkiye
23/03/2023
Derya AYDIN
1986
Sincan
Turkish
Hilal Tuğçe ŞAHİN
180.
14395/23
Yanık v. Türkiye
24/03/2023
Gıyasettin YANIK
1969
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
181.
14513/23
Bişkin v. Türkiye
27/03/2023
Murat BİŞKİN
1970
İzmir
Turkish
Elif GİRGİN
182.
15779/23
Çığcı v. Türkiye
14/04/2023
Mehmet Resul ÇIĞCI
1990
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
183.
16048/23
Korkmaz v. Türkiye
07/04/2023
Hümeyra KORKMAZ
1991
Ankara
Turkish
Burak ÇOLAK
184.
16438/23
Mehmet v. Türkiye
17/04/2023
Mete MEHMET
1988
Silivri
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
185.
17053/23
Ünay v. Türkiye
05/04/2023
Sedat ÜNAY
1973
Kütahya
Turkish
Halil ÇETİN
186.
17310/23
Yenilmez v. Türkiye
13/04/2023
Murat YENİLMEZ
1987
Denizli
Turkish
Burak ÇOLAK
187.
17679/23
Akçay v. Türkiye
03/04/2023
Hüseyin AKÇAY
1975
Samsun
Turkish
Ekrem KAYA
188.
17815/23
Öztürk v. Türkiye
30/03/2023
Mehmet ÖZTÜRK
1970
Samsun
Turkish
Ekrem KAYA
189.
17992/23
Temel v. Türkiye
07/04/2023
Sezgin TEMEL
1974
Giresun
Turkish
Elif CİVELEKOĞLU
190.
18012/23
Avşar v. Türkiye
14/04/2023
İbrahim Erkam AVŞAR
1986
Ankara
Turkish
Burak ÇOLAK
191.
18309/23
İskender v. Türkiye
03/04/2023
Metin İSKENDER
1973
Samsun
Turkish
Ekrem KAYA
192.
18331/23
Akbaş v. Türkiye
14/04/2023
Ahmet AKBAŞ
1982
Ankara
Turkish
Burak ÇOLAK
193.
18687/23
Kılınç v. Türkiye
14/01/2023
Gökhan KILINÇ
1992
Samsun
Turkish
Ekrem KAYA
194.
24034/23
Rüzgaresen v. Türkiye
26/05/2023
Ahmet RÜZGARESEN
1985
İzmir
Turkish
Nafize GÜLCÜ
195.
24096/23
Yetişkin v. Türkiye
18/05/2023
Mehmet Reşit YETİŞKİN
1980
Ankara
Turkish
Burhan DEMİRCİ
196.
26652/23
Dayanır v. Türkiye
04/07/2023
Niyazi DAYANIR
1968
Denizli
Turkish
Mehmet MİRZA
197.
26654/23
Yıldırım v. Türkiye
04/07/2023
Türkan YILDIRIM
1984
Denizli
Turkish
Mehmet MİRZA
198.
26665/23
Kaplan v. Türkiye
04/07/2023
Abdurrahman KAPLAN
1983
Denizli
Turkish
Mehmet MİRZA
199.
28217/23
Küçükçancı v. Türkiye
11/07/2023
Erdem KÜÇÜKÇANCI
1975
Turkish
Halil ÇETİN
200.
28223/23
Acar v. Türkiye
07/07/2023
Ali ACAR
1988
Ankara
Turkish
Burak ÇOLAK