SECOND SECTION
DECISION
Application no. 9977/08
Anıl KARADEMİR and others against Turkey
and 165 other applications
(see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (Second Section), sitting on 5 November 2013 as a Committee composed of:
Peer Lorenzen, President,
András Sajó,
Nebojša Vučinić, judges,
and Seçkin Erel, Acting Deputy Section Registrar,
Having regard to the above applications lodged on the dates indicated in the annex,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
THE FACTS
A. The circumstances of the cases
The facts of the cases, as submitted by the applicants whose names are listed in the appendix, may be summarised as follows.
On different dates, the applicants initiated actions before various courts or had civil, administrative or criminal proceedings brought against them. All proceedings lasted several years.
B. Relevant domestic law
A description of the relevant domestic law may be found in Müdür Turgut and others v. Turkey ((dec.), no 4860/09, §§ 19-26, 26 March 2013).
COMPLAINTS
The applicants complained under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention that the proceedings before the national courts had not been concluded within a reasonable time.
Some of the applicants raised other complaints, particularly under Articles 5, 6, 8, 13 and 14 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol no. 1. These complaints are linked to the same proceedings which they complain about the excessive length.
THE LAW
I. JOINDER OF THE APPLICATIONS
The Court considers that, pursuant to Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court, the applications should be joined, given their similar factual and legal backgrounds.
II. ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 6 § 1 OF THE CONVENTION
All the applicants complained that the length of the relevant proceedings before national tribunals were excessive and thus fell short of the requirements of Article 6 § 1, which provides:
“1. In the determination of his civil rights and obligations or of any criminal charge against him, everyone is entitled to a (...) hearing within a reasonable time (...) by a tribunal (...)”
The Court observes that the applicants considered the length of the proceedings in question to be incompatible with the requirement of “reasonable time” laid down in Article 6 § 1 of the Convention.
In that respect, the Court found in its decision Müdür Turgut and others (cited above, § 56) that the Compensation Commission established by Law no. 6384, insofar as it is accessible and capable of offering reasonable prospects of redress for complaints concerning the length of proceedings, constituted a remedy which applicants were required to exhaust for the purposes of Article 35 § 1 of the Convention.
In the present cases, the Court sees no reason to come to a different conclusion.
It follows that these complaints must be rejected under Article 35 §§ 1 and 4 of the Convention for non-exhaustion of domestic remedies.
III. OTHER ALLEGED VIOLATIONS OF THE CONVENTION
Relying on various Articles of the Convention or its Protocols, the applicants also presented some other complaints.
Having examined the applicants’ complaints in the light of all the material in its possession, and insofar as the matters complained of are within its competence, the Court finds that they do not disclose any appearance of a violation of the rights and freedoms set out in the Convention or its Protocols.
It follows that these parts of the present applications are manifestly ill‑founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 and 4 of the Convention.
For these reasons, the Court unanimously
Decides to join the applications;
Declares the applications inadmissible.
Seçkin ErelPeer Lorenzen
Acting Deputy RegistrarPresident
Appendix
No
Application No
Lodged on
Applicant
Date of birth
Place of residence
Represented by
9977/08
26/02/2008
Anıl KARADEMİR
01/01/1971
Erzin
Mehmet OCAK
01/01/1957
Hatay
Mustafa GÖRGEL
01/01/1970
Hatay
Alaaddin AYHAN
01/01/1970
Hatay
Yusuf OCAK
01/01/1969
Hatay
Vaysal ŞİMŞEK
01/01/1964
Hatay
Lütfi DÖNMEZ
01/01/1964
Hatay
Yılmaz KAYAR
01/01/1977
Hatay
Bülent KAYAR
01/01/1974
Hatay
Metin DİKİCİOĞLU
01/01/1963
Hatay
Ahmet DAĞLI
01/01/1959
Hatay
Bünyamin GÖKDOĞAN
01/01/1971
Hatay
Bestami KAYA
01/01/1968
Hatay
Ali KARACA
21/12/1962
Hatay
Mehmet KELEŞ
01/01/1957
Hatay
Hurşit AVCI
01/01/1967
Hatay
Mustafa KAYA
01/01/1965
Hatay
Turan ÜLGER
01/01/1962
Hatay
Mehmet CİHAT
01/01/1966
Hatay
Mehmet AVCI
01/01/1970
Hatay
Cemal ARPAY
01/01/1960
Hatay
Ali ÇAPAROGLU
01/01/1967
Hatay
Murat OKUR
01/01/1972
Hatay
Ercihan KAMBUR
01/01/1960
Hatay
Abdullah AŞIK
01/01/1968
Hatay
Halis KALI
01/01/1959
Hatay
Ömer DURMUŞ
01/01/1971
Hatay
Sedat ÇİNGİL
01/01/1972
Hatay
Hayri GÜLMEN
01/01/1966
Hatay
Bilal USTA
01/01/1963
Hatay
Şemsettin LEK
01/01/1959
Hatay
Metin REÇBER
01/01/1966
Hatay
Selahattin ÖZASLAN
02/04/1966
Hatay
Hasan ŞAHİN
01/01/1964
Hatay
Hurşit ORMAN
01/01/1973
Hatay
Osman KURT
01/01/1972
Hatay
Reşit YIRTICI
01/01/1966
Hatay
Ali KÜLTÜR
01/01/1974
Hatay
Mehmet Şerif KOÇ
01/01/1966
Hatay
Mustafa DEMİR
01/01/1970
Hatay
Bedi USLU
01/01/1967
Hatay
Kadir GÜNAY
01/01/1975
Hatay
Cafer YEŞİL
01/01/1964
Hatay
Yahya KÜRKÇÜ
01/01/1974
Hatay
İshak NAL
01/01/1969
Hatay
Erol GÖDEN
01/01/1966
Hatay
Halil ŞİMŞEK
01/01/1965
Hatay
Erdal UZGAŞ
01/01/1971
Hatay
Necmettin BERKER
01/01/1961
Hatay
Kazım TABAK
01/01/1963
Hatay
Fadıl TEKELİ
01/01/1970
Hatay
Kemal KARACA
01/01/1971
Hatay
Şirzat GÜLLER
01/01/1961
Hatay
Musa
KILIÇASLAN
01/01/1969
Hatay
Serdal KARTAL
01/01/1960
Hatay
Kemal UZGAŞ
01/01/1967
Hatay
Sami ORDULUOĞLU
01/01/1967
Hatay
Hasan KIRAÇ
01/01/1967
Hatay
Osman Nuri KINALI
01/01/1967
Hatay
Hasan GAYIR
01/01/1965
Hatay
Yılgör KORKMAZ
01/01/1960
Hatay
İsmail BAŞAR
17538/08
02/04/2008
Hülya ERDEM
01/03/1965
Bursa
Günsel DEDE
43225/09
03/08/2009
Mustafa GÜRBÜZ
16/04/1931
Ankara
Zehra GÜRBÜZ ÖNAL
48885/09
04/09/2009
Özkan GÜNDÜZ
19/07/1981
İstanbul
49129/09
02/09/2009
Metin SAYGIN
05/07/1981
İstanbul
Çelik HASAN
25/02/1982
İstanbul
Şengül İLKAY
24/04/1984
İstanbul
Nergis ÜMİT
24/10/1983
İstanbul
Kazım Erkut GÜZEL
52513/09
07/09/2009
Necdet KUTOĞLU
02/06/1963
Zonguldak
53791/09
29/05/2009
Cemil AKKAYA
05/05/1964
Ankara
Gökçal Çetin EKŞİOĞLU
58474/09
23/10/2009
Metin KONDAKÇI
04/04/1957
İstanbul
İsmail Deniz GÖKKILIÇ
58871/09
23/10/2009
Nazım KULALI
12/06/1940
İstanbul
Hayati ŞAHİN
26981/10
26/04/2010
Fikri ER
01/07/1977
Ankara
26982/10
26/04/2010
Fikri ER
01/07/1977
Ankara
26983/10
26/04/2010
Fikri ER
01/07/1977
Ankara
26984/10
26/04/2010
Fikri ER
01/07/1977
Ankara
64890/10
09/10/2010
Ahmet ÖZDEMİR
05/12/1946
Ankara
ÖZLER YAPI İNŞAAT SANAYİ TİCARET LİMİTED ŞİRKETİ
Muş
4099/11
30/12/2010
İsmail NAZLIOĞLU
03/12/1967
Edirne
40463/11
29/03/2011
İsa KAYA
01/06/1938
Şanlıurfa
Nabi ÖZALP
40532/11
28/03/2011
Hakkı TALAŞLI
01/11/1974
Bitlis
Mehmet ERBİL
40627/11
03/03/2011
Güner GÜNDÜZ
24/05/1952
Elazığ
Aziz DİNÇ
42177/11
05/07/2011
İLKAY BALIKÇILIK TURİZM SANAYİ TİCARET A.Ş
Diyarbakır
Zeki UÇAR
42194/11
11/01/2011
Hasan DEMİREL
24/03/1943
Marmaris
Meral ÖNDERSEV
43267/11
09/06/2011
Bayram BAYAR
05/05/1972
Antalya
43444/11
09/07/2011
Samime SANAY
21/10/1940
İstanbul
Mehmet Semih GEMALMAZ
43709/11
22/06/2011
Hüsamettin GÖZÜAÇIK
24/02/1975
Antalya
Ayten ÜNAL
44640/11
27/06/2011
Mustafa YILMAZ
15/02/1939
Antalya
45859/11
24/05/2011
Yusuf ÖZER
15/12/1963
İzmir
Cem ALTIPARMAK
45868/11
20/06/2011
Ekrem YAMAL
02/11/0972
Diyarbakır
Arzu PAMUKÇU YÖRDEM
46281/11
17/06/2011
Faik CEBEL
24/03/1969
İzmir
Mehmet Nur TERZİ
46710/11
29/06/2011
Şadi BAYRAMOĞLU
10/07/1940
İstanbul
46853/11
08/07/2011
Mehmet Nesim KAR
01/01/1976
Şırnak
Mehmet Zeki ERGİN
03/02/1977
Istanbul
Mirhan ÖZBEKLİ
47482/11
02/06/2011
Necmi VAROL
01/01/1974
Şanlıurfa
Nabi ÖZALP
47574/11
20/06/2011
Basri YERKAZAN
05/01/1938
Elazığ
Feride KAVAKLI
01/07/1926
Elazığ
Sabriye ULUCAN
01/07/1929
Elazığ
Niyazi Nezir YERKAZAN
01/01/1944
Elazığ
Semedin YERKAZAN
05/03/1950
Elazığ
Halise YERKAZAN
18/03/1954
Elazığ
Hane YERKAZAN
15/03/1975
Giresun
Hasan YERKAZAN
05/03/1979
Erzurum
47735/11
02/06/2011
Cevat Ferruh KATRANCIGİL
01/01/1925
Istanbul
47786/11
03/05/2011
Raziye ERTEM
16/08/1970
Ankara
Tansu BATUR
47798/11
15/06/2011
Fettah BİTİRGİÇ
03/12/1973
Kocaeli
47930/11
25/04/2011
Mehmet YILMAZ
01/01/1956
Diyarbakır
Mustafa Günşat AKSU
48171/11
02/07/2011
Ahmet Nuri DEMİRSOY
03/07/1945
Kassel
Hakan ÜZENLİ
48257/11
02/06/2011
Harun YILDIZKÜÇÜK
24/01/1962
Hatay
Maruf KAYMAZ
48284/11
20/12/2010
Seyfi KARAARSLAN
13/07/1948
Zonguldak
Ergin KAYA
48391/11
13/05/2011
Mahmut DELİ
09/12/1947
Antakya
Ali DAĞ
48593/11
02/05/2011
Yusuf Vehbi OCAK
23/01/1955
Şanlıurfa
Ali Rıza GERGER
01/12/1955
Şanlıurfa
Ramazan UYAR
11/11/1968
Antalya
Müslüm Cengizhan AKALIN
48597/11
09/04/2011
Radife SON
01/01/1961
Aydın
Şebnem TOKAT
48614/11
11/04/2011
Özgür ŞAHİN
25/05/1971
Kocaeli
Kureyş BİLGİÇ
48616/11
10/01/2011
Kerim TANIR
17/04/1955
Ulm
48763/11
27/04/2011
Şükrü KARAHASANOĞLU
01/02/1947
İstanbul
Eyüp ERASLAN
48943/11
22/03/2011
Tekin KARAKÜLAH
22/02/1977
Aksaray
Beytullah COŞKUN
49023/11
08/04/2011
İbrahim AYKAÇ
30/07/1959
Balıkesir
Şerif TOPUZ
49271/11
15/05/2011
Kamuran MALGİL
15/06/1937
Istanbul
Ahmet Cumhur MALGİL
29/10/1963
Istanbul
Zekiye Gülnur DALKILIÇ
12/07/1967
Istanbul
Sabiha ÇAM
05/03/1938
Istanbul
Gülçin ÇAM
13/06/1968
Istanbul
Neslihan ÇAM
08/08/1974
Istanbul
Hüseyin AYDIN
49330/11
12/05/2011
Halil KUT 01/11/1943
Mardin
Hüsnü KUT
01/01/1937
Mardin
Ziver KUT
07/02/1959
Mardin
Süleyman DEMİR
06/04/1964
Mardin
Nezir KUT
14/02/1960
Mardin
Suphiye METE
01/05/1948
İzmir
Müşerref KAYA
18/02/1986
Mardin
Şerafettin KUT
25/03/1980
Mardin
Semire KARAKOYUN
01/01/1965
Adana
Mizgin AKMEŞE
02/03/1976
Mardin
Kasım KURT
25/10/1936
Mardin
Hamdiye BAYSAL
01/01/1940
İzmir
Ferhat KUT
01/03/1974
Mardin
Şener KUT
10/07/1984
Mardin
Mehmet Salih ALİOĞLU
03/12/1949
Mardin
Fahriye ORAL
01/01/1953
Mersin
Gülistan TAŞ
01/01/1980
Mardin
Lema DENİZ
01/01/1966
Mardin
Mustafa KUT
01/01/1976
Muğla
Abdurrahim KUT
01/07/1966
Mardin
Azat KUT
02/12/1975
Mardin
Abdülselam KUT
01/02/1969
Mardin
Nezehat KUT
01/05/1959
Mardin
Yusuf KUT
01/01/1964
Mersin
Pale KUT
01/01/1991
Mardin
Mehmet Hatip KUT
25/08/1986
Mardin
Yazgı ÇİMEN FİDAN
49557/11
29/12/2010
Halil LİMON
13/03/1938
Antalya
Ayşe ŞEN
12/02/1940
Antalya
Hatice BALAMAN
08/02/1944
Antalya
Emine LİMON
10/01/1947
Antalya
Levent ERCAN
50186/11
08/06/2011
Hasan ÖZÇELİK
07/08/1949
Ankara
Hakkı Oğulcan ÖZÇELİK
05/10/1990
Ankara
Gökçal Çetin EKŞİOĞLU
50620/11
23/03/2011
Şevket ERTÜRK
12/09/1938
Kocaeli
Saide ARSLAN ÇALIŞKAN
50678/11
08/07/2011
Mehmet ÇALIŞKAN
12/11/1933
Aydın
Mustafa GÜVENÇ
16/12/1931
Aydın
Serkan CENGİZ
51231/11
14/07/2011
Mehmet DEVELİ
01/01/1989
Van
Kerem AKDOĞAN
51472/11
25/03/2011
Sinan YILMAZ
14/10/1984
Istanbul
Nesrin KARAGÖZ KARATEPE
51500/11
04/04/2011
Suat ÖZBAL
01/01/1965
İzmir
Türkan ASLAN
51512/11
03/05/2011
Eyyüp EROL
01/01/1962
Mardin
Yılmaz FİDAN
51519/11
25/05/2011
Hüseyin SEZEN
24/07/1968
Samsun
Mesut BEDİRHANOĞLU
51527/11
11/04/2011
Mahfuz DEMİR
01/02/1959
Erzurum
Celal DEMİR
19/03/1952
Erzurum
Ahmet DEMİR
07/06/1956
Erzurum
Ömer KURT
51528/11
11/04/2011
Mahfuz DEMİR
01/02/1959
Erzurum
Celal DEMİR
19/03/1952
Erzurum
Ahmet DEMİR
07/06/1956
Erzurum
Ömer KURT
51529/11
11/04/2011
Mahfuz DEMİR
01/02/1959
Erzurum
Celal DEMİR
19/03/1952
Erzurum
Ahmet DEMİR
07/06/1956
Erzurum
Ömer KURT
51530/11
11/04/2011
Mahfuz DEMİR
01/02/1959
Erzurum
Celal DEMİR
19/03/1952
Erzurum
Ahmet DEMİR
07/06/1956
Erzurum
Ömer KURT
52417/11
27/07/2011
Köksal DENİZ
31/07/1965
Ankara
Haluk PEKŞEN
52418/11
27/07/2011
Etem UZUNAY
15/03/1957
Istanbul
52419/11
27/07/2011
Şeref KOCAMAN
17/06/1960
Ankara
Haluk PEKŞEN
52745/11
13/07/2011
Mehmet SAVCI
Mardin
Zeynep HAZAR
Mardin
Zübeyde SAVCI
Mardin
Zahra DÜZGÖREN
Mardin
Selahattin HAZAR
Mardin
Mustafa HAZAR
Mardin
Meryem KORHAN
Mardin
İbrahim SAVCI
Mardin
Mahsun HAZAR
Mardin
Hıdır SAVCI
10/08/1969
Mardin
Fatma DÜZGÖREN
Mardin
Hatice TALAYHAN
Mardin
Fatma HAZAR
Mardin
Emine İLBOĞA
Mardin
Ayşe HAZAR
04/02/1964
Mardin
Ahmet HAZAR
Mardin
Ahmet SAVCI
Mardin
Abdürrezak HAZAR
01/02/1963
Mardin
Abdulvahit HAZAR
Mardin
Zeynep HAZAR
Mardin
İnci Fidan AYDEMİR
52791/11
07/06/2011
Fatih ÖZEL
01/01/1974
Adana
Hüseyin ÖZVEREN
53041/11
15/07/2011
Şeyhmus AKSOY
03/03/1960
Derik
Metin AKSOY
03/03/1974
Derik
Reşat AKSOY
06/07/1944
Derik
Bülent AKSOY
03/05/1974
Derik
Yaşar AKSOY
05/02/1970
Derik
Serdar AKSOY
20/10/1989
Derik
Filiz AKSOY
01/06/1972
Derik
Sinan AKSOY
20/01/1988
Derik
53209/11
05/07/2011
Candan KOZANLI
01/01/1965
Çanakkale
Ceyda AKKAŞ DEMİRCİ
53231/11
29/06/2011
Hamza ÇİFTÇİ
01/01/1952
Aksaray
Beytullah COŞKUN
53257/11
08/06/2011
Sevil ADA
23/03/1955
İstanbul
Faruk ÖKSÜZ
53820/11
20/05/2011
ALTUNTAS KÖYÜ VE AŞAĞI KÖY MUHTARLIĞI
Malatya
Mehmet GÖRGEÇ
54560/11
08/07/2011
Yücel MANDACI
01/01/1940
Çanakkale
Hasan Erokay MANDACI
54786/11
19/08/2011
Hasan Turan YETİM
13/02/1962
Istanbul
Eyüp ERASLAN
54793/11
06/07/2011
Gökhan ARSLANTÜRK
29/09/1972
Ankara
Yılmaz İÇÖZ
54795/11
23/06/2011
Abbas BAYIR
01/03/1965
Istanbul
54796/11
20/06/2011
Ahmet ÜÇEK
20/04/1978
Istanbul
Yusuf EYCAN
54801/11
15/07/2011
Taner KANDEMİR
16/09/1949
Istanbul
Ömer ÖNEREN
55497/11
17/06/2011
Osman AKTAŞ
10/04/1966
Sivas
Mirhan ÖZBEKLİ
55693/11
01/08/2011
Serhat ŞAŞOĞLU
21/03/1961
İzmir
Sevgi DEMİRTAŞ
55879/11
30/06/2011
Mustafa NAZLIER
26/09/1969
İzmir
İlkay PALA ÖGE
56164/11
12/05/2011
Metin TUNCEL
08/04/1933
Istanbul
Eyüp ERASLAN
56995/11
12/07/2011
Gülten DEMİRHAN
20/10/1954
Ankara
Z. Cem DEMİRHAN
57296/11
05/08/2011
Selman AYDIN
01/01/1978
Istanbul
Hüseyin ÇALİŞCİ
57471/11
01/07/2011
Yusuf ÇİÇEK
11/05/1965
Viyana
Figen OPAK ÇİÇEK
57594/11
25/06/2011
Tuncay KARAKAŞ
18/03/1975
Bursa
Nigar YILMAZ
57596/11
27/06/2011
Salih BEKTAŞ
15/03/1960
Freudenstadt
58011/11
05/08/2011
Mehmet Ali ÇELİK
13/10/1977
Şanlıurfa
İlyas BARAN
58568/11
08/08/2011
Vahit COŞAR
10/05/1964
Amasya
Makbule ÖZER ARPAĞ
58936/11
11/07/2011
Ahmet EKİNCİ
12/02/1972
Diyarbakır
58943/11
25/08/2011
Özen NURAY
17/10/1960
Muğla
Selçuk KURT
59979/11
25/07/2011
Salih ASLAN
05/04/1971
Şanlıurfa
İlyas BARAN
60059/11
22/07/2011
Kerim CİCİ
21/05/1938
Bingöl
Mustafa ALPTEKİN
60558/11
24/08/2011
Adnan HALİS
01/01/1952
Hendek
Erol ARIKAN
01/01/1962
Gönen
Esral KARAGÖZ
30/01/1961
Istanbul
Fazıl Ahmet TAMER
11/08/1966
Istanbul
Volkan KARTAL
01/01/1977
Istanbul
Kemal TUFAN
01/01/1967
Istanbul
Erol KAPLAN
01/01/1967
Istanbul
Hikmet KALE
08/12/1970
Tekirdağ
Mehmet ÇİFTÇİ
01/10/1952
Edirne
Mehmet GÖKTAŞ
01/01/1966
Tunceli
Mehmet BOZTEPE
01/01/1968
Malatya
Hacı Aziz HUN
01/01/1965
Samsun
Dinçer OTLUÇİMEN
01/01/1976
Istanbul
Yılmaz YİĞİT
01/01/1976
Istanbul
Bülent YİĞİT
01/01/1977
Istanbul
Cem ŞAHİN
01/01/1976
Istanbul
Gülizar TUNCER
60943/11
14/09/2011
Nuran ÖZDEMİR
01/10/1961
Ankara
Ömer ÜNLÜ
60986/11
07/06/2011
Memnune KARAKULAK
04/01/1961
Istanbul
61290/11
11/08/2011
İmam AYDIN
01/01/1977
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
62408/11
27/07/2011
İhsan KÖRPE
07/12/1986
Siirt
62442/11
24/08/2011
Özgür SAĞLAM
01/01/1981
Istanbul
Cengiz KARAKAŞ
17/04/1978
Tekirdağ
Vedat ÇELİK
01/01/1981
Istanbul
Several BALLIKAYA
62655/11
20/09/2011
Atilla GÜRDER
02/01/1947
Ankara
İlhan BİÇER
63115/11
21/09/2011
Babur Nuri KILIÇ
01/01/1960
Istanbul
Ergin CİNMEN
63129/11
21/09/2011
Yücel KÜRKLÜ
01/01/1945
Istanbul
Ergin CİNMEN
63135/11
21/09/2011
Didem ERGİN
21/07/1975
Istanbul
Ergin CİNMEN
63138/11
21/09/2011
Gülgün TREN
14/06/1948
Istanbul
Ergin CİNMEN
63163/11
21/09/2011
Abdülkadir SAĞER
28/02/1958
Istanbul
Ergin CİNMEN
63167/11
21/09/2011
Nuriye ÖSER
03/02/1934
Istanbul
Ergin CİNMEN
63169/11
21/09/2011
Ayfer Ahu ÇAKIR
25/12/1954
Ankara
Ergin CİNMEN
63173/11
21/09/2011
Savaş Ahmet BUĞRA
11/01/1965
Amasra
Ergin CİNMEN
63176/11
21/09/2011
Sevgi ILGAZ
27/12/1942
Eskişehir
Ergin CİNMEN
63186/11
21/09/2011
Özcan EMEK
01/11/1944
Sakarya
Ergin CİNMEN
63190/11
29/08/2011
Bircan KAYSUN
20/12/1965
Ankara
Özcan GÜÇLÜ
24/05/1964
Ankara
Gürcan GÜÇLÜ
22/03/1970
Ankara
Nevin ÖZKAN
63191/11
21/09/2011
Timur Ahmet KILIÇ
01/01/1959
Istanbul
Ergin CİNMEN
63198/11
21/09/2011
Cengiz Mehmet KILIÇ
01/01/1957
Istanbul
Ergin CİNMEN
63213/11
21/09/2011
Saliha Solmaz ÖĞET
06/10/1931
Istanbul
Ergin CİNMEN
68064/11
26/09/2011
Bekir ARPA
10/03/1935
Diyarbakır
Fırat ÜGER
70415/11
04/10/2011
Hakkı AKBAŞ
29/06/1966
İzmir
Yüksel KAVAK KILINÇ
72974/11
31/10/2011
Ahmet ÇELEBİ
01/01/1945
Istanbul
Cem ALPTEKİN
74392/11
10/10/2011
Ersin ÖZŞEN
04/05/1973
Istanbul
Haluk PEKŞEN
76763/11
23/11/2011
Süleyman SARIBOĞA
01/08/1951
Aydın
Gül SÖZEN
7527/12
29/11/2011
Nurettin BORAN
10/03/1962
Ankara
9725/12
25/01/2012
Ahmet BESER
12/05/1962
Istanbul
Ahmet Ersin BAZMANOĞLU
17/08/1950
Istanbul
HİDRO-MAK DAMPER VE HİDROLİK MAKİNALARI SAN. TİC. A.Ş.
Istanbul
Eyüp ERASLAN
10037/12
23/12/2011
Yıldız İMREK
15/11/1964
Istanbul
Semir KARADAŞ
10325/12
14/12/2011
Aziz ÖZDEMİR
01/01/1957
Adana
Sinan TUMLUKOLÇU
13479/12
06/01/2012
Melek ORHAN
15/06/1949
Muğla
Şuayip ORHAN
11/11/1967
Muğla
Naciye CEYLAN
13714/12
13/02/2012
Ahmet KIZIL
01/07/1941
Adıyaman
Mustafa YAVUZ
13730/12
27/01/2012
Mustafa YILMAZ
30/03/1953
Sakarya
Nadir KURTDERE
14538/12
23/02/2012
Necati ÇALIŞKAN
29/08/1959
İzmir
Barış KAŞKA
14539/12
23/02/2012
Halime DALMIŞ
09/11/1964
İzmir
Barış KAŞKA
14540/12
23/02/2012
Birsen ÜLKÜ
20/10/1969
İzmir
Barış KAŞKA
15079/12
24/01/2012
Mehmet Nuri KARAKAYA
10/02/1976
Kırklareli
16379/12
03/02/2012
Mithat CABA
19/07/1954
Amasya
Kasım ER
16385/12
20/02/2012
Süleyman ERDEM
01/01/1968
Istanbul
Baran DOĞAN
16439/12
10/02/2012
Sabit DURMUŞ
10/07/1951
İskenderun
16452/12
23/02/2012
Ali Sait BULUT
09/08/1966
Istanbul
Şefik KARAKIŞ
16532/12
22/02/2012
Fuat ÇETİNKAYA
01/01/1964
Şanlıurfa
Fatma TAVAŞ
01/01/1966
Şanlıurfa
Ayşe ÇETİNTAŞ
03/03/1981
Şanlıurfa
Abdullah ÇETİNKAYA
02/04/1985
Şanlıurfa
Hasan ÇETİNKAYA
01/04/1980
Şanlıurfa
Osman ÇETİNKAYA
01/01/1959
Şanlıurfa
Hüseyin ÇETİNKAYA
01/01/1978
Aydın
Saliha ÇETİNKAYA
01/03/1940
Şanlıurfa
Muhammet ÇETİNKAYA
10/01/1977
Şanlıurfa
Mustafa YAVUZ
16569/12
23/02/2012
Bedriye AZEMOĞLU
22/02/1981
Şanlıurfa
Şükran YILMAZER
22/02/1974
Şanlıurfa
Hasan BALTACI
22/02/1979
Şanlıurfa
Cengiz BALTACI
22/04/1973
Şanlıurfa
Sedat BALTACI
22/02/1986
Şanlıurfa
Kadriye YILDIZ
22/02/1977
Şanlıurfa
Mustafa YAVUZ
18143/12
16/02/2012
Asiye FARAÇ
01/01/1971
Şanlıurfa
Eyüp AVCI
01/07/1949
Şanlıurfa
Ziya AVCI
01/01/1969
Şanlıurfa
Binevş İNCE
02/03/1946
Şanlıurfa
Mehmet AVCI
08/05/1947
Şanlıurfa
Fatma AVCI
01/01/1945
Şanlıurfa
Emine AKMAN
04/06/1953
Şanlıurfa
Mustafa YAVUZ
19659/12
09/06/2011
Hikmet GAYIP
01/05/1965
Istanbul
19747/12
07/06/2011
Azmi GÜNGÖR
19/04/1960
Istanbul
21064/12
22/02/2012
Murtaza ANSEN
13/09/1951
İzmir
Kubilay İstemi ERGÜN
26141/12
06/04/2012
Sebahattin YALÇIN
05/04/1967
Eskişehir
27087/12
13/03/2012
Fikret ESMEROĞLU
01/01/1948
Şanlıurfa
Lütfü POLAT
27348/12
30/03/2012
Tahir Nafiz ÖZKUL
01/08/1949
Denizli
27373/12
05/04/2012
Arif ÖTLEŞ
21/05/1983
Ankara
Nuran ÖZDEMİR
29252/12
02/04/2012
Bilal ÇETİNER
03/02/1974
Gümüşhane
48753/12
03/06/2012
Mehmet GÜNGÖR
01/01/1965
Şanlıurfa
Mehmet KIRBOĞA
49490/12
04/06/2012
Sevil KARABURÇAK
10/03/1952
Muğla
51150/12
14/06/2012
Filiz GÜMELİ
06/06/1960
İzmir
Sevim ÇAM (LAPÇİN)
04/07/1956
İzmir
Günay TÜRK
15/03/1960
İzmir
Turgay TÜRK
24/09/1958
İzmir
Güney DİNÇ
54588/12
18/06/2012
Hamdi GÜNGÖR
01/05/1976
Manisa
Mustafa ROLLAS
56073/12
25/06/2012
Hatice Semra BAŞTÜRK
03/08/1957
İzmir
Havva Zülal KARATÜFEK
15/10/1955
İzmir
Fatma Nihal ISPARTA
30/11/1964
İzmir
Sümeyra ÜNLÜ ÇELİK
56283/12
02/07/2012
Halil GEÇKİL
01/01/1961
Şanlıurfa
Ahmet GÜNGÖR
01/01/1962
Şanlıurfa
Deham GÜNGÖR
01/01/1957
Şanlıurfa
İsmail GEÇKİL
01/01/1962
Şanlıurfa
Mehmet KIRBOĞA
56761/12
16/07/2012
Ziya KÖROĞLU
01/01/1967
Antalya
Bekir ASRİ
56922/12
11/06/2012
Ayşan DEMİR
19/02/1962
Batman
Fahrettin DEMİR
01/01/1978
Batman
Abdurrahim DEMİR
01/10/1992
Batman
Sibetullah DEMİR
01/01/1987
Batman
Alaattin DEMİR
10/11/1979
Batman
Muhittin DEMİR
25/09/1983
Batman
Seyhan GÜZEL
01/01/1985
Batman
Ceyhan DEMİR
01/01/1989
Batman
Naif DEMİR
01/01/1960
Batman
Bayram DEMİR
02/02/1962
Batman
Rıfat DEMİR
15/04/1958
Batman
Mehmet Masum ERKEN
62289/12
30/07/2012
Mustafa UÇAR
18/12/1950
Aydın
Adnan ÇUKUR
62535/12
18/11/2011
Güler SÖYLEMEZ (YILMAZ)
01/01/1982
Istanbul
Gülizar TUNCER
62612/12
11/09/2012
Osman GÖKDAL
01/01/1956
Mersin
Erdoğan ATA
63107/12
11/09/2012
Fatma GÖREN
05/05/1927
Istanbul
İlhan GÖREN
01/05/1954
Istanbul
Zahide HASPOLAT
04/10/1949
Istanbul
Sedat HASPOLAT
65432/12
20/09/2012
Yavuz BİLEN
01/06/1975
Istanbul
Osman SALMAN
66487/12
10/09/2012
Atilla GÜRDER
02/01/1947
Ankara
İlhan BİÇER
66508/12
20/09/2012
Halil ŞAHİN
01/01/1968
Sincan
Cengiz KAHRAMAN
15/05/1974
Ankara
Naki DEMİR
01/01/1981
Ankara
Sedat OT
01/01/1975
Ankara
Yaşar İNCE
01/01/1972
Ankara
Deniz TEPELİ
01/01/1977
Ankara
Hakan KARAKUŞ
66603/12
01/09/2012
Sabri TOLUAY
05/04/1928
Bingöl
Türkan KIRMIZITAŞ
67044/12
21/09/2012
Hasan ÖZGE
10/11/1974
Aydın
Ece SOLMAZ
75633/12
21/09/2012
Bülent ÇAN
21/09/1980
Istanbul
Hüseyin ÇALİŞCİ
75761/12
21/09/2012
Mehmet Reşit AKAR
01/01/1975
Istanbul
Hüseyin ÇALİŞCİ
77609/12
09/09/2012
Ahmet ERCİYAŞ
01/01/1961
Diyarbakır
Gülcan KARTAL
32/13
09/11/2012
Yanık SATILMIŞ
08/04/1974
Zonguldak
21323/13
15/03/2013
Şahin ŞAMDAN
01/09/1975
Kocaeli
Saide ARSLAN ÇALIŞKAN
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy