SECOND SECTION
DECISION
This version was rectified on 13 June 2017
under Rule 81 of the Rules of Court.
Application no. 41831/10
Ayhan DEMİRKOL and Others against Turkey
and 18 other applications
(see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (Second Section), sitting on 14 June 2016 as a Committee composed of:
Paul Lemmens, President,
Ksenija Turković,
Jon Fridrik Kjølbro, judges,
and Hasan Bakırcı, Deputy Section Registrar,
Having regard to the above applications lodged on the dates indicated in the appendix,
Having regard to the declaration submitted by the respondent Government on 14 December 2015 requesting the Court to strike the applications out of the list of cases and the applicants’ reply to that declaration,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
FACTS AND PROCEDURE
1. A list of the three hundred and eighteen applicants is set out in the appendix. The applicants are Turkish nationals. They were all represented by Mr M. N. Eldem, a lawyer practising in Ankara.
2. The Turkish Government (“the Government”) were represented by their Agent.
3. The applicants, public agents, complained that the disciplinary sanction of warning imposed on them for taking part in a demonstration infringed their right to freedom of association. They further complained regarding the absence of a domestic remedy to challenge these disciplinary sanctions. They relied on Articles 6 § 1, 11 and 13 of the Convention.
4. The applications were communicated to the Government on 14 October 2013.
THE LAW
5. Given that the applications at hand concern similar facts and complaints and raise identical issues under the Convention, the Court decides to join them in accordance with Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of the Court.
6. Relying on Articles 6 § 1, 11 and 13 of the Convention, the applicants complained that disciplinary sanctions were imposed upon them for participating in a demonstration and alleged further a lack of domestic remedy to challenge the impugned disciplinary measures.
7. After attempts failed to reach a friendly settlement, by a letter of 14 December 2015, the Government informed the Court that they proposed to make a unilateral declaration with a view to resolving the issue raised by the applications. They further requested the Court to strike out the applications in accordance with Article 37 of the Convention.
8. The declaration provided as follows:
“The Government hereby wish to express by way of unilateral declaration their acknowledgment that in the light of the Karaçay v. Turkey judgment (no. 6615/03, §§ 39 and 45, 27 March 2007), the disciplinary sanctions imposed on the applicants in the present cases constitute an infringement of their right to freedom of association and their right to an effective remedy. In this connection, the Government point out that, in order to provide an effective remedy against disciplinary sanctions through judicial review, Article 129 of the Constitution and section 135 of Law no. 657 on civil servants were amended on 12 September 2010 and 13 February 2011 respectively.
Consequently, the Government offers to pay to each of the three hundred and eighteen applicants EUR 400 (four hundred euros) to cover any and all non-pecuniary damages and a total of EUR 13,500 (thirteen thousand five hundred euros) in respect of costs and expenses, plus any tax that may be chargeable to the applicants.
These sums will be converted into national currency at the rate applicable on the date of payment, and will be payable within three months from the date of notification of the decision taken by the Court to strike the case out of its list of cases. In the event of failure to pay these sums within the said three-month period, the Government undertake to pay simple interest on them, from expiry of that period until settlement, at a rate equal to the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank during the default period plus three percentage points. The payment will constitute the final resolution of the case.
The Government therefore invites the Court to strike the present cases out of the list of cases. They suggest that the present declaration might be accepted by the Court as “any other reason” justifying the striking out of the case of the Court’s list of cases, as referred to in Article 37 § 1 (c) of the Convention.”
9. By a letter of 10 February 2016, the applicants indicated that they were not satisfied with the terms of the unilateral declaration.
10. The Court reiterates that Article 37 of the Convention provides that it may at any stage of the proceedings decide to strike an application out of its list of cases where the circumstances lead to one of the conclusions specified, under (a), (b) or (c) of paragraph 1 of that Article. Article 37 § 1 (c) enables the Court in particular to strike a case out of its list if:
“for any other reason established by the Court, it is no longer justified to continue the examination of the applications”.
11. It also reiterates that in certain circumstances, it may strike out applications under Article 37 § 1 (c) on the basis of a unilateral declaration by a respondent Government even if the applicants wish the examination of the cases to be continued.
12. To this end, the Court has examined the declaration carefully in the light of the principles emerging from its case-law, in particular the Tahsin Acar judgment (Tahsin Acar v. Turkey (preliminary objections) [GC], no. 26307/95, §§ 75-77, ECHR 2003-VI; WAZA SP. z o.o. v. Poland (dec.), no. 11602/02, 26 June 2007; and Sulwińska v. Poland (dec.), no. 28953/03, 18 September 2007).
13. The Court has established in its judgment Karaçay v. Turkey (no. 6615/03, §§18-45, 27 March 2007) the violation of Articles 11 and 13 of the Convention with regard to the disciplinary sanction imposed on the applicant for his union-related activities. The Court also considered that the finding of a violation constituted in itself sufficient just satisfaction for the non-pecuniary damage sustained by the applicant.
14. Having regard to the nature of the admissions contained in the Government’s declaration, as well as the amount of compensation proposed, the Court considers that it is no longer justified to continue the examination of the applications (Article 37 § 1 (c)).
15. Moreover, in light of the above considerations, and in particular given the clear and extensive case-law on the topic, the Court is satisfied that respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and the Protocols thereto does not require it to continue the examination of the applications (Article 37 § 1 in fine).
16. The Court considers that the amounts proposed by the Government should be converted into the national currency of the respondent State at the rate applicable at the date of payment, and paid within three months from the date of notification of the Court’s decision issued in accordance with Article 37 § 1 of the Convention. In the event of failure to settle within this period, simple interest shall be payable on the amounts in question at a rate equal to the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank plus three percentage points.
17. Finally, the Court emphasises that, should the Government fail to comply with the terms of their unilateral declaration, the applications could be restored to the list in accordance with Article 37 § 2 of the Convention (Josipović v. Serbia (dec.), no. 18369/07, 4 March 2008).
18. In view of the above, it is appropriate to strike the cases out of the list.
For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,
Decides to join the applications;
Takes note of the terms of the respondent Government’s declaration and of the modalities for ensuring compliance with the undertakings referred to therein;
Decides to strike the applications out of its list of cases in accordance with Article 37 § 1 (c) of the Convention.
Done in English and notified in writing on 7 July 2016.
Hasan BakırcıPaul Lemmens
Deputy RegistrarPresident
APPENDIX
No.
Application No.
Lodged on
Applicant
Date of birth
Place of residence
41831/10
08/07/2010
Ayhan DEMİRKOL
01/01/1979
Diyarbakır
Hacı Bayram DEMİROĞLU
01/01/1966
Diyarbakır
Maşallah TOPÇU
01/01/1985
Diyarbakır
Gülderen MARANKOZ
31/12/1972
Diyarbakır
Cemal BABAOĞLU
25/10/1955
Malatya
Abuzer BAYDAR
09/09/1968
Malatya
Tuğba UZUN
17/12/1975
Malatya
Seyfettin EREN
11/01/1977
Malatya
Haydar KORKMAZ
01/01/1965
Malatya
Mazlum KIZILDAĞ
05/04/1969
Malatya
Faruk ABACILI
01/01/1976
Malatya
Muharrem YEŞİLYURT
01/06/1964
Malatya
Ahmet ADIGÜZEL
05/03/1966
Kars
46432/10
30/06/2010
Mehmet TOPAL
15/02/1968
Malatya
Kemal GÜNGÖRDÜ
20/05/1969
Malatya
Zerrin KAPIKIRAN
21/04/1966
Malatya
Ender YÜCEKAYA
01/01/1973
Malatya
Leyla Seval EMİR
02/03/1971
Malatya
Bilal DEMİR
03/06/1973
Malatya
Özcan SARIAKÇALI
03/08/1959
Osmaniye
46855/10
05/07/2010
Celal TAŞKIRAN
19/03/1957
Malatya
47102/10
07/07/2010
Gülnaz KÖSE
15/03/1962
Malatya
Zeynep GÜRSES
26/07/1973
Malatya
Fatma KILIÇ
20/04/1968
Malatya
Canan ASLAN
15/08/1970
Malatya
Gülten SARIKAYA
22/03/1967
Malatya
Erol AYTEN
31/12/1956
Malatya
Özlem ERGİN
27/10/1974
Malatya
Şerife YILDIRIM
01/01/1965
Malatya
Ali SARIKAYA
16/01/1956
Malatya
Sevim KIRMIZIGÜL
28/09/1972
Malatya
Hatice MİLLİOĞULLARI TUNÇ
03/01/1974
Malatya
Fatma KAYA
12/05/1970
Malatya
Ali Ekber ADIGÜZEL
05/05/1958
Diyarbakır
Mehmet ASLANCA
10/08/1980
Diyarbakır
47664/10
22/07/2010
Ahmet AYLAZ
01/01/1965
Malatya
İbrahim CANPOLAT
01/01/1975
Malatya
Ayfer YILDIRIM
03/07/1966
Malatya
Salim DUDAKLI
01/01/1978
Hatay
Halife KİLİSLİ
29/10/1966
Hatay
Yasemin EZELSOY
15/08/1981
Hatay
Süleyman DOĞAN
01/05/1970
Malatya
Metin TOPAL
26/03/1973
Malatya
Tatar UÇAR
01/01/1963
Muğla
Aydın ATICI
19/09/1961
Muğla
[1]
48058/10
12/07/2010
Lokman AYDIN
01/01/1985
Diyarbakır
Muhterem TAYFUR
01/01/1982
Diyarbakır
Soner SUNA
10/05/1973
Malatya
Erdoğan CANPOLAT
31/12/1960
Malatya
Enver DURDU
10/05/1960
Malatya
Sebaha GÜLERYÜZ
23/04/1967
Malatya
Seyit İNCE
01/01/1971
Malatya
Serap KARATAŞTAN
06/06/1972
Batman
Adalet ÇAMUR
24/07/1969
Malatya
Mesude ZENGİN
05/06/1969
Malatya
Şadiye ÖZCAN
11/03/1966
Malatya
Çiçek FIRAT
01/06/1973
Malatya
Mehmet Ali KAPLAN
10/06/1969
Malatya
Ülkü Güler ÇELİK
30/09/1969
Malatya
Kenan ERDOĞAN
01/07/1969
Malatya
Aziz MENGÜÇOGLU
20/01/1963
Malatya
Memet AVŞAR
30/12/1970
Malatya
Ferhat TURAN
06/11/1969
Malatya
Müslüm ÖZTÜRKOĞLU
16/01/1971
Malatya
[2]
Hayri BAYSAL
08/03/1963
Malatya
Metin ÖZDEMİR
19/12/1964
Malatya
Kadime ALPAR
11/11/1964
Malatya
Cihangir Serkan MERİÇ
12/12/1973
Malatya
Ali ERCAN
21/03/1965
Malatya
Semine DENGEŞIK
09/02/1970
Malatya
Şah Hüseyin DEĞİRMENCİOĞLU
08/02/1972
Malatya
Hanife EREN KUTLAR
05/05/1966
Malatya
Doğan YAMAN
20/09/1960
Malatya
Kazım ALBAYRAK
18/12/1961
Malatya
Zülfükar Ejder SÜTCÜ
11/10/1968
Malatya
Feyzullah ŞAHİN
05/07/1964
Malatya
Mehmet AKYİĞİT
15/06/1980
Malatya
Tarık GÖKÇEN
08/12/1962
Malatya
Murat GÜLPINAR
06/10/1974
Malatya
Ali YİĞİTOĞLU
05/01/1970
Malatya
Hasan ARAR
01/09/1966
Malatya
Fatma DEMİR
14/01/1974
Malatya
Esen KAPLAN
23/09/1981
Malatya
Kemal KAYA
01/01/1980
Muğla
50170/10
10/07/2010
Kenan DEMİRKOL
01/01/1982
Diyarbakır
Mehmet KAYA
01/01/1974
Diyarbakır
Fevzi UNUK
01/01/1976
Diyarbakır
50418/10
17/07/2010
Güllü YAMAN
10/11/1961
Malatya
Sati ASLAN
01/03/1972
Malatya
Özlem ŞAŞ
02/09/1972
Malatya
Ayşe GÜLDOĞAN
05/04/1960
Malatya
Zeliha DUMAN
02/09/1972
Malatya
Saniye KAYA
17/08/1969
Malatya
Zuhal ASLAN
01/01/1969
Muğla
Emel KARAMAN
01/01/1961
Muğla
Ümürüye DOĞAN
01/01/1960
Muğla
Selim ÖZTÜFEKÇİ
01/01/1974
Muğla
Mine UZ
01/01/1970
Muğla
Arzu Cürül ALTINKIRAN
01/01/1974
Muğla
Hürriyet KARGIN
01/01/1960
Muğla
51154/10
17/07/2010
Tuncer UŞAR
02/01/1966
Kars
Ahmet ADIGÜZEL
05/03/1966
Kars
55375/10
03/08/2010
Sencer ELMACI
05/03/1968
Malatya
Pınar Oğuz UNUK
01/01/1984
Diyarbakır
Lütfü İŞİK
01/11/1984
Diyarbakır
Levent ERDOĞMAZ
28/05/1980
Diyarbakır
Mehmet BAKIŞ
24/07/1976
Diyarbakır
Veysel GÜNDÜZ
20/02/1966
Malatya
Yasemin GÜNDÜZ
09/04/1967
Malatya
Bahattin GÜNDÜZ
01/02/1966
Malatya
Şehriban SÜLEYMANOĞLU ER
30/03/1970
Malatya
Gülenber TEKİN
10/06/1969
Malatya
Bektaş ZENGİN
10/01/1972
Malatya
Ayfer YİĞİTOĞLU
08/07/1972
Malatya
Ali DEMİRCİ
01/10/1963
Malatya
Mustafa YAYLAGÜL
01/11/1962
Malatya
Seyfettin AYYILDIZ
23/12/1965
Malatya
Muhammet AKDAĞ
08/03/1958
Malatya
Zafer UZUNHAN
08/08/1976
Malatya
Hakkı TÜRKER
01/01/1956
Malatya
Vahap ERDEM
01/01/1955
Malatya
İbrahim MERKAN
03/01/1953
Malatya
Necla GÜL
16/02/1965
Malatya
Özge ÇALIŞKAN
17/06/1983
Malatya
Tacettin ŞAŞ
26/10/1968
Malatya
Funda TURHAN
14/04/1970
Malatya
İsmail KAYA
20/12/1971
Malatya
Mahperi YUKA
02/02/1975
Malatya
Hüsna ERKMEN
01/01/1973
Malatya
Aynur ERBAŞ
08/10/1975
Malatya
Erhan ALBAYRAK
01/01/1975
Malatya
Hüseyin İSPİR
01/10/1970
Malatya
Ali Rıza ÖZER
25/10/1958
Diyarbakır
57982/10
26/08/2010
Ayhan KIZILASLAN
05/05/1966
Malatya
74618/10
08/09/2010
Bedriye FİLİK YILMAZ
01/01/1981
Mardin
Sedat SERÇİK
01/01/1971
Mardin
Servan BAŞDAŞ
01/01/1979
Mardin
Mehmet Şerif ARDA
01/01/1966
Mardin
Mehmet Ali KANAT
01/01/1958
Mardin
Mehmet CİCİM
01/01/1957
Mardin
Tekin ÇİFTÇİ
Mardin
Mustafa POLAT
01/01/1978
Mardin
Numan ÇELEBİ
01/01/1979
Mardin
Eyyüp İRDAM
01/01/1974
Mardin
Faik HOMAN
01/01/1972
Mardin
Serfiraz ÖKMEN
01/01/1979
Mardin
Ali AKBULUT
05/04/1972
İzmir
İnci CİNDEMİR ÜNAY
12/09/1973
İzmir
Nuray SEZGEN
28/08/1978
İzmir
İbrahim SEZGEN
12/01/1970
İzmir
Eyüp AKSOY
16/02/1965
İzmir
Anıl ALKAN
05/04/1984
İzmir
Yasemin Hatun FİL
01/01/1968
İzmir
Zeynep GÜNER ÇETİN
06/06/1975
İzmir
Atay AKTÜRK
İzmir
Özer TEKİN
01/01/1962
İzmir
Fatih ALADOĞAN
10/07/1976
İzmir
Canpaşa OFLAZ
12/09/1968
İzmir
Rujdan YENER
26/02/1970
İzmir
Zeliha Figen AKÇA
15/01/1965
İzmir
Emir Ayşe GÜLER
05/01/1963
İzmir
Sadık CAN
15/08/1971
İzmir
Soner BİNGÖL
23/09/1968
İzmir
Fatma TÜRKOĞLU
01/01/1969
İzmir
Şerafettin DEMİR
01/06/1963
İzmir
Dilber YENER
17/04/1970
İzmir
Erdal ARSLAN
01/11/1971
İzmir
Betül ERDEM
01/01/1973
İzmir
Fatoş SAFİ
26/11/1979
İzmir
Gönül KARACA UCER
12/06/1963
İzmir
Hasan ERDEM
25/09/1966
İzmir
Turhan SIMSEK
09/09/1969
İzmir
Muhsin BOZKURT
11/01/1973
İzmir
Bircan BAŞARAN ULUDAĞ
05/07/1971
İzmir
Metin AZMANER
02/06/1977
İzmir
Mustafa YENER
15/07/1962
İzmir
Tanju ÇELİKKANAT
20/06/1965
İzmir
Murat ÜNAY
31/05/1973
İzmir
Mehmet Reşit BAYIK
01/09/1976
İzmir
Derya DOĞAN
21/05/1971
İzmir
Sibel ÇOŞGUN
09/08/1971
İzmir
Erol DEMİR
25/01/1964
İzmir
Demir İSMİYE
01/01/1963
İzmir
Tiran TETİK
15/08/1963
İzmir
Gezay ÜNAL
26/01/1959
İzmir
Cahit KADAKAL
20/02/1966
İzmir
Mehmet FİDAN
13/01/1964
İzmir
Şehriban MARANGÖZ
01/01/1965
İzmir
Filiz BOZKURT
01/01/1978
İzmir
Namık ÇETİN
31/05/1972
İzmir
Cem ÇAY
20/06/1974
İzmir
Mustafa DELİCE
01/01/1958
İzmir
Habibe ÜNSAL
İstanbul
Şefika ERDEM
10/06/1972
Konya
İlknur KIPIRTI
09/02/1983
Mardin
Mehmet Faruk KARABAT
20/09/1977
Mardin
Eyyüp İNCE
14/10/1977
Mardin
Mirza DOLAŞIR
01/05/1968
Mardin
Mehmet ÖZYILDIZ
01/01/1975
Mardin
Mehmet YAŞAR
07/09/1968
Kayseri
Muzaffer KARAKAYA
Kayseri
75433/10
19/07/2010
Hakan YUKA
23/07/1981
Malatya
Tekin ÖZDEMİR
19/02/1956
Ankara
Vahap YILDIRIM
01/12/1961
Malatya
Duran ŞAHİN
04/09/1956
Malatya
Murat YALÇINKAYA
25/10/1971
Malatya
Nural KIZILDAĞ
11/09/1968
Malatya
Mahfuz ÖZGÜNLÜK
25/02/1978
Diyarbakır
Umut Ulaş ÇELİK
01/01/1979
Diyarbakır
Zülküf ERDİL
15/03/1970
Diyarbakır
Ercan ÖĞÜT
01/03/1969
Diyarbakır
Fahri TAŞ
07/07/1964
Diyarbakır
Şiar ERBATUR
11/06/1975
Diyarbakır
Orhan BONCUK
20/01/1964
Diyarbakır
Mehmet TAŞ
01/01/1978
Diyarbakır
Ersin ÇOLAK
06/07/1965
Diyarbakır
Saniye ZERİN
21/04/1974
Diyarbakır
Yalçın DENİZ
01/01/1981
Diyarbakır
Yalçın CÜRO
27/10/1975
Diyarbakır
Abdurrazak ŞAHİN
22/01/1971
Diyarbakır
Abdulmuttalip ORAL
01/01/1958
Diyarbakır
Zülfiye YİĞİT
01/01/1980
Diyarbakır
Mustafa Remzi KAYGUSUZ
01/02/1966
Diyarbakır
Duygu DUYMAZ
02/10/1983
Diyarbakır
Sezai KAPLAN
27/07/1971
Diyarbakır
İlker TÜZER
20/10/1979
Diyarbakır
Servet PALA
28/09/1959
Diyarbakır
Yılmaz KAÇAR
01/01/1971
Diyarbakır
Bozan ASLAN
12/08/1976
Diyarbakır
Hasan GEDİKOĞLU
13/09/1978
Diyarbakır
Münir CAN
01/01/1960
Diyarbakır
Bedriye ÖZGÜNLÜK
05/01/1978
Diyarbakır
Mehmet Ali KESKİN
02/06/1978
Diyarbakır
Zülfi TOKAT
01/02/1984
Diyarbakır
Ramazan AKAT
22/05/1966
Diyarbakır
Muharrem BEYAZİT
01/01/1984
Diyarbakır
Hasan KARAOĞLAN
01/01/1966
Diyarbakır
Yücel ARAS
01/01/1975
Diyarbakır
Muhsin TARİKAN
01/01/1978
Diyarbakır
Tuncay ÖĞÜT
01/01/1977
Diyarbakır
Menduh EROĞLU
01/01/1979
Diyarbakır
Mehmet KÜÇÜKKAYA
01/01/1980
Diyarbakır
Ferhat GÜNEŞ
01/01/1981
Diyarbakır
Celebi OYAN
01/01/1978
Diyarbakır
Yasin GÜNEŞ
01/01/1978
Diyarbakır
Abdurazzak AL
01/01/1972
Diyarbakır
Mehmet EKİN
01/01/1983
Diyarbakır
Remezan BALİ
01/01/1964
Diyarbakır
İbrahim ATASOY
01/01/1955
Diyarbakır
Zülküf ERNEZ
01/01/1976
Diyarbakır
Ramazan YILDIRIM
01/01/1958
Diyarbakır
Bediha ÇOLAK
01/01/1977
Diyarbakır
Nebile KILIÇKAP
01/01/1959
Diyarbakır
Mustafa ŞİMŞEK
01/01/1974
Diyarbakır
9797/11
06/09/2010
Musa BALIK
01/01/1975
Siirt
Ahmet KONUK
17/06/1968
Siirt
Ünal DİKTAŞ
30/03/1975
Siirt
Yeliz YETİŞİR
04/11/1982
Siirt
Ramazan ATABAY
30/06/1952
Siirt
Halil POLAT
01/01/1981
Siirt
Lokman KAÇAR
11/11/1980
Siirt
Seyfettin KOCA
25/10/1979
Siirt
Ekrem KILIÇASLAN
20/07/1981
Siirt
Bedri ÇEKİN
25/01/1984
Siirt
Kemal Şerif ÇAKIR
08/05/1981
Siirt
Şemsettin KAYIKÇI
01/01/1976
Siirt
Abdulbaki ESEN
30/07/1974
Siirt
Mahmut NAYIR
01/01/1964
Siirt
Rezan ÜZÜM
12/05/1979
Siirt
Ahmet YILDIZ
26/09/1977
Siirt
İsmail SULA
01/01/1981
Siirt
Ersan YILMAZ
01/01/1982
Siirt
Abdurrahman ESEN
05/10/1984
Siirt
Halime KARAKAŞ DAYAN
08/02/1977
Siirt
Fevzi GEZ
01/01/1981
Siirt
Kamil KUTLU
29/09/1975
Siirt
İdris YARDIM
01/01/1976
Siirt
Orhan ÇELİK
20/11/1983
Siirt
Melek ÜZÜM
01/06/1982
Siirt
Yusuf ÖNER
01/03/1979
Siirt
Abdurrahim KAÇAR
01/06/1982
Siirt
Nezir KUTLU
01/09/1980
Siirt
Halil TOPRAK
02/08/1981
Siirt
Pınar KARATAŞ
03/09/1982
Siirt
Mehmet Yaşar AYDIN
25/01/1954
Siirt
Özkan YILMAZ
01/01/1976
Siirt
Kasım NAS
01/01/1979
Siirt
Mukaddes KAYA
01/01/1979
Siirt
Özgür Barış ÇAĞLAYAN
14/01/1982
Siirt
Murat YILDIZ
01/01/1973
Siirt
Suat DÜZELTİREN
01/01/1971
Siirt
Süleyman BEŞTAŞ
04/01/1976
Siirt
Remzi ÇEKİN
03/03/1982
Siirt
15115/11
07/01/2011
Funda EROL
24/12/1977
Mardin
Sulhaddin BAHTİYAROĞLU
21/07/1977
Mardin
Serhat AVŞAR
08/01/1978
Mardin
Mehmet ÇELİK
22/06/1976
Mardin
Yasemin DERİN
01/05/1982
Mardin
Edip ÇAKI
01/01/1981
Mardin
Hacı GÜL
01/01/1977
Mardin
15179/11
24/12/2010
Haydar KORKMAZ
01/01/1965
Malatya
Ayfer YİGİTOĞLU
08/07/1972
Malatya
Tarik GÖKÇEN
08/12/1962
Malatya
Ali YİĞİTOĞLU
05/01/1970
Malatya
Hasan ARAR
01/09/1966
Malatya
Tacettin ŞAŞ
26/10/1968
Malatya
Savaş İLHAN
12/11/1977
Afyonkarahisar
Necmettin AĞDAĞLI
17/03/1973
Malatya
Nurgül TOKAT
01/01/1973
Malatya
Nilay GELMEZ
15/01/1978
Malatya
Işılay DEMİREL
10/06/1964
Malatya
Gonca GÜLPINAR
15/08/1983
Malatya
17827/11
14/01/2011
Abdulgani CAYHAN
01/01/1966
Bitlis
17974/11
01/02/2011
Coşkun AĞTAŞ
01/01/1980
Elaziğ
23809/11
31/12/2010
Zekeriya SEVER
10/06/1976
Batman
Semra KAPLAN
19/03/1979
Ankara
Mahir ALTUN
27/10/1969
Rize
Ercan ÖZAY
18/03/1963
Ankara
[1]. Rectified on 13 June 2017: The name of Ayhan KIZILASLAN was removed.
[2]. Rectified on 13 June 2017: The names of Bektaş ZENGİN and Ayfer YİGİTOĞLU were removed.
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy