Published on 3 November 2025
FOURTH SECTION
Application no. 50489/22
Lyubov Antonivna MUZYLYOVA against Russia
and 30 other applications
(see table appended)
PROCEDURAL INFORMATION
Following a preliminary examination of the admissibility of the applications on 16 October 2025, the Court decided, under Rule 54 § 2 (b) of the Rules of Court, that notice of the applications should be given to the Government of Russia. It is to be noted that the issue of jurisdiction over the area where the incidents giving rise to the complaints allegedly took place has been examined and decided by the Grand Chamber of the Court in the case of Ukraine and the Netherlands v. Russia ([GC], nos. 8019/16 and 3 others, §§ 327-66, 9 July 2025). The Grand Chamber’s finding will then be applied in these individual cases.
In some applications, other complaints were raised. Their examination has been adjourned, or they have been struck out of the Court’s list of cases or declared inadmissible by the Court, sitting in a single-judge formation, assisted by a rapporteur as provided for in Article 24 § 2 of the Convention.
In the enclosed table, whenever an applicant is referred to using initials, this indicates that the Court has authorised anonymity for that person, whose identity will not be disclosed to the public (Rule 47 § 4).
For further information on the procedure following communication of an application brought against Russia, subject of well-established case law of the Court, please refer to the Court’s website.
SUBJECT MATTER
The applications concern complaints raised under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 and Article 13 of the Convention relating to damage, destruction and/or continuous lack of access to property arising from the conflict between Russia and Ukraine and the lack of any effective remedy in domestic law which are the subject of well-established case law of the Court (see Ukraine and the Netherlands v. Russia ([GC], nos. 8019/16 and 3 others, §§ 768-72 and 1622, 9 July 2025).
APPENDIX – STATEMENT OF FACTS
List of applications raising complaints under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 and Article 13 of the Convention
(damage, destruction and/or continuous lack of access to property arising from the conflict between Russia and Ukraine and the lack of any effective remedy in domestic law)
No.
Application no.
Date of introduction
Applicant’s name
Year of birth
Representative’s name and location
Property allegedly damaged (description and location)
Dates / Period when damage occurred and when the applicant learned about it
Evidence provided (photos, property certificate, etc.)
Level of damage
Other complaints under well‑established case-law
50489/22
07/10/2022
Lyubov Antonivna MUZYLYOVA
1948
(1) Private house and outbuildings (265.7 sq. m) at 23 Pershotravneva St, Mali Shcherbaky village, Vasylivka district, Zaporizhzhia region;
(2) Tractor МТЗ-80, registration number 16-89 ЗГ (1985 year of release)
Allegedly destroyed as a result of repeated artillery shelling on 07/03/2022 and 03/07/2022. On 18/07/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police.
The applicant’s passport with a registration stamp for the house dated 06/12/1995 and a marriage stamp dated 03/12/1966; title documents (the applicant owns ½ share in the property - purchase agreement dated 30/12/1991, extracts from the real estate register for the house and for the land plot dated 28/09/2021 and 25/10/2021 respectively, technical passport dated 14/09/2021; ownership certificate for the tractor dated 27/03/2001); photos of the private house and outbuildings after the destruction (destroyed buildings, signs of fire, only few walls left standing, rubble); extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 18/07/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint lodged on the same date; horned cattle passport dated 31/08/2012; witness statements dated 05/10/2022; envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region.
complete destruction
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the private house in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by her passport registration stamp dated 06/12/1995 and statements, which she was forced to abandon and relocate to Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region (envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region).
53973/22
25/10/2022
Vasylyna Vasylivna LUTANYUK
1961
Private house and outbuildings (62.4 sq. m) at 31 Sadova St, Mali Shcherbaky village, Vasylivka district, Zaporizhzhia region
Allegedly damaged as a result of repeated artillery shelling on 06/05/2022 and 07/06/2022. On 28/09/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Security Service of Ukraine.
The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the house dated 13/03/1997 and marriage stamp dated 24/12/1983; title documents (the applicant owns ½ share in the property – purchase agreement dated 23/02/2000, technical passport dated December 1999); photos of the damaged house (destroyed roof and some walls, broken windows, rubble inside); extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 14/07/2022; notification from the Security Service of Ukraine dated 18/10/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint lodged on 28/09/2022; witness statement dated 19/10/2022, confirming the damage and a list of damaged belongings; envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia, Zaporizhzhia region.
damage
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the private house in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by her passport registration stamp dated 13/03/1997 and statements, which she was forced to abandon and relocate to Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region (envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region).
16536/24
13/06/2022
Valentyna Grygorivna SHCHERBAK
1957
Apartment no. 33 at 119 Poshtova St, Zaporizhzhia, Zaporizhzhia region
Allegedly damaged as a result of the blast wave from a missile strike on 25/05/2022.
On 25/05/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police.
The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the apartment; title document (technical passport dated 15/08/2016); photos of the damaged apartment (damaged ceiling and walls, broken windows); police complaint dated 25/05/2022.
damage
Art. 8 (1) - interference with the right to home - the apartment in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence registration stamp in her passport, photos of the apartment depicting elements of the interior and her statements.
20362/24
28/06/2022
Svitlana Volodymyrivna BONDARENKO
1961
Apartment no. 12 (59.4 sq. m) at 330 Mahistralna (previously K. Marksa) St, Polohy, Zaporizhzhia region
Allegedly damaged by artillery shelling on 07/03/2022.
The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the apartment; title documents (technical passport dated 04/02/1993; exchange agreement dated 23/04/1998; property registration certificate dated 04/05/1998); photos of the damaged apartment (damaged balcony and external walls; broken windows; cracked internal walls; damaged furniture; room covered in rubble).
damage
Art. 8 (1) - interference with the right to home - the apartment in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence registration stamp in her passport, photos of the apartment depicting elements of the interior and her statements.
21898/24
11/07/2022
Volodymyr Ivanovych BOZHKOV
1961
Private house (86.1 sq. m) at 40 Peremohy Ave, Berdiansk, Zaporizhzhia region
The applicant allegedly lost access to his house on 27/06/2022, after fleeing from the occupied territory.
The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the house dated 27/01/1986 and marriage stamp dated 28/05/1986; title documents (the applicant owns 9/40 share in the house - purchase agreement dated 27/04/2020, technical passport dated 24/07/1998, extract from the real estate register dated 27/04/2020); envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region.
loss of access to property
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the house in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence stamp for the apartment dated 27/01/1986, which he was forced to abandon on 27/06/2022 and relocate to Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region (envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region).
23808/24
11/08/2022
Viktor Volodymyrovych NECHET
1949
Maryna Yuriyivna Kaletnik
Kyiv
Private house (102.8 sq. m) at 3B Kostenka M. St, Huliaipole, Zaporizhzhia region
Allegedly damaged as a result of repeated artillery shelling on 22/06/2022 and 03/07/2022. On 18/07/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police.
The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the house dated 10/04/1987 and marriage stamp dated 30/12/1972; title documents (the applicant owns ½ share in the private house - agreement on the division of a house dated 18/03/2021, extract from the real estate register dated 02/04/2021, technical passport dated 25/07/2019); photos of the house after the destruction (roof destroyed, only few walls left standing, broken windows, rubble inside); complaint to the Ukrainian police dated 18/07/2022; screenshot of the online application to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation without a date; IDP certificate dated 26/05/2022.
complete destruction
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the house in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence stamp in his passport dated 10/04/1987, which he was forced to abandon and relocate to Marivka village, Zaporizhzhia region (IDP certificate dated 26/05/2022).
27843/24
24/06/2022
Volodymyr Viktorovych GOLUSHKO
1980
Apartment no. 9 (41.3 sq. m) at 174 Derzhavna St, Polohy, Zaporizhzhia region
Allegedly damaged by artillery shelling on 18/06/2022. The applicant lost access to his property after fleeing from the occupied territory on the same date.
The applicant’s passport; title documents (the applicant owns ½ share in the apartment - purchase agreement and extract from the real estate register, both dated 10/10/2019); photos of the apartment depicting elements of the applicant’s daily life; photo of a damaged apartment building; envelope with the address in Dnipro, Dnipropetrovsk region.
damage, loss of access to property
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the apartment in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by its photos depicting elements of the applicant’s daily life and his statements, which he was forced to abandon on 18/06/2022 and relocate to Dnipro, Dnipropetrovsk region (envelope with the address in Dnipro, Dnipropetrovsk region).
28554/24
01/08/2022
Oleksiy Mykolayovych TUCHKOV
1987
Private house (89.95 sq. m) at 40 Pryiaruzhna St, Zaporizhzhia, Zaporizhzhia region
Allegedly damaged by the missile strike on 28/04/2022. On 06/06/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police.
The applicant’s passport with the residence stamp for the house in question dated 17/06/2003; title documents (the applicant owns ½ share in the house - court decision on the acquisition of the applicant’s ownership through inheritance dated 14/03/2019, extract from the real estate register dated 01/11/2019); photos after the damage (damaged walls, broken windows, damaged roof, destroyed garage, signs of fire); police report recognising the applicant as a victim in the criminal proceedings dated 06/06/2022; witness statement dated 13/07/2022.
damage
Art. 8 (1) - interference with the right to home - the private house in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence stamp in his passport dated 17/06/2003 and statements.
29960/24
03/08/2022
Yuriy Mykolayovych DUBOVSKYY
1958
Private house (130.8 sq. m) at 4 Lesi Ukrainky (previously Rozy Liuksemburh) St, Orikhiv, Zaporizhzhia region
Allegedly destroyed by artillery shelling between 30/05/2022 and 31/05/2022. The applicant learnt about the fact of destruction from his neighbour. On 30/05/2022 and 01/06/2022, the applicant’s wife lodged complaints with the Ukrainian police.
The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the private house; marriage certificate dated 29/07/2022; title documents (the applicant owns ½ share in the house - ownership certificate dated 05/11/2002; technical passport dated 17/10/2000; state act on land ownership dated 12/06/1996); photos of the house before and after the destruction (completely destroyed second floor, severely damaged first floor, broken windows, everything covered in rubble); extract from the register of pre-trial investigations, confirming the registration of complaints lodged on 30/05/2022 and 01/06/2022; screenshot of the online application about destruction of property submitted via the DIIA website on 29/06/2022; request to the prosecutor’s office dated 29/07/2022 for the information on the progress of criminal proceedings; letter from the prosecutor’s office dated 29/07/2022; screenshot of the online application to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation dated 01/08/2022; IDP certificate dated 27/04/2022.
complete destruction
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the house in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence stamp in his passport, which he was forced to abandon and relocate to the Poltava region (IDP certificate dated 27/04/2022).
29981/24
26/07/2022
Lyudmyla Mykolayivna NAUMOVA
1972
(1) Private house (66.7 sq. m) at 4 Vilna St, Polohy village, Polohy district, Zaporizhzhia region;
(2) Household appliances, power tools, televisions and computer equipment (looting).
The applicant’s house had been allegedly occupied, damaged, and her belongings looted by Russian soldiers between 07/04/2022 and 15/06/2022. On 22/04/2022 she lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police.
The applicant lost access to her property after fleeing from the occupied territory.
The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the private house; title documents (purchase agreement for a land plot and extract from the real estate register, both dated 24/06/2014; purchase agreement for the house and extract from the real estate register, both dated 24/06/2014); photos of the house before the damage and looting depicting household appliances and computer equipment; notification from the Ukrainian police dated 04/07/2022 confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint filed on 22/04/2022; police report dated 04/07/2022; screenshot of the application about damage of property submitted via the DIIA website (damaged windows and balcony); envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia, Zaporizhzhia region.
loss of access to property, damage, looting
Art. 3 - torture, inhuman or degrading treatment as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the applicant complained that, in March 2022, owing to regular shelling and the occupation of her village, she and her family were deprived for several weeks of access to basic necessities, including water, electricity, heating, food and medicine; she further submitted that she suffered psychological trauma on account of the constant fear for her life, her pre-existing medical condition, and the forced entry and looting of her home;
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the house in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence stamp in the passport, which she was forced to abandon and relocate to Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region (envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region); she is unable to return to her home owing to fear and the continuing occupation.
30146/24
29/07/2022
Anastasiya Igorivna AKHMADYEYEVA
1996
***
Kyrylo Igorovych AKHMADYEYEV
2000
Svitlana Mykolayivna AKHMADYEYEVA
1976
(these two applicants are not the owners of the house in question)
Private house (112.1 sq. m) at 24 Shlamova St, Zaporizhzhia, Zaporizhzhia region
Allegedly destroyed by a missile strike on 28/04/2022. On 29/06/2022 Ms Akhmadyeyeva Anastasiya lodged a complaint with the State Security Service of Ukraine.
The applicants’ passports with the residence stamps for the house in question; title documents (deed of gift and extract from the real estate register, both dated 16/12/2014 – the sole owner is Ms Akhmadyeyeva Anastasiya); photos of the house after the destruction (destroyed roof, few walls left standing, broken windows, rubble inside); report of the State Security Service of Ukraine dated 02/07/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint lodged on 29/06/2022.
complete destruction
Art. 8 (1) - interference with the right to home - the house in question was the applicants’ home as confirmed by the residence stamps in their passports and their statements.
30506/24
28/06/2022
Yevgen Olegovych BILYY
1991
Private house (62.4 sq. m) and outbuildings at 1 Zlahody St, Huliaipole, Polohy district, Zaporizhzhia region.
Allegedly damaged by artillery shelling on 18/06/2022.
The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the house in question; title document (purchase agreement dated 21/01/2021); photos of the house before and after the destruction (several exterior walls are missing, windows and doors are broken, the roof and ceiling are damaged, and the fence near the house is destroyed); envelope with the address in Zelenyi Hai, Zaporizhzhia region.
damage
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the house in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence stamp in his passport, which he had to abandon in June 2022, and relocate to Zelenyi Hai, Zaporizhzhia region (envelope with the address in Zelenyi Hai, Zaporizhzhia region).
30933/24
13/11/2022
Lyudmyla Ivanivna KHVOSTENKO
1966
***
Igor Vasylyovych DYADYA
1966
(this applicant is not the owner of the house in question)
(1) Private house (41.4 sq. m) and outbuildings at 25 Sadova St, Mali Scherbaky village, Vasylivskyi district, Zaporizhzhia region;
(2) Furniture, household appliances, agricultural equipment and livestock.
Allegedly damaged for the first time during the night of 4 to 5 May 2022 by artillery shelling and rocket fire from a Hrad MLRS.
In July 2022 the applicants learned from their neighbours that by the end of June 2022, their house had been completely destroyed as a result of the attack.
On 12 July 2022 a criminal investigation into the property in question was opened by the Security Service of Ukraine. On 05/10/2022 Ms Lyudmyla Khvostenko sought information on the progress of the investigation from the Ukrainian prosecutor’s office.
The passport of Mr Igor Dyadya; residence certificate issued by the local council in respect of Mr Igor Dyadya on 13/05/2022; title documents (inheritance certificate and extract from the real estate register dated 26/02/2021 – owned by Ms Lyudmyla Khvostenko); photos of the destroyed property (completely destroyed roof, partially destroyed outbuildings, killed poultry, debris in the yard); extract from the Ukrainian register of criminal investigations dated 12/07/2022; letter from the Zaporizhzhia Regional Prosecutor’s office dated October 2022; witness statements dated 21/10/2022 containing a detailed list of the furniture, household appliances, agricultural equipment and livestock that was destroyed at the applicants’ address from March until July 2022; envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region.
complete destruction
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the house in question was the applicants’ home as confirmed by the residence certificate dated 13/05/2022 in respect of Mr Igor Dyadya, which they had to abandon on 06/05/2022, and relocate to Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region (envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region).
30937/24
24/11/2022
Lyudmyla Borysivna CHUPAKHINA
1956
Private house (50.3 sq. m) and outbuildings at 54 Maria Sakhno St, Mali Scherbaky village, Vasylivskyi district, Zaporizhzhia region
Allegedly damaged by artillery shelling on 26/04/2022. At the end of August 2022, the applicant learned from her neighbours that the house had been entirely destroyed at the beginning of the same month.
On 12/07/2022 a criminal investigation into the property in question was opened by the Security Service of Ukraine.
On 26/09/2022 the applicant sought information on the progress of the investigation from the Security Service of Ukraine.
The applicant’s passport with a residence registration stamp for the private house; title documents (purchase agreement dated 30/06/2000; extract from the real estate register for a land plot dated 07/02/2022; technical passport); photos of the destroyed property (destroyed roof, partially destroyed external facade, everything covered in rubble, partially destroyed outbuildings); extract from the Ukrainian register of pre-trial investigations dated 12/07/2022; letter from the Security Service of Ukraine dated 18/10/2022; envelope with the address in Pavlivske village, Zaporizhzhia region.
complete destruction
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the house in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence stamp in her passport, which she had to abandon on 26/04/2022, and relocate to Pavlivske village, Zaporizhzhia region (envelope with the address in Pavlivske village, Zaporizhzhia region).
31385/24
16/09/2022
Abakar Isayevych ISAYEV
1981
Private house (114 sq. m) at 1/14 Ivana Franka St, Melitopol, Zaporizhzhia region
Allegedly damaged by hand grenades and grenade launcher fire on 26/07/2022.
The applicant learnt about the damage from his neighbour on 27/07/2022.
On 08/08/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police.
The applicant lost access to his property after fleeing from the occupied territory.
The applicant’s passport; residence certificate dated 05/09/2017; title documents (house purchase agreement and extract from the real estate register, both dated 27/09/2005, land plot purchase agreement dated 02/09/2005); photos of the damaged house (damaged ceiling, shrapnel damage to the walls, damaged doors, broken windows, belongings turned upside down, damage furniture); police report dated 08/08/2022; witness statements dated 05/09/2022; IDP certificate dated 05/08/2022.
damage, loss of access to property
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the house in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence certificate, which he was forced to abandon and relocate to Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region (IDP certificate dated 05/08/2022).
31707/24
12/10/2022
Leonid Fedorovych KAULKO
1952
Olga Mykolayivna KAULKO
1959
Private house (99.6 sq. m) with outbuildings at 13 Yuvileina St, Kamyanske village, Vasylivka district, Zaporizhzhia region
Allegedly damaged for the first time as a result of artillery shelling on 14/06/2022.
In July 2022 the applicants learned from their neighbours that their property had been destroyed in another shelling in mid-June 2022.
On 14/06/2022 the Security Service of Ukraine initiated criminal proceedings in respect of the destruction. On 25 July 2022 Mr Kaulko inquired with the Security Service of Ukraine about the progress of those proceedings.
The applicants’ passports (with a residence stamp for the apartment as regards Ms Kaulko); residence registration certificate dated 13/09/2021 and issued in respect of Mr Kaulko; marriage certificate dated 23/11/1987; title documents (joint ownership – ownership certificate dated 07/02/2008; technical passport dated 04/06/2007; ownership certificate for the land plot dated 25/02/1997); photos of the destroyed house (few walls left standing, entirely destroyed roof, everything covered in rubble); witness statements dated 07/10/2022 containing the list of destroyed furniture and other possessions; extract from the Ukrainian register of criminal investigations dated 14/06/2022; letter from the Security Service of Ukraine dated 24/08/2022; receipts for the purchase of construction materials; envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region.
complete destruction
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the house in question was the applicants’ home as confirmed by residence stamp in Ms Kaulko’s passport and residence registration certificate of Mr Kaulko, which they were forced to abandon on 14/04/2022 and relocate to Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region (envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region).
31759/24
24/10/2022
Dunata Stanislavivna KUZLO
1963
Ivan Oleksandrovych KUZLO
1956
(1) Private house (57.2 sq. m) with outbuildings at 16 Sakhno Marii St, Mali Shcherbaky village, Vasylivka district, Zaporizhzhia region,
(2) Agricultural equipment and livestock.
Allegedly damaged for the first time as a result of artillery shelling on 17/06/2022.
On 21/07/2022 the applicants learned from their neighbours that their property had been destroyed in another shelling in the end of June 2022. On the same day Mr Kuzlo lodged a complaint with the Security Service of Ukraine.
The applicants’ passports (with a residence stamp for the house as regards Mr Kuzlo); marriage certificate dated 05/11/1983; title documents (ownership certificate dated 18/08/2004; extract from the Bureau of Technical Inventory dated 01/10/2004; technical passport dated 01/10/2004; ownership certificate for the land plot dated 14/04/2011); photos of the destroyed house (completely ruined house, everything covered in rubble); extract from the Ukrainian register of criminal investigations dated 21/07/2022; witness statements confirming the fact of destruction and the applicants’ residence in the house dated 15/10/2022; envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region.
complete destruction
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the house in question was the applicants’ home as confirmed by the residence stamp in the passport of Mr Kuzlo and witness statements dated 15/10/2022, which they were forced to abandon on 06/05/2022 and relocate to Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region (envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region).
31863/24
12/09/2022
Kostyantyn Viktorovych PANTELEYEV
1967
Olena Mykolayivna PANTELEYEVA
1967
(1) Apartment no. 22 (53.8 sq. m) at 4 Kashtanovyi Blvd., Enerhodar, Zaporizhzhia region;
(2) Transportation vehicle (van) and trailer “SKIF”, 1987 year of release, registration number AP6480XO;
(3) Mercedes-Benz 814, 1997 year of release, registration number AP6975CI;
(4) Land plot (400 sq. m) at 651 Abrykosova St, garden society “Enthusiast”, Enerhodar, Zaporizhzhia region.
The applicants alleged that, following the occupation of Enerhodar by Russian forces on 04/03/2022, they had been forced to leave the city on 22/04/2022 and had thereby lost access to all their property.
On 19/08/2022 the applicants lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police about loss of access to their property.
The applicants’ passports with a residence stamp for the apartment; marriage certificate dated 14/10/1989; title documents (joint ownership – apartment: ownership certificate dated 13/01/2000 and technical passport dated 1999; vehicle registration certificates dated 16/03/2018 (van and trailer) and 01/02/2013 (Mercedes-Benz); membership ticket for the garden society “Enthusiast” dated 17/11/2002); extract from the register of individual entrepreneurs in respect of both applicants dated 22/08/2022; photos of the apartment prior to the applicants’ fleeing, depicting their personal belongings; photos of the vehicles; screenshot of the complaint lodged with the Ukrainian police dated 19/08/2022; screenshot of the online application to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation dated 18/08/2022; IDP certificates dated 16/05/2022.
loss of access to property
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the applicants complained that they had been forced to flee their home in Enerhodar, Zaporizhzhia region on 22/04/2022, and relocate to Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region (IDP certificates dated 16/05/2022).
32033/24
27/06/2022
Mariya Ivanivna AMELCHENKO
1962
Demyan Mykolayovych AMELCHENKO
1959
(1) Apartment no. 28 (64.8 sq. m) at 106A Melitopolske Highway, Berdiansk, Zaporizhzhia region;
(2) Apartment no. 1 (55.7 sq. m) at 97 Svobody St, Berdiansk, Zaporizhzhia region.
According to the applicants, on 03/03/2022 they were forced to leave their home owing to break-ins by Russian soldiers and the risk of shelling. The applicants lost access to their property after fleeing from the occupied territory.
The applicants’ passports (with a residence stamp for the apartment no. 28 as regards Ms Amelchenko and a residence stamp for the apartment no. 1 as regards Mr Amelchenko); title documents (apartment no. 28 – each applicant owns 1/3 share in the apartment: ownership certificate dated 22/01/1998 and technical passport dated 09/01/1998); apartment no. 1 – owned solely by Mr Amelchenko: inheritance certificate dated 26/12/2002, extract from the real estate register dated 29/01/2003, technical passport dated 12/11/1993); envelopes with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region.
loss of access to property
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the apartments in question were the applicants’ homes as confirmed by the residence stamps in their passports, which they were forced to abandon on 03/03/2022 and relocate to Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region (envelopes with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region).
32116/24
30/08/2022
Oleg Oleksandrovych NATUCHA
1975
Private house (59 sq. m) at 7A Zaporizka St, Orikhiv, Zaporizhzhia region
Allegedly damaged on 20/04/2022 by shelling.
The applicant lost access to his property after fleeing from Orikhiv owing to hostilities and repeated shelling.
The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the house in question; title documents (ownership certificate dated 13/06/2006, technical passport dated 08/09/2005); photos of the damaged house (damaged exterior wall, destroyed roof, broken windows, damaged ceiling, damaged household appliances, debris in the yard); victim’s interview report dated 18/08/2022; screenshot of the online application to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation without a date; receipts for the purchase of household appliances; envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region.
loss of access to property
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the house in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence stamp in his passport, which he was forced to abandon and relocate to Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region (envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region).
33701/24
18/08/2022
Iryna Oleksandrivna REUCHENKO
1958
Private house (62.6 sq. m) at 4 Pishchanyi Ln, Polohy, Zaporizhzhia region
Allegedly damaged by artillery shelling on 26/06/2022. On 09/08/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police.
The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the house in question dated 16/06/1982 and marriage stamp dated 24/04/1982; title documents (the applicant owns 1/2 share in the house – ownership certificate and extract from the real estate registry, both dated 01/07/2013); photos of the house after the damage (destroyed roof and exterior wall, damaged interior walls and furniture, broken windows and doors); extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 10/08/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint lodged on 09/08/2022; envelope with the address in Zhytomyr region.
damage, loss of access to property
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the house in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence stamp in her passport, which she was forced to abandon and relocate to Velyka Tsvilia, Novohrad-Volonskyi district, Zhytomyr region (envelope with the address in Zhytomyr region).
34352/24
25/10/2022
Viktor Grygorovych BABYCH
1961
Olga Mykolayivna BABYCH
1964
Private house (54.8 sq. m) and outbuildings (barn, cellar) at 52 Sakhno Marii St, Mali Shcherbaky village, Vasylivka district, Zaporizhzhia region
Allegedly damaged as a result of artillery shelling between 10/05/2022 and 25/05/2022, and then destroyed between June and July 2022. The applicants learnt about the destruction from their neighbours. On 04/07/2022 and 19/09/2022 the applicants lodged complaints with the Ukrainian police.
The applicants’ passports with the residence stamp for the private house; marriage certificate dated 17/07/1982; title documents (purchase agreement dated 30/12/1991; technical passport dated 25/02/2021; extract from the real estate register dated 21/02/2022); photos of the private house after the destruction (completely destroyed and reduced to rubble; few walls left; no windows left; destroyed roof; yard covered in rubble); extract from the register of pre-trial investigations, confirming the registration of the applicants’ complaint lodged on 04/07/2022; notification from the Ukrainian police dated 18/10/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint lodged on 19/09/2022; witness statement from the neighbours dated 19/10/2022, confirming that the private house was destroyed between March and July; envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region.
complete destruction
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the house in question was the applicants’ home as confirmed by the residence stamp in their passports, which they were forced to abandon and relocate to Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region (envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region).
34488/24
15/07/2022
Tetyana Sergiyivna KHMEL
1983
Private house (110 sq. m) at 13 Udarna St, Preobrazhenka village, Polohy district, Zaporizhzhia region
Allegedly damaged by artillery shelling on 21/05/2022. On 24/06/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police.
The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the house dated 06/11/2007; title documents (the applicant owns ½ share in the house – deed of gift dated 29/10/2010, extract from the real estate register 11/11/2010); photos of the house after the damage (windows and doors broken, damaged roof and fence); extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 24/06/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint lodged on the same date.
damage, loss of access to property
Art. 8 (1) - interference with the right to home - the house in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence stamp in her passport dated 06/11/2007, which she was forced to abandon and relocate to Chernivtsi region (envelope with the address in Chernivtsi, Chernivtsi region).
35318/24
15/08/2022
Dmytro Valeriyovych KOVALYOV
1975
Denys Dmytrovych KOVALYOV
1998
Oksana Oleksandrivna KOVALYOVA
1975
(1) Apartments nos. 8 (85.96 sq. m) and 11 (64.43 sq. m) at 6 Pushkina St, Pryazovske, Pryazovske district, Zaporizhzhia region;
(2) Land plots in Pryazovske district, Zaporizhzhia region: in Pryazovske (0.0069 ha; 0.0063 ha; 0.01 ha; 0.0196 ha; 5.8702 ha; 6.0000 ha; 6.5901 ha; 6.8500 ha; 7.00 ha; 7.62 ha; 7.78 ha; 8.7300 ha (4 land plots of this size); 12,6798 ha; 19.2001 ha; 44.3808 ha); in Stepanivka Persha (0.1500 ha); in Botiieve (0.1200 ha (2 land plots of this size)); in Prymorsko-Posadskyi Village Council (7.7800 ha).
The applicants fled Pryazovske on 07/04/2022 and 22/04/2022, and have since lost access to their property in the occupied territory.
The applicants’ passports with residence stamps for the apartments; marriage certificate confirming marriage between Mr Dmytro Kovalyov and Ms Oksana Kovalyova on 31/08/1996; title documents (apartment no. 8: joint ownership of Mr Dmytro Kovalyov and Ms Oksana Kovalyova – extract from the real estate register dated 11/06/2018; apartment no. 11: Mr Dmytro Kovalyov and Ms Oksana Kovalyova own ¼ share each, Mr Denys Kovalyov owns ½ share in the apartment – ownership certificate dated 23/09/2002; land plots – joint ownership of Mr Dmytro Kovalyov and Ms Oksana Kovalyova: ownership certificates 04/04/2003; 13/12/2006; 20/03/2007; 04/07/2007; 12/11/2007; 04/12/2007; 15/01/2008; 21/01/2008; 18/02/2008; 20/02/2008, and extract from the real estate register concerning ownership of a land plot (7.78 ha)); IDP certificates issued in Zaporizhzhia region on 26/04/2022 (Mr Dmytro Kovalyov) and in Chernivtsi region (Ms Kovalyova) on 07/06/2022.
loss of access to property
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the apartments in question were homes of Mr Dmytro Kovalyov and Ms Oksana Kovalyova, as confirmed by the residence stamps in their passports, which they had been forced to abandon on 07/04/2022 and 26/04/2022 respectively, and relocate to Chernivtsi and Zaporizhzhia city (IDP certificates dated 26/04/2022 and 07/06/2022).
36138/24
12/07/2022
Nelya Valeriyivna GRYSHCHENKO
1977
Private house (52.3 sq. m) and outbuildings (toilet, summer kitchen, garage) at 35 Luhova (previously Chervonoarmiiska) St, Huliaipole, Polohy district, Zaporizhzhia region
The house was allegedly damaged and the garage was allegedly destroyed on 31/05/2022. On 06/06/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Zaporizhzhia Regional Prosecutor’s Office.
The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the private house; title documents (house: purchase agreement dated 15/08/2005, extract from the real estate register dated 25/08/2005, technical passport dated 18/05/2000; land plot: extract from the real estate register dated 01/09/2021); photos of the severely damaged house (destroyed roof, broken windows and destroyed window openings, damaged exterior walls, damaged fence, the garage destroyed to the ground); complaint to the regional prosecutor’s office dated 06/06/2022; letter from the Ukrainian police dated 30/06/2022 confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint; application to the Zaporizhzhia Administrative Services Centre with the request to record the destruction; screenshot of the application about destruction of property submitted via the DIIA website dated 06/06/2022; IDP certificate dated 29/04/2022.
damage
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the house in question was the applicant’s home, as confirmed by the residence stamp in her passport, which she was forced to abandon and relocate to Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region (IDP certificate dated 29/04/2022).
36215/24
27/10/2022
Valentyna Vasylivna KRYVOBOK
1969
Viktor Oleksiyovych KRYVOBOK
1956
(1) Private house (65.7 sq. m) and grain warehouse (312.2 sq. m) at 36 Pershotravneva St, Mali Shcherbaky, Vasylivka district, Zaporizhzhia region;
(2) Tractor MT3-80, 1987 year of release, registration no. 01581AP.
Allegedly damaged as a result of artillery shelling from 03/03/2022 to 01/05/2022, and then destroyed between May and August 2022. The applicants learnt about the destruction from their neighbours.
The applicants’ passports with a residence stamp for the private house; marriage certificate dated 28/05/1988; title documents (joint ownership: purchase agreement for the house and warehouse dated 05/08/2002 and extract from the real estate register dated 24/06/2019; extract from the real estate register for the land plot dated 05/07/2021; vehicle registration certificate dated 12/02/2009); photos of severely damaged property (warehouse roof completely destroyed; house damaged and covered in rubble); witness statements indicating that destruction occurred between March and July 2022, dated 19/10/2022; envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region.
complete destruction
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the house in question was the applicants’ home, as confirmed by the residence stamp in their passports, which they were forced to abandon and relocate to Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region (envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region).
36411/24
19/09/2022
Iryna Oleksandrivna SLISARENKO
1985
Private house (n/a) at 184 Lesi Ukrainky (previously – Krupskoi) St, Polohy, Zaporizhzhia region
Allegedly damaged by artillery shelling on 22/05/2022.
The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the private house; title documents (ownership certificate of a land plot dated 28/11/2014; extract from the real estate register dated 29/05/2014); photos of the house prior to its damage, showing the interior of the house and elements of applicant’s daily life; photos of the house after the damage (damaged roof and external facade; explosion holes in the walls; broken windows); envelope with the address in Kyiv, Kyiv region.
damage
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the house in question was the applicant’s home, as confirmed by the residence stamp in her passport and photos of the house taken prior to its damage, which she was forced to abandon and relocate to Kyiv, Kyiv region (envelope with the address in Kyiv, Kyiv region).
36635/24
30/06/2022
Sergiy Andriyovych TARASENKO
1949
Lyubov Oleksiyivna TARASENKO
1950
Apartment no. 1 (67.3 sq. m) at 7 Robocha St, Novozlatopil, Polohy district, Zaporizhzhia region
Allegedly destroyed on 27/03/2022 by artillery shelling and the Hrad MLRS.
The applicants’ passports with residence stamps for the apartment; title documents (joint ownership, each applicant owns ½ share – ownership certificate and technical passport dated 03/08/1995); witness statements dated 25/06/2022; envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region.
complete destruction
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the apartment in question was the applicants’ home, as confirmed by the residence stamps in their passports, which they were forced to abandon on 27/03/2022 and relocate to Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region (envelope with the address in Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region).
36764/24
01/08/2022
Valentyna Mykhaylivna NYKONOVA
1951
Anna Sergiyivna Zhegulina
Kyiv
(1) Private house (115.5 sq. m) at 33 Tsentralna St, Kamyanske village, Vasylivka district, Zaporizhzhia region;
(2) Private house (30.8 sq. m) at 126 Kakhovska St, Kamyanske village, Vasylivka district, Zaporizhzhia region
Allegedly damaged as a result of artillery shelling on 05/04/2022 and 30/05/2022.
On 30/06/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Security Service of Ukraine.
The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the private house no. 33; title documents (house no. 33: technical passport dated 27/01/2009, deed of gift and extract from the real estate register dated 28/04/2020; house no. 126: technical passport dated 21/01/1999; purchase agreement and extract from the real estate register dated 19/06/2020); photos of the damaged private house no. 33 (destroyed roof, burnt to the ground) and private house no. 126 (damaged roof); expert evaluation reports for the houses dated 29/06/2022;
complaint to the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation dated 18/07/2022; letter from the Security Service of Ukraine dated 19/07/2022; extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 15/07/2022; decision on recognising the applicant as a victim in criminal proceedings dated 18/07/2022; witness statements dated 12/07/2022 and 19/07/2022; IDP certificate dated 30/04/2022.
damage
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine – the house at 33 Tsentralna St was the applicant’s home, as confirmed by the residence stamp in her passport, which she was forced to abandon and relocate to Zaporizhzhia city, Zaporizhzhia region (IDP certificate dated 30/04/2022).
36824/24
05/07/2022
Maksym Vasylyovych KANDYBA
1979
Private house at 26 Hvardiiskoi Striletskoi Dyvizii St, Orikhiv, Zaporizhzhia region
Allegedly damaged as a result of artillery shelling on 28/04/2022.
The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the private house; title document (extract from the real estate register dated 01/07/2008); photos of the private house after the damage (damaged roof and external facade; broken windows; damaged interior walls and furniture; rooms and yard covered in rubble); envelope with the address in Turiisk, Volyn region.
damage
Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the house in question was the applicant’s home, as confirmed by the residence stamp in his passport, which he was forced to abandon and relocate to Turiisk, Volyn region (envelope with the address in Turiisk, Volyn region).
2996/25
23/08/2022
Vitaliy Viktorovych POROKHNYA
1985
Private house (44.7 sq. m) at 82 Michurina St, Polohy, Zaporizhzhia region
Allegedly destroyed as a result of rocket fire from a Hrad MLRS and mortar shelling on 17/04/2022.
On 24/06/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian prosecutor’s office.
The applicant’s passport; title documents (house purchase agreement dated 28/10/2011, extract from the real estate register dated 31/10/2011, technical passport dated 21/08/2011); photos of the destroyed house (destroyed roof, fire inside the house, burned down inside); police report dated 24/06/2022; screenshot of the online application to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation without a date.
complete destruction