Published on 29 April 2024
SECOND SECTION
Application no. 47625/21
Mustafa KELEBEK against Türkiye
and 199 other applications
(see list appended)
communicated on 16 April 2024
STATEMENT OF FACTS
1. A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix.
The circumstances of the case2. The applications mainly concern the applicants’ conviction for membership of an armed terrorist organisation described by the Turkish authorities as the “Fetullahist Terror Organisation/Parallel State Structure” (Fetullahçı Terör Örgütü / Paralel Devlet Yapılanması, hereinafter referred to as “the FETÖ/PDY”), considered by the authorities to be behind the coup attempt that took place in Türkiye on 15 July 2016.
3. According to the information submitted by the applicants, the convictions were based, inter alia, on their alleged use of the encrypted messaging application “ByLock”, which the domestic courts held was used exclusively by FETÖ/PDY members and which therefore constituted sufficient evidence to prove on its own that a person had been part of the FETÖ/PDY’s hierarchical structure.
4. The broader domestic background and context to the present applications was set out by the Grand Chamber in the case of Yüksel Yalçınkaya v. Türkiye ([GC], no. 15669/20, §§ 10-22 and 108-40, 26 September 2023).
Relevant domestic law and practice5. A description of the relevant domestic law and practice can be found in Yüksel Yalçınkaya (cited above, §§ 141-93).
COMPLAINTS
6. The applicants mainly complained that their trial and conviction for membership of the FETÖ/PDY had violated the principle of no punishment without law under Article 7 of the Convention and/or the right to a fair trial under Article 6 § 1.
QUESTIONS TO THE PARTIES
Since the issues raised by the present applications are already the subject of well-established case-law of the Court (see Yüksel Yalçınkaya v. Türkiye [GC], no. 15669/20, §§ 237-356, 26 September 2023), the Court does not put any questions to the parties or require any observations on these applications. However, if they so wish, the Government may submit observations on the complaints set out in the appended table, to the extent that they refer essentially to the factual aspects of the applications and not to preliminary objections or legal issues already decided by the Court in Yüksel Yalçınkaya (cited above) or other similar cases against Türkiye.
APPENDIX
List of applications raising complaints under Article 7 (no punishment without law) and/or Article 6 § 1 of the Convention (right to a fair trial)
(conviction for membership of the FETÖ/PDY based, inter alia, on the applicants’ alleged use of the encrypted messaging application “ByLock”):
No.
Application no.
Case name
Lodged on
Applicant
Year of Birth
Place of Residence
Nationality
Represented by
1.
47625/21
Kelebek v. Türkiye
13/09/2021
Mustafa KELEBEK
1976
Antalya
Turkish
Özkan MIZRAK
2.
47766/21
Evren v. Türkiye
31/08/2021
Enver EVREN
1977
İzmir
Turkish
Fatih DÖNMEZ
3.
48166/21
Demirci v. Türkiye
17/09/2021
Bülent Yüce DEMİRCİ
1973
Balıkesir
Turkish
Ebubekir RENK
4.
48199/21
Özdemir v. Türkiye
24/09/2021
Arif ÖZDEMİR
1969
Eskişehir
Turkish
Burhan DEMİRCİ
5.
48267/21
Şen v. Türkiye
24/09/2021
Davut ŞEN
1974
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
İsa KAYA
6.
48288/21
Yücebaş v. Türkiye
29/09/2021
Berna YÜCEBAŞ
1992
Gebze
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
7.
49056/21
Gün v. Türkiye
30/09/2021
Aydın GÜN
1979
Denizli
Turkish
Mehmet MİRZA
8.
49057/21
Karaoğlu v. Türkiye
30/09/2021
Fehmi KARAOĞLU
1969
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
Mehmet MİRZA
9.
49059/21
Güner v. Türkiye
30/09/2021
Arife Zeynep GÜNER
1983
Denizli
Turkish
Mehmet MİRZA
10.
49182/21
Kuzu v. Türkiye
23/09/2021
Asım KUZU
1980
İzmir
Turkish
Nafize GÜLCÜ
11.
50004/21
Gümüşgöz v. Türkiye
06/10/2021
Bekir GÜMÜŞGÖZ
1980
Isparta
Turkish
Mehmet KARAKOÇ
12.
50126/21
Çeltekli v. Türkiye
04/10/2021
Mustafa ÇELTEKLİ
1985
Balıkesir
Turkish
Mehmet ÇELTEKLİ
13.
51151/21
Derdiyok v. Türkiye
08/10/2021
Mustafa DERDİYOK
1982
İzmir
Turkish
Mehmet DERDİYOK
14.
51878/21
Bilgiç v. Türkiye
07/10/2021
Semra BİLGİÇ
1986
İzmir
Turkish
Rümeysa DENİZ
15.
52023/21
Alanka v. Türkiye
08/10/2021
Mikail ALANKA
1978
Sakarya
Turkish
Hilal Tuğçe ŞAHİN
16.
52438/21
Kuş v. Türkiye
20/10/2021
Şenol KUŞ
1987
Antalya
Turkish
Hasan Hüseyin COŞKUN
17.
52694/21
Ataş v. Türkiye
25/10/2021
Fuat ATAŞ
1973
Samsun
Turkish
Ekrem KAYA
18.
52996/21
Yolcu v. Türkiye
23/10/2021
Ahmet Tunçer YOLÇU
1972
Samsun
Turkish
Ekrem KAYA
19.
53003/21
Ak v. Türkiye
13/10/2021
Mustafa AK
1972
Kayseri
Turkish
Hamide Nur ALKAÇ
20.
53031/21
Gürel v. Türkiye
15/10/2021
Mehmet GÜREL
1990
Elazığ
Turkish
Mehmet Sıddık KARAGÖZ
21.
53194/21
Çabuk v. Türkiye
28/10/2021
Mustafa ÇABUK
1987
Antalya
Turkish
Halil İbrahim KEBEŞOĞLU
22.
53602/21
Orbay v. Türkiye
20/10/2021
Ahmet ORBAY
1986
Elazığ
Turkish
Sevim KAYA ORBAY
23.
53619/21
Aktepe v. Türkiye
21/10/2021
Deniz AKTEPE
1971
Osmaniye
Turkish
Bilal ÇÖRTÜK
24.
53633/21
Temuçin v. Türkiye
15/10/2021
İbrahim TEMUÇİN
1970
Erzurum
Turkish
25.
54100/21
Bağa v. Türkiye
26/10/2021
Mehmet BAĞA
1989
Malatya
Turkish
İsa KARGIN
26.
54512/21
Us v. Türkiye
04/11/2021
Murat US
1968
Manisa
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
27.
55025/21
Eroğlu v. Türkiye
04/11/2021
İbrahim EROĞLU
1981
Adıyaman
Turkish
Ayşegül AKTUĞ EROĞLU
28.
55049/21
Atalay v. Türkiye
28/10/2021
Cemal ATALAY
1986
Bursa
Turkish
Elif KARDEŞ
29.
55067/21
Özkan v. Türkiye
05/11/2021
Mustafa ÖZKAN
1989
Antalya
Turkish
Muhammet DEMİREL
30.
55203/21
Aşık v. Türkiye
01/11/2021
Ahmet Tarık AŞIK
1986
Sakarya
Turkish
Fatih DÖNMEZ
31.
55286/21
Candivarci v. Türkiye
04/11/2021
Fevzi CANDİVARCİ
1983
Balıkesir
Turkish
Zeynep CANDİVARCİ
32.
55343/21
Ceylan v. Türkiye
09/11/2021
İsa CEYLAN
1982
Amasya
Turkish
Funda CEYLAN
33.
55423/21
Sancak v. Türkiye
09/11/2021
Bülent SANCAK
1967
Samsun
Turkish
Fatih DÖNMEZ
34.
55752/21
Çetinkaya v. Türkiye
26/10/2021
İsmail ÇETİNKAYA
1990
Elazığ
Turkish
İsa KARGIN
35.
55756/21
Demir v. Türkiye
26/10/2021
Yılmaz DEMİR
1979
Akçadağ
Turkish
İsa KARGIN
36.
55780/21
Özkul v. Türkiye
26/10/2021
Ahmet ÖZKUL
1986
Malatya
Turkish
İsa KARGIN
37.
55902/21
Çetinkaya v. Türkiye
16/11/2021
Fahri ÇETİNKAYA
1966
Uşak
Turkish
Mehmet ÇETİNKAYA
38.
56090/21
Barutçu v. Türkiye
15/11/2021
Soner BARUTÇU
1994
İzmir
Turkish
Yavuz CAN
39.
56323/21
Bulut v. Türkiye
06/11/2021
Ümmü Umare BULUT
1993
Aydın
Turkish
Orçun MUŞLU
40.
56371/21
Asrak v. Türkiye
06/11/2021
Tolga ASRAK
1989
Aydın
Turkish
Orçun MUŞLU
41.
56627/21
Azak v. Türkiye
19/11/2021
Süleyman AZAK
1973
Soma
Turkish
Fatma KAYA
42.
57259/21
Çiçek v. Türkiye
22/11/2021
Ali ÇİÇEK
1991
Erzincan
Turkish
Hatice ÇİÇEK
43.
57269/21
Çulhacı v. Türkiye
10/11/2021
Ali ÇULHACI
1969
İzmir
Turkish
Refia ÇULHACI TÜRBEDAR
44.
57431/21
Erdem v. Türkiye
13/11/2021
Sadık ERDEM
1987
Antalya
Turkish
Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
45.
57482/21
Aslan v. Türkiye
08/11/2021
Coşkun ASLAN
1984
Elazığ
Turkish
Mehmet Sıddık KARAGÖZ
46.
57889/21
Çavuşoğlu v. Türkiye
16/11/2021
Halil ÇAVUŞOĞLU
1977
Bursa
Turkish
Ebubekir RENK
47.
57984/21
Bekir v. Türkiye
26/11/2021
İğde BEKİR
1979
Kayseri
Turkish
Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
48.
57987/21
Demir v. Türkiye
26/11/2021
Mehmet DEMİR
1982
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
49.
58276/21
Bezan v. Türkiye
26/11/2021
Mehmet Fatih BEZAN
1990
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
50.
58873/21
Özen v. Türkiye
26/11/2021
Mehmet Naci ÖZEN
1987
Tekirdağ
Turkish
Zeynep POLAT
51.
59111/21
Bayram v. Türkiye
30/11/2021
Mehmet BAYRAM
1989
Diyarbakır
Turkish
Rümeysa DENİZ
52.
59182/21
Aygün v. Türkiye
25/11/2021
Arif AYGÜN
1965
Bolu
Turkish
Fatih DÖNMEZ
53.
59792/21
Begen v. Türkiye
01/12/2021
Süleyman BEGEN
1971
Eskişehir
Turkish
Fatih DÖNMEZ
54.
60649/21
Çakmak v. Türkiye
08/12/2021
Osman ÇAKMAK
1977
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Yahya DEMİREL
55.
60784/21
Akçay v. Türkiye
09/12/2021
Nazım AKÇAY
1973
Samsun
Turkish
Ekrem KAYA
56.
61473/21
Sürücüler v. Türkiye
14/12/2021
Mert SÜRÜCÜLER
1992
Kütahya
Turkish
Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
57.
165/22
Görgülü v. Türkiye
15/12/2021
Ramazan GÖRGÜLÜ
1986
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
Hatice ÇİLOĞLU
58.
922/22
Daştan v. Türkiye
31/12/2021
Mustafa DAŞTAN
1985
Kayseri
Turkish
Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
59.
1082/22
Kesgin v. Türkiye
28/12/2021
Fatih KESGİN
1981
Muğla
Turkish
Dilek KESGİN
60.
1638/22
Eskigün v. Türkiye
09/12/2021
Mehmet ESKİGÜN
1974
Malatya
Turkish
Hanifi KARTAL
61.
2294/22
Yıldırım v. Türkiye
25/12/2021
Fatma YILDIRIM
1980
Ankara
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
62.
2357/22
Polat v. Türkiye
04/01/2022
Halil POLAT
1981
Kayseri
Turkish
Metin POLAT
63.
2360/22
Özpınar v. Türkiye
31/12/2021
Mehmet Erhan ÖZPINAR
1975
İzmir
Turkish
Yavuz CAN
64.
2392/22
Acar v. Türkiye
26/11/2021
Emre ACAR
1985
Kırıkkale
Turkish
Burak ÇOLAK
65.
2454/22
Özyurt v. Türkiye
03/01/2022
Muhammet Sait ÖZYURT
1984
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Özlem ÖZYURT
66.
2525/22
Adıgüzel v. Türkiye
26/12/2021
Ayşe ADIGÜZEL
1977
Trabzon
Turkish
Elif CİVELEKOĞLU
67.
2755/22
Tekinay v. Türkiye
28/12/2021
Mustafa TEKİNAY
1978
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
İsa KAYA
68.
2891/22
Karaköse v. Türkiye
07/01/2022
Muhammed KARAKÖSE
1989
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
69.
3194/22
Solak v. Türkiye
08/01/2022
Ömer SOLAK
1984
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
70.
3223/22
Yüksel v. Türkiye
24/12/2021
Veyis YÜKSEL
1988
Burdur
Turkish
Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
71.
3333/22
Taşkın v. Türkiye
27/12/2021
Sema TAŞKIN
1989
Manisa
Turkish
Havva ALAN ÖZCEL
72.
3338/22
Taşkın v. Türkiye
24/12/2021
Hakan TAŞKIN
1984
Manisa
Turkish
Havva ALAN ÖZCEL
73.
3606/22
Devecioğlu v. Türkiye
13/01/2022
Ali DEVECİOĞLU
1979
Aydın
Turkish
Orçun MUŞLU
74.
3619/22
Devecioğlu v. Türkiye
13/01/2022
Ümmühan DEVECİOĞLU
1980
Aydın
Turkish
Orçun MUŞLU
75.
3773/22
Sevim v. Türkiye
14/01/2022
Mehmet SEVİM
1973
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
76.
3850/22
Ilıkan v. Türkiye
19/11/2021
Akın Hamit ILIKAN
1976
Kocaeli
Turkish
Emir KARAKOL
77.
3857/22
Özer v. Türkiye
08/12/2021
Mehmet ÖZER
1974
Istanbul
Turkish
Ahmet ÇİFTÇİ
78.
3929/22
Babaarslan v. Türkiye
14/01/2021
Recep BABAARSLAN
1976
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
79.
4228/22
Turmak v. Türkiye
12/01/2022
Ali TURMAK
1986
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
80.
4229/22
Koçak v. Türkiye
05/01/2022
Yusuf KOÇAK
1985
Eskişehir
Turkish
Ahmet ALPARSLAN
81.
4516/22
Arslan v. Türkiye
05/01/2022
Mustafa ARSLAN
1978
Manisa
Turkish
Erdem ALP
82.
4934/22
Gözütok v. Türkiye
19/01/2022
Mevlüt GÖZÜTOK
1981
Yalova
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
83.
5770/22
Yenigün v. Türkiye
17/01/2022
İzzedin YENİGÜN
1988
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
84.
5811/22
Yavuz v. Türkiye
20/01/2022
Salih YAVUZ
1990
Kocaeli
Turkish
İlyas TEKİN
85.
5841/22
Özgentürk v. Türkiye
23/12/2021
İlyas ÖZGENTÜRK
1969
Eskişehir
Turkish
Fatih DÖNMEZ
86.
5844/22
Aldırmaz v. Türkiye
23/12/2021
Necati ALDIRMAZ
1970
Istanbul
Turkish
Yılmaz POLAT
87.
6286/22
Şahin v. Türkiye
03/01/2022
Akif ŞAHİN
1993
Kayseri
Turkish
Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
88.
6309/22
Sağıroğlu v. Türkiye
28/12/2021
Cengiz SAĞIROĞLU
1979
Turkish
Nazlı MERT
89.
6353/22
Uysal v. Türkiye
27/01/2022
Hilal UYSAL
1983
İzmir
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
90.
6355/22
Bekdemir v. Türkiye
27/01/2022
Nahit Mehdi BEKDEMİR
1988
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
91.
6622/22
Demirez v. Türkiye
29/12/2021
Aşır DEMİREZ
1979
Ankara
Turkish
Hamide Nur ALKAÇ
92.
6652/22
Esen v. Türkiye
25/01/2022
Sezgin ESEN
1987
Samsun
Turkish
Ekrem KAYA
93.
6790/22
Fidan v. Türkiye
27/01/2022
Nurullah FİDAN
1987
Ankara
Turkish
Gülhis YÖRÜK
94.
6914/22
Duman v. Türkiye
31/01/2022
Özcan DUMAN
1973
İzmir
Turkish
Yavuz CAN
95.
7142/22
Çolak v. Türkiye
18/01/2022
Aysun ÇOLAK
1976
Malatya
Turkish
Hanifi KARTAL
96.
7165/22
Demir v. Türkiye
18/01/2022
Selçuk DEMİR
1985
Malatya
Turkish
İmmihan DEMİR
97.
7235/22
Çakan v. Türkiye
04/02/2022
Sadi ÇAKAN
1982
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
98.
7236/22
Kuzu v. Türkiye
04/02/2022
Turgay KUZU
1989
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
99.
7237/22
Yıldız v. Türkiye
04/02/2022
Murat YILDIZ
1975
Balıkesir
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
100.
7711/22
Çevik v. Türkiye
01/02/2022
Samet ÇEVİK
1994
Manisa
Turkish
Şaban ÇEVİK
101.
7749/22
Kaya v. Türkiye
03/02/2022
Mehmet KAYA
1983
Kastamonu
Turkish
Selma KAYA
102.
7969/22
Araboğa v. Türkiye
28/01/2022
Ferhat ARABOĞA
1985
Aydın
Turkish
Orçun MUŞLU
103.
7976/22
Şaylıca v. Türkiye
28/01/2022
Tayfur ŞAYLICA
1990
Aydın
Turkish
Orçun MUŞLU
104.
8162/22
Öztaş v. Türkiye
09/02/2022
Tarık ÖZTAŞ
1977
Antalya
Turkish
Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
105.
8614/22
Atalay v. Türkiye
13/01/2022
Kadri ATALAY
1968
Ankara
Turkish
Naciye Refia ÇOKER
106.
8658/22
Vural v. Türkiye
20/01/2022
Hamdi VURAL
1978
Kocaeli
Turkish
İlyas TEKİN
107.
8710/22
Aygören v. Türkiye
31/01/2022
Gökhan AYGÖREN
1975
Kayseri
Turkish
Yusuf ÇAKMAK
108.
8795/22
Aksoy v. Türkiye
08/02/2022
Özcan AKSOY
1969
Denizli
Turkish
Serhat ŞAHİN
109.
8952/22
Tanrıseven v. Türkiye
28/01/2022
Ahmet TANRISEVEN
1994
Hatay
Turkish
Bilal ÇÖRTÜK
110.
8958/22
Kaygas v. Türkiye
03/02/2022
Semra KAYGAS
1990
Antalya
Turkish
Muhammet DEMİREL
111.
9192/22
Yavuz v. Türkiye
31/01/2022
Fuat YAVUZ
1973
Kayseri
Turkish
Yusuf ÇAKMAK
112.
9423/22
Sürücüler v. Türkiye
24/01/2022
Gönül SÜRÜCÜLER
1991
Kütahya
Turkish
Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
113.
9585/22
Çelik v. Türkiye
02/02/2022
Zeynel Bülent ÇELİK
1976
Batman
Turkish
Sinan DAĞ
114.
9765/22
Semen v. Türkiye
15/02/2022
Mehmet SEMEN
1985
Antalya
Turkish
Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
115.
9810/22
Orakçı v. Türkiye
11/02/2022
Adem ORAKÇI
1976
Konya
Turkish
Mustafa DEMİRCAN
116.
9873/22
Daşçı v. Türkiye
01/02/2022
Zeki DAŞÇI
1983
Çorum
Turkish
Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
117.
10006/22
Sayın v. Türkiye
24/01/2022
Bayram SAYIN
1984
Antalya
Turkish
Hilal Tuğçe ŞAHİN
118.
10020/22
Pehlivan v. Türkiye
11/02/2022
Haluk PEHLİVAN
1971
Ankara
Turkish
Halil ŞAHİN
119.
10121/22
Karğın v. Türkiye
03/02/2022
İbrahim KARĞIN
1984
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
Afra Betül KARĞIN
120.
10231/22
Çelik v. Türkiye
04/02/2022
Zeki ÇELİK
1978
Kayseri
Turkish
Zehra KARAKULAK BOZDAĞ
121.
10586/22
Ateş v. Türkiye
21/01/2022
Abdulrahim ATEŞ
1979
Hatay
Turkish
Bilal ÇÖRTÜK
122.
10810/22
Güneş v. Türkiye
01/02/2022
İsmail GÜNEŞ
1983
Eskişehir
Turkish
Gökhan DİRİCAN
123.
10879/22
Kafalı v. Türkiye
16/02/2022
Kürşat KAFALI
1976
Adana
Turkish
Selhan SAĞIRER
124.
10886/22
Sapmaz v. Türkiye
16/02/2022
Mustafa SAPMAZ
1970
Adana
Turkish
Selhan SAĞIRER
125.
11103/22
Çebişli v. Türkiye
11/02/2022
Mustafa Furkan ÇEBİŞLİ
1996
Hatay
Turkish
Bilal ÇÖRTÜK
126.
11111/22
Çevik v. Türkiye
11/02/2022
Yunus Emre ÇEVİK
1988
Çanakkale
Turkish
Serap ÇEVİK
127.
11392/22
Alan v. Türkiye
22/02/2022
Çiğdem ALAN
1990
Düzce
Turkish
Zehra ARSLAN ALKAÇ
128.
11603/22
Kaçan v. Türkiye
28/02/2022
Hüseyin KAÇAN
1990
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
129.
11799/22
Tuzak v. Türkiye
18/02/2022
İbrahim TUZAK
1973
Istanbul
Turkish
Hamid KAYNARPINAR
130.
11808/22
Turhan v. Türkiye
21/02/2022
Murat TURHAN
1984
Denizli
Turkish
Gülhis YÖRÜK
131.
11829/22
Demir v. Türkiye
21/02/2022
Sebile DEMİR
1972
Mersin
Turkish
Sümeyra DEMİR
132.
11995/22
Durmazoğlu v. Türkiye
28/02/2022
Fatih DURMAZOĞLU
1990
Manisa
Turkish
Hatice ÇİLOĞLU
133.
12032/22
Gülçimen v. Türkiye
21/02/2022
Tuğba GÜLÇİMEN
1998
Antalya
Turkish
Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
134.
12058/22
Aytar v. Türkiye
03/03/2022
Osman AYTAR
1988
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
Orçun MUŞLU
135.
12061/22
Aslan v. Türkiye
03/03/2022
Mehmet Yunus ASLAN
1982
Aydın
Turkish
Orçun MUŞLU
136.
12152/22
Kaya v. Türkiye
22/02/2022
İsa KAYA
1978
Sakarya
Turkish
Emrullah POLAT
137.
12450/22
Kalaycı v. Türkiye
01/03/2022
Fatih KALAYCI
1981
Ankara
Turkish
Kübra ALAKUŞ
138.
12499/22
Karadağ v. Türkiye
22/02/2022
Sultan KARADAĞ
1986
Elazığ
Turkish
Hüseyin DÖNMEZ
139.
12551/22
Bulut v. Türkiye
02/03/2022
Yaşar BULUT
1971
Ordu
Turkish
Ekrem KAYA
140.
12613/22
Çetin v. Türkiye
21/01/2022
İrfan ÇETİN
1977
Konya
Turkish
Kadir ÖZTÜRK
141.
12766/22
Karataş v. Türkiye
07/03/2022
Mustafa KARATAŞ
1983
Istanbul
Turkish
Ahmet ÇİFTÇİ
142.
12926/22
Karaaslan v. Türkiye
28/02/2022
Yakup KARAASLAN
1990
Mersin
Turkish
Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
143.
12973/22
Dinler v. Türkiye
07/03/2022
Halil DİNLER
1968
Kayseri
Turkish
Fatih DÖNMEZ
144.
13041/22
Avcı v. Türkiye
04/03/2022
Ali AVCI
1983
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
145.
13371/22
Meyveci v. Türkiye
01/03/2022
Ahmet MEYVECİ
1980
Elazığ
Turkish
Zeynep MEYVECİ
146.
13612/22
Pamuk v. Türkiye
03/03/2022
Kaan PAMUK
1984
Ordu
Turkish
Rüşan YÜKSEL
147.
13664/22
Açıkgöz v. Türkiye
08/03/2022
Rauf AÇIKGÖZ
1989
İzmir
Turkish
Hatice ÇİLOĞLU
148.
13919/22
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
15/03/2022
Duray YILMAZ
1969
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
149.
14300/22
Kerek v. Türkiye
09/03/2022
Yasimen KEREK
1987
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Ali KAYA
150.
14431/22
Üstün v. Türkiye
09/03/2022
Feyzi ÜSTÜN
1991
Antalya
Turkish
Sümeyra ÇELİK AKINCI
151.
14488/22
Özkan v. Türkiye
14/03/2022
Hüseyin ÖZKAN
1985
Samsun
Turkish
Ekrem KAYA
152.
14812/22
Özpiricci v. Türkiye
08/03/2022
Mahir ÖZPİRİCCİ
1980
Istanbul
Turkish
Fahrettin PİYADE
153.
14956/22
Akca v. Türkiye
07/03/2022
Resul AKCA
1983
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Muhammed Murat POYRAZ
154.
14990/22
Çelik v. Türkiye
14/03/2022
Tuğba ÇELİK
1988
Sakarya
Turkish
Salih ÇELİK
155.
15375/22
Albayrak v. Türkiye
09/03/2022
Serhat ALBAYRAK
1986
Antalya
Turkish
Sümeyra ÇELİK AKINCI
156.
15380/22
Nacar v. Türkiye
23/03/2022
Yunus Emre NACAR
1991
Kırıkkale
Turkish
Miyaser AKSU
157.
15487/22
Işık v. Türkiye
14/03/2022
Nuran IŞIK
1993
Bakırköy
Turkish
Erdem ALP
158.
15741/22
Yiğen v. Türkiye
16/03/2022
Ramazan YİĞEN
1995
Manisa
Turkish
Memnune Melike AKYILDIZ
159.
15746/22
Akbulut v. Türkiye
09/03/2022
Özlem AKBULUT
1977
Kütahya
Turkish
Muhammed ÇAPRAK
160.
15916/22
Duman v. Türkiye
25/03/2022
Olcay DUMAN
1983
Istanbul
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
161.
15933/22
Kartal v. Türkiye
11/03/2022
Ülkü KARTAL
1984
Amasya
Turkish
Fatih KARTAL
162.
16356/22
Aymaz v. Türkiye
02/03/2022
Muhammet Bekir AYMAZ
1990
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
Mehmet SARIKAYA
163.
16686/22
Mercan v. Türkiye
29/03/2022
Ayhan MERCAN
1988
İzmir
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
164.
16784/22
Çetinadam v. Türkiye
22/03/2022
Ömer ÇETİNADAM
1994
Gaziantep
Turkish
Emrullah POLAT
165.
16984/22
Karakaş v. Türkiye
29/03/2022
Remzi KARAKAŞ
1978
Antalya
Turkish
Yusuf Sait PEKGÖZ
166.
17199/22
Kömürcüoğlu v. Türkiye
23/03/2022
Mehmet KÖMÜRCÜOĞLU
1975
Isparta
Turkish
Yekta Mustafa POLAT
167.
17334/22
Akbayrak v. Türkiye
23/03/2022
Turgut AKBAYRAK
1983
Turkish
Ali ARTUK
168.
17541/22
Bas v. Türkiye
17/03/2022
Okan BAŞ
1982
Trabzon
Turkish
Halil ŞAHİN
169.
17613/22
Öztan v. Türkiye
21/03/2022
Dündar ÖZTAN
1992
Sakarya
Turkish
Emrullah POLAT
170.
17615/22
Çıngır v. Türkiye
04/04/2022
Mehmet ÇINGIR
1987
Antalya
Turkish
Hasan Hüseyin COŞKUN
171.
17994/22
Çerçi v. Türkiye
31/03/2022
Mustafa ÇERÇİ
1987
Adana
Turkish
Mehmet Ali KAYA
172.
18149/22
Güner v. Türkiye
05/04/2022
Mecit GÜNER
1970
Malatya
Turkish
İsa KARGIN
173.
18581/22
Akbaş v. Türkiye
31/03/2022
Serkan AKBAŞ
1988
Ankara
Turkish
Regaip DEMİR
174.
18741/22
Sargın v. Türkiye
29/03/2022
Yasin SARGIN
1976
Malatya
Turkish
İsa KARGIN
175.
18752/22
Yaray v. Türkiye
05/04/2022
Ramazan YARAY
1975
Malatya
Turkish
İsa KARGIN
176.
18807/22
Can v. Türkiye
08/04/2022
Umut İslam CAN
1983
İzmir
Turkish
Yavuz CAN
177.
18826/22
Erkuş v. Türkiye
25/03/2022
Ramazan ERKUŞ
1991
Malatya
Turkish
Banu ÇUKADAR YILMAZ
178.
19045/22
Büyükkaçar v. Türkiye
11/04/2022
Fatmana BÜYÜKKAÇAR
1972
Denizli
Turkish
Mehmet MİRZA
179.
19083/22
Yalçın v. Türkiye
01/04/2022
Mehmet YALÇIN
1973
Sakarya
Turkish
Emrullah POLAT
180.
19714/22
Okay v. Türkiye
13/04/2022
Mustafa OKAY
1989
Hatay
Turkish
Şeyma ALKAN
181.
19808/22
Sır v. Türkiye
19/04/2022
Emin SIR
1976
İzmir
Turkish
Mert DİNÇ
182.
19814/22
Çalışkan v. Türkiye
18/04/2022
Mehmet ÇALIŞKAN
1989
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
İsmail DOĞAN
183.
19853/22
Dülger v. Türkiye
22/02/2022
Muhammed DÜLGER
1993
Eskişehir
Turkish
Cihat ÇITIR
184.
20313/22
Özdemir v. Türkiye
07/04/2022
Ümit ÖZDEMİR
1978
Batman
Turkish
Sinan DAĞ
185.
20338/22
Kalkan v. Türkiye
13/04/2022
Erkan KALKAN
1975
Samsun
Turkish
Ekrem KAYA
186.
20360/22
Sevim v. Türkiye
15/04/2022
Necip Ercüment SEVİM
1977
Antalya
Turkish
Hasan Hüseyin COŞKUN
187.
20367/22
Başaran v. Türkiye
08/04/2022
Hakan BAŞARAN
1974
Ankara
Turkish
Gülbeyaz ÇOLAK
188.
20450/22
Alp v. Türkiye
11/04/2022
Muhammet Aslan ALP
1992
Bolvadin
Turkish
Zelal ALP
189.
20513/22
Altuntaş v. Türkiye
11/04/2022
Fatih Mehmet ALTUNTAŞ
1978
Turkish
Murat ÇİÇEK
190.
20532/22
Ulutaş v. Türkiye
11/04/2022
Yaşar ULUTAŞ
1984
Sakarya
Turkish
Emrullah POLAT
191.
20692/22
Erkan v. Türkiye
15/03/2022
Suna ERKAN
1982
Kırklareli
Turkish
Mehmet ÇAVDAR
192.
20876/22
Sızlağ v. Türkiye
23/04/2022
Mesut SIZLAĞ
1985
Aydın
Turkish
Orçun MUŞLU
193.
21044/22
Şahin v. Türkiye
15/04/2022
Muharrem ŞAHİN
1976
Kırıkkale
Turkish
Fatma ALTUN ŞAHİN
194.
21449/22
Atalay v. Türkiye
29/04/2022
Ayşegül ATALAY
1986
İzmir
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
195.
21555/22
Tüt v. Türkiye
15/04/2022
Erdem TÜT
1972
Kırşehir
Turkish
Mikail Mustafa ŞAHİN
196.
21595/22
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
18/04/2022
Yalçın YILMAZ
1972
Kastamonu
Turkish
Fatma ALBAYRAK
197.
21618/22
Erzen v. Türkiye
14/04/2022
Burhan ERZEN
1988
Sakarya
Turkish
Emrullah POLAT
198.
22139/22
Savcı v. Türkiye
29/04/2022
Tuba SAVCI
1981
Bursa
Turkish
Adnan ZEYBEK
199.
22522/22
Ustabaşı v. Türkiye
18/04/2022
Samet USTABAŞI
1987
Istanbul
Turkish
Erdem ALP
200.
22953/22
Gür v. Türkiye
29/04/2022
Süleyman GÜR
1983
Konya
Turkish
Fatıma Nur AKYAZI