Communicated on 11 July 2017
THIRD SECTION
Application no 27670/07
Olga Petrovna KARGINA against Russia
and 6 other applications
(see list appended)
STATEMENT OF FACTS
The applicants are Russian nationals.
The facts of the cases, as submitted by the applicants, may be summarised as follows.
The applicants were parties to civil proceedings. Only operative parts of judgments in their cases (see table appended) were read out by courts. The reasoned judgments were prepared after the hearings.
COMPLAINT
The applicants complain that the judgments in their civil cases were not pronounced publicly as required by Article 6 § 1 of the Convention.
QUESTIONS to the parties
1. Were the judgments in the present cases (see table appended) of the first‑instance and the appeal courts pronounced publicly, as required by Article 6 § 1 of the Convention? In particular, was the reading out of the judgments of the first-instance and the appeal courts at the hearings limited to the operative part (резолютивная часть), and, if so, were the reasoned judgments, which were prepared after the hearings, made public by any other means (see Ryakib Biryukov v. Russia, no. 14810/02, ECHR 2008; and also Malmberg and Others v. Russia, nos. 23045/05 and 3 others, 15 January 2015)?
2. When were the reasoned judgments of the first‑instance and the appeal courts in their final forms (мотивированные решения суда, решения суда в окончательной форме) prepared?
The Government are requested to submit the court records of the hearings (протоколы судебных заседаний) before the first‑instance and the appeal courts, and the operative parts (резолютивная часть) of the judgments, unless submitted by the applicants.
APPENDIX
No.
Application
no.
Lodged on
Applicant’s name
date of birth
place of residence
Represented by
Judgments which were allegedly not pronounced publicly
27670/07
08/06/2009
Olga Petrovna KARGINA
03/08/1963
Baykonur, Kazakhstan
26th garrison military court’s judgment of 6 October 2008, upheld by
3d circuit military court on 14 January 2009 (non-payment of military allowances)
26th garrison military court’s judgment of 20 January 2009, upheld by 3d circuit military court on 6 May 2009 (provision of housing following retirement from military service)
26th garrison military court’s judgment of 26 March 2009, upheld by 3d circuit military court on 24 June 2009 (military retirement allowances)
41481/09
02/07/2009
Valeriy Vasilyevich GRIGORYEV
05/06/1953, Velikiye Luki
Boris Mikhaylovich POPIK
19/02/1939, Velikiye Luki
Yuriy Semenovich LEBEDEV
08/08/1938, Velikiye Luki
Denis Yevgenyevich KOZYREV, a lawyer practising in Velikiye Luki, Pskov region
Pskov Town Court’s judgment of 20 November 2008 and the Pskov Regional Court’s judgment of 17 February 2009 (recalculation of military pension)
21810/10
16/03/2010
Larisa Yevgenyevna ALABINA
31/05/1955, Tula
Judgment of the Privokzalniy District Court of Tula of 11 September 2009 and the Tula Regional Court’s judgment of 26 November 2009 (eviction from a college dormitory)
33296/10
17/05/2010
Oleg Fedorovich BONDARENKO
05/08/1941, Velikiye Luki
Fedor Karpovich DENISOV
09/04/1953, Velikiye Luki
Aleksey Petrovich ZHUK
08/01/1942, Velikiye Luki
Vyacheslav Petrovich KOROLEV
13/02/1936, Velikiye Luki
Vasiliy Panteleyevich KRAVCHENKO
08/02/1947, Pereslegino,
Velikiye Luki district
Vyacheslav Ivanovich MIKHAYLOV
22/11/1939, Velikiye Luki
Yevtikhey Mironovich SAVELYEV
02/04/1941, Velikiye Luki
Vitaliy Kalenyevich SAVCHUK
19/07/1936, Velikiye Luki
Vladimir Viktorovich TISHEVSKIY
10/10/1948, Velikiye Luki
Valeriy Fedorovich ULYANOV
13/12/1938, Velikiye Luki
Valentin Filippovich TSVETKOV
01/04/1938, Velikiye Luki
Denis Yevgenyevich KOZYREV, a lawyer practising in Velikiye Luki, Pskov region
Pskov Town Court’s judgment of 21 September 2009 and the Pskov Regional Court’s judgment of 1 December 2009 (recalculation of military pension)
As regards Mr V. P. Kravchenko:
Pskov Town Court’s judgment of 6 October 2009 and the Pskov Regional Court’s judgment of 24 November 2009
59998/10
14/09/2010
Anastasiya Andreyevna TUROVA
21/04/1987, Perm
Judgment of the Ordzhonikidzevskiy District Court of Perm of 12 January 2010 and the Perm Regional Court’s judgment of 30 March 2010 (expulsion from university / Nizhniy Novgorod Academy of the Ministry of Interior of the Russian Federation).
69840/10
06/11/2010
Anzhela Vladimirovna USTINOVA
26/11/1968, Solikamsk
Perm Garrison Military Court’s judgment of 5 April 2010, upheld by the Privolzhsk Circuit Military Court on 21 May 2010 (dismissal from military service and related allowances)
74493/10
12/11/2010
Aleksey Viktorovich SAVINOV
10/03/1966, Barnaul
Judgment of the Oktyabrskiy District Court of Barnaul of 26 March 2010 and the Altay Regional Court’s judgment of 12 May 2010 (non-pecuniary damages for unlawful detention)
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy