SECOND SECTION
DECISION
Application no. 40869/07
Yadin KARAGÖL against Turkey
and 174 other applications
(see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (Second Section), sitting on 5 November 2013 as a Committee composed of:
Dragoljub Popović, President,
Paulo Pinto de Albuquerque,
Helen Keller, judges,
and Seçkin Erel, Acting Deputy Section Registrar,
Having regard to the 175 applications lodged on the dates indicated in the annex,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
THE FACTS
A. The circumstances of the cases
The facts of the cases, as submitted by the applicants whose names are listed in the appendix, may be summarized as follows.
On different dates, the applicants initiated actions before various courts or had civil, administrative or criminal proceedings brought against them. All proceedings lasted several years.
B. Relevant domestic law
A description of the relevant domestic law may be found in Müdür Turgut and others v. Turkey ((dec.), no 4860/09, §§ 19-26, 26 March 2013).
COMPLAINTS
The applicants complained under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention that the proceedings before the national courts had not been concluded within a reasonable time.
Some of the applicants raised other complaints, particularly under Articles 6, 8, 13 and 14 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol no. 1.
These complaints are linked to the same proceedings which they complain about the excessive length.
THE LAW
I.JOINDER OF THE APPLICATIONS
The Court considers that, pursuant to Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court, the applications should be joined, given their similar factual and legal backgrounds.
II.ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 6 § 1 OF THE CONVENTION
All the applicants complained that the length of the relevant proceedings before national tribunals were excessive and thus fell short of the requirements of Article 6 § 1, which provides:
“1. In the determination of his civil rights and obligations or of any criminal charge against him, everyone is entitled to a (...) hearing within a reasonable time (...) by a tribunal (...)”
The Court observes that the applicants considered the length of the proceedings in question to be incompatible with the requirement of “reasonable time” laid down in Article 6 § 1 of the Convention.
In that respect, the Court found in its decision Müdür Turgut and others (cited above, § 56) that the Compensation Commission established by Law no. 6384, insofar as it is accessible and capable of offering reasonable prospects of redress for complaints concerning the length of proceedings, constituted a remedy which applicants were required to exhaust for the purposes of Article 35 § 1 of the Convention.
In the present cases, the Court sees no reason to come to a different conclusion.
It follows that these complaints must be rejected under Article 35 §§ 1 and 4 of the Convention for non-exhaustion of domestic remedies.
III.OTHER ALLEGED VIOLATIONS OF THE CONVENTION
Relying on various articles of the Convention or its Protocols, the applicants also presented some other complaints.
Having examined the applicants’ complaints in the light of all the material in its possession, and insofar as the matters complained of are within its competence, the Court finds that they do not disclose any appearance of a violation of the rights and freedoms set out in the Convention or its Protocols.
It follows that these parts of the present applications are manifestly ill‑founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 and 4 of the Convention.
For these reasons, the Court unanimously
Decides to join the applications;
Declares the applications inadmissible.
Seçkin ErelDragoljub Popović
Acting Deputy RegistrarPresident
Appendix
No
Application No
Lodged on
Applicant
Date of birth
Place of residence
Represented by
40869/07
10/09/2007
Yadin KARAGÖL
02/03/1961
Kayseri
9976/08
27/02/2008
Sait TANGÖR
01/04/1950
Manisa
İbrahim Halil TANGÖR
23658/08
19/05/2008
Müzeyyen ONGAN
23/06/1945
Istanbul
Mehmet UÇUM
47713/08
26/09/2008
Hüseyin ERTUĞRUL
04/11/1940
Ankara
15833/09
20/02/2009
Kamil Engin ÖZTÜRK
01/01/1950
Istanbul
Gülsevim UZUNLAR
01/01/1941
Istanbul
Ümit ÖZTÜRK
01/01/1952
Istanbul
Eyüp Dursun AYTAÇ
01/01/1949
Istanbul
Şerife KARA
Istanbul
Halil ÜÇLER
01/01/1935
Istanbul
Sinem ÜÇLER
01/01/1990
Istanbul
Hasene ŞEN
01/01/1927
Istanbul
Emine Yüksel TAŞOVA
01/01/1947
Istanbul
Hatice Gülsüm KILIÇARSLAN
01/01/1956
Istanbul
Fatma Zehra ALTINEL
01/01/1949
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali BİLGİLİ
Istanbul
Halit SEZER
01/01/1943
Istanbul
Ömer Lütfi SEZER
01/01/1915
Istanbul
Ayşe KARASU
01/01/1949
Istanbul
Nalan ARAÇ
01/01/1970
Istanbul
Nazan TANK
01/01/1978
Istanbul
Elif KARASU
01/01/1983
Istanbul
Atiye ÜLKÜ
38314/09
01/07/2009
Kani FİDAN
01/01/1962
Samsun
Rahime FİDAN
14/02/1960
Samsun
Orhan FİDAN
25/02/1981
Samsun
Hakan FİDAN
08/01/1985
Samsun
Nurgül FİDAN
30/03/1989
Samsun
Hayrettin AYYILDIZ
05/10/1971
Samsun
Yılmaz ÖZTÜRK
01/12/1969
Samsun
Ali UZUN
22/03/1965
Samsun
57081/10
10/08/2010
Dilif KIRMIZITAŞ
01/07/1924
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
57091/10
10/08/2010
Leyla AKTAŞ
01/08/1948
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
57102/10
10/08/2010
Rıza BOZOOĞLU
01/04/1956
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
57212/10
10/08/2010
Dursun AĞGÜL
15/05/1973
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
57219/10
10/08/2010
Selvi AĞGÜL
06/04/1935
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
57226/10
10/08/2010
Yeter KARATAŞ
02/11/1964
Istanbul
Halil KARATAŞ
01/01/1957
Istanbul
Sabire İÇYER
17/05/1948
Istanbul
Aslı İÇYER
10/04/1973
Istanbul
Seda BOZOOĞLU
10/03/1962
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
58251/10
01/09/2010
Murat PALANGO
01/01/1971
Istanbul
Celal ÖZGÜL
01/01/1961
Tunceli
Paşa AĞGÜL
01/01/1939
Elif COŞAN
01/01/1952
Istanbul
Aydın ÇILGIN
01/01/1966
Istanbul
Gülten ÖNDER
01/01/1960
Istanbul
Haydar TOPUZ
01/01/1951
Istanbul
İbis TOPUZ
01/01/1935
Istanbul
Hıdır ENGİN
01/01/1934
Duisburg
Ani ÇILGIN
01/01/1936
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
12885/11
31/08/2010
Teslim GÜLOĞLU
16/09/1965
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17040/11
10/08/2010
Turan AĞGÜL
01/03/1965
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17041/11
10/08/2010
Ali İhsan AĞGÜL
01/01/1964
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17042/11
10/08/2010
Selvi TOPUZ
01/01/1946
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17043/11
10/08/2010
Celal KIRMIZITAŞ
01/01/1953
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17044/11
10/08/2010
İbrahim KARATAŞ
01/01/1939
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17045/11
10/08/2010
Cahit AKTAŞ
01/01/1954
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17046/11
10/08/2010
Cafer AĞGÜL
01/01/1935
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17047/11
10/08/2010
Alettin BOZTAŞ
01/01/1964
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17048/11
10/08/2010
Ağa LAZIM
01/01/1959
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17049/11
10/08/2010
Zabit KUL
01/01/1951
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17050/11
10/08/2010
Müslüm KIRMIZITAŞ
01/01/1954
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17051/11
10/08/2010
Halit KIRMIZITAŞ
01/01/1947
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17052/11
10/08/2010
Ahmet LAZIM
01/01/1950
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17053/11
10/08/2010
Kenan AĞGÜL
01/01/1966
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17054/11
10/08/2010
Hamu ELMAS
01/01/1935
Tunceli
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17055/11
10/08/2010
Keziban BOZOOĞLU
01/01/1938
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17056/11
10/08/2010
Sait AKTAŞ
01/01/1954
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17057/11
10/08/2010
Teslim KIRMIZITAŞ
01/01/1960
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17058/11
10/08/2010
Cemal BOZOOĞLU
01/01/1956
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17059/11
10/08/2010
Hüseyin GÜNGÖR
01/01/1951
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17060/11
10/08/2010
Seydo BOZOOĞLU
01/01/1949
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17061/11
10/08/2010
Metin BOZOOĞLU
01/01/1952
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17062/11
10/08/2010
Hüseyin BOZTAŞ
01/01/1950
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17063/11
10/08/2010
Özkan KIRMIZITAŞ
01/01/1964
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17064/11
10/08/2010
Kenan BOZOOĞLU
01/01/1952
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17065/11
10/08/2010
Hasan BOZTAŞ
01/01/1954
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17066/11
10/08/2010
Yakup BOZOOĞLU
01/01/1962
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17067/11
10/08/2010
Erdoğan GÜNGÖR
01/01/1961
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17068/11
10/08/2010
Ali BOZTAŞ
01/01/1933
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17069/11
10/08/2010
Saher ELMAS
01/01/1938
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17070/11
10/08/2010
Mazlum BOZTAŞ
01/01/1961
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17071/11
10/08/2010
Ahmet ELMAS
01/01/1955
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17072/11
10/08/2010
İbrahim AĞGÜL
01/01/1968
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17073/11
10/08/2010
Zefi AĞGÜL
01/01/1926
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17074/11
10/08/2010
Kerem ELMAS
01/01/1964
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17075/11
10/08/2010
Haydar AKTAŞ
01/01/1932
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17076/11
10/08/2010
Aziz BOZOOĞLU
01/01/1956
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17077/11
10/08/2010
Aydın ELMAS
01/01/1965
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17078/11
10/08/2010
Abbas AĞGÜL
01/01/1970
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17079/11
10/08/2010
Nuray ELMAS
01/01/1973
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
17080/11
10/08/2010
Emirali BOZOOĞLU
01/01/1958
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
20268/11
10/08/2010
Yusuf KUL
01/01/1958
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
20271/11
10/08/2010
Sabri KIRMIZITAŞ
20/03/1963
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
27320/11
01/03/2011
Rıza ARAT
02/06/1965
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
27321/11
01/03/2011
Süleyman YOM
01/01/1961
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
27322/11
01/03/2011
Rıza ÇUBUK
01/01/1952
Tunceli
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
33852/11
10/08/2010
Cemsi LAZIM
01/01/1962
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
38313/11
26/05/2011
İdris İLHANLI
01/01/1990
Selahattin KAYA
40819/11
22/03/2011
Demet AKKAYA
05/02/1971
Ankara
Bülent AKKAYA
30/08/1959
Ankara
Levent AKKAYA
30/09/1962
Ankara
Perihan AKKAYA
06/05/1942
Ankara
Şengül BİRLEŞTİRİCİ
42508/11
15/02/2011
Fatma YILDIZ
01/01/1962
Aydın
Şebnem TOKAT
48361/11
27/06/2011
Jale MUSLUOĞLU
17/03/1929
Ankara
Hüseyin ÜÇPINAR
01/03/1931
Muğla
Makbule TİRELİ
12/03/1927
Muğla
Hikmet Tülay ÜÇPINAR
04/06/1943
Muğla
Mediha Ebru MERZİFONLU
09/05/1972
Muğla
Levent ÜÇPINAR
13/09/1969
Balıkesir
Ayşe ÜÇPINAR
30/06/1943
Muğla
Ahmet ÜÇPINAR
01/01/1961
Muğla
Aysu KINACI
26/04/1964
Muğla
Şefika ÖZTÜRK
30/07/1940
Muğla
Esat ÖZTÜRK
04/01/1971
Muğla
Önder ÖZTÜRK
01/01/1962
Denizli
Hasan KOCAGÖZ
01/01/1941
Denizli
Bülent ÜÇPINAR
24/04/1963
Muğla
Serkan CENGİZ
48535/11
02/05/2011
Nesrin KEÇE (KARABULUT)
20/01/1957
Ankara
Çağan Mehmet DAYANIR
48578/11
04/05/2011
Sultan Melek TEKİN
03/03/1959
Ankara
Ali İhsan GÜZEL
54840/11
14/07/2011
Fatma Şenay MERİÇ
27/07/1954
İstanbul
59075/11
26/07/2011
2C ENERJİ LTD. ŞTİ
Ankara
Baran ÖZCAN
63010/11
29/08/2011
Ergül YENİCE
15/05/1959
Kırıkkale
Nizamettin ÖZAYDIN
65015/11
27/09/2011
Sabahattin Engin AKKAYA
20/08/1947
Bursa
Gülbahar KARADENİZ
28/09/1942
Zonguldak
Cemal ERTUĞ
01/01/1945
Zonguldak
Ergün BODUR
22/02/1944
Zonguldak
Ahmet BÜK
08/06/1967
Zonguldak
Zeki YÜKSEL
08/11/1948
Zonguldak
Mete ORHAN
07/11/1951
Bartın
66469/11
19/09/2011
Havva AK
31/12/1972
Malatya
Kadir AKGÜNEŞ
66702/11
16/09/2011
Ali ÇAPAL
06/04/1960
Istanbul
69488/11
07/10/2011
Silva BENLİ
01/01/1955
Istanbul
Murat ÇELİK
69957/11
06/10/2011
Yılmaz DOĞAN
01/01/1950
Istanbul
Murat ÇELİK
70350/11
05/10/2011
Yunus KIBIK
05/06/1985
Istanbul
Mehmet AKBAŞ
72302/11
01/03/2011
Dursun EMRE
03/04/1936
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
72306/11
01/03/2011
Ali ÖZTAŞ
18/03/1956
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
72308/11
01/03/2011
Şahsenem CİHAN
01/01/1923
Istanbul
Ahmet CİHAN
01/01/1954
İstanbul
Hanım ŞAHİN
01/01/1957
İstanbul
Sakine ŞAHİN
01/01/1944
İstanbul
Songül EMRE
01/01/1962
İstanbul
Cevahir YAĞAN
01/01/1947
İstanbul
Eylem ÖZTÜRK
01/01/1973
Istanbul
Mehmet Ali KIRDÖK
6950/12
17/01/2012
Mustafa TÜRKOĞLU
25/03/1975
Samsun
Havva TÜRKOĞLU
04/04/1944
Samsun
Mustafa AKTAŞ
12/01/1964
Samsun
Nuray AKTAŞ
15/09/1969
Samsun
Refiye KARABABA
19/11/1970
Samsun
Fevzi Cem ŞENOCAK
7857/12
22/06/2011
Ali Rıza YILDIRIM
02/02/1966
Istanbul
10454/12
27/12/2011
Oya YILMAZ
12/06/1955
İzmir
Naciye CEYLAN
11849/12
03/01/2012
Namık Kemal YILMAZ
16/08/1951
Mersin
Mustafa ERDOĞDU
14591/12
17/02/2012
Ramazan TOPAL
13/09/1987
Şanlıurfa
Filiz TOPAL
25/09/1989
Şanlıurfa
Emine GÜLER
05/10/1984
Şanlıurfa
Fatma GÜLER
08/01/1984
Şanlıurfa
Aşhan DOKUMACI
01/01/1981
Şanlıurfa
Hanım GÖÇER
20/01/1966
Şanlıurfa
Mustafa YAVUZ
14627/12
20/01/2012
HİMAK ŞASİ ÜSTÜ SANAYİ VE TİCARET A.Ş.
05/06/1950
Istanbul
Eyüp ERASLAN
14629/12
20/01/2012
HİMAK ŞASİ ÜSTÜ SANAYİ VE TİCARET A.Ş.
05/06/1950
Istanbul
Eyüp ERASLAN
14633/12
23/01/2012
HİMAK ŞASİ ÜSTÜ SANAYİ VE TİCARET A.Ş.
05/06/1950
Istanbul
HİDRO-MAK DAMPER VE HİDROLİK MAKİNALARI SAN. TİC. A.Ş.
Istanbul
Eyüp ERASLAN
19595/12
04/01/2012
Ahmet BOZKIR
01/06/01975
Batman
Mirhan ÖZBEKLİ
20875/12
16/03/2012
Hacer ARIKAN
01/01/1966
Balıkesir
Hüseyin KARAKAŞ
21314/12
12/03/2012
YEŞİL ANTALYA MÜFTÜ ARAZİSİ HİSSEDARLARI YAPI KOOPERATİFİ
Antalya
Salih PINAR
24601/12
19/03/2012
Dilber ÖZTÜRK
20/02/1974
İzmir
Nermin SELÇUK
24738/12
07/03/2012
Kazım ÇAYAN
01/04/1948
Samsun
Gülcan AYDIN
15/02/1981
Samsun
Musa ÇAYAN
15/03/1985
Samsun
Muammer ÇAYAN
02/04/1973
Samsun
Muhammet ÇAYAN
02/04/1977
Samsun
Rasime ÇAYAN
01/01/1949
Samsun
Nazmiye ÇAYAN
10/04/1988
Samsun
Sezai DEMİRKAN
26879/12
04/05/2012
Kadriye TURCAN
01/01/1946
Diyarbakır
Halit GÖZEN
23/02/1946
Diyarbakır
Fikri KASSAP
01/01/1965
Diyarbakır
Gülcan KARTAL
30698/12
06/04/2012
Senar CAMCI
06/02/1960
Mersin
Takyettin TAŞKIN
15/09/1981
Aydın
Hamdi TURGUT
31711/12
10/04/2012
Süleyman Barış KÖROĞLU
07/09/1985
İstanbul
Ali YILDIZ
31721/12
05/04/2012
Yusuf GÜN
03/08/1943
Batman
Abdullah BAŞARAN
12/09/1935
Batman
Mehmet BAĞATIR
32062/12
21/03/2012
Rasul KOCATÜRK
01/10/1965
Bolu
Mehmet Aytunç ALTAY
08/06/1956
Kocaeli
Mehmet Baha GÜVELOĞLU
01/01/1964
Kocaeli
Mehmet GÜNEŞ
01/01/1951
Tekirdağ
Hüseyin ATICI
01/01/1970
Istanbul
Bülent BARMAKSIZ
06/01/1965
Istanbul
Hüseyin TUT
28/01/1972
Kocaeli
Bekir BALYEMEZ
01/01/1970
Ankara
Önder ÇARKÇI
01/01/1973
Kocaeli
Kamil YILDIZ
01/01/1965
Bülent GEDİK
01/01/1974
Kocaeli
Tamer TUNCER
25/10/1971
Kocaeli
Yüksel YİĞİTDOĞAN
22/07/1968
Kocaeli
Mustafa YAŞAR
01/01/1959
Istanbul
Murat TARI
01/01/1975
Giresun
Mustafa DEMİRER
01/01/1966
İzmir
M. Tarık DİRİK
01/01/1965
Adana
Sevdağ YILMAZ
01/01/1967
Edirne
Asude Şafak DİRİK
01/01/1972
Adana
Hasan SEVİM
05/09/1954
Tunceli
Hüsamettin ÖZDEM
01/01/1970
Ankara
Bağdegül KOCATÜRK
01/01/1969
Istanbul
Gülizar TUNCER
35296/12
11/04/2012
Erhan YETİK
13/05/1964
Istanbul
37093/12
13/04/2012
Kemal ALKAN
10/04/1975
Istanbul
Ömer ÇELİK
01/01/1963
Istanbul
Seyit Nusret ÖZTÜRK
38780/12
01/05/2012
Mehmet DİKER
13/09/1945
Diyarbakır
Nalan BENER
38888/12
02/04/2012
Ömer KURT
03/01/1979
Ankara
39154/12
29/05/2012
Ayten ÇELİK
11/05/1959
İzmir
Berrin ALTIOK
39523/12
09/05/2012
Necmettin AYDINLI
06/04/1955
Diyarbakır
Ümüt MİKE
47741/12
28/06/2012
Fahrettin ESENDEMİR
14/08/1968
Istanbul
47793/12
28/05/2012
Musa ÖZCAN
01/01/1981
Istanbul
Nurten KORKUSUZ
14/12/1967
Istanbul
Oğuzhan GÜNER
01/01/1972
Istanbul
Hüseyin AKIN
05/02/1982
Istanbul
Umut BİNBİR
01/01/1979
Istanbul
Güler SALMAN
01/01/1979
Istanbul
Sultan YENİGÜL
01/01/1981
Istanbul
Seyhan KABADAYI
01/01/1979
Istanbul
Nuray GÜNDÜZ
01/01/1980
Istanbul
Aytaç DİNÇÇETİN
01/01/1975
Istanbul
Hikmet KORKUSUZ
13/03/1962
Istanbul
Özgür KABADAYI
04/09/1982
İstanbul
Eray GERGİN
01/01/1980
Istanbul
Mehmet YENİGÜL
01/01/1978
Istanbul
Mesut BAYRAKTAR
01/01/1986
Istanbul
Suat EREN
49095/12
06/06/2012
Ziya COŞKUN
10/11/1964
Adana
Buğra YEGÜL
49357/12
25/05/2012
Nimet KÖŞE
01/01/1955
Diyarbakır
Mehmet Sıddık KÖŞE
01/01/1946
Diyarbakır
Mehmet Fesih KÖŞE
01/01/1970
Diyarbakır
Mehmet YUKUŞ
01/01/1946
Diyarbakır
Salih YUKUŞ
01/01/1950
Diyarbakır
Servet KÖSE
01/01/1961
Diyarbakır
Mehmet Şakir ORUÇLU
01/01/1951
Diyarbakır
Mehmet Selim ÇİÇEK
01/01/1943
Diyarbakır
Remzi YUKUŞ
01/01/1973
Diyarbakır
Yahya ÇİÇEK
01/01/1943
Diyarbakır
Abdurrahman YUKUŞ
01/01/1964
Diyarbakır
Mehmet Şafii YUKUŞ
01/01/1966
Diyarbakır
Ahmet YUKUŞ
01/01/1954
Diyarbakır
Mehmet Rauf ÇİÇEK
49888/12
24/05/2012
Cuma PULGAT
01/01/1967
Diyarbakır
Zeki KARTAL
50102/12
03/05/2012
Şeyhmus BAŞTUĞ
04/01/1976
Mardin
Kemal BAŞTUĞ
05/08/1989
Mardin
Şeyhdavut BAŞTUĞ
05/08/1989
Mardin
Nezihe BAŞTUĞ
12/11/1973
Mardin
Sultan BAŞTUĞ
01/01/1952
Mardin
Tenzile BABUR
12/11/1970
Mardin
Emine BAŞTUĞ
31/07/1993
Mardin
Fatma BAŞTUĞ
31/07/1993
Mardin
Halil BAŞTUĞ
25/07/1995
Mardin
Sadiye BAŞTUĞ
04/04/1986
Mardin
Yahya TURAN
50441/12
19/07/2012
Hatice DUMAN
05/04/1974
Gebze
Faruk Nafiz ERTEKİN
53846/12
27/06/2012
Durdu Mehmet DALKANAT
01/01/1953
Kahramanmaraş
Ramazan Selçuk EREN
53962/12
30/05/2012
Hasan TAPAN
01/03/1969
Şanlıurfa
54103/12
25/06/2012
Gürkan KULAKOĞLU
15/10/1962
Aydın
Faruk İŞÇEN
25/12/1957
Aydın
Serpil ÖZÇELİK
08/03/1963
Aydın
Eşref SARIBAŞ
01/04/1956
Aydın
Bekir TİMUÇİN
14/02/1961
Aydın
Halit MORALIOĞLU
54386/12
24/07/2012
Şükrü KARAHASANOĞLU
01/02/1947
Istanbul
Eyüp ERASLAN
54610/12
28/06/2012
Gaye ONAN
04/02/1976
İzmir
54814/12
09/07/2012
Nurhan KILIÇ
14/04/1974
Batman
Nurhayat KILIÇ
05/01/1993
Batman
Mehmet Hakan TOY
54845/12
31/07/2012
Yıldız OTO AĞCA
06/08/1954
Antalya
55012/12
09/07/2012
Nüfer ŞEN
01/09/1963
Diyarbakır
İhsan NARÇİÇEK
01/01/1963
Diyarbakır
Mihdiye KOÇEROĞLU
01/01/1940
Diyarbakır
Cemal KOÇEROĞLU
01/01/1963
Diyarbakır
Keziban NARÇİÇEK
01/01/1963
Diyarbakır
Şaban YEŞİL
01/01/1965
Diyarbakır
İzzettin YEŞİL
01/01/1965
Diyarbakır
Mehmet Şirin KOÇEROĞLU
01/01/1965
Diyarbakır
Zeki ÇELİK
55679/12
10/05/2012
Songül ATLI
11/03/1966
Istanbul
55958/12
05/07/2012
Mehmet Nuri ACAR
01/07/1971
Istanbul
Mehmet ERBİL
56503/12
28/06/2012
Gülseven TUNCER
25/01/1936
İzmir
Türkan BUHARALI
05/06/1934
Ankara
Sevtap TUNCER
06/05/1966
İzmir
Murat Hamdi TUNCER
26/02/1969
İzmir
Mehtap KARAOSMANOĞLU
26/02/1969
İzmir
İclal İLİMOĞLU
56618/12
07/06/2011
Aysel GÖLLER
12/04/1952
Istanbul
Mustafa GÖLLER
28/03/1951
Istanbul
57231/12
08/08/2012
Mehmet GÜL
20/04/1973
Diyarbakır
Ramazan DEMİR
57578/12
20/07/2012
Filiz EYÜBOĞLU
01/01/1959
Istanbul
Boran ÇİÇEKLİ
58181/12
12/08/2012
Orhan ERSOY
01/01/1959
Löhne
58961/12
02/07/2012
Mustafa ÜNLÜSOY
01/02/1961
Istanbul
59753/12
23/07/2012
Tuncay EREN
05/11/1981
Istanbul
Yücel GÖKTAŞ
59791/12
16/07/2012
Mesher İBİŞ
11/11/1978
Istanbul
Yusuf Kenan ALTAN
59840/12
12/07/2012
GAZİPAŞA TURİZM VE İNŞAAT TİCARET LİMİTED ŞİRKETİ
Konya
Güner KUTLUK
60213/12
18/06/2012
Mehmet Atilla ÖZMEN
01/01/1973
Samsun
Lütfi KESKİN
60218/12
18/06/2012
Haluk ERTÜRK
13/10/1955
Aydın
Levent ERCAN
60583/12
20/07/2012
Aydın YILDIZ
01/01/1972
Bursa
Tekin ÖZTÜRK
60797/12
24/07/2012
Nedim ÇONKARA
20/03/1973
İzmir
Serkan CENGİZ
60803/12
24/07/2012
Fazıl Zafer AYDOĞAN
02/12/1961
İzmir
Serkan CENGİZ
60808/12
24/07/2012
Nuri TAŞBAŞ
15/01/1961
İzmir
Serkan CENGİZ
62604/12
10/09/2012
Şeyhmus TURAN
01/01/1958
Ankara
Ömer Faruk SEVGİLİ
62650/12
17/09/2012
Selim KESGİN
22/01/1972
Mersin
63018/12
13/08/2012
Rıza AYDIN
01/01/1956
Adana
Kemal DERİN
63226/12
02/08/2012
Yılmaz Can ÖZALP
01/01/1988
Istanbul
Hüseyin ÇALİŞCİ
63259/12
06/08/2012
Ali TÜRKMEN
22/02/1946
Samsun
Tuba Rana TÜRKMEN
63310/12
12/08/2012
Mehmet KORKMAZ
10/09/1959
Mersin
Mustafa ERDOĞDU
63313/12
17/09/2012
Sevil UYSAL
06/02/1967
Ankara
Kamer BEYAZTAŞ
63366/12
11/09/2012
Mine ÖZGENLER YILMAZ
15/01/1969
Istanbul
Güneş TOSUN ÖZENSOY
63375/12
13/09/2012
Ersoy TOSUN
27/12/1945
İzmir
Muharrem TOSUN
19/02/1940
İzmir
Güneş TOSUN ÖZENSOY
63591/12
10/09/2012
Aziz BOZYEL
24/05/1952
Ankara
Ömer Faruk SEVGİLİ
63595/12
10/09/2012
Aleattin KAVİT
10/10/1977
Istanbul
Ömer Faruk SEVGİLİ
64608/12
15/08/2012
Senem KANDİL
01/01/1945
Istanbul
İbrahim KANDİL
01/01/1965
Istanbul
Celal KANDİL
01/01/1970
Istanbul
Ali İhsan KANDİL
01/01/1974
Istanbul
Nazlı AKBULUT
01/01/1977
Istanbul
Serdar KANDİL
01/01/1981
Istanbul
Kamil Tekin SÜREK
65028/12
23/09/2012
Zehra YILMAZ
01/01/1962
Istanbul
Fazıl Ahmet TAMER
65469/12
08/08/2012
Barış GEBOLOĞLU
02/02/1960
İzmir
Müşerref DEMİR
01/02/1962
İzmir
Layika EREN
02/02/1949
İzmir
Hanım ATEŞ
02/03/1957
İzmir
Fedile Hanım ATEŞ
26/01/1933
İzmir
Ayşete KAYA
01/01/1950
İzmir
65531/12
07/08/2012
Selim ŞAHİN
02/10/1950
Hakkari
Adnan DEMİRKAN
65898/12
22/08/2012
Müjdat ŞENGÜLER
26/07/1952
Istanbul
Haluk PEKŞEN
66069/12
21/09/2012
Ferhat ÖZDEMİR
01/01/1983
Istanbul
Gül ALTAY
66162/12
17/08/2012
Mesut GÜL
20/06/1971
Tekirdağ
Taliphan KIYMAZ
66169/12
17/08/2012
Elbey ERYILMAZ
23/08/1977
Tekirdağ
Taliphan KIYMAZ
66173/12
17/08/2012
Cemal AKÇAY
12/01/1971
Tekirdağ
Taliphan KIYMAZ
66176/12
17/08/2012
İsmail MACİT
20/02/1973
Tekirdağ
Taliphan KIYMAZ
66638/12
05/09/2012
Ünsal ÖMER
29/07/1972
Nevşehir
66662/12
31/08/2012
Ali ÇELEBİOĞLU
15/05/1942
Istanbul
66739/12
09/12/2011
Cevher ÜREK
22/02/1952
Kocaeli
Elvan KARATAŞ
66822/12
24/08/2012
Suna SELÇUK
10/10/1958
Istanbul
Didem SELÇUK
15/09/1985
Istanbul
Iraz SELÇUK
16/04/2006
Istanbul
Filiz ERDEN (SELÇUK)
05/02/1988
Istanbul
Halit BOSTANCI
67609/12
28/08/2012
Ali ÇELEBİOĞLU
15/05/1942
Istanbul
67738/12
15/08/2012
Hasan TOR
01/01/1969
Aydın
Şebnem TOKAT
67802/12
13/08/2012
Semire ERCAN
26/02/1980
Mardin
Sarı KAYA
01/04/1965
Mardin
Selima DEMİR
23/03/1982
Mardin
Mehmet DEMİR
01/02/1974
Mardin
Ali DEMİR
12/03/1987
Mardin
Perihan DEMİR
12/03/1987
Mardin
Halise AY
01/03/1981
Mardin
Emine DEMİR
24/02/1955
Mardin
Halise ASLAN
10/01/1962
Mardin
Burca OĞUR
01/01/1965
Mardin
Kifehi AKA
02/01/1977
Mardin
Faysal DEMİR
25/02/1976
Mardin
Fesih DEMİR
03/01/1979
Mardin
Muzaffer DEMİR
01/02/1975
Mardin
Hasine DEMİR
01/01/1941
Mardin
Yazgı ÇİMEN FİDAN
67904/12
07/09/2012
Sadullah ARIK
16/07/1971
İzmir
Hanife YILDIRIM
68131/12
09/08/2012
Orhan KESKİN
30/09/1974
Hakkari
Adnan DEMİRKAN
68492/12
10/09/2012
Nilgün EKMEKÇİ
İzmir
Ayşe ÖKSÜZ
01/01/1950
İzmir
Özgür BİNGÖL
69514/12
25/07/2012
Fulya Saliha ÜLÇEK KESENCİ
11/10/1977
Batman
Rahşan Bengi GEZGİN KAYAN
69540/12
23/03/2012
Tarık ERKAN
31/05/1985
İzmir
Ahmet Sinan SÜRÜCÜ
70693/12
20/09/2012
Bülent BARMAKSIZ
06/01/1965
Istanbul
Gülizar TUNCER
70768/12
20/09/2012
Ali İhsan İŞİTMEZ
10/05/1981
Istanbul
Orhan ÖZERLİ
01/01/1983
Istanbul
Gül ALTAY
70893/12
18/09/2012
Mustafa Asım ÖZTÜRK
01/01/1946
Bodrum
70931/12
21/09/2012
Perihan YÜKSEL
01/01/1939
Ankara
Bülent UTKU
78959/12
10/08/2012
Mehmet Nafi AKGÜL
01/01/1960
Diyarbakır
Hüseyin AKGÜL
05/04/1962
Diyarbakır
Mehmet Şerif AKGÜL
01/01/1958
Hatay
Mehmet Emin AKGÜL
01/01/1969
Istanbul
Yılmaz AKGÜL
01/01/1980
Mardin
Devran AKGÜL
24/01/1978
Mardin
Sakine GÜNEŞ
01/07/1985
Mardin
Zeynep GÜL
01/03/1982
Mardin
Akisa YILDIZ
06/04/1964
Mardin
Fati AKGÜL
01/02/1938
Mardin
Yahya TURAN
81546/12
21/08/2009
Niyazi BULGAN
10/06/1963
Gaziantep
Ercan KANAR
39/13
19/09/2012
İnayet AKSU
20/12/1977
Istanbul
Barış ÇİLİNGİR
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy