Communicated on 23 February 2018
SECOND SECTION
Application no. 14947/09
Şevkiye Serpil DİLBAŞ and Others against Turkey
and 91 other applications
(see list appended)
SUBJECT MATTER OF the CASEs
The present applications concern the expropriation of the applicants’ plots of land while there was a dispute over the ownership of those plots of land.
In 1958, upon a cadastral survey, the disputed plots of land were registered in the land registry in the name of the applicants and the Treasury. On 2 August 1958, some individuals claiming to be the legal owner of the plots of land objected to the outcome of the survey before the cadastral court.
On different dates between 1973 and 1986, when the proceedings before the cadastral court were still pending, some public administration authorities decided to expropriate the applicants’ plots of land. The expropriation decisions were notified by way of public announcements and/or to curators appointed by the domestic courts. The compensation for the said expropriation was deposited in bank accounts opened in the name of the prospective owners.
On 29 June 2004 the Antalya Cadastral Court delivered a judgment ordering that some parts of the land in question be registered in the land registry as belonging to the applicants. After the said judgment became final on 31 July 2006, considering that their land had been expropriated de facto, the applicants initiated compensation proceedings before the civil courts. During these proceedings the applicants alleged that they had been neither notified of any expropriation decision nor received any expropriation compensation. However the civil courts dismissed the applicants’ claims. In their judgments they held, inter alia, that their land could not be considered as being de facto expropriated since there were formal expropriation decisions taken by the public authorities.
The relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.
The applicants complain under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention that despite the existence of a final judgment establishing their property rights over several plots of land, they were deprived of their land without receiving any compensation
QUESTIONS to THE PARTIES
1. Did the Turkish law, as in force at the material time, require the public authorities to notify to the parties to the proceedings before the cadastral courts, concerning the ownership of the plots of land, about their decision to expropriate? The Government are invited to provide examples of such cases.
2. Before lodging their compensation claims before the civil courts in 2006, did the applicants become aware of the fact that their plots of land had been expropriated and that the compensation for expropriation had been deposited in bank accounts opened in the name of the prospective owners? If so, when and how?
3. What were the amounts of compensation deposited in the bank accounts opened in the name of the prospective owners? Have these amounts been increased following the proceedings initiated by the curators before the civil courts for additional compensation?
4. Did the authorities apply default interest to the compensation for expropriation, deposited in the bank accounts opened in the name of the prospective owners?
5. Did any of the applicants apply to the expropriating authorities or to the bank in order to collect the amounts for compensation? Are the compensation amounts still being held in those bank accounts and is it still possible for the applicants to collect their compensation? If yes, how?
6. Have the applicants been deprived of their possessions in accordance with the requirements of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention? Did that deprivation impose an excessive individual burden on the applicants given the absence of compensation?
The parties are requested to submit copies of all relevant documents including those concerning whether any payment has been made to the applicants for expropriation of their plots of land.
APPENDIX
Application no. and the date of introduction
Details of the disputed plot of land, the date of expropriation and the expropriating public authority
Date and no. of the final decision delivered in the proceedings before the cadastral court
Date and no. of the final decision delivered in the compensation proceedings before the civil court
14947/09
Dilbaş and others
25/02/2009
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 5010, Parcel no. 3
Block no. 5015, Parcel no. 3
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
30/06/2008
E.2008/7904
K.2008/8903
18107/09
Kahraman and others
28/02/2009
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 5010, Parcel no. 3
Block no. 5015, Parcel no. 3
1986, the Akdeniz University
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
30/06/2008
E.2008/7903
K.2008/8901
29878/10
Ülkü and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 4520, Parcel no. 86
1986, the Akdeniz University
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16553
K.2009/16043
29981/10
Ülkü and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3698, Parcel no. 1
1976, the General Directorate of the State Property (Arsa Ofisi Genel Müdürlüğü)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
15/10/2009
E.2009/12114
K.2009/12747
32862/10
Ülkü and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 4520, Parcel no. 123
1983, the Ministry of Village Services and Cooperatives
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
15/10/2009
E.2009/12118
K.2009/12733
32863/10
Ülkü and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 4520, Parcel no. 32
1983, the Ministry of Justice
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
15/10/2009
E.2009/12108
K.2009/127363
32864/10
Ülkü and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3698, Parcel no. 5
1976, the General Directorate of the State Property (Arsa Ofisi Genel Müdürlüğü)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
15/10/2009
E.2009/12109
K.2009/12748
32865/10
Ülkü and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 4520, Parcel no. 95
1984, the Ministry of Interior
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
15/10/2009
E.2009/12110
K.2009/12750
32866/10
Ülkü and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 4520, Parcels no. 89 and 111
1976, the General Directorate of the State Property (Arsa Ofisi Genel Müdürlüğü)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
15/10/2009
E.2009/12116
K.2009/12725
32867/10
Ülkü and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3702, Parcel no.1
1976, the General Directorate of the State Property (Arsa Ofisi Genel Müdürlüğü)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
15/10/2009
E.2009/12106
K.2009/12739
32868/10
Ülkü and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3701, Parcel no. 2
1973, the General Directorate of the State Property (Arsa Ofisi Genel Müdürlüğü)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
15/10/2009
E.2009/12125
K.2009/12740
32869/10
Ülkü and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 4520, Parcel no. 8
1973, the General Directorate of the State Property (Arsa Ofisi Genel Müdürlüğü)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
15/10/2009
E.2009/12122
K.2009/12735
35567/10
Dilbaş and others
18/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 5015, Parcel no. 6
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/17119
K.2009/16092
35568/10
Dilbaş and others
18/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 5016, Parcel no. 1
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/17070
K.2009/16047
35569/10
Dilbaş and others
18/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 6267, Parcels no. 2 and 3
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/17132
K.2009/16054
35570/10
Dilbaş and others
18/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 6261, Parcels no. 5 and 6
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/17127
K.2009/16046
35571/10
Dilbaş and others
18/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 6263, Parcel no. 1
Block no. 6264, Parcel no. 1
Block no. 6265, Parcel no. 1
Block no. 6266, Parcel no. 1
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/17129
K.2009/16064
35572/10
Dilbaş and others
18/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 6267, Parcel no. 4
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/17130
K.2009/16055
35573/10
Dilbaş and others
18/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 6333, Parcel no. 1
Block no. 6334, Parcel no. 1
Block no. 6335, Parcels no. 1 and 2
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/17121
K.2009/16062
35574/10
Dilbaş and others
18/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 6262, Parcel no. 1
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/17125
K.2009/16056
35575/10
Dilbaş and others
15/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3409, Parcel no. 2
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/15757
K.2009/16069
35576/10
Dilbaş and others
15/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3412, Parcel no. 1
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/15980
K.2009/16093
35577/10
Ülkü and others
15/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3412, Parcel no. 1
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/15981
K.2009/16059
35578/10
Ülkü and others
15/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3409, Parcel no. 4
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/15982
K.2009/16068
35579/10
Ülkü and others
15/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3409, Parcel no. 3
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/15983
K.2009/16071
35580/10
Dilbaş and others
15/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3409, Parcel no. 4
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/15977
K.2009/16073
35581/10
Ülkü and others
18/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 6263, Parcel no.1
Block no. 6264, Parcel no.1
Block no. 6265, Parcel no.1
Block no. 6266, Parcel no.1
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/17120
K.2009/16049
35582/10
Ülkü and others
18/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 6267, Parcels no. 2 and 3
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/17131
K.2009/16096
35583/10
Ülkü and others
18/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 6333, Parcel no. 1
Block no. 6334, Parcel no. 1
Block no. 6335, Parcels no. 1 and 2
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/17128
K.2009/16060
35584/10
Ülkü and others
18/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 6261, Parcel no. 5
Block no. 6261, Parcel no. 6
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/17122
K.2009/16104
35585/10
Ülkü and others
18/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 5015, Parcel no. 6
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/17118
K.2009/16058
35586/10
Ülkü and others
18/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 5015, Parcel no. 5
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/15975
K.2009/16070
35587/10
Ülkü and others
18/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 6267, Parcel no. 4
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/17123
K.2009/16088
35588/10
Ülkü and others
18/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 6262, Parcel no. 1
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/17124
K.2009/16078
35589/10
Ülkü and others
18/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 5016, Parcel no. 1
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/17126
K.2009/16061
35590/10
Ülkü and others
18/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3409, Parcel no. 2
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/15978
K.2009/16053
35591/10
Ülkü and others
18/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3411, Parcel no. 1
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/15984
K.2009/16063
51523/10
Dilbaş and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3926, Parcel no. 9
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16602
K.2009/16076
51524/10
Dilbaş and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3416, Parcel no. 1
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16587
K.2009/16094
51525/10
Dilbaş and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3414, Parcel no. 1
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16595
K.2009/16072
51526/10
Dilbaş and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3926, Parcel no. 4
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16584
K.2009/16042
51527/10
Dilbaş and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3415, Parcel no. 1
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16603
K.2009/16108
51528/10
Dilbaş and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3421, Parcel no. 1
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16586
K.2009/16066
51529/10
Dilbaş and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3926, Parcel no. 10
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16583
K.2009/16084
51530/10
Dilbaş and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3415, Parcel no. 2
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16594
K.2009/16089
51531/10
Dilbaş and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3425, Parcel no. 1
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16605
K.2009/16107
51532/10
Dilbaş and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3926, Parcel no. 8
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16596
K.2009/16105
51533/10
Dilbaş and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3424, Parcel no. 1
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16589
K.2009/16067
51534/10
Dilbaş and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3415, Parcel no. 3
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16601
K.2009/16044
51535/10
Dilbaş and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3926, Parcel no. 5
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16582
K.2009/16090
51536/10
Ülkü and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3414, Parcel no. 1
1985, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16597
K.2009/16086
51537/10
Ülkü and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3415, Parcel no. 2
1985, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16600
K.2009/16051
51538/10
Ülkü and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3415, Parcel no. 3
1985, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16590
K.2009/16091
51539/10
Ülkü and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3926, Parcel no.10
1985, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16592
K.2009/16045
51540/10
Ülkü and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3926, Parcel no. 4
1985, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16604
K.2009/16074
51541/10
Ülkü and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3926, Parcel no. 5
1985, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16593
K.2009/16048
51542/10
Ülkü and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3415, Parcel no. 1
1985, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16585
K.2009/16052
51543/10
Ülkü and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3926, Parcel no. 8
1985, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16591
K.2009/16097
51544/10
Ülkü and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3425, Parcel no. 1
1985, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16581
K.2009/16065
51545/10
Ülkü and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3926, Parcel no. 9
1985, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16588
K.2009/16050
51546/10
Ülkü and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3424, Parcel no. 1
1985, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16606
K.2009/16095
51547/10
Ülkü and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3421, Parcel no. 1
1985, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16599
K.2009/16087
51548/10
Ülkü and others
28/06/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3416, Parcel no. 1
1985, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16598
K.2009/16085
61066/10
Dilbaş and others
18/08/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3409, Parcel no. 3
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
11/02/2010
E.2009/20885
K.2010/1773
61218/10
Dilbaş and others
18/08/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 12567, Parcel no. 7
1976, the General Directorate of the State Property (Arsa Ofisi Genel Müdürlüğü)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
11/02/2010
E.2009/20640
K.2010/1758
61222/10
Dilbaş and others
18/08/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 12567, Parcel no. 2
1976, the General Directorate of the State Property (Arsa Ofisi Genel Müdürlüğü)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
28/01/2010
E.2009/20655
K.2010/1410
61225/10
Dilbaş and others
18/08/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 12567, Parcel no. 4
1986, the General Directorate of the State Property (Arsa Ofisi Genel Müdürlüğü)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
28/01/2010
E.2009/20644
K.2010/1397
61230/10
Dilbaş and others
18/08/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 5021, Parcels nos. 2, 39, 40, 41 and 42
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
28/01/2010
E.2009/19880
K.2010/1422
61237/10
Dilbaş and others
18/08/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 6268, Parcel no. 1
Block no. 6269, Parcel no. 1
Block no. 6270, Parcel no. 1
Block no. 6458, Parcels nos. 1, 4 and 5
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
11/02/2010
E.2009/18795
K.2010/1762
61241/10
Dilbaş and others
18/08/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 5015, Parcel no. 5
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
11/02/2010
E.2009/19241
K.2010/1781
61245/10
Dilbaş and others
18/08/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3411, Parcel no. 1
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
11/02/2010
E.2009/19239
K.2010/1782
61252/10
Dilbaş and others
18/08/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 6368, Parcel no. 4
1980, the Ministry of Public Works and Settlement (Bayındırlık ve İskân Bakanlığı)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
28/01/2010
E.2009/20642
K.2010/1402
61259/10
Dilbaş and others
18/08/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 6336, Parcels nos.1 and 2
Block no. 6337, Parcel no. 1
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
28/01/2010
E.2009/18791
K.2010/1421
61262/10
Dilbaş and others
18/08/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 6267, Parcel no. 5
1988, the Ministry of Education
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
28/01/2010
E.2009/20641
K.2010/1408
61285/10
Dilbaş and others
18/08/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 5011, Parcel no. 1
Block no. 5012, Parcel no. 2
1986, the Antalya Municipality
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
28/01/2010
E.2009/18793
K.2010/1424
61298/10
Dilbaş and others
18/08/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 12567, Parcel no. 9
1986, the General Directorate of the State Property (Arsa Ofisi Genel Müdürlüğü)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
28/01/2010
E.2009/20651
K.2010/1411
61304/10
Dilbaş and others
18/08/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 12565, Parcel no. 1
1991, the Ministry of Education
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
11/02/2010
E.2009/20653
K.2010/1772
61310/10
Dilbaş and others
18/08/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 12581, Parcels nos. 1 and 2
1976, the General Directorate of Physical Training and Sports (Beden Terbiyesi ve Spor Genel Müdürlüğü)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
28/01/2010
E.2009/19198
K.2010/1405
61319/10
Dilbaş and others
18/08/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 5021, Parcels nos. 3, 43, 44, 45 and 46
1986, the Turkish Radio and Television Corporation
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
11/02/2010
E.2009/19882
K.2010/1784
61327/10
Dilbaş and others
18/08/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 12581, Parcels nos. 3 and 4
1976, the General Directorate of Physical Training and Sports (Beden Terbiyesi ve Spor Genel Müdürlüğü)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
11/02/2010
E.2009/19240
K.2010/1777
63210/10
Dilbaş and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 4520, Parcel no. 8
1973, the Ministry of Education
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
15/10/2009
E.2009/12103
K.2009/12734
63211/10
Dilbaş and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3698, Parcel no. 1
1976, the General Directorate of the State Property (Arsa Ofisi Genel Müdürlüğü)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
15/10/2009
E.2009/12111
K.2009/12731
63212/10
Dilbaş and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 4520, Parcel no. 95
1981, the Ministry of Interior
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
15/10/2009
E.2009/12117
K.2009/12729
63213/10
Dilbaş and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3698, Parcel no. 5
1976, the General Directorate of the State Property (Arsa Ofisi Genel Müdürlüğü)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
15/10/2009
E.2009/12112
K.2009/12741
63214/10
Dilbaş and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 4520, Parcel no. 32
1983, the Ministry of Justice
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
15/10/2009
E.2009/12115
K.2009/12742
63215/10
Dilbaş and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 4520, Parcels nos. 84 and 85
1985, the General Directorate of Land Registration (Tapu Kadastro Genel Müdürlüğü)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
15/10/2009
E.2009/12119
K.2009/12737
63216/10
Dilbaş and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 4520, Parcel no. 86
1985, the University of Akdeniz
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
19/11/2009
E.2009/16518
K.2009/16057
63217/10
Dilbaş and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3702, Parcel no. 1
1980, the General Directorate of the State Property (Arsa Ofisi Genel Müdürlüğü)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
15/10/2009
E.2009/12102
K.2009/12732
63218/10
Dilbaş and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3700, Parcel no. 1
1976, the General Directorate of the State Property (Arsa Ofisi Genel Müdürlüğü)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
15/10/2009
E.2009/12104
K.2009/12738
63219/10
Dilbaş and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 4520, Parcel no. 123
1982, the General Directorate for Village Services (Köy Hizmetleri Genel Müdürlüğü)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
15/10/2009
E.2009/12113
K.2009/12749
63220/10
Dilbaş and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 3699, Parcel no. 4
1976, the General Directorate of the State Property (Arsa Ofisi Genel Müdürlüğü)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
13/10/2009
E.2009/12124
K.2009/12744
63221/10
Dilbaş and others
24/05/2010
Antalya, Merkez,
Bahçelievler,
Block no. 4520, Parcels nos. 89 and 111
1976, the General Directorate of the State Property (Arsa Ofisi Genel Müdürlüğü)
The Antalya Cadastral Court
29/06/2004
E:2003/27
K:2004/19
Became final on 31 July 2006
The Court of Cassation
15/10/2009
E.2009/12121
K.2009/12726
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy