Published on 18 December 2023
SECOND SECTION
Application no. 45699/22
Numan DÖNMEZ against Türkiye
and 199 other applications
(see list appended)
communicated on 12 December 2023
STATEMENT OF FACTS
1. A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix.The circumstances of the case
2. The applications mainly concern the applicants’ conviction for membership of an armed terrorist organisation described by the Turkish authorities as the “Fetullahist Terror Organisation/Parallel State Structure” (Fetullahçı Terör Örgütü / Paralel Devlet Yapılanması, hereinafter referred to as “the FETÖ/PDY”), considered by the authorities to be behind the coup attempt that took place in Türkiye on 15 July 2016.
3. According to the information submitted by the applicants, the convictions were based, inter alia, on the applicants’ alleged use of the encrypted messaging application “ByLock”, which the domestic courts held was used exclusively by FETÖ/PDY members and which therefore constituted sufficient evidence to prove on its own that a person had been part of the FETÖ/PDY’s hierarchical structure.
4. The broader domestic background and context to the present applications was set out by the Grand Chamber in the case of Yüksel Yalçınkaya v. Türkiye ([GC], no. 15669/20, §§ 10-22 and 108-40, 26 September 2023).Relevant domestic law and practice
5. A description of the relevant domestic law and practice can be found in Yüksel Yalçınkaya (cited above, §§ 141-193).
COMPLAINTS
6. The applicants mainly complained that their trial and conviction for membership of the FETÖ/PDY had violated the principle of no punishment without law under Article 7 of the Convention and/or the right to a fair trial under Article 6 § 1.
QUESTIONS TO THE PARTIES
Since the issues raised by the present applications are already the subject of well-established case-law of the Court (see Yüksel Yalçınkaya v. Türkiye [GC], no. 15669/20, §§ 237-356, 26 September 2023), the Court does not put any questions to the parties or require any observations on these applications. However, if they so wish, the Government may submit observations on the complaints set out in the appended table, to the extent that they refer essentially to the factual aspects of the applications and not to preliminary objections or legal issues already decided by the Court in Yüksel Yalçınkaya (cited above) or other similar cases against Türkiye.
APPENDIX
List of applications raising complaints under Article 7 (no punishment without law) and/or Article 6 § 1 of the Convention (right to a fair trial) (conviction for membership of the FETÖ/PDY based, inter alia, on the applicants’ alleged use of the encrypted messaging application “ByLock”)
No.
Application no.
Case name
Lodged on
Applicant
Year of Birth
Place of Residence
Nationality
Represented by
45699/22
Dönmez v. Türkiye
21/09/2022
Numan DÖNMEZ
1974
Adana
Turkish
Ali KIZILTEPE
62032/19
Kıran v. Türkiye
01/11/2019
Zeynep KIRAN
1988
Zonguldak
Turkish
Sevgi
KÜMÜŞ TEK
11160/20
Okur v. Türkiye
25/02/2020
Mustafa OKUR
1977
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
11165/20
Aksoy v. Türkiye
26/02/2020
Dilaver AKSOY
1976
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
11168/20
Coşkun v. Türkiye
26/02/2020
Abdullah COŞKUN
1974
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
13615/20
Sezgin v. Türkiye
02/03/2020
Kemal Hasan Hüseyin SEZGİN
1966
Kütahya
Turkish
Orçun MUŞLU
14859/20
Mortaş v. Türkiye
17/02/2020
Emin MORTAŞ
1986
Kayseri
Turkish
Turgut ÖZKAN
15811/20
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
12/03/2020
Erol YILMAZ
1976
Şanlıurfa
Turkish
Ahmet MUSRİ
19758/20
Hamalosmanoğlu v. Türkiye
07/05/2020
Harun HAMALOSMANOĞLU
1978
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
19768/20
Tunahan v. Türkiye
08/05/2020
İsmail TUNAHAN
1977
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
24338/20
Köroğlu v. Türkiye
08/05/2020
Sinan KÖROĞLU
1974
Erzincan
Turkish
Ozlem KÖROGLU
29793/20
Namal v. Türkiye
03/07/2020
Hüseyin Ercan NAMAL
1977
Burdur
Turkish
Merve
MENGİ ELTUTAN
33294/20
Murt v. Türkiye
22/07/2020
Osman MURT
1971
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
36681/20
Uçak v. Türkiye
07/08/2020
Haydar UÇAK
1979
Diyarbakır
Turkish
Şivan Cemil ÖZEN
37488/20
Kaya v. Türkiye
05/08/2020
Ertan KAYA
1973
Düzce
Turkish
Osman Rahmi OFLUOĞLU
39559/20
Karaaslan v. Türkiye
03/09/2020
Hasan KARAASLAN
1973
Trabzon
Turkish
Sümeyye KETHÜDA
40117/20
Köse v. Türkiye
25/08/2020
Yaşar KÖSE
1985
Denizli
Turkish
Sümeyra KÖSE
40133/20
Özfidan v. Türkiye
02/09/2020
Zafer ÖZFİDAN
1987
Aydın
Turkish
Orçun MUŞLU
41141/20
Mutlu v. Türkiye
31/08/2020
Onur MUTLU
1984
Denizli
Turkish
Elçin MUTLU
43204/20
Erkoç v. Türkiye
10/09/2020
Fatih Mehmet ERKOÇ
1979
Kırıkkale
Turkish
Mustafa KOÇ
44828/20
Altın v. Türkiye
10/09/2020
Mustafa ALTIN
1973
Osmaniye
Turkish
Hamdi MERSİN
44969/20
Gözen v. Türkiye
19/08/2020
Ahmet GÖZEN
1982
Konya
Turkish
Kadir ÖZTÜRK
45070/20
Karaboğa v. Türkiye
10/09/2020
Osman KARABOĞA
1987
Osmaniye
Turkish
Hamdi MERSİN
46562/20
Öztürk v. Türkiye
06/10/2020
Ertuğrul ÖZTÜRK
1989
Bingöl
Turkish
Mucahit NUSRETOĞLU
48924/20
Kaya v. Türkiye
27/10/2020
Recep KAYA
1981
Karabük
Turkish
Tayfun ÖZSOY
50829/20
Mehmet v. Türkiye
03/10/2020
Yetiş MEHMET
1979
Niğde
Turkish
Fuat ÖZGÜL
53954/20
Uyanık v. Türkiye
30/11/2020
Ömer UYANIK
1970
Tokat
Turkish
Özkan OGURLU
55038/20
Savaş v. Türkiye
27/11/2020
Muhammed SAVAŞ
1989
Van
Turkish
Abdülkadir ÖZ
565/21
Tekin v. Türkiye
27/11/2020
Murat Yasin TEKİN
1975
Niğde
Turkish
Hilmi KÖRPEKAYA
3058/21
Araz v. Türkiye
14/12/2020
Mehmet Emin ARAZ
1979
Van
Turkish
Cihan MACİT
6097/21
Demir v. Türkiye
11/01/2021
Kurtuluş DEMİR
1985
İzmir
Turkish
Aydın KIRMIZITAŞ
6463/21
Pehlivan v. Türkiye
13/01/2021
Orhan PEHLİVAN
1975
Samsun
Turkish
Osman MEŞE
7945/21
Aydın v. Türkiye
15/01/2021
Ümit Yaşar AYDIN
1977
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Sedat ORAL
8877/21
Beyaztaş v. Türkiye
02/02/2021
Ekrem BEYAZTAŞ
1970
Erzurum
Turkish
Yılmaz POLAT
12232/21
Koçaş v. Türkiye
26/02/2021
Erdinç KOÇAŞ
1982
Ankara
Turkish
Mehmet Cabir NARİN
12992/21
Güneş v. Türkiye
18/02/2021
Muzaffer GÜNEŞ
1975
Ordu
Turkish
Ayşe ÖZCAN GÜNEŞ
13816/21
Ar v. Türkiye
03/03/2021
İlyas AR
1975
Kocaeli
Turkish
Esra ÖZTÜRK
15444/21
Irmak v. Türkiye
15/03/2021
Mehmet IRMAK
1984
Metin POLAT
15447/21
Cansever v. Türkiye
15/03/2021
Gültekin CANSEVER
1972
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
15449/21
Eroğlu v. Türkiye
15/03/2021
Bestami EROĞLU
1978
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
15451/21
Karadeniz v. Türkiye
15/03/2021
Zekeriya KARADENİZ
1993
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
15468/21
Taktak v. Türkiye
15/03/2021
Mahmut TAKTAK
1975
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
15483/21
Atık v. Türkiye
15/03/2021
Kemal ATIK
1970
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
15485/21
Kancı v. Türkiye
15/03/2021
Fati KANCI
1972
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
15493/21
Cingöz v. Türkiye
15/03/2021
Mustafa CİNGÖZ
1971
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
15496/21
Bezgin v. Türkiye
15/03/2021
Mehmet BEZGİN
1966
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
15506/21
Poyraz v. Türkiye
15/03/2021
Süleyman POYRAZ
1994
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
15527/21
Çokgez v. Türkiye
15/03/2021
Abdulkadir ÇOKGEZ
1974
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
15915/21
Kocaer v. Türkiye
16/03/2021
Kadir KOCAER
1979
Manisa
Turkish
Emine KOCAER
15954/21
Köç v. Türkiye
10/03/2021
Mustafa KÖÇ
1987
Çanakkale
Turkish
Uğur KÖÇ
17692/21
Aytaç v. Türkiye
25/03/2021
Ahmet AYTAÇ
1988
Bingöl
Turkish
Mucahit NUSRETOĞLU
18751/21
Menekşe v. Türkiye
30/03/2021
Yusuf MENEKŞE
1987
Kayseri
Turkish
Kadriye MENEKŞE
19172/21
Eş v. Türkiye
02/04/2021
Selim EŞ
1979
Niğde
Turkish
Ahmet Oğuz ÖZMEN
19522/21
Eroğlu v. Türkiye
23/03/2021
Hasan EROĞLU
1989
Osmaniye
Turkish
Muhammed Murat POYRAZ
21155/21
Kaldırım v. Türkiye
19/04/2021
Enver KALDIRIM
1972
Istanbul
Turkish
Aslı ÖZKAN KALDIRIM
21703/21
Özçelik v. Türkiye
15/04/2021
Umut ÖZÇELİK
1984
Bandırma
Turkish
Pınar ÖZÇELİK
23857/21
Öztoprak v. Türkiye
28/04/2021
Fahri ÖZTOPRAK
1970
Erzurum
Turkish
Emine ÖZTOPRAK
24772/21
Oktar v. Türkiye
05/05/2021
Ferhat OKTAR
1981
Aydın
Turkish
Orçun MUŞLU
24778/21
Yıldız v. Türkiye
27/04/2021
Özcan YILDIZ
1984
Çorum
Turkish
Oğuzhan KISA
25587/21
Üsküplü v. Türkiye
05/05/2021
Mustafa ÜSKÜPLÜ
1969
Şanlıurfa
Turkish
Mustafa NOYAN
25794/21
Atıcı v. Türkiye
05/05/2021
Turgut ATICI
1985
Istanbul
Turkish
Ahmet KÖROĞLU
25844/21
Öztürk v. Türkiye
11/05/2021
Engin ÖZTÜRK
1975
Antalya
Turkish
Ahmet KESKİN
26163/21
Cırık v. Türkiye
07/05/2021
Furkan CIRIK
1993
İzmir
Turkish
Seçkin KESKİN
26983/21
Kocadiz v. Türkiye
27/04/2021
Tahir KOCADİZ
1971
Konya
Turkish
Fuat ÖZGÜL
27372/21
Yamaç v. Türkiye
11/05/2021
Gökay YAMAÇ
1979
Giresun
Turkish
Samet KÖROĞLU
27951/21
Maç v. Türkiye
26/05/2021
Önder MAÇ
1973
Antalya
Turkish
Rumi MERCAN
28162/21
Polat v. Türkiye
25/05/2021
Zafer POLAT
1976
İstanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÖNCÜ
28229/21
Çakıroğlu v. Türkiye
29/05/2021
Emin ÇAKIROĞLU
1983
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Ferhat MEMMEDZADE
28719/21
Özer v. Türkiye
28/05/2021
Adem ÖZER
1989
Ağrı
Turkish
Ahmet KESKİN
30852/21
Erkılıç v. Türkiye
25/05/2021
Adem ERKILIÇ
1971
Kayseri
Turkish
Fuat ÖZGÜL
31628/21
Bala v. Türkiye
11/06/2021
Esat BALA
1988
Adana
Turkish
Nusret SAÇLI
31921/21
Yüce v. Türkiye
07/06/2021
Emrah YÜCE
1986
Elazığ
Turkish
Elif Süeda ÖZDEMİR
32722/21
Alptekin v. Türkiye
04/06/2021
Harun ALPTEKİN
1984
Ankara
Turkish
Fuat ÖZGÜL
34093/21
Gedikli v. Türkiye
18/06/2021
Abdullah GEDİKLİ
1979
Aydın
Turkish
Orçun MUŞLU
35032/21
Yavuz v. Türkiye
09/06/2021
Ramazan YAVUZ
1985
AFYONKARAHISAR
Turkish
İbrahim KOCAOĞUL
36071/21
Öztürk v. Türkiye
08/06/2021
Bahtiyar ÖZTÜRK
1983
İzmir
Turkish
Gülten ÖZTÜRK
36277/21
Alp v. Türkiye
05/07/2021
Sedat ALP
1971
Antalya
Turkish
Kamile KILDAN
36360/21
Aladoğan v. Türkiye
16/07/2021
Davut ALADOĞAN
1966
Osmaniye
Turkish
Fatma Zehra ÖZDİPİ
36874/21
Şimşek v. Türkiye
14/07/2021
Mehmet ŞİMŞEK
1981
Kırıkkale
Turkish
Ferhat MEMMEDZADE
37197/21
Polat v. Türkiye
12/07/2021
Orhan POLAT
1972
Antalya
Turkish
Ahmet KESKİN
38198/21
Bayram v. Türkiye
09/07/2021
Tamer BAYRAM
1971
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
38240/21
Akkaya v. Türkiye
09/07/2021
Salih AKKAYA
1985
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
39372/21
Nergiz v. Türkiye
27/07/2021
Cemil NERGİZ
1991
Istanbul
Turkish
Süha OĞUZ İŞLER
42971/21
Yıldız v. Türkiye
23/08/2021
Betül YILDIZ
1985
Ankara
Turkish
Oğuzhan KISA
43605/21
Aydın v. Türkiye
26/08/2021
Eşref AYDIN
1991
Hatay
Turkish
Enes ÖZEN
44014/21
Aslım v. Türkiye
28/07/2021
Yavuz ASLIM
1980
Bingöl
Turkish
Mucahit NUSRETOĞLU
44512/21
Kılıçer v. Türkiye
31/08/2021
İbrahim KILIÇER
1964
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
Süleyman ÖZGÜN
45188/21
Karaduman v. Türkiye
27/08/2021
Ahmet KARADUMAN
1977
Bitlis
Turkish
Fuat ÖZGÜL
46353/21
İvdil v. Türkiye
10/09/2021
Murat İVDİL
1989
İzmir
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
47197/21
Cenk v. Türkiye
16/09/2021
Cendel CENK
1979
Balıkesir
Turkish
Hasan ÖZÇELİK
49017/21
Yıldız v. Türkiye
24/09/2021
Mahmut Cengiz YILDIZ
1969
Elazığ
Turkish
Mucahit NUSRETOĞLU
51838/21
Kocaoğul v. Türkiye
06/10/2021
Fatih Rüştü KOCAOĞUL
1981
Denizli
Turkish
İbrahim KOCAOĞUL
52275/21
Kul v. Türkiye
07/10/2021
Züfer KUL
1977
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
52992/21
Kara v. Türkiye
01/10/2021
Hakan Batırhan KARA
1976
Bitlis
Turkish
Fuat ÖZGÜL
54076/21
Arslan v. Türkiye
01/11/2021
İsmail ARSLAN
1987
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
54120/21
Öz v. Türkiye
18/10/2021
Mahmut ÖZ
1984
Kastamonu
Turkish
Fatma Zehra ÖZDİPİ
55549/21
Topuz v. Türkiye
19/10/2021
Halil TOPUZ
1974
Izmir
Turkish
Buğra KENDİRLİOĞLU
55793/21
Karabulut v. Türkiye
19/10/2021
İbrahim Şahin KARABULUT
1994
Manisa
Turkish
Kadir ÖZTÜRK
56004/21
Tosun v. Türkiye
15/11/2021
Serkan TOSUN
1982
Kırıkkale
Turkish
Ümmühan Rabianur ÖZKAN
57292/21
Ekemen v. Türkiye
23/11/2021
Emine EKEMEN
1995
Manisa
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
58852/21
Büyükaslan v. Türkiye
24/11/2021
Abddülkadir BÜYÜKASLAN
1977
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Muhammed Murat POYRAZ
59681/21
Candemir v. Türkiye
01/12/2021
Neslihan CANDEMİR
1982
Manisa
Turkish
Menşur NAVRUZ
59860/21
Şengül v. Türkiye
09/12/2021
Mehmet ŞENGÜL
1971
Manisa
Turkish
Ferhat KONUR
60135/21
Özgül v. Türkiye
22/11/2021
Osman ÖZGÜL
1972
Isparta
Turkish
Güler ÖZGÜL
60880/21
Çalayır v. Türkiye
02/12/2021
Birol ÇALAYIR
1966
İzmir
Turkish
Seçkin KESKİN
78/22
Bakır v. Türkiye
14/12/2021
İsmail BAKIR
1982
Niğde
Turkish
Mustafa ÖZŞAHİN
670/22
Duman v. Türkiye
13/12/2021
Samet Uğur DUMAN
1989
Bitlis
Turkish
Fuat ÖZGÜL
2356/22
Karaisa v. Türkiye
04/01/2022
Ercan KARAİSA
1984
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
2578/22
Darçın v. Türkiye
29/12/2021
Mehmet DARÇIN
1984
Ankara
Turkish
Ferhat MEMMEDZADE
3211/22
Didar v. Türkiye
07/01/2022
Dilek DİDAR
1980
İzmir
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
3601/22
Kaya v. Türkiye
13/01/2022
Songül KAYA
1986
Aydın
Turkish
Orçun MUŞLU
3985/22
Şıhanoğlu v. Türkiye
06/01/2022
Hekim Cihan ŞIHANOĞLU
1980
Van
Turkish
Lale KULA ÇELİK
4560/22
Yontar Demirci v. Türkiye
07/01/2022
Esra YONTAR DEMIRCİ
1979
Antalya
Turkish
Seranur ÖZMEN
6516/22
Güngör v. Türkiye
11/01/2022
Yakup GÜNGÖR
1978
Denizli
Turkish
Nazlı MERT
7984/22
Sarı v. Türkiye
28/01/2022
Ömer SARI
1974
Aydın
Turkish
Orçun MUŞLU
9031/22
Erciyas v. Türkiye
07/02/2022
Hamza ERCİYAS
1984
Istanbul
Turkish
Büşra KURT KÜÇÜK
9061/22
Kaya v. Türkiye
14/02/2022
Yüksel KAYA
1992
Duzce
Turkish
Osman ÖZATA
9157/22
Can v. Türkiye
12/02/2022
Salih CAN
1969
Denizli
Turkish
Nazlı MERT
10038/22
Tari v. Türkiye
15/02/2022
Aziz TARİ
1982
Aydın
Turkish
Sümeyye ÖZTÜRK YURT
10465/22
Gür v. Türkiye
15/02/2022
Arif GÜR
1971
Antalya
Turkish
Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
11251/22
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
22/02/2022
Mustafa YILMAZ
1972
Mersin
Turkish
Kadir ÖZTÜRK
12021/22
Demirel v. Türkiye
25/02/2022
Bülent DEMİREL
1983
Sakarya
Turkish
Savaş Barış PEKER
12049/22
Akın v. Türkiye
03/03/2022
Cezmi AKIN
1973
Aydin
Turkish
Muşlu ORÇUN
14043/22
Çil v. Türkiye
11/03/2022
Muhammed İkbal ÇİL
1973
Denizli
Turkish
Kadir KURUCU
14693/22
Küçük v. Türkiye
07/03/2022
Hacı İbrahim KÜÇÜK
1980
Tokat
Turkish
Şeyma MISIRLIOĞLU
14715/22
Manka v. Türkiye
18/03/2022
İsmail MANKA
1987
İzmir
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
15096/22
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
09/03/2022
Orhan YILMAZ
1991
Balikesir
Turkish
Hasan ÖZÇELİK
15599/22
Sürücü v. Türkiye
22/03/2022
Ayla SÜRÜCÜ
1962
Denizli
Turkish
Mehmet MİRZA
16376/22
Erşahıs v. Türkiye
18/03/2022
Ümit ERŞAHIS
1979
Malatya
Turkish
Ahmet PEKTAŞ
16801/22
Alpaslan v. Türkiye
18/03/2022
Atilla ALPASLAN
1970
Malatya
Turkish
Ahmet PEKTAŞ
17644/22
Okkay v. Türkiye
31/03/2022
Pembe Leyla OKKAY
1988
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Cemile ÖZCAN
17974/22
Ünsal v. Türkiye
30/03/2022
Mehmet ÜNSAL
1979
Samsun
Turkish
Ayşenur ÖZDEMİR
18548/22
Altuntaş v. Türkiye
01/04/2022
Emre ALTUNTAŞ
1994
Karabük
Turkish
Tayfun ÖZSOY
18831/22
Bingöl v. Türkiye
07/04/2022
Mehmet Ali BİNGÖL
1973
İstanbul
Turkish
Büşra KURT KÜÇÜK
18904/22
Öztürk v. Türkiye
04/04/2022
Emrah ÖZTÜRK
1981
Manisa
Turkish
Elçin MERİÇ
18969/22
Kalkan v. Türkiye
07/04/2022
Yıldıray KALKAN
1969
Rize
Turkish
Büşra KURT KÜÇÜK
19030/22
Tosun v. Türkiye
06/04/2022
Fatih TOSUN
1980
Aydın
Turkish
Hanım ÖNKOL
19143/22
Osmanoğlu v. Türkiye
12/04/2022
Fatih OSMANOĞLU
1977
Çorum
Turkish
Muhammet MARAŞLI
19383/22
Dönmez v. Türkiye
12/04/2022
İsmail DÖNMEZ
1991
Istanbul
Turkish
Ömer Faruk ÖZÜTEMİZ
19431/22
Ölmez v. Türkiye
07/04/2022
Yusuf ÖLMEZ
1975
İzmir
Turkish
Feride PAMUKÇU
19759/22
Güler v. Türkiye
11/04/2022
Süleyman GÜLER
1974
İzmir
Turkish
Elçin MERİÇ
20268/22
Altıntaş v. Türkiye
15/04/2022
Şükran ALTINTAŞ
1990
Istanbul
Turkish
Kasım KUTBOĞA
20889/22
Gedik v. Türkiye
23/04/2022
Arif GEDİK
1983
Malatya
Turkish
Orçun MUŞLU
22258/22
Soylu v. Türkiye
14/04/2022
İsmail SOYLU
1977
Samsun
Turkish
Ahmet Hamit POLAT
22297/22
Orak v. Türkiye
25/04/2022
Mehmet Şerif ORAK
1978
Balıkesir
Turkish
Meleknur ORAK
22349/22
Özlü v. Türkiye
25/04/2022
Ferit ÖZLÜ
1980
Istanbul
Turkish
Büşra KURT KÜÇÜK
23213/22
Kumak v. Türkiye
19/04/2022
Cengiz KUMAK
1978
Konya
Turkish
Hurigül ÖZCAN KISA
23228/22
Karamustafaoğlu v. Türkiye
21/04/2022
Murat KARAMUSTAFAOĞLU
1986
Trabzon
Turkish
Veysel MALKOÇ
24294/22
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
20/04/2022
Salih YILMAZ
1969
Düzce
Turkish
Özgür METİN
24676/22
Kasapoğlu v. Türkiye
10/05/2022
Murat KASAPOĞLU
1981
İstanbul
Turkish
Büşra KURT KÜÇÜK
25784/22
Öztürk v. Türkiye
10/05/2022
Zübeyde ÖZTÜRK
1991
Bitlis
Turkish
Fuat ÖZGÜL
25785/22
Ateş v. Türkiye
25/04/2022
Aziz ATEŞ
1965
Ankara
Turkish
Özkan OGURLU
27235/22
Çam v. Türkiye
25/05/2022
Muhammet ÇAM
1988
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Safiyye SABUNCU KARAKURT
28065/22
Ayhan v. Türkiye
26/05/2022
Gökhan AYHAN
1976
Yozgat
Turkish
Ömer MERCANTAŞ
28331/22
Tosun v. Türkiye
20/05/2022
Yasemin TOSUN
1995
Denizli
Turkish
Hasan Hüseyin KOZAK
28344/22
Pişken v. Türkiye
25/05/2022
İbrahim PİŞKEN
1985
Adana
Turkish
Tuǧba PİŞKEN
29649/22
Peker v. Türkiye
09/06/2022
İhsan Mehmet PEKER
1980
İstanbul
Turkish
Sait ÖZAĞCA
29720/22
Alkan v. Türkiye
08/06/2022
Muhammed Talha ALKAN
1981
Balıkersir
Turkish
Büşra KURT KÜÇÜK
29734/22
Bulut v. Türkiye
27/05/2022
Faik BULUT
1969
Bingöl
Turkish
Mucahit NUSRETOĞLU
30328/22
Önal v. Türkiye
15/06/2022
Mehmet Ali ÖNAL
1974
Denizli
Turkish
Nazlı MERT
30735/22
Gümüş v. Türkiye
01/06/2022
Ercan GÜMÜŞ
1974
Elazığ
Turkish
Lale KULA ÇELİK
33635/22
Ekelik v. Türkiye
30/06/2022
Tahir EKELİK
1977
Denizli
Turkish
Kadir KURUCU
33993/22
Aslan v. Türkiye
28/06/2022
Mehmet ASLAN
1984
Şanlıurfa
Turkish
Hatice ÖZ
34088/22
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
27/06/2022
Nurullah Ömer YILMAZ
1988
Sinop
Turkish
Ünver ÖZGÜL
34264/22
Bozdemir v. Türkiye
23/06/2022
Mehmet Sait BOZDEMİR
1990
Balıkesir
Turkish
Seranur ÖZMEN
34928/22
Cabir v. Türkiye
30/06/2022
Hamdi Murat CABİR
1983
Manisa
Turkish
Bahattin ÖZDEMİR
36027/22
Erbaş v. Türkiye
29/06/2022
Mustafa ERBAŞ
1973
Ankara
Turkish
Sultan PENEZ ABAY
36627/22
Akkurt v. Türkiye
08/07/2022
Cengiz AKKURT
1976
Aksaray
Turkish
Bülent Teoman ÖZKAN
37168/22
Alçiçek v. Türkiye
06/07/2022
Ertan ALÇİÇEK
1990
Ankara
Turkish
Mustafa Alper ORAL
37728/22
Aksoy v. Türkiye
25/07/2022
Emre AKSOY
1979
Ankara
Turkish
Bülent Teoman ÖZKAN
37974/22
Okut v. Türkiye
07/07/2022
Ali OKUT
1983
Denizli
Turkish
Safiye OKUT
37987/22
Güngördü v. Türkiye
08/07/2022
Melike Kevser GÜNGÖRDÜ
1988
Nazlı MERT
38286/22
Oran v. Türkiye
08/07/2022
Ökkeş ORAN
1988
Osmaniye
Turkish
Armağan ORAN
38671/22
Darıcı v. Türkiye
25/07/2022
Akif DARICI
1979
Aksaray
Turkish
Bülent Teoman ÖZKAN
38815/22
Yolcu v. Türkiye
21/06/2022
Gülbey YOLCU
1973
Eskişehir
Turkish
Ömer Tarık ORMANCI
38970/22
Gendihal v. Türkiye
13/07/2022
Hüseyin GENDİHAL
1978
Giresun
Turkish
Meral ÖZATA ÖZGÜROL
39045/22
İsen v. Türkiye
19/07/2022
Mehmet İSEN
1979
Elazığ
Turkish
Ahmet ÖZCAN
39127/22
Kaplan v. Türkiye
26/07/2022
Osman KAPLAN
1968
Istanbul
Turkish
Orçun MUŞLU
39469/22
Karagöl v. Türkiye
12/08/2022
Süheyla KARAGÖL
1990
İzmir
Turkish
Selman Senih KÖSE
40515/22
Sultan v. Türkiye
09/08/2022
Mehmet Uğur SULTAN
1977
Kocaeli
Turkish
Sinem KURAL
41073/22
Bostan v. Türkiye
29/07/2022
Ahmet BOSTAN
1991
Dordrecht
Turkish
Gülnaz POYRAZ GÖKAYAZ
41233/22
Aydın v. Türkiye
05/08/2022
Selim AYDIN
1973
Aksaray
Turkish
Susam MERDAN
41266/22
Ümit v. Türkiye
05/08/2022
Necip ÜMİT
1976
İzmir
Turkish
Ozan ÖZÖKSEL
42155/22
Baktır v. Türkiye
17/08/2022
Hüseyin BAKTIR
1991
Eskişehir
Turkish
Ömer Tarık ORMANCI
42187/22
Sarısakal v. Türkiye
12/08/2022
Ramazan SARISAKAL
1987
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Muhammed Murat POYRAZ
42275/22
Taşıyan v. Türkiye
17/08/2022
Emre TAŞIYAN
1990
Çorum
Turkish
Enes Burak ÖZDEMİR
42506/22
Haliloğlu v. Türkiye
19/08/2022
Nurten HALİLOĞLU
1984
Trabzon
Turkish
Eda PEHLEVAN
43609/22
Orasan v. Türkiye
20/08/2022
Bülent ORASAN
1990
Aydın
Turkish
Orçun MUŞLU
43646/22
Kepenek v. Türkiye
20/08/2022
Memnune KEPENEK
1979
Aydın
Turkish
Orçun MUŞLU
43749/22
Seba v. Türkiye
31/08/2022
Rıdvan SEBA
1993
Istanbul
Turkish
Yavuz KOLBOYU
43914/22
Ersoy v. Türkiye
02/09/2022
Mehmet Akif ERSOY
1989
Konya
Turkish
Fatma Zehra ÖZDİPİ
44299/22
Koç v. Türkiye
31/08/2022
Zehra KOÇ
1990
Sivas
Turkish
Hakan ÖNER
44301/22
Doğanlı v. Türkiye
29/08/2022
Mustafa DOĞANLI
1979
İzmir
Turkish
Tarık ÖZYER
44697/22
Çolak v. Türkiye
01/09/2022
Melike Esra ÇOLAK
1978
Kastamonu
Turkish
Mesut ÖZTÜRK
44750/22
Çolak v. Türkiye
01/09/2022
İsmail ÇOLAK
1978
Kastamonu
Turkish
Mesut ÖZTÜRK
44753/22
Korkmaz v. Türkiye
05/09/2022
Esma KORKMAZ
1983
Bönen
Turkish
İlyas KORKMAZ
44797/22
Kara v. Türkiye
05/09/2022
Mustafa KARA
1976
Samsun
Turkish
Ayşenur ÖZDEMİR
46580/22
Oğuz v. Türkiye
26/09/2022
Nail OĞUZ
1963
Denizli
Turkish
Süha OĞUZ İŞLER
47895/22
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
28/09/2022
Nihat YILMAZ
1973
Bolu
Turkish
Fatma ÖZTÜRK
353/23
Çetinkaya v. Türkiye
13/12/2022
Uğur ÇETİNKAYA
1987
Muğla
Turkish
Mehmet MİRZA
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy