Communicated on 15 May 2020
Published on 22 June 2020
FIRST SECTION
Application no. 79696/13
Giacomo PANSITTA and Others
against Italy
lodged on 28 November 2013
SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE
The applicants, members of the Revenue Police (Guardia di Finanza), complain about the ban provided by law (section 1475 § 2 of the Legislative Decree no. 66/2010) to form trade unions. By judgment no. 120 of 7 June 2018, the Constitutional Court confirmed the unconstitutionality of the above mentioned provisions.
QUESTIONS TO THE PARTIES
1. Does the interference with the applicants’ freedom of association, in particular their right to form trade unions, provided for by section 1475 § 2 of the Legislative Decree no. 66/2010 (Military Code), constitute a violation of Article 11 § 1 of the Convention (see Matelly v. France, no. 10609/10, 2 October 2014, Demir and Baykara v. Turkey [GC], no. 34503/97, ECHR 2008 and National Union of Belgian Police v. Belgium, 27 October 1975, § 39, Series A no. 19 )?
In particular, did the alleged interference in the present case fall within the State’s margin of appreciation in the organisation of its armed forces, to which reference is expressly made in Article 11 § 2?
Were the applicants - before judgment no. 120 of 7 June 2018 of the Constitutional Court - prevented from carrying out any associative activities?
In that context, reference is made to the Constitutional Court’s case-law, according to which, under the old legal framework, while the military were denied the freedom to form trade unions, they were allowed certain activities, by way of specific bodies (see § 7 of the above mentioned judgment, which refers to judgment no 449 of 1999, § 3).
2. Have the applicants suffered discrimination contrary to Article 14 of the Convention, read in conjunction with Article 11?
In particular, have the applicants been subjected to a difference in treatment compared to other public servants belonging to State Police forces (Polizia di Stato), which are not prevented from forming trade unions? Is the different status between members of Polizia di Stato (civilians) and of Guardia di Finanza (military) merely formal?
If so, did that difference in treatment pursue a legitimate aim; and did it have a reasonable justification?
3. Can the applicants be still considered victims of the alleged violations of Articles 11 and 14 of the Convention in the light of the Constitutional Court judgment of 2018 no. 120, declaring the constitutional illegitimacy of Article 1475, paragraph 2, of the legislative Decree no. 66 of 15 March 2010 (Military Code), which now reads “Military personnel may form professional associations of a trade union nature under the conditions and within the limits fixed by law; they cannot join external union associations"?
4. Did the applicants have at their disposal, both before and after the above Constitutional Court’s judgment, an effective remedy for their complaints under Articles 11 and 14 of the Convention, as required by Article 13 of the Convention?
In particular, did the applicants have an effective remedy before the Regional Administrative Court (TAR) and could the TAR have interpreted the pre-existing legislative framework by recognizing the right in question, notwithstanding the disputed provisions, taking into account the decision of the Council of State no. 5845 of 2017 which recognised the military the right to register for a political party and the right to be elected with the limit of assuming a political office?.
APPENDIX
No.
Applicant’s Name
Birth date
Place of residence
1
Giacomo PANSITTA
04/04/1971
TRANI
2
Nunzio ABATE
01/10/1964
BERNALDA
3
Gianluca ACQUAVIVA
24/05/1968
MONTEIASI
4
Antonio ADDESSE
20/03/1976
SCOPPITO (AQ)
5
Marcello ADINOLFI
07/11/1966
VERONA
6
Roberto AGASUCCI
22/05/1969
SULMONA
7
Cosimo Vito ALBANO
31/01/1958
ASTI
8
Pierluigi ALBERTINI
16/05/1967
TROFARELLO (TO)
9
Luigi ALEARDI
05/09/1972
PREGANZIOL (TV)
10
Rocco ALESSIO
08/02/1967
TORINO
11
Claudio AMATO
16/10/1965
MONTE SAN VITO (AN)
12
Giorgio ANGELINO
28/11/1981
TORINO
13
Lucio ANNARUMMA
11/06/1973
POTENZA
14
Nicola APICELLA
26/10/1964
RIVOLI (TO)
15
Pierpaolo ARNOLD
06/12/1967
LATINA
16
Luigi ARZANO
17/09/1985
CARINARO (CE)
17
Nicola BALBO
04/05/1981
MARCIANISE (CE)
18
Danilo BALDONI
09/03/1972
PISA
19
Giovanni BARRALE
24/03/1964
REGGIO EMILIA
20
Basilio BARRECA
09/10/1964
REGGIO CALABRIA
21
Luca BARTALONI
04/01/1964
GIGNOD (AO)
22
Bruno BARTOLONI
08/10/1964
ROMA
23
Alessio BASILI
20/12/1974
PRATO
24
Leandro BATTAGLIA
30/10/1970
MORGEX (AO)
25
Giulio BATTAGLINI
25/06/1968
ROMA
26
Manuel Maria BELISARDI
11/11/1979
CASTELLETTO MONFERRATO (AL)
27
Nicola BELLOPEDE
15/06/1969
SAN MARCELLINO (CE)
28
Dino BERALDO
13/12/1967
SONA (VR)
29
Sergio BERNARDINI
08/10/1971
DOLO (VE)
30
Franco BERTAGNOLLI
17/06/1963
CEVA (CN)
31
Antonio BEVACQUA
29/08/1967
SETTINGIANO (CZ)
32
Cesare BIANCHI
14/12/1961
TRIESTE
33
Christian BIANCO
19/12/1978
MONOPOLI (BA)
34
Alessandro BIZZARRI
21/03/1975
CAPISTRELLO (AQ)
35
Gaetano BLASI
10/03/1977
TARANTO
36
Marco BOCCACCI
03/11/1962
ROMA
37
Luca BOERO
27/04/1975
GENOVA
38
Mauro BORGHINO
10/04/1970
SAN SALVATORE MONFERRATO (AL)
39
Mauro BORRELLI
15/03/1979
ZOLA PREDOSA (BO)
40
Giovanni BORSCI
20/01/1960
MONTEPARANO (TA)
41
Luigi BRAMATO
04/02/1964
MIGGIANO (LE)
42
Carmelo BUCCA
26/07/1963
BARCELLONA POZZO DI GOTTO (ME)
43
Giovanni BUONAIUTO
10/04/1968
RONCO BIELLESE (BI)
44
Filippo CADDEO
11/08/1978
QUARTU SANT’ELENA (CA)
45
Salvatore CAIAZZA
09/12/1975
PIOLTELLO (MI)
46
Luca CAIONE
24/04/1966
LECCE
47
Giovanni CALABRESE
16/06/1975
CASTELLAMMARE DI STABIA (NA)
48
Rosario CALANDRINO
05/08/1985
SEGRATE (MI)
49
Massimo CALATI
04/11/1970
LEPORANO (TA)
50
Francesco CALENZO
28/12/1976
MASSAFRA (TA)
51
Stefano CALLAI
19/12/1976
VIDIGULFO (PV)
52
Raffaele CAMBERLINGO
29/08/1964
BATTIPAGLIA (SA)
53
Luca CAMILOTTO
05/08/1965
ALESSANDRIA
54
Bartolomeo CAMMARINO
12/02/1977
TRIESTE
55
Emanuele Concetto CAMPAGNA
25/02/1990
ANCONA
56
Riccardo CAMPANELLI
13/08/1972
AOSTA
57
Pasquale CANNAVACCIUOLO
26/10/1972
TARANTO
58
Roberto CANNAVALE
13/02/1964
ROMA
59
Aristide CANOVA
17/02/1974
AOSTA
60
Enrico CANTA
03/02/1978
TERRACINA (LT)
61
Raffaele CAPASSO
03/08/1970
ROMA
62
Piercarlo CAPPELLINO
16/05/1960
RIVOLI (TO)
63
Patrick CAPRI
29/11/1971
SAN CANDIDO (BZ)
64
Davide CARANNANTE
24/06/1972
SETTALA (MI)
65
Tommaso CARBONE
20/10/1973
VICOPISANO (PI)
66
Michele Antonio CARETTO
27/02/1957
SAN GIOVANNI TEATINO (CH)
67
Antonio CARFORA
13/06/1969
GROTTAGLIE (TA)
68
Massimo CARLESI
19/12/1965
ROMA
69
Claudio CARLINI
05/09/1974
PONDERANO (BI)
70
Giuseppe CAROLI
30/05/1972
MONTEIASI (TA)
71
Luigi CARROZZO MAGLI
24/06/1965
CASCINA (PI)
72
Giuseppe CASAMASSIMA
22/05/1984
TARANTO
73
Luigi Matteo CASCAVILLO
05/07/1970
VERZUOLO (CN)
74
Arcangelo CASO
26/04/1973
VICO EQUENSE (NA)
75
Stefano CASTELLI
23/10/1963
SAN PIETRO IN CASALE (BO)
76
Stefania CASTRICONE
12/05/1973
ROMA
77
Gennaro Ciro CAVALIERE
31/01/1981
GROTTAGLIE (TA)
78
Amedeo Salvatore CELENTANO
18/04/1967
ROMA
79
Giuseppe CERCHIO
13/07/1981
LATINA
80
Vincenzo CETANI
23/01/1958
POTENZA
81
Loris CHIARAMELLO
22/12/1966
CUNEO
82
Mario CHIOCCINI
20/10/1966
EBOLI (SA)
83
Vittorio CICCHIELLO
23/08/1976
GROTTAGLIE (TA)
84
Luca CICERO
28/11/1972
SAN GIOVANNI IN FIORE (CS)
85
Francesco CILIONE
16/10/1981
REGGIO CALABRIA
86
Giuseppe CIMINO
03/06/1975
CATANIA
87
Agostino CIMMINO
08/11/1970
CATANIA
88
Francesco CIOLA
07/01/1962
FALCONARA MARITTIMA (AN)
89
Domenico CIPOLLA
02/11/1975
GIZZERIA (CZ)
90
Massimo CIPOLLA
03/08/1970
TORINO
91
Vincenzo CLEMENTE
13/06/1974
REGGIO CALABRIA
92
Marcello COFINI
11/03/1963
ROMA
93
Salvatore COLANGELO
02/08/1971
BERGAMO
94
Piero COLAZZO
13/07/1965
ANCONA
95
Roberto COLETTA
19/01/1974
AOSTA
96
Alessandro COMITINI
10/05/1964
CAGLIARI
97
Raffaele Marco CONCAS
13/03/1974
SANGANO (TO)
98
Antonino CONIGLIO
15/03/1972
BARONISSI (SA)
99
Alessandro COPPOLA
24/10/1978
PAVONE CANAVESE (TO)
100
Angela COPPOLA
14/03/1984
SANT’ANTONIO ABATE (NA)
101
Massimo CORCHIA
27/07/1966
TARANTO
102
Giovanni Angelo CORDOVA
21/07/1965
FRUGAROLO (AL)
103
Davide CORSARO
15/01/1973
SEGRATE (MI)
104
Francesco COSCIA
07/08/1975
TORINO
105
Massimo COSTA
16/06/1973
SEGRATE (MI)
106
Salvatore COZZOLINO
28/04/1968
LECCE
107
Giuseppe CROCAMO
25/02/1972
BARDONECCHIA (TO)
108
Maurizio CUCCI
01/05/1970
FERMO
109
Giovanni CULICI
26/06/1969
PIANEZZA (TO)
110
Luigi CUOMO
26/08/1971
BARI
111
Patrizio CUOMO
24/02/1964
ARICCIA (RM)
112
Pierangelo CURRI
30/10/1981
LOCOROTONDO (BA)
113
Giovanni CUTRUPI
01/01/1967
APRILIA (LT)
114
Luca D’APOLLONIO
11/06/1975
VENEZIA
115
Franco D’AVANZO
26/05/1968
LEPORANO (TA)
116
Giuseppe D’ERCHIE
03/04/1959
CRISPIANO (TA)
117
Marco D’ADDIO
23/03/1975
BARI
118
Nicola D’ALBA
17/06/1976
VENTIMIGLIA
119
Ugo Raffaele DALLERICE
06/11/1957
ANDORA (SV)
120
Felice D’AURIA
18/10/1970
GALLARATE (VA)
121
Rosario DE DOMINICIS
30/06/1962
SOMMA VESUVIANA (NA)
122
Ippazio DE MATTEIS
04/12/1964
CASARANO (LE)
123
Domenico DE PINTO
08/07/1962
PALAZZOLO SULL’OGLIO (BS)
124
Corrado DE RUVO
23/10/1961
BISCEGLIE (BT)
125
Antonio DE VENEZIA
25/09/1961
ROMA
126
Domenico DEL SORBO
05/01/1962
CASTELLAMMARE DI STABIA (NA)
127
Dario DELLA PORTA
04/01/1970
LATIANO (BR)
128
Giorgio DENARO
20/02/1969
CANDELO (BI)
129
Daniele DI CHIO
17/01/1963
MACERATA
130
Enrico DI DIO
22/10/1975
MESSINA
131
Rocco DI FILIPPO
21/08/1972
SIANO (SA)
132
Cosimo DI FONZO
26/02/1970
CASTELLANETA (TA)
133
Felice Ruggero DI LELLO
03/10/1974
QUARTU SANT’ELENA (CA)
134
Vincenzo DI MATTEO
22/03/1958
RIETI
135
Pasquale DI NARDO
16/07/1970
MONZA
136
Emiliano DI SEGNA
25/08/1973
POSTALESIO (SO)
137
Angelo DITTA
26/07/1973
LECCE
138
Donatello DODARO
12/07/1972
MONTALTO UFFUGO (CS)
139
Angelo EFRATI
14/04/1974
AYMAVILLES (AO)
140
Antonino ESPOSITO
10/05/1975
GRUGLIASCO (TO)
141
Leondino ESPOSITO
03/02/1972
TRIESTE
142
Michele ESPOSITO
05/09/1969
ROMA
143
Stefano FALCONE
27/01/1969
SILANDRO (BZ)
144
Paolo FALZETTI
26/12/1964
ASTI
145
Domenico FARETRA
13/11/1964
COMO
146
Francesco FARINA
29/03/1967
APRILIA (LT)
147
Roberto FEDELE
13/10/1967
TRIVIGNANO UDINESE (UD)
148
Cristiano FEDERICI
21/08/1970
CASTEL GIORGIO (TR)
149
Carmine FERRANTE
17/06/1970
CASTEL FRENTANO
150
Natalino FERRI
05/04/1960
POLIGNANO A MARE (BA)
151
Paolo FESTA
18/03/1983
TORINO
152
Giuseppe FILIPPO
20/06/1972
SAN BENEDETTO ULLANO (CS)
153
Maurizio FILIPPONE
30/09/1969
NOVARA
154
Paolo FINETTI
25/05/1967
POGGIO RUSCO (MN)
155
Roberto FIORI
14/07/1974
CASTELSARDO (SS)
156
Stefano FOIANO
07/05/1957
GENOVA
157
Gianluca FORCELLINO
17/11/1973
ROMA
158
Joseph FORGIONE
03/02/1968
PREZZA (AQ)
159
Pasquale FRANCIOSO
28/03/1971
GALATONE (LE)
160
Donato FRATIANNI
11/05/1968
ROMA
161
Massimo FUSCO
17/06/1975
MARINO (RM)
162
Antonio FUSILLI
13/06/1960
BARI
163
Manielo GALASSO
14/02/1975
NONANTOLA (MO)
164
Giuseppe GALLINA
30/03/1969
GIANO VETUSTO (CE)
165
Armando GALLUCCI
01/05/1972
AIELLO DEL FRIULI (UD)
166
Alberico GAMBINO
03/10/1962
LORETO (AN)
167
Salvatore GENOVESE
21/09/1973
URGNANO (BG)
168
Luciano GERVASI
22/01/1962
GALLIATE (NO)
169
Antonio GIANNUZZI
15/05/1958
PALO DEL COLLE (BA)
170
Giuseppe GIORDANO
06/03/1964
ACQUI TERME (AL)
171
Basilio GIUFFRIDA
02/08/1957
MONFALCONE (GO)
172
Paolo GOZZERINI
11/11/1963
UDINE
173
Vincenzo GRASSO
05/04/1966
LECCE
174
Teresa GRAVANTE
05/01/1982
PESCHIERA BORROMEO (MI)
175
Marco GRAZIANO
21/06/1969
TORINO
176
Raffaele GRAZIANO
24/04/1975
SAN GIORGIO JONICO (TA)
177
Marco GRAZIOLI
22/10/1961
TORINO
178
Martino GRECO
16/04/1974
TRIVERO (BI)
179
Michele GUERRA
13/08/1977
MEDOLE (MN)
180
Gaetano GUERRIERO
11/12/1963
MARCIANISE (CE)
181
Alessandro GUTTUSO
11/02/1977
CAGLIARI
182
Cleto IAFRATE
22/09/1966
PALAGIANO (TA)
183
Massimo IERO
04/10/1971
S. STEFANO IN ASPROMONTE (RC)
184
Antonio IEZZI
25/01/1970
CAPRANICA (VT)
185
Gaetano INSINNA
16/06/1964
MILANO
186
Massimo LA GATTA
26/07/1974
ZELO BUON PERSICO (LO)
187
Giovanni LAI
18/04/1975
TORINO
188
Davide LANFRANCO
08/03/1975
SERMONETA (LT)
189
Gianni LASTELLA
30/10/1959
MILANO
190
Michele LAURO
15/10/1971
MESSINA
191
Simone LEDDA
15/06/1976
TORINO
192
Rosario Antonio LEONARDO
27/02/1968
TARANTO
193
Massimo Verdo LEONETTI
27/07/1972
AOSTA
194
Diego Mario LIBERTO
24/11/1968
VENARIA REALE (TO)
195
Filippo LO PRESTI
26/09/1969
LAMEZIA TERME (CZ)
196
Silvestro LO PRESTI
16/09/1963
LACES (BZ)
197
Davide LODDO
15/08/1976
TORINO
198
Massimo LOFFREDI
01/12/1967
ROCCA DI PAPA (RM)
199
Antonio LOMBARDI
17/09/1969
ROMA
200
Vincenzo LOMBARDO
24/09/1957
FIUMEFREDDO DI SICILIA (CT)
201
Luigi LOSASSO
05/06/1963
ROMA
202
Giovanni MAGLIE
12/06/1969
TARANTO
203
Giovanni MAGLIOLI
01/02/1978
SUCCIVO (CE)
204
Michele MAJORANA
17/03/1968
TERMOLI
205
Arnaldo MALVASO
10/02/1959
CATANZARO
206
Roberto MANCINI
03/08/1971
TORINO
207
Vincenzo MANDARANO
18/01/1965
VARZO (VB)
208
Marco MANGIACAPRA
14/06/1984
SIMERI CRICHI (CZ)
209
Giacomo MANNINO
22/09/1975
SOVERATO (CZ)
210
Bruno MARENCO
27/07/1967
QUARGNENTO (AL)
211
Alessandro MARGIOTTA
17/02/1963
BUDRIO (BO)
212
Andrea MARONGIU
15/07/1972
NOVARA
213
Alessandro MARRA
11/04/1979
ROMA
214
Valerio MARTINO
28/08/1967
CEVA (CN)
215
Ignazio MARTIRADONNA
10/12/1965
VARESE
216
Ilenia MARZO
20/02/1980
TORINO
217
Luca MASPERO
13/01/1967
TORINO
218
Maurizio MASSARENTI
28/03/1963
TORINO
219
Biagio MASTRANGELO
16/11/1986
PUTIGNANO (BA)
220
Gaetano MATRECANO
17/08/1960
SENIGALLIA (AN)
221
Vincenzo MATTEO
03/01/1961
ROMA
222
Marco MAURO
03/07/1975
TORINO
223
Giovanni MAZZARELLA
03/03/1964
FROSSASCO (TO)
224
Paolo MAZZEO
06/11/1973
CASIER (TV)
225
Francesco MAZZOCCHI
04/01/1971
ASSEMENI
226
Luigi Antonio MELIS
01/05/1969
NICHELINO (TO)
227
Luca MELLO
16/09/1967
CAMERANO (AN)
228
Sergio MELONI
04/12/1979
TORINO
229
Marco MENEGAZZO
09/04/1968
MILANO
230
Gian Luca MEOLA
17/04/1973
ROMA
231
Giampaolo MERLANO
13/03/1966
TASSAROLO (AL)
232
Cirino MICELI
08/07/1966
GROTTAGLIE (TA)
233
Americo MIGLIACCIO
31/03/1971
SERIATE (BG)
234
Domenico MILANESIO
18/02/1962
CUNEO
235
Giovanni MINIERI
10/02/1974
POZZUOLO MARTESANA (MI)
236
Angelo MONTRANO
01/03/1964
GIVOLETTO (TO)
237
Emanuele MORCIANO
22/09/1981
CAVALLINO (LE)
238
Mauro MORELLI
13/09/1962
SARRE (AO)
239
Alessio MORONI
07/04/1977
ROMA
240
Arturo MOZZILLO
06/08/1974
ORTA DI ATELLA (CE)
241
Giuseppe MUGNO
07/03/1964
LENTINI
242
Salvatore MUNDO
03/07/1976
TORINO
243
Pierluigi MUOIO
05/12/1981
TORINO
244
Giuseppe MURRI
16/08/1960
BRINDISI
245
Giovanni MUSELLA
05/09/1959
LATINA
246
Graziano NADILE
02/05/1968
SIDERNO (RC)
247
Luciano NAPOLITANO
25/12/1964
BANCHETTE (TO)
248
Felice NARDIELLO
09/02/1970
ACIREALE (CT)
249
Raffaele NARDONE
23/12/1961
ROMA
250
Donato NARDUCCI
05/06/1973
OLBIA (OT)
251
Germano NATRELLA
13/07/1970
L’AQUILA
252
Giuseppe NATUZZI
10/06/1971
PISTICCI (MT)
253
Daniele NEGRO
28/12/1974
COLLEGNO (TO)
254
Michele OLIVO
06/08/1974
SANTA MARIA LA CARITÀ (NA)
255
Michele Sandokan ORTODOSSO
23/03/1976
CAGLIARI
256
Lorenzo PACELLA
07/03/1968
BARI
257
Mario PAESANI
03/12/1970
SARRE (AO)
258
Luigi PAGLIARO
19/06/1973
RIVOLI (TO)
259
Luigi PALMA
18/05/1963
FORMIA (LT)
260
Pietro PALMAS
12/05/1962
COMO
261
Giuseppe PALMISANO
11/10/1963
BRINDISI
262
Luigi PALUMBO
12/09/1966
BORGIA (CZ)
263
Salvatore Giuseppe PANTALEO
11/04/1979
CARPIANO (MI)
264
Antonio PARADISO
21/02/1960
TARANTO
265
Tommaso PARADISO
18/04/1972
NOVOLI (LE)
266
Lucio PARISI
13/12/1962
MONDOVÌ (CN)
267
Pierpaolo PASCALICCHIO
23/01/1978
NARDÒ (LE)
268
Antonio PATACCOLI
03/11/1972
PESCINA (AQ)
269
Pasquale PATELLA
17/05/1978
GAETA (LT)
270
Domenico PAVONE
28/01/1966
CASELLE TORINESE (TO)
271
Andrea PERONE
04/12/1969
BONEA (BN)
272
Vincenzo PERULLI
18/09/1962
CAVALLINO (LE)
273
Mario Vito PESCE
20/04/1975
RUSSI (RA)
274
Silvio PETRELLI
10/03/1969
PRATO
275
Giovanni PETTERUTI
28/11/1970
TARANTO
276
Guglielmo PICCIUTO
29/08/1964
SPINEA (VE)
277
Pasquale PINTO
07/03/1975
LATINA
278
Mariano PIRAS
24/05/1964
ROMA
279
Fabrizio PISANO
02/12/1976
CAPOTERRA (CA)
280
Paolo PISCITELLI
19/11/1973
ORBASSANO (TO)
281
Matteo PIZZI
07/01/1983
MONTJOVET (AO)
282
Francesco POLLIFRONE
27/11/1965
CHIERI (TO)
283
Rinaldo POMPILI
12/09/1960
GROSSETO
284
Lorenzo PONTILLO
29/09/1977
MARCON (VE)
285
Vincenzo PONZO
03/12/1962
POTENZA
286
Renzo PORFIRIO
03/03/1960
GIULIANOVA (TE)
287
Piero PORTALURI
03/12/1975
CORIGLIANO CALABRO (CS)
288
Salvatore POSA
06/07/1970
MASSAFRA (TA)
289
Luca POVERO
19/07/1972
MAZZÉ (TO)
290
Carmelo PRATICÒ
10/05/1969
CREMONA
291
Nicola PUCILLO
03/10/1969
POTENZA
292
Piero PUOZZO
02/08/1972
AOSTA
293
Giuseppe QUARTA
18/05/1970
MELENDUGNO (LE)
294
Giovanni RACANATI
19/10/1970
BARI
295
Carolina RAFFAELE
15/05/1980
CATANZARO
296
Luca RAGOZZINO
09/10/1972
BRINDISI
297
Enrico RAIMONDI
22/12/1967
ALGHERO (SS)
298
Fabrizio RICCHIELLO
18/07/1969
VERRÈS (AO)
299
Vincenzo RICCIARDI
02/05/1969
AOSTA
300
Pasquale Maurizio RICCIO
08/04/1964
ROMA
301
Bruno RIPEPI
09/06/1970
MEDA (MB)
302
Antonio RIZZO
28/10/1973
NARDÒ (LE)
303
Carlo RIZZO
28/02/1970
ROMA
304
Michele ROCA
24/02/1974
TORINO (TO)
305
Christian ROLLI
30/05/1973
ROMA
306
Antonino ROMEO
01/01/1972
REGGIO CALABRIA
307
Michele ROMONDIA
24/12/1968
VICO DEL GARGANO (FG)
308
Emiliano ROSSI
16/04/1976
ROMA
309
Filippo ROVETTO
01/01/1967
PINEROLO (TO)
310
Francesco RUSSO
16/12/1975
TRIESTE
311
Gaetano RUSSO
21/04/1968
MANDURIA (TA)
312
Mario RUSSO
04/03/1961
OSIMO (AN)
313
Eugenio SABATINO
11/05/1975
ROMA
314
Orazio SACCÀ
20/11/1972
CAROSINO (TA)
315
Michele SACCO
11/06/1969
GROTTAGLIE (TA)
316
Massimiliano SALCE
03/01/1964
L’AQUILA
317
Attilio SALESE
06/04/1967
TORINO
318
Vincenzo SALZANO
13/01/1984
AFRAGOLA (NA)
319
Flavio SANNA
08/12/1976
TORINO
320
Simone SANSONI
30/10/1972
COLLEGNO (TO)
321
Frank SANTINI
31/08/1962
TAGLIACOZZO (AQ)
322
Maurizio SANTO
08/06/1973
MINERVINO DI LECCE (LE)
323
Antonio SANTORO
19/04/1973
CONDOVE (TO)
324
Francesco SANTORO
15/08/1976
TRIESTE
325
Salvatore SAVASTA
07/06/1964
MONCALIERI (TO)
326
Cosimo SCARDINO
12/11/1957
TARANTO
327
Emanuele SCARSELLETTA
12/10/1965
CASALINO (NO)
328
Letterio SCILIBERTO
30/07/1960
MESSINA
329
Claudio SCRIMIERI
22/10/1973
SARRE (AO)
330
Giovanni SEMERARO
01/03/1960
CISTERNINO (BR)
331
Gaspare SENA
18/07/1972
MONTEROTONDO (RM)
332
Pierluigi SERRA
20/09/1965
GALATINA (LE)
333
Antonio SIANO
16/12/1965
CONDOVE (TO)
334
Michele SIRAVO
30/03/1979
MONTAQUILA (IS)
335
Domenico SISTI
10/10/1974
VIGNOLO (CN)
336
Angelo SORECA
06/11/1977
AOSTA
337
Salvatore SORRENTINO
11/03/1967
TORRE DEL GRECO (NA)
338
Giuseppe SOTTILOTTA
07/12/1967
CORBETTA (MI)
339
Marcello SPADA
20/10/1975
SAINT CHRISTOPHE (AO)
340
Mario SPIGA
06/08/1973
SESTU (CA)
341
Vincenzo SPIZZIRRI
13/07/1969
CERISANO (CS)
342
Ernesto STELLA
09/04/1969
BARI
343
Vincenzo STELLAVATECASCIO
07/08/1960
PEVERAGNO (CN)
344
Antonio STERPETTI
08/11/1967
ROMA
345
Michele STIMOLA
06/04/1963
ROMA
346
Pasquale STRIANO
22/02/1965
ROMA
347
Gianluca SUNDA
13/10/1967
SELARGIUS (CA)
348
Gianluca TACCALOZZI
07/07/1974
GUIDONIA MONTECELIO (RM)
349
Raimondo TAFURI
30/07/1970
PRATO
350
Giancarlo TANCREDI
08/04/1963
TORINO
351
Michele TANTULLI
15/04/1975
MATERA
352
Pietro TAURINO
04/05/1967
CASTEL SAN PIETRO TERME (BO)
353
Eliseo TAVERNA
19/11/1966
L’AQUILA
354
Salvatore TERRANOVA
21/11/1964
CUNEO
355
Simone TERRERI
30/10/1984
PESCOPENNATARO (IS)
356
Luca TESTA
05/01/1975
GIAVENO (TO)
357
Daniele TISCI
09/07/1968
ROMA
358
Giancarlo TOCCI
17/06/1960
ROMA
359
Tommaso TODARO
13/04/1968
DECIMOMANNU (CA)
360
Roberto TOFANELLI
07/10/1974
GROSSETO
361
Fulvio TOIGO
11/01/1968
LIVORNO
362
Giuseppe TONDI
16/02/1975
REANO (TO)
363
Michelangelo TONTI
13/11/1950
BARI
364
Luca TORNELLO
04/01/1972
LEQUILE (LE)
365
Salvatore TORRISI
28/06/1977
GIARRE (CT)
366
Giuseppe TORTORELLI
02/04/1973
POZZUOLI (NA)
367
Pier Luca TOSELLI
09/05/1965
GALLO DI POGGIO RENATICO (FE)
368
Mauro TRAMIS
14/09/1977
MILANO
369
Cosimo TRANI
13/06/1980
GROTTAGLIE (TA)
370
Giuseppe TRENTINO
17/01/1983
AOSTA
371
Giuseppe TRIA
20/03/1972
MILANO
372
Salvatore TRINX
01/02/1960
TORINO
373
Cesare TROVATO
30/08/1978
AOSTA
374
Vincenzo VACCA
03/08/1960
NAPOLI
375
Luca VALENTE
02/05/1967
SAN NICOLA MANFREDI (BN)
376
Nicolino VALENTI
10/04/1964
PISTOIA
377
Domenico VALLEFUOCO
01/01/1963
ROMA
378
Vincenzo Christian VARONE
07/07/1976
AOSTA
379
Antonio VECCARI
28/10/1971
CATANZARO
380
Giovanni VENAFRO
25/06/1963
EMPOLI (FI)
381
Antonio VENTRIGLIA
13/11/1979
SEREGNO (MB)
382
Pietro VENUTOLO
29/04/1971
SALERNO
383
Alessandro VERALLI
19/10/1977
LA LOGGIA (TO)
384
Alessandro VERARDO
22/07/1975
REGGIO EMILIA
385
Fabrizio VERCELLI
02/11/1966
BIENTINA (PI)
386
Giovanni VERNA
04/12/1971
RIVOLI (TO)
387
Carmelo VERSACE
28/05/1969
METAPONTO DI BERNALDA (MT)
388
Giuseppe VIGLIOTTI
28/03/1981
GROTTAGLIE (TA)
389
Pietro Paolo VOLLONO
18/08/1963
CASTELLAMMARE DI STABIA (NA)
390
Emilio VOLPE
23/07/1956
ROMA
391
Enrico ZACCARIA
11/02/1973
PULSANO (TA)
392
Mario ZARRILLO
30/03/1953
BALVANO (PZ)
393
Francesco ZAVATTOLO
01/11/1971
POMEZIA (RM)
394
Domenico ZINGARO
25/03/1963
LORETO
395
Giovanni Antonio ZITO
30/10/1973
NOVA SIRI (MT)
396
Fabio Pasquale ZUCCO
11/08/1974
SARRE (AO)
397
Maurizio ZUMMO
04/01/1961
ROMA
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy