PREOBRAZOVATEL-SERVIS AND OTHERS v. UKRAINE

FIFTH SECTION

DECISION

Application no. 510/07
PREOBRAZOVATEL-SERVIS against Ukraine
and 331 other applications
(see appended table)

The European Court of Human Rights (Fifth Section), sitting on 7 June 2018 as a Committee composed of:

Yonko Grozev, President,
Gabriele Kucsko-Stadlmayer,
Lәtif Hüseynov, judges,
and Liv Tigerstedt, Acting Deputy Section Registrar,

Having regard to the above applications lodged on the various dates indicated in the appendices below,

Having regard to the observations submitted by the respondent Government and the observations in reply submitted by the applicants,

Having deliberated, decides as follows:

FACTS AND PROCEDURE

1. The applicants are Ukrainian nationals and their personal details are set out in the appendices below.

2. After the institution of the Convention proceedings the applicants Mr Mykola Yakovych Burka (application no. 15533/15) and Mr Leonid Fedorovych Lunko (application no. 46873/13) died. Their heirs Mrs Nataliya Vasylivna Burka and Ms Viktoriya Leonidivna Lunko respectively informed the Court that they wished to pursue the applications of their late relatives.

3. The Ukrainian Government (“the Government”) were represented by their Agent, most recently, Mr I. Lishchyna, from the Ministry of Justice.

4. The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarized as follows.

5. On the dates set out in the appendices the national courts found for the applicants and ordered the defendants under these judgments to take certain measures or to pay various amounts to the applicants. The applicants claimed that the judgments became binding, but has not been enforced or were enforced after prolonged delays. The relevant circumstances of the cases are outlined in the appendices below.

6. The applications were communicated to the Ukrainian Government within the pilot judgment procedure following the case of Yuriy Nikolayevich Ivanov v. Ukraine (no. 40450/04, judgment of 15 October 2009).

7. In their observations the respondent Government argued that the applications did not comply with the admissibility criteria of the Convention and invited the Court to declare them inadmissible.

8. The applicants disagreed.

COMPLAINTS

9. The applicants, referring mainly to Articles 6 § 1 and 13 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1, complained about the delayed enforcement of judgments in their favour. Additionally, several applicants raised other complaints, mainly challenging the alleged unfairness, outcome and duration of the proceedings before the domestic courts. Some of the applicants also raised other complaints relying on Articles 3, 5, 7, 8, 14 and 17 of the Convention and Article 3 of Protocol No. 7.

THE LAW

A. Joinder of the applications

10. Having regard to the similar subject matter of the applications, the Court finds it appropriate to examine them jointly in a single decision.

B. Standing of the applicants’ heirs in applications no. 15533/15 and no. 46873/13

11. The Court considers that the applicants’ heirs in applications no. 15533/15 and no. 46873/13 (see paragraph 2 above) have standing to continue the proceedings in the applicants’ stead (see, among other authorities, Mironov v. Ukraine, no.19916/04, § 12, 14 December 2006). However, reference will still be made to the applicants throughout the ensuing text.

C. Complaints related to protracted non-enforcement

Applications set out in Appendix 1

(a) Application no. 23739/13

12. The applicant complained about the protracted non-enforcement of the judgment of the Shpola Local Court of Cherkasy Region of 17 May 2011.

13. As it appears from the copy of the above-mentioned judgment, it was rendered in favour of a certain Mr K whose identity or relationship with the applicant could not be discerned from the documents provided by the latter. The judgment of the same court rendered in the applicant’s favour was also provided, however, the applicant did not raise any complaints with regard to it in the present application.

14. In order to claim to be a victim of a violation, a person must be directly affected by the impugned measure (see Burden v. the United Kingdom [GC], no. 13378/05, § 33, ECHR 2008). The applicant failed to substantiate in what way, if any, the non-enforcement of the above-mentioned judgment of 17 May 2011 affected his rights under the Convention. Therefore, the applicant cannot claim to be a “victim” of the alleged violations.

15. It follows that the application is incompatible ratione personae with the provisions of the Convention within the meaning of Article 35 § 3 and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 § 4.

(b) Other applications

16. The Court has carefully examined the applications and notes that in each case the communicated non-enforcement complaints are inadmissible on the grounds set out in the last column of Appendix 1 which should be understood as follows:

(i) Six months

17. The respective complaints were lodged more than six months after the end of the situations in which the State could be held responsible for the non-enforcement of the judgments and must be rejected pursuant to Article 35 §§ 1 and 4 of the Convention for having been lodged too late.

(ii) Manifestly ill-founded

18. The following complaints must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 and 4 of the Convention as manifestly ill-founded:

(1) complaints about the non-enforcement of judgments which were enforced within a reasonable time (see Soloshenko v. Ukraine (dec.), no. 3952/04, 15 November 2005);

(2) complaints about the failure of the domestic authorities to continue payments or recalculation of social benefits in the amount fixed by the judgments favourable to the applicants after the amendments to the legislation entered into force on 23 July 2011 (see Velikoda v. Ukraine (dec.), no. 43331/12, § 21, 3 June 2014); and

(3) complaints that the domestic authorities failed to take additional (not ordered under the respective judgments) measures to remedy the alleged violations of the applicants’ rights (e.g., the failure to pay recalculated amounts of social benefits under the judgments ordering only recalculation of such social benefits; the failure to pay compensation for the uninhabitable property under the judgments obliging the domestic authorities to put the applicants on the waiting list for receiving such compensation etc.).

(iii) No significant disadvantage

19. These applications are similar to Svystun v. Ukraine ((dec.), no. 25250/16 and 2 other applications, 3 November 2016) in which the judgment debt was less than equivalent to 200 euros (EUR) and the amount did not constitute the primary source of revenue for the applicant. Therefore, the complaints should be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 (b) and 4 of the Convention since the applicants have not suffered a significant disadvantage.

(iv) Substantially the same

20. The complaints raised in these applications are substantially identical to the ones raised by the same applicants in their previous applications and which have already been adjudicated by the Court. In view of the absence of any relevant new facts in the present applications, they must be rejected pursuant to Article 35 §§ 2 (b) and 4 of the Convention as substantially the same.

(v) Ratione personae

21. In application no. 44255/08 one of the applicant’s complaints concerns the protracted non-enforcement of the judgment of the Odesa Administrative Court of Appeal of 28 October 2009. In their observations the Government informed the Court that on 9 November 2011 the Higher Administrative Court quashed the judgment of 28 October 2009 and remitted the case for fresh consideration to the first instance court. On 28 March 2012 the applicant lodged a request to leave his claims without consideration and the Leninskyy Local Court of Mykolayiv granted his request.

22. In application no. 49057/14 the applicant complains about the lengthy non-enforcement of the judgment of the Suvorovskyy Local Court of Kherson of 19 July 2012. In their observations the Government submitted that the above mentioned judgment was partially enforced in October 2012. In July 2014 the applicant renounced her claims concerning the enforcement of the remaining unenforced part of the judgment. On 31 October 2014 the Suvorovskyy Local Court of Kherson accepted the renouncement.

23. The applicants did not provide any comments as regards the observations of the Government.

24. The Court notes that under such circumstances the applicants can neither complain of the lengthy non-enforcement of the relevant judgments, nor can they claim to be victims of any alleged violations of their Convention rights. It follows that these complaints are incompatible ratione personae with the provisions of the Convention within the meaning of Article 35 § 3 (a) and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 § 4.

Applications set out in Appendix 2

(a) Applications nos. 49198/13, 54908/13, 63128/13 and 7298/15

25. The debtors in respect of the judgments at stake are private persons (applications nos. 54908/13 and 63128/13), and private legal entities (applications nos. 49198/13 and 7298/15), for the debts of which the State cannot be held responsible. The State’s responsibility extends no further than the involvement of its bodies in enforcement proceedings (see, mutatis mutandis, Ponomaryov v. Ukraine, no. 3236/03, § 51, 3 April 2008, Karpenko v. Ukraine, no. 17216/05 and 10 other applications, 30 April 2013).

26. The Court reiterates that the Ukrainian legislation provides for the possibility to challenge before the courts the lawfulness of acts and omissions of the State Bailiffs’ Service in enforcement proceedings and to claim damages from that Service for delays in payment of the amount awarded (see, for instance, Kukta v. Ukraine (dec.), no. 19443/03, 22 November 2005). In the present cases, the applicants failed to do so.

27. The Court notes that the applicants cannot be regarded as having exhausted the domestic remedies available to them, and the applications are to be declared inadmissible in accordance with Article 35 §§ 1, 3 (a) and 4 of the Convention.

(b) Application no. 41679/13

28. The Government submitted in their observations that the State disposed of all its shares in the debtor in respect of the judgment at issue more than six months before the applicant lodged his application with the Court. After this period the responsibility of the State extended no further than the involvement of State bodies in enforcement proceedings, and the applicant had not challenged before the domestic courts the Bailiffs’ alleged inactivity in the enforcement of the judgment (see Ponomaryov, cited above, § 51).

29. The Court notes the observations of the Government, comes to the same conclusions and declares the application inadmissible pursuant to Article 35 §§ 1, 3 (a) and 4 of the Convention.

(c) Application no. 510/07

30. In their observations the Government informed the Court that the debtor under the judgment at issue became a private legal entity in May 2003 that is more than six months before the application was lodged with the Court. In addition, the Government noted that in January 2004 the Commercial Court of Lugansk Region instituted bankruptcy proceedings against the debtor. The applicant failed to submit its claims as a creditor under the bankruptcy proceedings. On 1 July 2004 the Commercial Court of Lugansk Region declared that not submitted claims were deemed to be paid off. The applicant’s lawsuit against the State Bailiffs’ Service was rejected by the domestic courts. The Government stated that the State was not responsible for the non-enforcement of the judgment after May 2003 and invited the Court to declare the application inadmissible.

31. Considering the abovementioned the Court comes to the conclusion that the application is to be declared inadmissible in accordance with Article 35 §§ 1, 3 (a) and 4 of the Convention.

(d) Applications nos. 48413/12 and 70750/12

32. The Government submitted in their observations that the debtors in respect of the judgments at issue were private legal entities. They maintained that the State was responsible for the non-enforcement in the applicants’ favour only insofar as the State Bailiffs’ Service was involved, while the applicants had not duly challenged before the domestic courts the Bailiffs’ alleged inactivity in the enforcement of their judgments. They further submitted that the bankruptcy proceedings against the debtors were brought in the domestic courts, but the applicants had not challenged the inactivity of the debtors’ liquidators. The Government maintained that, taking into account the above, these applications were inadmissible as manifestly ill-founded.

33. The Court notes the observations of the Government, comes to the same conclusions and declares the applications inadmissible pursuant to Article 35 §§ 1, 3 (a) and 4 of the Convention.

(e) Application no. 12719/13

34. The debtor under the judgment at issue was a private company ‘Energovugillya’. Until 30 July 2010 the company was protected from the creditors by the State (the enforcement proceeding against the debtor had to be suspended), as it was included in the Register of fuel and energy enterprises taking part in the procedure for recovery of debts pursuant to the 2005 Act ‘On measures designed to ensure the stable functioning of fuel and energy enterprises’. The applicant lodged her application on 6 February 2013, that is more than six months after the date when the company was excluded from the Register and thus after the responsibility of the Government for the lengthy non-enforcement of the judgment ended. Besides, the Government noted that the judgment was fully enforced on 28 February 2013.

35. The Court, therefore, rejects the application as inadmissible in accordance with Article 35 § 1 and 4 of the Convention.

(f) Application no. 48419/13

36. The applicant complains about the protracted non-enforcement of the judgment of the Bilogirsk Local Court of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea (hereinafter – ‘the Bilogirsk Court’) of 26 May 2008 against a private company.

37. In their observations the Government state that the applicant challenged actions of the State Bailiffs’ Service before the domestic courts. On 14 June 2011 the Bilogirsk Court found orders on termination of enforcement proceedings unlawful and ordered the State Bailiffs’ Service to take exhaustive measures for the enforcement of the above-mentioned judgment. Under the judgment of the Bilogirsk Court of 23 August 2012 (upheld by the Court of Appeal of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea on 29 October 2012) the applicant was awarded damages which were paid within a reasonable time. Therefore the Government invited the Court to declare the application inadmissible, as the applicant lost his victim status.

38. As it appears from the documents provided by the parties, the applicant lodged other lawsuits challenging the actions of the State Bailiffs’ Service and claiming damages, however, those further claims were rejected by the domestic courts.

39. The Court notes that the domestic courts acknowledged the alleged breach of the applicant’s rights and awarded him compensation and therefore the applicant has lost his victim status (see Khaynatskyy and Others v. Ukraine [Committee], nos. 12895/08 and foll., § 35, 9 January 2014). Therefore, the Court declares application no. 48419/13 inadmissible within the meaning of Article 35 § 3 (a), and rejects it pursuant to Article 35 § 4 of the Convention.

Applications set out in Appendix 3

(a) Applications nos. 14444/14, 15441/14, 15944/14, 19279/14, 40927/14, 40958/14 and 41065/14

40. In their observations the Government informed the Court that the individuals indicated as applicants in the above-mentioned applications died before the applications in their name were lodged with the Court. The dates of death as stated in the death certificates provided by the Government and the dates when the applications (or the first letters, where applicable) were lodged with the Court are outlined in Appendix 3 below. The observations were sent to the addresses indicated on the application forms as those of the applicants or their representatives. The Court received no comments in reply.

41. The Court reiterates that an application may be rejected as abusive under Article 35 § 3 of the Convention if it was knowingly based on untrue facts (see, among other authorities, Akdivar and Others v. Turkey, 16 September 1996, §§ 53-54, Reports of Judgments and Decisions 1996 IV, and Keretchashvili v. Georgia (dec.), no. 5667/02, 2 May 2006) or if incomplete and therefore misleading information was submitted to the Court (see Bekauri v. Georgia (preliminary objection), no. 14102/02, §§ 21 and 24, 10 April 2012, and Hüttner v. Germany (dec.), no. 23130/04, 19 June 2006).

42. In the present applications the deceased individuals were presented as applicants with full legal capacity, living at that time in Zaporizhzhya (applications nos. 15441/14, 15944/14, 40927/14 and 40958/14), Sumy (applications nos. 14444/14 and 41065/14), and Kruti Gorby, Tarashcha District of Kyiv Region (application no. 19279/14). On the application forms there appear signatures in the fields designated to be signed by the applicants. In the applications, except for no. 19279/14, Mr S.M. Klopkov was named as a representative with the designated fields of the authority forms signed. In addition, as regards application no. 40927/14, the Court received a letter dated 7 July 2014 allegedly signed by Mr Anikanov (who according to the death certificate died on 13 December 2012) with a request to attach additional documents in support of the submitted complaints.

43. In such circumstances, the Court considers that the application forms were based on the false claims that the applicants were alive and willing to lodge applications with the Court. In addition to the application forms, the authority forms and the letter in application no. 40927/14 bearing signatures of the deceased and issued after their death were necessarily forged. Although it is unclear who exactly sought to deceive the Court and falsified the signatures on the above mentioned documents, the consequence of such misleading procedural manipulations is obviously incompatible with the purpose of the right of individual application (compare, for instance, with Poznanski and Others v. Germany (dec.), no. 25101/05, 3 July 2007, and Gogitidze and Others v. Georgia, no. 36862/05, 12 May 2015).

44. That being so, the applications lodged in the name of Ms Germanchuk, Mr Batsman, Ms Antonets, Ms Kotlyarenko, Mr Anikanov, Mr Yatchenko and Mr Pugach are abusive for the purposes of Article 35 § 3 (a) in fine of the Convention and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 § 4.

(b) Application no. 15778/13

45. In their observations in the above-mentioned application the Government informed the Court that Mrs Kitaygorodskaya died before the application in her name was lodged with the Court.

46. The Court observes that the application and the authority form naming Mr V.P. Kovalenko as a representative of Mrs Kitaygorodskaya appear to be signed on 15 August 2012. According to the death certificate provided by the Government the applicant died on 21 November 2012. The application in the applicant’s name was lodged by her representative on 10 February 2013. While it is unclear what caused the delay of almost six months in lodging the application, the Court has no evidence in its possession to suggest that it was not the applicant who signed the application and authorized Mr Kovalenko to be her representative. Nevertheless, the application was lodged after the death of Mrs Kitaygorodskaya.

47. The Court notes that an application cannot be brought in the name of a deceased person, since a deceased person is unable, even through a representative, to lodge an application with the Court (see Yaşa v. Turkey, no. 22495/93, Commission’s report of 8 April 1997, § 88, Reports of Judgments and Decisions 1998 VI, and Sterjov and Others v. The Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, no. 40160/04, § 14, 16 October 2014).

48. Therefore, the application is incompatible ratione personae with the Convention within the meaning of Article 35 § 3 (a) and must be rejected pursuant to Article 35 § 4.

D. Other complaints raised by the applicants

49. Several applicants also raised other complaints. In particular, referring to Articles 6 § 1 and 13 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1, they challenged the outcome, alleged unfairness and duration of the proceedings before the domestic courts. They also raised other complaints under Articles 3, 5, 7, 8, 14 and 17 of the Convention and Article 3 of Protocol No. 7 of the Convention.

50. In the light of all the material in its possession, and in so far as the matters complained of are within its competence, the Court finds that these complaints do not disclose any appearance of a violation of the rights and freedoms set out in the Convention or its Protocols and should therefore be declared inadmissible in accordance with Article 35 §§ 1, 3 and 4 of the Convention.

For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,

Decides to join the applications;

Declares the applications inadmissible.

Done in English and notified in writing on 28 June 2018.

Liv TigerstedtYonko Grozev
              Acting Deputy RegistrarPresident

APPENDIX 1

No.

Application no. and date of introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Relevant domestic decision

Reasons for inadmissibility   

26046/08

04/05/2008

Yaroslav Vasylyovych KOSTYNYUK

25/05/1960

Pistyn

Ukrainian

1) Pecherskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 29/12/2005, as amended by Kyiv City Court of Appeal, 20/06/2006

2) Lutsk Local Court of Volyn Region, 22/12/2006

No significant disadvantage   

44255/08

07/09/2008

Anatoliy Vasylyovych BILOBRATOV

01/09/1936

Mykolayiv

Ukrainian

1) Leninskyy Local Court of Mykolayiv, 06/04/2004

2) Odesa Administrative Court of Appeal, 28/10/2009

1) Six months and manifestly ill-founded

2) Ratione personae   

62255/09

28/08/2009

Vitaliy Alekseyevich OSTRIKOV

17/10/1958

Kharkiv

Ukrainian

Kharkiv Circuit Administrative Court, 18/11/2009

Manifestly ill-founded   

60180/11

13/09/2011

Sergey Vasilyevich NIKODIM

01/01/1964

Odesa

Ukrainian

Odesa Regional Court of Appeal, 14/03/2011

Manifestly ill-founded   

12179/12

09/02/2012

Oleg Vladimirovich UDOVCHENKO

28/07/1960

Lugansk

Ukrainian

Leninskyy Local Court of Lugansk, 19/06/2006

Six months   

26534/12

23/04/2012

Viktor Ivanovych VASYLCHENKO

12/01/1957

Kagarlyk

Ukrainian

1) Kagarlyk Local Court of Kyiv Region, 21/03/2011

2) Kagarlyk Local Court of Kyiv Region, 07/02/2011

1) Manifestly ill-founded

2) Manifestly ill-founded   

28441/12

26/04/2012

Oleksandr Anatoliyovych SHUTYAK

10/02/1951

Lviv

Ukrainian

Lychakivskyy Local Court of Lviv, 19/03/2008

Manifestly ill-founded   

73769/12

16/11/2012

Volodymyr Mykolayovych SAZHYN

12/05/1954

Antratsyt

Ukrainian

Lugansk Circuit Administrative Court, 14/07/2008

Six months and manifestly ill-founded   

12537/13

08/02/2013

Oleksandra Petrivna DOMINOVA

17/06/1952

Krasnyy Lyman

Ukrainian

Krasnyy Lyman Local Court of Donetsk Region, 13/01/2012

Manifestly ill-founded 

14792/13

22/02/2013

Borys Yakovych YAROVYY

19/07/1955

Stebliv

Ukrainian

Korsun-Shevchenkivskyy Local Court of Cherkasy Region, 11/07/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

14985/13

08/02/2013

Mariya Mykhaylivna KORZHYLOVA

28/09/1938

Sumy

Ukrainian

Kovpakivskyy Local Court of Sumy, 07/10/2011

No significant disadvantage 

16071/13

17/01/2013

Viktor Vladimirovich LITVISHKO

22/03/1946

Konotop

Ukrainian

Konotop Local Court of Sumy Region, 14/12/2011

Six months 

17528/13

26/02/2013

Oleksandr Semenovych ARSHEVSKYY

20/10/1943

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Tsentralno-Miskyy Local Court of Makiyivka, 06/05/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

17540/13

07/02/2013

Oleksandra Fedorivna SHAGA

04/12/1951

Chernigiv

Ukrainian

Novozavodskyy Local Court of Chernigiv, 18/12/2009

Substantially the same 

17723/13

01/03/2013

Oleg Vasylyovych SHCHERBIN

12/11/1959

Truskavets

Ukrainian

Zhovtnevyy Local Court of Lugansk, 04/12/2007, as amended by Donetsk Administrative Court of Appeal, 20/02/2008

Manifestly ill-founded 

18411/13

11/01/2013

Vadym Oleksiyovych PLATOV

31/10/1952

Vasylivka Druga

Ukrainian

1) Barvinkove Local Court of Kharkiv Region, 24/05/2011

2) Barvinkove Local Court of Kharkiv Region, 15/04/2011

3) Kharkiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 26/10/2009

1) Substantially the same

2) Substantially the same

3) Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

20829/13

07/03/2013

Sergiy Oleksandrovych PURDES

22/07/1963

Zaporizhzhya

Ukrainian

Kovpakivskyy Local Court of Sumy, 21/09/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

20951/13

16/03/2013

Petro Pavlovych SMITYUKH

29/09/1958

Monastyryshche

Ukrainian

Cherkasy Regional Court of Appeal, 18/04/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

22036/13

20/03/2013

Oleksandr Vasylyovych PETRENKO

11/03/1960

Cherkasy

Ukrainian

Prydniprovskyy Local Court of Cherkasy, 09/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

23117/13

26/03/2013

Inna Anatoliyivna STEPANENKO

02/02/1977

Bila Tserkva

Ukrainian

Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine, 21/09/2011

Manifestly ill-founded 

23739/13

28/03/2013

Oleksandr Stanislavovych ROGOZINSKYY

03/10/1962

Maryanivka

Ukrainian

Shpola Local Court of Cherkasy Region, 17/05/2011

Manifestly ill-founded 

23863/13

01/03/2013

Yevgeniya Ivanivna SEVRUK

19/06/1944

Zhytomyr

Ukrainian

Bogunskyy Local Court of Zhytomyr, 31/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

24718/13

03/04/2013

Yuriy Ivanovych SAKHNO

23/10/1959

Nizhyn

Ukrainian

Nizhyn Local Court of Chernigiv Region, 22/07/2009

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

25212/13

08/04/2013

Ganna Mykolayivna MARTYNOVA

08/06/1955

Mazurivka

Ukrainian

Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 18 /03/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

26820/13

15/04/2013

Yuriy Mykhaylovych YERMOLAYEV

07/08/1951

Cherkasy

Ukrainian

Sosnivskyy Local Court of Cherkasy, 21/06/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

28263/13

20/02/2013

Larysa Mykolayivna KUPRIYANCHUK

20/01/1967

Bila Tserkva

Ukrainian

Bila Tserkva Local Court of Kyiv Region, 17/06/2009

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

29532/13

19/04/2013

Mykola Grygorovych KAPSHUK

01/01/1950

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 31/05/2011, as amended by Vinnytsya Administrative Court of Appeal, 27/08/2012

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

30506/13

11/04/2013

Mykola Mykolayovych SALKO

05/12/1952

Mykolayiv

Ukrainian

Leninskyy Local Court of Mykolayiv, 14/12/2006

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

32361/13

10/05/2013

Igor Romanovych MAGMET

20/08/1959

Kolomyya

Ukrainian

Kolomyya Local Court of Ivano-Frankivsk Region, 14/05/2007

Six months 

32613/13

03/05/2013

Oleksandr Viktorovych KORNUS

15/05/1967

Gorodyshche

Ukrainian

Gorodyshche Local Court of Cherkasy Region, 15/10/2009

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

34928/13

13/05/2013

Grygoriy Yakovych KLYMENKO

20/12/1958

Odesa

Ukrainian

Odesa Administrative Court of Appeal, 28/08/2012

Six months 

35008/13

22/05/2013

Volodymyr Illich YEVTUSHENKO

24/01/1953

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 16/06/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

35446/13

20/05/2013

Nataliya Viktorivna PETRENKO

15/01/1955

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Golosiyivskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 10/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

36476/13

22/05/2013

Mykola Mykolayovych SHARPATYY

17/10/1956

Gorodnya

Ukrainian

Chernigiv Regional Court of Appeal, 12/05/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

38371/13

30/05/2013

Galyna Oleksandrivna KRUTAS

08/02/1937

Kherson

Ukrainian

Suvorovskyy Local Court of Kherson, 02/07/2009, as amended by Kherson Regional Court of Appeal, 06/07/2011

Six months 

39147/13

06/06/2013

Oleksandr Ivanovych BYEDNIN

15/04/1941

Kakhovka

Ukrainian

1) Kakhovka Local Court of Kherson Region, 21/03/2001

2) Kakhovka Local Court of Kherson Region, 18/11/2011

1) Six months

2) Six months 

39611/13

10/06/2013

Andriy Anatoliyovych VORONKO

07/07/1969

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Kyiv City Circuit Administrative Court, 29/01/2009

No significant disadvantage 

40051/13

08/05/2013

Viktor Ivanovych PONEDILOK

17/04/1957

Afrykanivka

Ukrainian

Barvinkove Local Court of Kharkiv Region, 21/06/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

41311/13

13/06/2013

Svitlana Stepanivna ULRYKH

12/09/1963

Slavutych

Ukrainian

1) Slavutych Local Court of Kyiv Region, 04/04/2011 (case no. 2-a-2123/11/1023)

2) Slavutych Local Court of Kyiv Region, 04/04/2011 (case no. 2-a-2122/11/1023)

1) Manifestly ill-founded

2) Manifestly ill-founded 

41533/13

18/05/2013

Georgiy Petrovych LEBEDYEV

01/05/1952

Cherkasy

Ukrainian

Sosnivskyy Local Court of Cherkasy, 22/10/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

41828/13

19/06/2013

Viktor Stepanovych PEREDERIY

05/02/1954

Semenivka

Ukrainian

Semenivka Local Court of Poltava Region, 23/07/2009

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

42306/13

18/03/2013

Nina Ivanivna OSYPENKO

28/02/1939

Boyarka

Ukrainian

Kyyevo-Svyatoshynskyy Local Court of Kyiv Region, 25/12/2009, as amended by Kyiv Regional Court of Appeal, 09/06/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

42372/13

20/06/2013

Mykola Andriyovych KYSIL

17/12/1952

Cherkasy

Ukrainian

Prydniprovskyy Local Court of Cherkasy, 13/09/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

43108/13

27/06/2013

Ganna Panasivna KRAVCHUK

02/01/1952

Rivne

Ukrainian

Rivne Local Court of Rivne Region, 12/04/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

43787/13

29/06/2013

Valentyna Ivanivna MATSAPURA

15/01/1959

Fastiv

Ukrainian

Fastiv Local Court of Kyiv Region, 26/11/2009

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

44051/13

25/06/2013

Kateryna Oleksandrivna TATARINA

05/04/1944

Kherson

Ukrainian

1) Komsomolskyy Local Court of Kherson, 25/03/2011

2) Komsomolskyy Local Court of Kherson, 26/07/2011

1) Six months and manifestly ill-founded

2) No significant disadvantage 

44228/13

26/06/2013

Dmytro Ivanovych STOGNIY

22/12/1936

Kherson

Ukrainian

Komsomolskyy Local Court of Kherson, 25/06/2011, as amended by Odesa Administrative Court of Appeal, 05/06/2012

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

46604/13

05/07/2013

Petro Vasylyovych OSKOLOV

20/09/1944

Chernivtsi

Ukrainian

1) Shevchenkivskyy Local Court of Chernivtsi, 11/12/2008, as amended by Lviv Administrative Court of Appeal, 18/06/2009

2) Shevchenkivskyy Local Court of Chernivtsi, 15/03/2010

3) Shevchenkivskyy Local Court of Chernivtsi, 30/03/2011

1) No significant disadvantage

2) No significant disadvantage

3) No significant disadvantage 

46638/13

10/07/2013

Tetyana Anatoliyivna SHYRSHOVA

25/08/1972

Slobozhanske

Ukrainian

Zmiyiv Local Court of Kharkiv Region, 01/12/2010, as amended by Kharkiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 08/04/2011

Six months 

46873/13

08/07/2013

Leonid Fedorovych LUNKO

28/08/1943

Kherson

Ukrainian

1) Komsomolskyy Local Court of Kherson, 22/12/2010, as amended by Odesa Administrative Court of Appeal, 04/11/2011

2) Komsomolskyy Local Court of Kherson, 17/05/2011

1) No significant disadvantage

2) Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

47034/13

08/07/2013

Ivan Grygorovych ZHUGAN

23/07/1937

Kherson

Ukrainian

Komsomolskyy Local Court of Kherson, 04/08/2011, as amended by Odesa Administrative Court of Appeal, 24/01/2013

Six months 

47560/13

08/07/2013

Mykola Ivanovych LOBACH

01/03/1944

Zaporizhzhya

Ukrainian

Shevchenkivskyy Local Court of Zaporizhzhya, 13/04/2011

No significant disadvantage and manifestly ill-founded 

48504/13

05/07/2013

Tetyana Stepanivna TRUNOVA

10/12/1935

Kherson

Ukrainian

Komsomolskyy Local Court of Kherson, 27/04/2011, as amended by Odesa Administrative Court of Appeal, 10/07/2012

No significant disadvantage 

49860/13

20/06/2013

Grygoriy Petrovych GORYACHENKO

26/04/1952

Krasnoarmiysk

Ukrainian

Krasnoarmiyskyy Local Court of Donetsk Region, 09/12/2009

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

50176/13

26/07/2013

Tamara Vasylivna GUTSOL

10/04/1949

Vinnytsya

Ukrainian

Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 26/11/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

50198/13

29/07/2013

Viktor Ivanovych BOBOSHKO

17/02/1960

Cherkasy

Ukrainian

Prydniprovskyy Local Court of Cherkasy, 12/05/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

52213/13

08/08/2013

Volodymyr Pavlovych KHANDOGIN

07/03/1955

Kremenchuk

Ukrainian

Avtozavodskyy Local Court of Kremenchuk, 11/12/2009

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

52838/13

09/08/2013

Volodymyr Mykhaylovych STOLYARYK

28/06/1955

Pishchanka

Ukrainian

1) Pishchanka Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 11/04/2011

2) Vinnytsya Administrative Court of Appeal, 26/06/2013

1) Six months and manifestly ill-founded

2) Manifestly ill-founded 

53018/13

09/08/2013

Petro Ivanovych STEPANENKO

01/10/1956

Kirovograd

Ukrainian

Kirovskyy Local Court of Kirovograd, 28/04/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

53611/13

10/08/2013

Viktor Mykolayovych USOLTSEV

06/01/1955

Dniprodzerzhynsk

Ukrainian

Dniprovskyy Local Court of Dniprodzerzhynsk, 13/01/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

53791/13

12/08/2013

Valentyn Vasylyovych ROMANYUK

30/09/1943

Dniprodzerzhynsk

Ukrainian

Dniprovskyy Local Court of Dniprodzerzhynsk, 27/01/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

53819/13

08/08/2013

Sergiy Omelyanovych VOLOSHYN

07/03/1972

Dnipro

Ukrainian

1) Industrialnyy Local Court of Dnipropetrovsk of 27/07/2001

2) Dnipropetrovsk Circuit Administrative Court, 03/04/2012

1) No significant disadvantage

2) Manifestly ill-founded 

54646/13

08/08/2013

Mykola Ivanovych BONDARENKO

11/04/1947

Prygozhe

Ukrainian

Barvinkove Local Court of Kharkiv Region, 20/05/2009

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

54747/13

17/08/2013

Nina Leonidivna AVRAMENKO

05/09/1952

Tagancha

Ukrainian

Kaniv Local Court of Cherkasy Region, 23/05/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

54758/13

16/08/2013

Vitaliy Leonidovych OKHRIMENKO

31/08/1963

Cherkasy

Ukrainian

Prydniprovskyy Local Court of Cherkasy, 30/09/2011, as amended by Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 19/06/2012

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

54925/13

19/08/2013

Lyubov Ivanivna SKOPYCH

08/08/1958

Pukhivka

Ukrainian

Brovary Local Court of Kyiv Region, 07/04/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

55472/13

22/08/2013

Mariya Andriyivna KASHTALYAN

10/11/1942

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Solomyanskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 23/09/2009

Six months 

56136/13

29/08/2013

Mykola Ivanovych RYABTSEV

21/10/1949

Kharkiv

Ukrainian

Zhovtnevyy Local Court of Kharkiv, 28/12/2010, as amended by Kharkiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 15/04/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

56348/13

21/08/2013

Mariya Leontiyivna KOLOMIYETS

14/05/1938

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Solomyanskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 27/01/2011, as amended by Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 08/06/2011

Six months 

56419/13

12/08/2013

Anatoliy Ivanovych VLASENKO

21/01/1956

Boryspil

Ukrainian

Boryspil Local Court of Kyiv Region, 24/11/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

57208/13

28/08/2013

Tetyana Volodymyrivna SVERGUNENKO

14/05/1967

Balashykha

Ukrainian

Ovruch Local Court of Zhytomyr Region, 02/11/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

57285/13

27/08/2013

Maya Sergiyivna SHAKHOVA

02/12/1937

Kyiv

Ukrainian

1) Dniprovskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 07/10/2009

2) Dniprovskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 31/08/2011

1) No significant disadvantage

2) No significant disadvantage 

57642/13

30/08/2013

Oleksandr Dmytrovych VYERYOVKIN

08/12/1960

Okhoche

Ukrainian

Nova Vodolaga Local Court of Kharkiv Region, 23/02/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

58119/13

20/08/2013

Ivan Petrovych KOMPANIYETS

05/06/1959

Stepanky

Ukrainian

1) Cherkasy Local Court of Cherkasy Region, 01/06/2011

2) Cherkasy Local Court of Cherkasy Region, 21/01/2011

1) Six months and manifestly ill-founded

2) Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

59581/13

10/09/2013

Olena Pavlivna NOVIKOVA

15/05/1941

Syeverodonetsk

Ukrainian

Stakhanov Local Court of Lugansk Region, 16/06/2011, as amended by Donetsk Administrative Court of Appeal, 16/01/2012

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

61256/13

17/09/2013

Ivan Oleksandrovych GRABOVSKYY

09/05/1956

Ivanivka

Ukrainian

Barvinkove Local Court of Kharkiv Region, 03/06/2009, as amended by Kharkiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 23/11/2009

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

62278/13

20/09/2013

Mykola Mykolayovych BOLGAROV

03/03/1960

Kremenchuk

Ukrainian

Kryukivskyy Local Court of Kremenchuk, 05/07/2010, as amended by Poltava Regional Court of Appeal, 21/02/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

63453/13

25/09/2013

Mykola Petrovych IVANCHENKO

22/06/1952

Fastiv

Ukrainian

Fastiv Local Court of Kyiv Region, 21/02/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

63968/13

23/09/2013

Antonina Vasylivna KOROBEYNIKOVA

02/12/1955

Bila Tserkva

Ukrainian

Bila Tserkva Local Court of Kyiv Region, 24/03/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

64116/13

01/10/2013

Mykhaylo Valentynovych NOVIKOV

14/01/1944

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 30/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

64418/13

12/09/2013

Olena Boleslavivna POPROTSKA

05/03/1939

Kyiv

Ukrainian

1) Dniprovskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 12/04/2011

2) Dniprovskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 23/11/2011

1) No significant disadvantage

2) No significant disadvantage 

64677/13

01/10/2013

Yuriy Mykolayovych SOVA

04/05/1948

Velyke Verbche

Ukrainian

Sarny Local Court of Rivne Region, 12/04/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

64777/13

01/10/2013

Lyudmyla Petrivna MARCHAK

28/05/1951

Ternopil

Ukrainian

1) Ternopil Local Court of Ternopil Region, 02/09/2010

2) Ternopil Local Court of Ternopil Region, 05/11/2012

1) Six months

2) Manifestly ill-founded 

65282/13

08/10/2013

Galyna Fedorivna BINYASH

08/03/1957

Kaniv

Ukrainian

Kaniv Local Court of Cherkasy Region, 30/06/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

65331/13

05/10/2013

Oleksandr Viktorovych NEVZOROV

23/02/1952

Boyarka

Ukrainian

Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine, 06/11/2012

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

65595/13

26/09/2013

Valentyna Petrivna RURYSHYNA

11/09/1948

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 07/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

65900/13

10/10/2013

Petro Ivanovych GEYKO

02/01/1955

Kaniv

Ukrainian

Kaniv Local Court of Cherkasy Region, 31/03/2010

Six months 

66390/13

08/10/2013

Anatoliy Dmytrovych VASKOV

25/07/1936

Dniprodzerzhynsk

Ukrainian

Dniprovskyy Local Court of Dniprodzerzhynsk, 25/12/2009

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

66391/13

11/10/2013

Mykhaylo Vasylyovych OMELCHUK

22/07/1945

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 10/01/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

66674/13

21/10/2013

Valentyna Yegorivna VORONKEVYCH

05/02/1940

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 13/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

66700/13

14/10/2013

Mykola Volodymyrovych KYRYLYUK

10/05/1936

Vorzel

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 24/09/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

66813/13

14/10/2013

Lyudmyla Adamivna KYRYLYUK

22/09/1936

Vorzel

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 31/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

67392/13

16/10/2013

Mykola Dmytrovych LYTVYNYUK

13/02/1948

Nestervarka

Ukrainian

Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 12/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

67431/13

19/10/2013

Anatoliy Volodymyrovych KASHPUR

12/07/1960

Gorodnya

Ukrainian

Gorodnya Local Court of Chernigiv Region, 17/09/2009

Six months 

67510/13

15/10/2013

Pavlo Andriyovych CHAYKA

05/09/1968

Kozarovychi

Ukrainian

Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 09/12/2011

Six months 

67610/13

16/10/2013

Liliya Oleksandrivna OSADCHA

21/02/1937

Dniprodzerzhynsk

Ukrainian

Dniprovskyy Local Court of Dniprodzerzhynsk, 13/05/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

68067/13

21/10/2013

Valentyna Yegorivna VORONKEVYCH

05/02/1940

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 22/12/2009

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

68416/13

21/10/2013

Gennadiy Petrovych DATSENKO

28/09/1959

Kochetivka

Ukrainian

Zachepylivka Local Court of Kharkiv Region, 04/04/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded 

68901/13

25/10/2013

Volodymyr Fedotovych KRAVCHUK

25/05/1949

Rivne

Ukrainian

Rivne Local Court of Rivne Region, 23/06/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

69930/13

01/11/2013

Nina Ivanivna PERERVA

21/04/1947

Maydanetske

Ukrainian

Talne Local Court of Cherkasy Region, 14/07/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

70113/13

31/10/2013

Nadiya Andriyivna GULENKO

24/02/1943

Pustovity

Ukrainian

1) Myronivka Local Court of Kyiv Region, 16/06/2011

2) Myronivka Local Court of Kyiv Region, 17/06/2011

1) Six months and manifestly ill-founded

2) Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

71025/13

01/11/2013

Yuriy Volodymyrovych LYAKHOV

10/12/1937

Kharkiv

Ukrainian

Moskovskyy Local Court of Kharkiv, 15/06/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

71036/13

06/11/2013

Vasyl Ivanovych DOYAK

14/04/1964

Ternopil

Ukrainian

Lviv Administrative Court of Appeal, 22/06/2010

Manifestly ill-founded            

71254/13

25/10/2013

Valeriy Vasylyovych RADIONOVSKYY

08/10/1957

Borova

Ukrainian

Kharkiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 09/06/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

71275/13

07/11/2013

Zurab Semenovych OKUDZHAVA

27/09/1943

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 22/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

71281/13

07/11/2013

Nadiya Anastasiyivna OKUDZHAVA

11/03/1949

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 22/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

71282/13

07/11/2013

Nadiya Anastasiyivna OKUDZHAVA

11/03/1949

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 22/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

71407/13

04/11/2013

Oleksandr Borysovych LYTVYNYUK

12/09/1961

Talne

Ukrainian

Talne Local Court of Cherkasy Region, 22/07/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

71529/13

04/11/2013

Veronika Mykolayivna MAKYTRENKO

11/09/1942

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 22/09/2010

Six months, manifestly ill-founded and no significant disadvantage            

71664/13

23/10/2013

Yuriy Nikolayevich DEMOCHKIN

15/06/1954

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Podilskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 12/04/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

72111/13

31/10/2013

Adalat Suleyman Ogly KERIMOV

19/01/1957

Kremenchuk

Ukrainian

Kryukivskyy Local Court of Kremenchuk, 11/03/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

72162/13

13/11/2013

Nataliya Yosypivna KISELYOVA

20/12/1958

Izyum

Ukrainian

Izyum Local Court of Kharkiv Region, 11/05/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

72219/13

07/11/2013

Vyacheslav Fedorovych OLKHOVYK

22/07/1948

Svesa

Ukrainian

Yampil Local Court of Sumy Region, 25/01/2010

Manifestly ill-founded            

72804/13

14/11/2013

Grygoriy Mykolayovych BURYACHENKO

25/11/1959

Stetsivka

Ukrainian

Chygyryn Local Court of Cherkasy Region, 22/10/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

72878/13

11/11/2013

Ivan Semenovych SAVCHENKO

30/10/1941

Chernechchyna

Ukrainian

Okhtyrka Local Court of Sumy Region, 31/05/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

72897/13

05/11/2013

Anatoliy Volodymyrovych FEDORENKO

28/10/1944

Kyiv

Ukrainian

1) Dniprovskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 04/08/2010

2) Dniprovskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 09/02/2011

3) Dniprovskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 28/11/2011

1) No significant disadvantage

2) No significant disadvantage

3) No significant disadvantage            

72996/13

12/11/2013

Ganna Sergiyivna TYTARENKO

23/09/1941

Kyiv

Ukrainian

1) Dniprovskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 10/06/2009

2) Dniprovskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 16/11/2011

1) No significant disadvantage

2) No significant disadvantage            

73532/13

18/11/2013

Antonina Lyudvygivna ZHOVTUN

28/02/1943

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 05/11/2010

Six months            

74375/13

19/11/2013

Viktor Danylovych SAKUN

08/02/1951

Kaniv

Ukrainian

Kaniv Local Court of Cherkasy Region, 27/05/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

74634/13

19/11/2013

Nataliya Mykolayivna SAKUN

27/06/1953

Kaniv

Ukrainian

Kaniv Local Court of Cherkasy Region, 18/04/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

75015/13

22/10/2013

Mykola Borysovych SOLOMKA

29/11/1956

Okhtyrka

Ukrainian

Okhtyrka Local Court of Sumy Region, 25/03/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

76269/13

22/11/2013

Pavlo Mykolayovych PYSAREVSKYY

07/10/1959

Izyum

Ukrainian

Izyum Local Court of Kharkiv Region, 02/03/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

76297/13

22/11/2013

Viktor Fedorovych KRYULIN

22/01/1955

Mykolayivka

Ukrainian

Zachepylivka Local Court of Kharkiv Region, 28/02/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

76441/13

27/11/2013

Larysa Pavlivna BERNATSKA

01/01/1945

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 31/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

76936/13

20/11/2013

Volodymyr Markovych KOLOMIYETS

25/03/1944

Zaliznychni Birky

Ukrainian

Zmiyiv Local Court of Kharkiv Region, 07/07/2011

No significant disadvantage and manifestly ill-founded             

76951/13

21/11/2013

Zoya Ivanivna KVASHENKO

01/08/1940

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 17/08/2010

Six months, no significant disadvantage and manifestly ill-founded            

77026/13

22/11/2013

Grygoriy Stepanovych SHULZHENKO

26/08/1938

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Dniprovskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 11/03/2011

No significant disadvantage            

77125/13

26/09/2013

Ivan Safronovych RURYSHYN

22/03/1945

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 14/10/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

77385/13

26/11/2013

Oleksandr Grygorovych GOLOVYUK

17/04/1959

Vinnytsya

Ukrainian

Krasnoarmiysk Local Court of Donetsk Region, 17/05/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

77531/13

26/11/2013

Stepan Bogdanovych VITSYNSKYY

01/06/1951

Cherkasy

Ukrainian

Prydniprovskyy Local Court of Cherkasy, 27/01/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

77640/13

02/12/2013

Anatoliy Anatoliyovych DERA

23/12/1962

Krolevets

Ukrainian

Krolevets Local Court of Sumy Region, 25/02/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

77752/13

27/11/2013

Anatoliy Pylypovych KHARTSYZ

28/07/1953

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 28/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

77785/13

20/11/2013

Ivan Trofimovich GRIB

05/12/1937

Starokostyantyniv

Ukrainian

1) Starokostyantyniv Local Court of Khmelnytskyy Region, 11/05/2011

2) Starokostyantyniv Local Court of Khmelnytskyy Region,14/03/2011

1) No significant disadvantage and manifestly ill-founded

2) No significant disadvantage and manifestly ill-founded            

77981/13

06/12/2013

Nina Ivanivna LIMONOVA

08/06/1941

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 29/05/2009, as amended by Kyiv Regional Court of Appeal, 21/02/2011

Six months            

78091/13

02/12/2013

Leonid Anatoliyovych ALITA

13/04/1940

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Obolonskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 02/03/2011

No significant disadvantage and manifestly ill-founded            

78460/13

05/12/2013

Mykhaylo Tymofiyovych SHAPORENKO

10/01/1951

Gostomel

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 15/10/2010

No significant disadvantage            

78667/13

04/12/2013

Ivan Petrovych YAKOVYNA

08/10/1950

Krolevets

Ukrainian

Krolevets Local Court of Sumy Region, 16/03/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

78828/13

04/12/2013

Mykhaylo Mykolayovych REMEZ

13/03/1956

Kotsyubynske

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 25/08/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

79063/13

06/12/2013

Galyna Mykolayivna OPALINSKA

23/05/1957

Talne

Ukrainian

Talne Local Court of Cherkasy Region, 01/07/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

79107/13

04/12/2013

Oleksandr Mykolayovych SHKURO

18/08/1961

Krolevets

Ukrainian

Krolevets Local Court of Sumy Region, 20/05/2010, as amended by Sumy Regional Court of Appeal, 17/08/2012

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

79176/13

05/12/2013

Ganna Fylonivna KYSIL

26/05/1941

Kyiv

Ukrainian

1) Dniprovskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 02/08/2011

2) Dniprovskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 16/03/2011

1) No significant disadvantage

2) No significant disadvantage             

79220/13

04/12/2013

Dmytro Vasylyovych ZHURBENKO

06/05/1934

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 20/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

79222/13

04/12/2013

Anatoliy Mykolayovych KUPCHENKO

23/04/1942

Kotsyubynske

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 01/03/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

79227/13

04/12/2013

Mariya Romanivna PASHYNA

20/09/1950

Bucha

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 31/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

79229/13

05/12/2013

Valentyna Borysivna SUSTAVENKO

06/08/1954

Vorzel

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 20/12/2010

Six months            

80068/13

29/11/2013

Petro Yefremovych SIMYNOVSKYY

26/10/1933

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Dniprovskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 10/06/2011

No significant disadvantage and manifestly ill-founded            

80565/13

10/12/2013

Stepan Nychyporovych KRAVCHUN

20/07/1944

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 10/06/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

701/14

10/12/2013

Zinayida Dmytrivna YASHCHYK

08/03/1933

Dolynska

Ukrainian

Dnipropetrovsk Administrative Court of Appeal, 23/06/2011

No significant disadvantage            

1203/14

14/12/2013

Yevgeniy Antonovych RUBANOVSKYY

23/01/1941

Vyshgorod

Ukrainian

Vyshgorod Local Court of Kyiv Region, 28/12/2010

No significant disadvantage            

1453/14

25/12/2013

Sergiy Oleksandrovych BYELAN

16/05/1950

Okhtyrka

Ukrainian

Okhtyrka Local Court of Sumy Region, 26/01/2011

Six months            

3198/14

10/12/2013

Ganna Sydorivna KRAVCHUN

05/06/1941

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 10/06/2010

Six months            

3265/14

27/12/2013

Zoya Sergiyivna GOLOKHVASTOVA

28/08/1946

Popravka

Ukrainian

Bila Tserkva Local Court of Kyiv Region, 21/08/2010

Manifestly ill-founded            

3571/14

26/12/2013

Oleksiy Svyrydovych BAZYUCHENKO

05/04/1939

Bila Tserkva

Ukrainian

Bila Tserkva Local Court of Kyiv Region, 05/04/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

4288/14

23/12/2013

Sergiy Valentynovych PODGORNOV

27/08/1958

Rivne

Ukrainian

Rivne Local Court of Rivne Region, 09/03/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

4333/14

24/12/2013

Ganna Mykolayivna BILYK

07/08/1955

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 17/05/2014

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

4430/14

11/12/2013

Valentyna Oleksiyivna POPOVA

01/05/1941

Mariupol

Ukrainian

1) Zhovtnevyy Local Court of Mariupol, 19/04/2010

2) Zhovtnevyy Local Court of Mariupol, 15/04/2009

1) Six months and manifestly ill-founded

2) Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

4871/14

04/12/2013

Nina Tykhonivna MAKOGONSKA

08/03/1930

Vorzel

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 29/11/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

4998/14

30/12/2013

Yevgeniya Zakharivna BONDAR

22/11/1939

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

1) Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 20/01/2011

2) Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 25/03/2011

1) Six months and manifestly ill-founded

2) Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

5044/14

27/12/2013

Galyna Petrivna YAKUSHOVA

17/12/1951

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 04/05/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

5058/14

30/12/2013

Olena Volodymyrivna KONDRATENKO

29/08/1952

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

Vinnytsya Administrative Court of Appeal, 29/08/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

5088/14

09/01/2014

Sergiy Mykolayovych SERDYUCHENKO

10/08/1955

Bogdanivka

Ukrainian

Pryluky Local Court of Chernigiv Region, 27/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

5201/14

26/12/2013

Oleksiy Vasylyovych KAPUSTYNSKYY

02/12/1960

Ovruch

Ukrainian

1) Ovruch Local Court of Zhytomyr Region, 31/01/2012

2) Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 24/03/2008

1) Six months and manifestly ill-founded

2) Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

5565/14

15/01/2014

Volodymyr Mykhaylovych KOVALENKO

05/10/1954

Kaniv

Ukrainian

Kaniv Local Court of Cherkasy Region, 27/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

5802/14

24/12/2013

Yuriy Pavlovich NIKONENKO

14/06/1944

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Shevchenkivskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 22/06/2011

No significant disadvantage            

6189/14

20/12/2013

Alla Ivanivna STARODUMOVA

01/01/1952

Tarashcha

Ukrainian

Tarashcha Local Court of Kyiv Region, 17/09/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

6924/14

18/12/2013

Volodymyr Grygorovych DOLGOYEROV

22/09/1965

Kirovograd

Ukrainian

Leninskyy Local Court of Kirovograd, 06/06/2011 in the light of Leninskyy Local Court of Kirovograd, 29/06/2011, as amended by Dnipropetrovsk Administrative Court of Appeal, 31/07/2012

Manifestly ill-founded            

7203/14

20/12/2013

Galyna Fedorivna SKRYPNYK

03/01/1956

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 15/02/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

7541/14

27/12/2013

Svitlana Yevgeniyivna SLIPKA

01/05/1971

Litky

Ukrainian

Brovary Local Court of Kyiv Region, 08/02/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

7546/14

27/12/2013

Nina Petrivna VOYTENKO

22/12/1939

Litky

Ukrainian

Brovary Local Court of Kyiv Region, 07/06/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

7551/14

27/12/2013

Mariya Fedorivna KONOPLYA

04/11/1927

Litky

Ukrainian

Brovary Local Court of Kyiv Region, 07/04/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

7558/14

27/12/2013

Galyna Vasylivna YESYPENKO

13/04/1947

Litky

Ukrainian

Brovary Local Court of Kyiv Region, 07/06/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

7567/14

27/12/2013

Ganna Mykolayivna DONTSOVA

18/04/1947

Litky

Ukrainian

Brovary Local Court of Kyiv Region, 07/04/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

7617/14

08/12/2013

Igor Yevgenovych KUZNYETSOV

03/12/1935

Poltava

Ukrainian

Oktyabrskyy Local Court of Poltava, 12/12/2012

Manifestly ill-founded            

8476/14

30/12/2013

Iryna Sergiyivna ZLOBINA

18/06/1986

Khmelnytskyy

Ukrainian

Khmelnytskyy Local Court of Khmelnytskyy Region, 26/04/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

8698/14

18/12/2013

Tamara Mykhaylivna BOBOK

09/02/1940

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 26/04/2011

No significant disadvantage            

8713/14

16/01/2014

Ivan Mykytovych SUKHOLYTKO

24/09/1948

Glybochok

Ukrainian

Talne Local Court of Cherkasy Region, 03/12/2010

Six months            

8931/14

13/05/2014

Anatoliy Volodymyrovych GOLOVENKO

30/06/1955

Sokilets

Ukrainian

Nemyriv Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 09/03/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

10451/14

21/01/2014

Galyna Ivanivna GUNKO

01/04/1939

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 21/09/2009

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

10600/14

16/12/2013

Nina Pavlivna VALCHUK

19/07/1948

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 04/05/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

11373/14

25/01/2014

Galyna Ivanivna GUNKO

01/04/1939

Irpin

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 01/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

11572/14

15/01/2014

Yuriy Mykolayovych DEMUKH

09/07/1965

Dymer

Ukrainian

Vyshgorod Local Court of Kyiv Region, 28/04/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

12308/14

23/12/2013

Mykola Petrovych PAVLENKO

04/01/1950

Vasylkiv

Ukrainian

Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 25/04/2012 in the light of Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 16/04/2013

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

12382/14

27/12/2013

Mariya Vasylivna DOCHYNETS

30/11/1936

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 24/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

12390/14

30/12/2013

Volodymyr Stepanovych KUSHNIRENKO

07/11/1955

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 21/02/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

13284/14

23/01/2014

Galyna Grygorivna KOSTYUCHENKO

07/03/1935

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

1) Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 01/07/2011

2) Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 22/07/2011

3) Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 02/02/2011

1) Six months and manifestly ill-founded

2) Six months and manifestly ill-founded

3) Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

13303/14

30/01/2014

Olga Ivanivna KLOCHKOVA

26/03/1947

Bila Tserkva

Ukrainian

Bila Tserkva Local Court of Kyiv Region, 31/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

13525/14

29/01/2014

Valentyna Kalynichna LUTCHENKO

17/08/1952

Rzhyshchiv

Ukrainian

Kagarlyk Local Court of Kyiv Region, 15/06/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

13653/14

30/12/2013

Svitlana Mykhaylivna KRAVTSUNENKO

10/09/1967

Mazurivka

Ukrainian

Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 18/07/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

13661/14

27/01/2014

Pavlo Mykolayovych MYRONOV

02/01/1942

Vepryk

Ukrainian

Fastiv Local Court of Kyiv Region, 22/09/2009

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

14376/14

05/02/2014

Tamara Ovsiyovna YURCHENKO

21/10/1941

Gostomel

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 03/09/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

14583/14

02/02/2014

Volodymyr Mykolayovych YERMAKOV

31/03/1954

Izyum

Ukrainian

Izyum Local Court of Kharkiv Region, 30/03/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

14881/14

08/02/2014

Mykola Pavlovych KUCHERENKO

01/07/1936

Gostomel

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 21/08/2009

Six months            

14981/14

29/04/2014

Nadiya Gavrylivna TVERDOKHLIB

25/07/1940

Mariupol

Ukrainian

Zhovtnevyy Local Court of Mariupol, 11/03/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

14986/14

29/04/2014

Pavlo Yosypovych LEVIN

18/07/1938

Mariupol

Ukrainian

Zhovtnevyy Local Court of Mariupol, 24/03/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

14988/14

29/04/2014

Vyacheslav Vasylyovych VOLYN

12/09/1936

Mariupol

Ukrainian

Zhovtnevyy Local Court of Mariupol, 19/03/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded             

14999/14

13/03/2014

Valentyna Dmytrivna BARANOVA

07/04/1939

Mariupol

Ukrainian

Illichivsk Local Court of Mariupol, 08/11/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

15298/14

07/02/2014

Olena Dmytrivna CHORNA

27/07/1938

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

1) Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 17/03/2011

2) Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 20/05/2011

1) Six months and manifestly ill-founded

2) Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

15328/14

07/02/2014

Olena Mykhaylivna KORNIYKO

13/01/1952

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

1) Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 08/12/2010

2) Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 31/05/2011

1) Six months and manifestly ill-founded

2) Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

15456/14

03/03/2014

Tamara Pavlivna ZINCHENKO

10/11/1949

Tarashcha

Ukrainian

Tarashcha Local Court of Kyiv Region, 25/11/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

15490/14

14/02/2014

Igor Vasylyovych FILONENKO

29/05/1978

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Desnyanskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 23/05/2011

No significant disadvantage and manifestly ill-founded            

15715/14

05/07/2014

Zynayida Gavrylivna MOROZOVA

15/11/1940

Mariupol

Ukrainian

Zhovtnevyy Local Court of Mariupol, 22/02/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

15854/14

06/02/2014

Galyna Fedorivna NIKIFOROVA

17/12/1937

Gostomel

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 13/09/2010

Six months, no significant disadvantage and manifestly ill-founded            

16006/14

12/02/2014

Tamara Kuzminichna FILONENKO

14/10/1949

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Desnyanskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 05/04/2011

No significant disadvantage and manifestly ill-founded            

16103/14

06/02/2014

Mariya Stepanivna DOROZHKO

12/07/1944

Mariupol

Ukrainian

Zhovtnevyy Local Court of Mariupol, 13/05/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

16223/14

02/02/2014

Olena Mykolayivna NEBELYTSA

21/10/1957

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

1) Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 15/11/2010

2) Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 18/03/2011

1) Six months and manifestly ill-founded

2) Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

16249/14

01/02/2014

Valeriy Oleksandrovych BOSYY

03/01/1959

Mayaky

Ukrainian

Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 11/01/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

16644/14

12/02/2014

Volodymyr Grygorovych KOZHUKHOVSKYY

14/09/1958

Nizhyn

Ukrainian

Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 18/03/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

17001/14

27/12/2013

Tamara Ivanivna AKSYONOVA

25/10/1938

Zaporizhzhya

Ukrainian

Khortytskyy Local Court of Zaporizhzhya, 02/11/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

17031/14

27/12/2013

Volodymyr Andriyovych KUCHER

18/06/1942

Zaporizhzhya

Ukrainian

Khortytskyy Local Court of Zaporizhzhya, 09/03/2011

No significant disadvantage            

17229/14

12/02/2014

Valentyna Vasylivna PODTYOLKOVA

12/09/1963

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 12/08/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

17284/14

18/02/2014

Valentyna Viktorivna KUCHURA

03/02/1958

Kagarlyk

Ukrainian

1) Kagarlyk Local Court of Kyiv Region, 14/03/2011

2) Kagarlyk Local Court of Kyiv Region, 04/04/2011

1) Six months and manifestly ill-founded

2) Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

17691/14

21/02/2014

Tamara Volodymyrivna TYMCHENKO

09/09/1950

Agronomichne

Ukrainian

Vinnytsya Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 09/12/1999

Six months            

17774/14

26/12/2013

Yuriy Mykolayovych TSURPAL

16/05/1948

Zaporizhzhya

Ukrainian

Komunarskyy Local Court of Zaporizhzhya, 17/05/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

18230/14

18/02/2014

Oleksandr Oleksandrovych BODKO

29/05/1941

Lisovi Sorochyntsi

Ukrainian

Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 30/03/2010, as amended by Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine, 17/01/2013

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

18831/14

03/04/2014

Volodymyr Dmytrovych SABUROV

25/09/1950

Kaniv

Ukrainian

Kaniv Local Court of Cherkasy Region, 17/12/2009, as amended by Cherkasy Regional Court of Appeal, 26/09/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

18988/14

21/02/2014

Mykola Petrovych OCHERETNYY

24/05/1951

Kholodivka

Ukrainian

Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 19/07/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

19028/14

20/02/2014

Galyna Ivanivna BARABASH

06/10/1949

Kyrnasivka

Ukrainian

Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 11/05/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

19032/14

20/02/2014

Galyna Mefodiyivna MAKUKHA

23/04/1937

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

1) Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 31/12/2010

2) Vinnytsya Administrative Court of Appeal, 15/03/2012

1) Six months and manifestly ill-founded

2) Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

19034/14

20/02/2014

Volodymyr Volodymyrovych CHUDAK

26/07/1955

Kyrnasivka

Ukrainian

1) Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 31/01/2011

2) Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 15/06/2011

1) Six months and manifestly ill-founded

2) Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

19096/14

20/02/2014

Yevgeniya Anatoliyivna OCHERETNA

11/06/1947

Kholodivka

Ukrainian

Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 04/07/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

19463/14

15/02/2014

Lyubov Oleksiyivna SHERGINA

01/08/1945

Bila Tserkva

Ukrainian

Bila Tserkva Local Court of Kyiv Region, 31/01/2011, as amended by Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 08/08/2013

Six months            

20550/14

31/03/2014

Nadiya Ivanivna STAROVIT

08/09/1955

Bila Tserkva

Ukrainian

1) Bila Tserkva Local Court of Kyiv Region, 26/04/2011 (case no. 2-a-35306/11)

2) Bila Tserkva Local Court of Kyiv Region, 26/04/2011 (case no. 2-a-35307/11)

1) No significant disadvantage

2) Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

22224/14

10/03/2014

Antonina Viktorivna KOSTYUK

17/05/1960

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 16/05/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

22227/14

28/02/2014

Lidiya Illivna NYCHYK

03/06/1939

Fastiv

Ukrainian

Fastiv Local Court of Kyiv Region, 26/04/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

22228/14

10/03/2014

Olga Ivanivna CHUDAK

16/03/1958

Kyrnasivka

Ukrainian

Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 09/02/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

23055/14

11/03/2014

Yevgeniya Mykhaylivna PIKALOVA

20/03/1937

Gostomel

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 29/11/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

23265/14

10/03/2014

Vitaliy Fedorovych PETRYCHENKO

03/07/1952

Fastiv

Ukrainian

Fastiv Local Court of Kyiv Region, 18/02/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

23500/14

28/04/2014

Vitaliy Oleksandrovych BURKATSKYY

07/10/1948

Stavyshche

Ukrainian

Stavyshche Local Court of Kyiv Region, 22/03/2011

Six months            

23567/14

13/03/2014

Mariya Mykhaylivna PRYKHODKO

29/08/1953

Ovruch

Ukrainian

1) Ovruch Local Court of Zhytomyr Region, 14/01/2011

2) Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 07/09/2007

1) Manifestly ill-founded

2) Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

23890/14

17/03/2014

Nikolay Ivanovich PAVLENKO

08/07/1950

Shostka

Ukrainian

Shostka Local Court of Sumy Region, 10/05/2011, as amended by Kharkiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 28/11/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

24088/14

27/01/2014

Mykola Ivanovych PAVLENKO

29/05/1959

Okhtyrka

Ukrainian

Okhtyrka Local Court of Sumy Region, 18/05/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

24868/14

19/03/2014

Galyna Demyanivna VORONA

04/12/1937

Pavlivka

Ukrainian

Bila Tserkva Local Court of Kyiv Region, 02/04/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

24903/14

14/03/2014

Olga Mykolayivna PUZIY

02/02/1945

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

1) Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 09/03/2011

2) Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 17/11/2011

1) Six months and manifestly ill-founded

2) No significant disadvantage and manifestly ill-founded            

25711/14

28/01/2014

Kateryna Makarivna SYNGAYEVSKA

02/06/1936

Voropayivka

Ukrainian

Ivankiv Local Court of Kyiv Region, 13/09/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

25770/14

28/01/2014

Grygoriy Ivanovych TRUS

10/02/1940

Bila Tserkva

Ukrainian

Bila Tserkva Local Court of Kyiv Region, 28/03/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

25823/14

17/03/2014

Vladimir Dmitriyevich PARKHOMETS

04/03/1947

Bila Tserkva

Ukrainian

Bila Tserkva Local Court of Kyiv Region, 16/05/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

25897/14

28/01/2014

Lyudmyla Mefodiyivna KOLESNYK

19/05/1955

Bila Tserkva

Ukrainian

Bila Tserkva Local Court of Kyiv Region, 01/10/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

25958/14

28/01/2014

Tetyana Petrivna BOYKO

24/03/1963

Bila Tserkva

Ukrainian

Bila Tserkva Local Court of Kyiv Region, 21/04/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

26251/14

24/03/2014

Lyudmyla Mykolayivna MELNYK

12/10/1971

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

1) Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 16/02/2011

2) Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 14/04/2011

1) Six months and manifestly ill-founded

2) Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

27684/14

28/01/2014

Vladyslav Danylovych KULAKOVSKYY

27/02/1938

Bila Tserkva

Ukrainian

Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine, 10/03/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

27971/14

17/03/2014

Tatyana Nikolayevna MIKHAYLYUK

12/02/1955

Bila Tserkva

Ukrainian

Bila Tserkva Local Court of Kyiv Region, 16/05/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

28017/14

11/12/2013

Kateryna Yefremivna YEPIKHINA

04/12/1940

Zaporizhzhya

Ukrainian

Leninskyy Local Court of Zaporizhzhya, 26/07/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

28813/14

01/04/2014

Vadym Mykhaylovych NESHCHERETNYY

07/10/1966

Merefa

Ukrainian

Leninskyy Local Court of Kharkiv, 06/12/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

33290/14

22/04/2014

Volodymyr Oleksandrovych DEGTYARYOV

27/04/1980

Rivne

Ukrainian

Rivne Regional Court of Appeal, 15/08/2013

Manifestly ill-founded            

34124/14

03/06/2014

Valentyna Stepanivna SEREDA

20/03/1958

Tarashcha

Ukrainian

Tarashcha Local Court of Kyiv Region, 22/11/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

34516/14

25/04/2014

Nadiya Yakivna NESTERENKO

20/05/1945

Tarashcha

Ukrainian

Tarashcha Local Court of Kyiv Region, 19/11/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

35524/14

24/06/2014

Mykola Petrovych SIRYK

21/07/1961

Liplyave

Ukrainian

Kaniv Local Court of Cherkasy Region, 10/06/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

35886/14

05/05/2014

Oleksandr Ivanovych PULYAKH

14/08/1965

Nedrygayliv

Ukrainian

Nedrygayliv Local Court of Sumy Region, 06/06/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

37017/14

28/04/2014

Kostyantyn Vasylyovych SOLOMATIN

03/05/1979

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Kyiv Court of Appeal, 13/10/2011

Six months             

37272/14

14/07/2014

Viktor Anatolevich DENISOV

31/03/1944

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Kyiv City Administrative Court, 12/03/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

37913/14

05/05/2014

Liliya Mykhaylivna BEKH

14/05/1967

Chernivtsi

Ukrainian

Shevchenkivskyy Local Court of Chernivtsi, 14/08/2009

Six months            

38157/14

05/05/2014

Oleksandr Mykhaylovych TEYKIN

21/10/1980

Novoaydar

Ukrainian

Donetsk Administrative Court of Appeal, 17/12/2009

Six months            

40034/14

08/05/2014

Iryna Oleksandrivna SHCHYPSKA

13/05/1986

Sholomkivska Sloboda

Ukrainian

Ovruch Local Court of Zhytomyr Region, 31/03/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

41037/14

26/05/2014

Olga Semenivna GARMASH

14/06/1941

Zaporizhzhya

Ukrainian

Shevchenkivskyy Local Court of Zaporizhzhya, 17/05/2011

No significant disadvantage and manifestly ill-founded            

43566/14

20/05/2014

Kateryna Mykhaylivna TKACHUK

02/09/1949

Bila Tserkva

Ukrainian

Bila Tserkva Local Court of Kyiv Region, 03/02/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

46201/14

17/06/2014

Viktor Volodymyrovych ONIKHOVSKYY

09/12/1954

Dmytrivka

Ukrainian

Kyiv Regional Court of Appeal, 31/08/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

46427/14

15/06/2014

Fedir Pavlovych PAVLOV

24/08/1958

Shyshaky

Ukrainian

Velyka Bagachka Local Court of Poltava Region, 25/07/2013

Manifestly ill-founded            

47027/14

19/06/2014

Mykola Ivanovych LUZAN

07/02/1957

Ovruch

Ukrainian

Ovruch Local Court, of Zhytomyr Region, 14/04/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

49057/14

15/06/2014

Valentina Grigoryevna NAZARENKO

25/12/1940

Kherson

Ukrainian

Suvorovskyy Local Court of Kherson, 19/07/2012

Ratione personae            

50083/14

03/07/2014

Viktor Grygorovych GRYB

19/12/1958

Bigun

Ukrainian

Ovruch Local Court of Zhytomyr Region, 30/07/2009

Six months            

50110/14

01/07/2014

Lyudmyla Volodymyrivna VYSOCHENKO

13/03/1953

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 14/06/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

50444/14

30/10/2014

Volodymyr Romanovych FESAK

04/10/1936

Luka

Ukrainian

Tarashcha Local Court of Kyiv Region, 29/11/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

50689/14

04/07/2014

Andriy Eduardovych KAZAROV

20/03/1960

Malynivka

Ukrainian

Moskovskyy Local Court of Kharkiv, 03/03/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

51407/14

28/10/2014

Oleksandr Andriyovych LITVINOV

02/10/1961

Kirovograd

Ukrainian

Kirovskyy Local Court of Kirovograd, 24/06/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

52026/14

28/10/2014

Oleksandr Grygorovych KOSHUTSKYY

08/05/1959

Kirovograd

Ukrainian

Kirovskyy Local Court of Kirovograd, 23/11/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

54316/14

22/07/2014

Agafiya Ivanivna GYKAVCHUK

15/06/1936

Chortkiv

Ukrainian

Chortkiv Local Court of Ternopil Region, 14/03/2011

Six months            

59830/14

27/08/2014

Yuriy Vasilyevich SOSNOVSKIY

17/06/1966

Nova Kakhovka

Ukrainian

Nova Kakhovka Local Court of Kherson Region, 14/01/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

59833/14

26/08/2014

Volodymyr Grygorovych SUNICHUK

15/03/1951

Dytynychi

Ukrainian

Dubno Local Court of Rivne Region, 31/05/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

60148/14

25/08/2014

Lidiya Kostyantynivna TOLKACH

06/11/1949

Ovruch

Ukrainian

Zhytomyr Regional Court of Appeal, 11/02/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

62837/14

21/10/2014

Mykola Vasylyovych BESPALKO

11/09/1948

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Darnytskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 23/05/2006

Six months            

65045/14

25/09/2014

Mariya Karpivna DUBNYTSKA

04/03/1937

Gostomel

Ukrainian

Irpin Local Court of Kyiv Region, 29/11/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

65396/14

24/09/2014

Yevgen Ivanovych KOZACHOK

21/12/1951

Pokotylivka

Ukrainian

Leninskyy Local Court of Kharkiv, 28/01/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

67731/14

03/10/2014

Vasyl Petrovych KRAPYVNYTSKYY

29/04/1954

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Ivankiv Local Court of Kyiv Region, 17/11/2006

Six months and manifestly ill-founded             

69388/14

17/10/2014

Sergiy Ivanovych POPKOV

26/11/1953

Znamyanka

Ukrainian

Znamyanka Local Court of Kirovograd Region, 13/05/2013, as amended by Kirovograd Regional Court of Appeal, 14/08/2013

Manifestly ill-founded            

69603/14

20/12/2014

Zoya Anatoliyivna PYLGUN

20/11/1955

Kivshuvata

Ukrainian

Tarashcha Local Court of Kyiv Region, 28/09/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

71600/14

28/10/2014

Viktor Mykolayovych KUZNYETSOV

12/12/1960

Kirovograd

Ukrainian

Kirovskyy Local Court of Kirovograd, 15/04/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

73218/14

07/11/2014

Goneli Polshayevich ZHVANIYA

14/03/1953

Fastiv

Ukrainian

Fastiv Local Court of Kyiv Region, 17/03/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

73543/14

28/10/2014

VSEUKRAINSKIY SOYUZ RABOTNIKOV TORGOVLI I USLUG TRUDOVOYE SODRUZHESTVO

12/09/2001

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Kyiv Circuit Administrative Court, 05/06/2013

Manifestly ill-founded            

73827/14

15/11/2014

Volodymyr Fedorovych REGEDA

26/04/1952

Fastiv

Ukrainian

Fastiv Local Court of Kyiv Region, 28/02/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

76889/14

03/12/2014

Nikolay Ivanovich TSYURUPA

30/11/1958

Velykyy Dalnyk

Ukrainian

Odesa Administrative Court of Appeal, 26/01/2012

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

1341/15

16/12/2014

Oleksandr Georgiyovych CHYNAROV

28/08/1946

Bila Tserkva

Ukrainian

Bila Tserkva Local Court of Kyiv Region, 09/06/2010, as amended by Kyiv Regional Court of Appeal, 24/02/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

3522/15

19/12/2014

Evdokiya Dmitrievna KOLOMOETS

03/01/1938

Malomykhaylivka

Ukrainian

1) Pokrovske Local Court of Dnipropetrovsk Region, 29/11/2011

2) Pokrovske Local Court of Dnipropetrovsk Region, 19/07/2011

3) Pokrovske Local Court of Dnipropetrovsk Region, 17/05/2011

4) Pokrovske Local Court of Dnipropetrovsk Region, 13/04/2011

5) Pokrovske Local Court of Dnipropetrovsk Region, 09/11/2010

6) Pokrovske Local Court of Dnipropetrovsk Region, 10/12/2010

1) No significant disadvantage

2) No significant disadvantage

3) No significant disadvantage

4) No significant disadvantage

5) No significant disadvantage

6) Six months            

5022/15

26/12/2014

Volodymyr Gavrylovych SULYM

29/03/1951

Ukrayinka

Ukrainian

Obukhiv Local Court of Kyiv Region, 10/07/2009, as amended by Kyiv Regional Court of Appeal, 29/07/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

5240/15

12/01/2015

Tetyana Volodymyrivna MYKHAYLENKO

17/09/1961

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 12/09/2013

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

5251/15

26/12/2014

Anton Vasylyovych MYKHAYLETS

19/08/1931

Odesa

Ukrainian

Odesa Regional Court of Appeal, 15/11/2011, as amended by Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine, 21/06/2012

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

5299/15

24/03/2015

Oleg Oleksiyovych SELEZNYOV

26/01/1958

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Svyatoshynskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 10/07/2009

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

6467/15

12/01/2015

Petro Oleksandrovych KYRYCHENKO

25/01/1971

Bila Tserkva

Ukrainian

Bila Tserkva Local Court of Kyiv Region, 16/03/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

6683/15

11/03/2015

Yaroslav Mykolayovych KAZYMYRIV

19/04/1954

Delyatyn

Ukrainian

Ivano-Frankivsk Regional Court of Appeal, 23/08/2013

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

9389/15

09/02/2015

Vitaliy Volodymyrovych MAYSTRENKO

24/11/1948

Berezan

Ukrainian

Kyiv Regional Court of Appeal, 12/10/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

15533/15

17/03/2015

Mykola Yakovych BURKA

27/04/1963

Boyarka

Ukrainian

Kyyevo-Svyatoshynskyy Local Court of Kyiv Region, 18/02/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

22773/15

14/04/2015

Valeriy Pavlovych PONOMARYOV

27/12/1940

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Obolonskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 15/03/2013

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

23095/15

29/04/2015

Konstantin Nikolayevich GRINCHENKO

23/07/1959

Odesa

Ukrainian

Odesa Administrative Court of Appeal, 04/06/2013, as amended by Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine, 19/12/2013

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

28216/15

08/06/2015

Mykola Fedorovych PAVLENKO

22/07/1953

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Svyatoshynskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 29/10/2009

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

29999/15

12/06/2015

Petro Mykolayovych ZABRODSKYY

08/07/1981

Korosten

Ukrainian

Zhytomyr Regional Court of Appeal, 16/07/2014

Manifestly ill-founded            

37059/15

09/07/2015

Ivan Ivanovych MELNYK

07/07/1956

Tetiyiv

Ukrainian

Tetiyiv Local Court of Kyiv Region, 18/06/2009, as amended by Kyiv Regional Court of Appeal, 05/04/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

38369/15

24/07/2015

Oleksandr Viktorovych TYEPTYAYEV

13/12/1952

Kovalivka

Ukrainian

Kolomyya Local Court of Ivano-Frankivsk Region, 22/07/2010

Six months            

38629/15

26/07/2015

Olena Vyacheslavivna YEROKHINA

19/11/1963

Chernigiv

Ukrainian

Chernigiv Regional Court of Appeal, 01/08/2014

Manifestly ill-founded            

47197/15

15/09/2015

Khrystyna Myroslavivna GRYB

19/02/1983

Pidvolochysk

Ukrainian

Brovary Local Court of Kyiv Region, 06/09/2013

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

49163/15

10/09/2015

Yana Valeriyivna KHVOSTENKO

09/10/1986

Shkarivka

Ukrainian

Bila Tserkva Local Court of Kyiv Region, 30/06/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

50102/15

19/09/2015

Lyudmyla Demyanivna GRYGORYEVA

25/01/1949

Luka

Ukrainian

Tarashcha Local Court of Kyiv Region, 15/09/2010

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

56635/15

11/08/2014

Oleg Oleksandrovych YURCHENKO

06/07/1957

Khodoriv

Ukrainian

Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine, 25/03/2014

Manifestly ill-founded            

56761/15

17/12/2015

Sergiy Anatoliyovych KULYK

15/12/1968

Novgorod-Siverskyy

Ukrainian

Lviv Administrative Court of Appeal, 28/11/2011

No significant disadvantage            

58077/15

02/02/2016

Tamara Mykhaylivna MELNYK

30/01/1959

Chapayevka

Ukrainian

Tarashcha Local Court of Kyiv Region, 05/04/2011

No significant disadvantage            

62044/15

02/02/2016

Mykola Ivanovych PAVLENKO

29/05/1959

Okhtyrka

Ukrainian

Okhtyrka Local Court of Sumy Region, 18/05/2011

Substantially the same            

14008/16

29/02/2016

Valentyn Viktorovych MOZHAROVSKYY

17/08/1976

Malyy Kobylyn

Ukrainian

Ovruch Local Court of Zhytomyr Region, 18/01/2011

Six months            

14384/16

02/03/2016

Valentyna Oleksiyivna LOBUTYNSKA

12/03/1962

Ovruch

Ukrainian

Ovruch Local Court of Zhytomyr Region, 04/10/2011

No significant disadvantage            

15848/16

11/03/2016

Valentyna Andriyivna TRYGUB

31/08/1940

Dnipropetrovsk

Ukrainian

Kirovskyy Local Court of Dnipropetrovsk, 21/01/2010, as amended by Dnipropetrovsk Administrative Court of Appeal, 27/05/2010

No significant disadvantage            

16009/16

22/03/2016

Sergiy Vitaliyovych KUSHNIR

26/05/1981

Goryshkivka

Ukrainian

Tomashpil Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 04/07/2011

Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

17250/16

05/03/2016

Nadiya Mykolayivna KROPYVKO

16/11/1945

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

1) Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 03/12/2010

2) Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 30/05/2011

1) Six months and manifestly ill-founded

2) Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

17278/16

17/03/2016

Lyudmyla Oleksandrivna MATVIYCHUK

16/05/1978

Chortkiv

Ukrainian

Chortkiv Local Court of Ternopil Region, 26/05/2011

No significant disadvantage            

18688/16

05/03/2016

Tamara Dmytrivna BAKLAZHENKO

08/08/1941

Tulchyn

Ukrainian

Tulchyn Local Court of Vinnytsya Region, 16/05/2011

Substantially the same            

20897/16

01/04/2016

Galyna Vasylivna ZALEVSKA

19/04/1959

Kaniv

Ukrainian

1) Kaniv Local Court of Cherkasy Region, 25/03/2011

2) Kaniv Local Court of Cherkasy Region, 22/07/2011

1) Six months and manifestly ill-founded

2) Six months and manifestly ill-founded            

22342/16

13/04/2016

Petro Mykolayovych MYKOLAYCHUK

11/07/1952

Noryntsi

Ukrainian

Narodychi Local Court of Zhytomyr Region, 12/10/2011

No significant disadvantage            

22940/16

12/04/2016

Lidiya Oleksandrivna KOVTUN

26/08/1955

Tarashcha

Ukrainian

1) Tarashcha Local Court of Kyiv Region, 10/12/2010

2) Tarashcha Local Court of Kyiv Region, 12/07/2011

1) No significant disadvantage

2) No significant disadvantage

APPENDIX 2

No.

Application no. and date of introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Relevant domestic decision 

510/07

18/11/2006

PREOBRAZOVATEL-SERVIS

Zaporizhzhya

Ukrainian

Arbitration Court of Lugansk Region, 05/12/2000 

48413/12

19/07/2012

Oleksandr Genrikhovych DRUBICH

17/03/1960

Kerch

Ukrainian

Kerch Local Court of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, 11/04/2011 

70750/12

24/10/2012

Viktor Vasilyevich ZELENSKIY

10/10/1951

Kerch

Ukrainian

1) Kerch Local Court of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, 19/02/2009

2) Kerch Local Court of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, 18/11/2009

3) Kerch Local Court of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, 23/11/2010

4) Kerch Local Court of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, 11/04/2011 in the light of Kerch Local Court of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, 19/05/2011, as amended by Court of Appeal of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, 14/06/2011

5) Kerch Local Court of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, 05/12/2011 

12719/13

06/02/2013

Tetyana Yuriyivna PASICHNA

19/04/1960

Oleksandriya

Ukrainian

Oleksandriya Local Court of Kirovograd Region, 09/07/2010 

41679/13

03/06/2013

Mykola Mykolayovych MISHURA

21/05/1963

Korovyi Yar

Ukrainian

Krasnyy Lyman Local Court of Donetsk Region, 24/11/2003 

48419/13

18/07/2013

Leonid Ivanovych OSTROVSKYY

08/03/1952

Bilogirsk

Ukrainian

1) Bilogirsk Local Court of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, 26/05/2008

2) Bilogirsk Local Court of the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, 23/08/2012 

49198/13

24/07/2013

Alla Fedorivna ARTYOMENKO

19/10/1939

Kharkiv

Ukrainian

Kharkiv Regional Court of Appeal, 01/07/2011 

54908/13

16/08/2013

Larysa Volodymyrivna VEYYELAYNEN

08/06/1970

Pivdenne

Ukrainian

Ordzhonikidzevskyy Local Court of Kharkiv, 13/02/2009 

63128/13

25/09/2013

Yevgen Volodymyrovych GRYNCHYSHYN

03/04/1973

Ugornyky

Ukrainian

Chortkiv Local Court of Ternopil Region, 20/03/2009, as amended by Ternopil Regional Court of Appeal, 30/06/2009 

7298/15

28/01/2015

Susanna Valentynovna KIBAROVA

14/03/1966

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Svyatoshynskyy Local Court of Kyiv, 03/07/2013

APPENDIX 3

No.

Application no. and date of introduction

Applicant name

date of birth

place of residence

nationality

Relevant domestic decision

Date of death of the Applicant 

15778/13

10/02/2013

Aleksandra Arsentyevna KITAYGORODSKAYA

03/03/1939

Balakliyia

Ukrainian

1) Balakliyia Local Court of Kharkiv Region, 08/05/2009

2) Balakliyia Local Court of Kharkiv Region, 17/10/2011

21/11/2012 

14444/14

23/12/2013

Yevdokiya Opanasivna GERMANCHUK

05/12/1925

Sumy

Ukrainian

Kovpakivskyy Local Court of Sumy, 23/09/2011

14/02/2013 

15441/14

30/12/2013

Volodymyr Sergiyovych BATSMAN

03/08/1939

Zaporizhzhya

Ukrainian

Shevchenkivskyy Local Court of Zaporizhzhya, 05/04/2011

30/01/2012 

15944/14

30/12/2013

Kateryna Andriyivna ANTONETS

02/01/1935

Zaporizhzhya

Ukrainian

Shevchenkivskyy Local Court of Zaporizhzhya, 03/06/2011

30/06/2013 

19279/14

16/05/2014

Tayisa Antonivna KOTLYARENKO

04/08/1934

Kruti Gorby

Ukrainian

1) Tarashcha Local Court of Kyiv Region, 08/02/2011, as amended by Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 18/11/2011

2) Tarashcha Local Court of Kyiv Region, 23/03/2011

15/04/2014 

40927/14

26/05/2014

Vasyl Ivanovych ANIKANOV

11/11/1934

Zaporizhzhya

Ukrainian

Energodar Local Court of Zaporizhzhya Region, 19/07/2011

13/12/2012 

40958/14

26/05/2014

Illya Fedorovych YATCHENKO

27/07/1949

Zaporizhzhya

Ukrainian

Energodar Local Court of Zaporizhzhya Region, 11/07/2011

19/03/2012 

41065/14

26/05/2014

Oleksandr Ivanovych PUGACH

17/03/1957

Sumy

Ukrainian

Zarichnyy Local Court of Sumy, 18/08/2011

27/10/2012

 

Full & Egal Universal Law Academy