SECOND SECTION
DECISION
Application no. 62696/11
Ebru SARIKAYA ÖZCAN against Turkey
and 138 other applications
(see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (Second Section), sitting on 15 October 2013 as a Committee composed of:
Peer Lorenzen, President,
András Sajó,
Nebojša Vučinić, judges,
and, Seçkin Erel, Acting Deputy Section Registrar,
Having regard to the above applications lodged on the dates indicated in the annex,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
THE FACTS
A. The circumstances of the cases
The facts of the cases, as submitted by the applicants whose names are listed in the appendix, may be summarised as follows.
On different dates, the applicants initiated actions before various courts or had civil, administrative or criminal proceedings brought against them. All proceedings lasted several years.
B. Relevant domestic law
A description of the relevant domestic law may be found in Müdür Turgut and others v. Turkey ((dec.), no 4860/09, §§ 19-26, 26 March 2013).
COMPLAINTS
The applicants complained under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention that the proceedings before the national courts had not been concluded within a reasonable time.
Some of the applicants raised other complaints, particularly under Articles 6, 8, 13 and 14 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1. These complaints are linked to the same proceedings in which they complain about the excessive length.
THE LAW
I. JOINDER OF THE APPLICATIONS
The Court considers that, pursuant to Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court, the applications should be joined, given their similar factual and legal backgrounds.
II. ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 6 § 1 OF THE CONVENTION
All the applicants complained that the length of the relevant proceedings before national tribunals were excessive and thus fell short of the requirements of Article 6 § 1, which provides:
“1. In the determination of his civil rights and obligations or of any criminal charge against him, everyone is entitled to a (...) hearing within a reasonable time (...) by a tribunal (...)”
The Court observes that the applicants considered the length of the proceedings in question to be incompatible with the requirement of “reasonable time” laid down in Article 6 § 1 of the Convention.
In that respect, the Court found in its decision Müdür Turgut and others (cited above, § 56) that the Compensation Commission established by Law no. 6384, insofar as it is accessible and capable of offering reasonable prospects of redress for complaints concerning the length of proceedings, constituted a remedy which applicants were required to exhaust for the purposes of Article 35 § 1 of the Convention.
In the present cases, the Court sees no reason to come to a different conclusion.
It follows that these complaints must be rejected under Article 35 §§ 1 and 4 of the Convention for non-exhaustion of domestic remedies.
III. OTHER ALLEGED VIOLATIONS OF THE CONVENTION
Relying on various Articles of the Convention or its Protocols, the applicants also presented some other complaints.
Having examined the applicants’ complaints in the light of all the material in its possession, and insofar as the matters complained of are within its competence, the Court finds that they do not disclose any appearance of a violation of the rights and freedoms set out in the Convention or its Protocols.
It follows that these parts of the present applications are manifestly ill‑founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 and 4 of the Convention.
For these reasons, the Court unanimously
Decides to join the applications;
Declares the applications inadmissible.
Seçkin Erel Peer Lorenzen
Acting Deputy RegistrarPresident
No
Application No
Lodged on
Applicant
Date of birth
Place of residence
Represented by
62696/11
16/09/2011
Ebru SARIKAYA ÖZCAN
28/04/1974
Ankara
Özgür ORUN
63216/11
21/09/2011
Atilla Fuat İNCE
01/01/1966
Istanbul
Ergin CİNMEN
63221/11
21/09/2011
M. Hulisi TÜRKER
01/01/1958
Istanbul
Ergin CİNMEN
63227/11
21/09/2011
Gonca RODMAN
01/01/1963
Istanbul
Ergin CİNMEN
63232/11
21/09/2011
Nejla KÖKER
01/01/1963
Ankara
Ergin CİNMEN
63235/11
21/09/2011
Ayşe Dilek ÜLGÜRAY
08/04/1943
Ankara
Ergin CİNMEN
63242/11
21/09/2011
Zehra Sevim İNCEOĞLU
30/09/1931
Ankara
Ergin CİNMEN
63250/11
21/09/2011
Oya ERKEK
01/01/1963
Istanbul
Ergin CİNMEN
63257/11
21/09/2011
Metin TUNCEL
01/01/1968
Istanbul
Ergin CİNMEN
63263/11
21/09/2011
Sevim ÇALAPVERDİ
04/09/1950
Istanbul
Ergin CİNMEN
64683/11
21/09/2011
Mehmet Feza MORAMOLLU
29/03/1955
Kocaeli
Halil EZİCİ
01/01/1972
Istanbul
Risalet DEMİRCİOĞLU
Istanbul
Ergin CİNMEN
64694/11
21/09/2011
Ruhsar Ergün TOKER
01/01/1931
Ankara
İbrahim BEKİN
19/03/1968
Istanbul
Ergin CİNMEN
64831/11
22/06/2011
Behçet ÖZBEK
01/01/1936
Mersin
Yahya TURAN
64887/11
04/07/2011
Ayhan SAYAN
01/01/1946
Istanbul
Özgür AŞIK
65159/11
25/07/2011
Cavit SİVRİHİSAR
23/11/1960
Ankara
Fikriye Leyla EVCİMEN
65278/11
20/09/2011
Ömer Nusret BOZKURT
09/01/1968
Marmaris
Yamaç KAYA
65438/11
06/10/2011
Cahit DALAK
10/11/1958
Kayseri
Haluk PEKŞEN
65525/11
21/09/2011
Sezgin AGUN
20/05/1939
Istanbul
Nebahat TATAR
07/06/1946
Istanbul
Ergin CİNMEN
65549/11
21/09/2011
Tuna Tufan BACANAK
28/04/1972
Amasra
Hamiye BACANAK
01/01/1938
Amasra
Ergin CİNMEN
66318/11
27/09/2011
Hüseyin ALMAZ
28/09/1981
Adana
Kemal DERİN
66326/11
13/09/2011
Nusret SÖNMEZ
29/06/1983
Diyarbakır
66892/11
17/09/2011
Sinan TÖKÜ
27/04/1978
Kocaeli
Mehmet ERBİL
67567/11
03/10/2011
ÖZSA İNŞAAT TAAHHÜT TURİZM SANAYİ VE TİCARET LİMİTED ŞİRKETİ
Aydın
Burcu BEKEMLER KUTLUKAYA
67656/11
08/09/2011
Mesut ÇELİK
15/09/1978
Bursa
Mediha ÖZGÜR
12/06/1974
Bursa
E. Hakan ÖZDEMİR
68703/11
08/09/2011
Ali İhsan KILIÇ
25/11/1972
Istanbul
68783/11
06/10/2011
Osman AKTAŞ
10/04/1966
Sivas
69508/11
29/09/2011
Cavit SÜMER
01/01/1934
Rize
Orhan SÜMER
01/01/1956
Rize
Münevver GENÇ
01/01/1937
Rize
Kadriye SÜMER
01/01/1938
Rize
Muazzez UZUN
01/01/1946
Rize
Mustafa SÜMER
01/01/1932
Rize
Ertürk SÜMER
26/04/1960
Rotterdam
Hüsamettin SÜMER
01/01/1950
Seyhan
Hüsniye ŞİRİN
01/01/1921
Rize
Dursune SÜMER
01/01/1956
Rize
Hamiyet KUTLUATA
01/01/1951
Aydın
Selamettin SÜMER
18/01/1953
Istanbul
Nezaket SÜMER
01/01/1959
Rize
Neylan MENGÜ
19/07/1955
Istanbul
Emine SÜMER
10/01/1953
Rize
Sibel SÜMER
11/06/1985
Istanbul
Arslan SÜMER
01/01/1932
Karabük
Özgür SÜMER
01/01/1970
Antalya
Nuran SÜMER
01/01/1948
Antalya
Sertan SÜMER
01/01/1980
Istanbul
Hatice SÜMER
20/05/1933
Istanbul
Mehpare SÜMER
09/12/1957
Istanbul
Timur SÜMER
01/01/1951
Rize
Emine SÜMER
01/01/1930
Rize
Ragıp SÜMER
02/02/1939
Ankara
Şükrü ORUÇ
17/05/1985
İzmit
Şeyda ORUÇ
01/06/1984
İzmit
Seda ORUÇ
01/06/1984
İzmit
Mustafa Hikmet SÜMER
01/01/1932
Rize
Serkan SÜMER
18/02/1977
Bodrum
Şemseddin SÜMER
25/01/1940
Istanbul
Ali Fuat SÜMER
20/02/1934
Istanbul
Fevzi SÜMER
23/03/1955
Istanbul
Fevzi SÜMER
01/01/1930
Rize
İzzet SÜMER
01/01/1933
Rize
Şeref SÜMER
01/01/1963
Rize
Rıfat ULUŞAHİN
71574/11
10/10/2011
SINIRLI SORUMLU HIRA NUR KONUT YAPI KOOPERATİFİ
Istanbul
Necip KİBAR
72035/11
17/10/2011
Mehmet KARABULUT
01/02/1963
Muş
Sıddık ASYA
01/05/1933
Muş
Enver GÜRBÜZ
01/03/1970
Muş
Abdülvahap BARLIK
10/04/1966
Istanbul
Seyit Ali YENİCİ
12/11/1954
İzmir
Şeyhmus SEVİMLİ
01/01/1969
Muş
Bahattin ESEN
26/12/1961
Muş
Mehmet Can MAMİŞ
01/01/1972
Bursa
Hamdullah BAĞATOR
01/02/1953
Muş
Kazım KARTAL
01/02/1966
Muş
Hikmet AYDIN
72774/11
21/10/2011
Raziye KORONCU
30/11/1945
Istanbul
72808/11
04/11/2011
Walter Ferdinand Otto MEEWIS
10/03/1944
İzmir
Derya BAYSAL KARAYÜKSEL
72812/11
04/11/2011
Evren HACICİHANGİROĞLU
18/01/1981
Hakkari
Mehmet Zahir KIZILAY
73618/11
15/08/2011
Azimet CEYHAN
01/07/1970
Istanbul
Tanzer GÜVEN
74145/11
20/10/2011
Zahide AK
01/01/1961
Tekirdağ
Sevim AKAT EŞKİ
74160/11
13/10/2011
Muhammet Ali ÜREK
16/02/1975
İstanbul
Haluk PEKŞEN
74588/11
13/10/2011
Zeki Hakan BURU
10/04/1971
Istanbul
Haluk PEKŞEN
74723/11
07/10/2011
Necla GÜROL
01/10/1938
İzmir
Tanju NALKIRAN
74743/11
10/10/2011
Halime AKDAĞ
01/01/1944
Şanlıurfa
Abdurrezzak AKDAĞ
01/01/1960
Şanlıurfa
Nabi ÖZALP
74810/11
10/10/2011
Ufuk ALKAN
23/11/1951
Ankara
76095/11
02/11/2011
Mahmut AİŞEOĞLU
01/01/1965
Şanlıurfa
Mahmut KAYA
76638/11
29/11/2011
Huri GÜMÜŞAY
05/06/1950
Istanbul
Eyüp ERASLAN
76961/11
13/10/2011
İsmet SARICI
01/01/1948
İzmir
77222/11
15/11/2011
Cavit KAHRAMAN
01/04/1950
Diyarbakır
Hasan Mete KAHRAMAN
01/10/1971
Diyarbakır
İhsan KAHRAMAN
15/06/1954
Diyarbakır
İrfan KAHRAMAN
02/03/1962
Diyarbakır
Mehmet Yavuz KAHRAMAN
20/12/1964
Diyarbakır
Hüsna KAHRAMAN
01/01/1930
Diyarbakır
Filiz KAHRAMAN
14/11/1967
Diyarbakır
Hayrettin GÜZEL
78357/11
08/09/2011
Aytekin ÇETİN
20/12/1979
Bursa
E. Hakan ÖZDEMİR
78871/11
24/11/2011
Fehmi KARAMAN
18/09/1983
Tekirdağ
Erdener DEMİREL
21/11/1980
Tekirdağ
Cengiz KARA
01/05/1977
Kandıra
Yasemin FİLORİNALI
78971/11
15/09/2011
Naci ÜNAL
01/01/1969
Van
Gönül ÜLGEN
1323/12
21/12/2011
İbrahim YILDIRIM
01/01/1933
Şanlıurfa
Ramazan AY
01/07/1932
Şanlıurfa
Mahmut KORKMAZ
01/01/1955
Şanlıurfa
Fatma Zehra EJDER
1977/12
04/11/2011
Mevlüt GENÇ
01/01/1952
Çanakkale
Aytekin GÜNDÜZ
1978/12
04/11/2011
Rüstem ATEŞ
01/01/1969
Samsun
Aytekin GÜNDÜZ
1979/12
04/11/2011
Kadir GENÇ
01/01/1966
İstanbul
Aytekin GÜNDÜZ
1980/12
04/11/2011
Teslime ŞİMŞEK
(YILMAZ)
01/01/1926
Samsun
Aytekin GÜNDÜZ
2226/12
30/11/2011
Abidin DEMİREL
01/01/1955
Marmaris
Ali DEMİREL
30/05/1953
Marmaris
Alaettin DEMİREL
06/05/1958
Marmaris
Sabahaddin DEMİREL
05/12/1960
Marmaris
Meral ÖNDERSEV
2234/12
30/11/2011
Zafet KORKMAZ
20/03/1964
Marmaris
Halil KORKMAZ
16/05/1957
Marmaris
Meral ÖNDERSEV
2248/12
30/11/2011
Mehmet Ali ÇELİK
03/10/1932
Marmaris
Meral ÖNDERSEV
2311/12
14/12/2011
Fatih KALDIRIM
20/05/1960
Ankara
Murat KALDIRIM
2330/12
12/12/2011
Kadir ŞENOL
05/09/1968
Bingöl
Aykanat KAÇMAZ
2370/12
09/12/2011
Hüseyin AYDIN
01/12/1960
Istanbul
Burhan KIZILGEDİK
2670/12
12/12/2011
Zafer BİÇER
11/02/1975
Tekirdağ
Aykanat KAÇMAZ
4109/12
12/01/2012
Makbule YAMAK
01/03/1956
Trabzon
Buğra YEGÜL
4114/12
12/01/2012
Abdullah GÜRDER
04/07/1945
Istanbul
Neslihan GÜRDER
24/08/1977
Istanbul
İlhan BİÇER
4122/12
12/01/2012
Tunay KARADELİ
28/02/1979
Ankara
Buğra YEGÜL
4567/12
16/12/2011
Murat OZAN
01/01/1955
Tunceli
Enver Erdal ŞİMŞEK
4799/12
12/12/2011
Gökhan TİMOÇİN
01/01/1982
Kassel
Ümit TİMOÇİN
5324/12
13/12/2011
Mustafa KAYA
10/12/1947
Nevşehir
Yusuf AKBAŞ
5938/12
06/12/2011
Mehmet Cemil GÜLAL
01/01/1933
İzmir
Kadir ÇOBAN
10/03/1936
İzmir
Saadet OPAN
03/06/1967
İzmir
Tevfik ÖZER
10/03/1937
İzmir
Saime TAŞDEMİR
01/02/1943
İzmir
İrfan ÇAKIR
15/08/1934
İzmir
İsmail Hakkı PAKCAN
01/07/1922
İzmir
Yusuf KIRILMAZ
12/12/1955
İzmir
Musa DURAN
20/02/1947
İzmir
Hasan ADIKTI
08/04/1939
İzmir
Şahin BAŞOL
18/11/1952
İzmir
Hasan YAMAN
11/10/1949
İzmir
Mustafa YALÇIN
08/04/1939
İzmir
Mehmet YAĞCI
01/01/1954
İzmir
İsmail ÖZKAN
13/05/1935
İzmir
Sümeyra ÜNLÜ ÇELİK
6006/12
16/11/2011
Fatma Nigar DEMİRSOY
09/11/1926
Üsküdar
Murat EFE
6230/12
21/12/2011
Murat ÜLKÜ
22/08/1972
İzmir
Adnan TERECE
6239/12
02/12/2011
K.SHIPS INC.
İzmir
Şevket KÜÇÜKÇELEBİ
6958/12
05/10/2011
Talat SÜREK
26/08/1938
Ankara
Ali SÜREK
25/08/1936
Istanbul
Perihan SÜREK
01/01/1935
Gelibolu
Bülent İLGÜ
7052/12
25/11/2011
Mehmet ÇOKTAN
15/04/1960
Istanbul
7964/12
04/01/2012
Leyla AKYILDIZ
06/09/1988
Istanbul
Mehmet ERBİL
8001/12
26/01/2012
Nazan AKYOL
01/03/1954
Ankara
Devrim Özgür AKYOL
8808/12
30/11/2011
Canan TANGÜN
19/01/1947
Istanbul
Melek Neslihan ÖZFİDAN
8851/12
25/11/2011
Jale YAMAN
09/07/1971
Yalova
8898/12
24/01/2012
Bülent ÇITACI
08/11/1973
Niğde
Şirin AYDIN
01/01/1974
Niğde
Ersin GÜNTUT
01/08/1978
Niğde
Nuri GÖKKAYA
26/05/1973
Niğde
Adem GÜNER
28/02/1969
Niğde
Nazmi BOZKIR
08/11/1982
Niğde
Cuma KOÇ
20/07/1976
Niğde
Kazım ÖZÜN
26/03/1974
Niğde
Ramazan GÜNGÖR
20/02/1972
Niğde
Mehmet Ali GÜNEŞ
11/08/1971
Niğde
Levent AKTAŞ
04/08/1977
Ankara
Mustafa ÇİNKILIÇ
8930/12
24/01/2012
Bayram GÜNDOĞDU
01/01/1965
Niğde
Cafer DEMİR
15/02/1974
Niğde
Nizamettin BOSTAN
25/12/1963
Niğde
Şuayip ESEN
20/07/1976
Adana
Emin DAŞDEMİR
15/04/1963
Niğde
Bülent AKGÖZ
04/09/1978
Niğde
Zaim Zaimoğlu BOZDAĞ
23/02/1975
Niğde
Mustafa KINA
05/01/1971
Niğde
Doğan YILDIZ
15/04/1972
Niğde
Hacı Ali BEYRET
06/02/1976
Niğde
Sebahattin KAYMAZ
06/04/1973
Niğde
Mustafa ÇİNKILIÇ
9336/12
02/02/2012
Emin KARTAL
20/03/1953
Düzce
Fazıl Ahmet TAMER
9902/12
22/12/2011
Gürsel AYDINLI
01/01/1966
Muş
Hasan GENÇ
9904/12
22/12/2011
Metin AKSOY
01/01/1969
Van
Abdulmenaf KIRAN
10056/12
03/02/2012
Nejmi KAYA
19/01/1961
Aydın
Halit MORALIOĞLU
10674/12
27/12/2011
Erhan TİPİ
12/01/1953
Istanbul
11999/12
05/12/2011
Recep ZEYDAN
17/03/1953
Ankara
Saim BOZKURT
12058/12
28/12/2011
Mehmet ÖZDEMİR
10/09/1943
Mersin
Ahmet BIYIKLI
13288/12
03/03/2012
Aysun TEZCAN
20/10/1963
Ankara
Saliha SAVAŞKAN
13732/12
30/01/2012
Yusuf AYDIN
03/07/1942
Sivas
Şefik KARAKIŞ
14676/12
04/02/2012
Kamil GÜNEYLİ
Adil AKTAY
16940/12
13/02/2012
Müyesser GÖLCÜK
27/09/1934
İzmir
Selahattin VARDAR
15/05/1944
Buca
Mustafa Yücel SEVER
18/09/1951
İzmir
Sümeyra ÜNLÜ ÇELİK
19606/12
02/12/2011
Hakan TEZEL
14/01/1969
İzmir
19610/12
26/12/2011
Hakan TEZEL
14/01/1969
İzmir
19755/12
30/12/2011
İbrahim SERİNDAĞ
05/10/1963
Istanbul
Kamber SOYPAK
27278/12
04/04/2012
Neslin Çağlar KILINÇ
10/07/1983
Istanbul
Havva Hülya DEVECİ
32792/12
13/02/2012
Mustafa KUZU
01/02/1945
Çorum
Ertuğrul GÖKEŞME
32925/12
10/04/2012
Mehmet ARSLAN
17/12/1977
Şanlıurfa
Mustafa YAVUZ
33063/12
09/04/2012
Azime ALEVCAN
11/02/1962
Istanbul
Meryem EKİNCİ
01/07/1981
Istanbul
Gülüstan CAM
22/07/1989
Istanbul
Reyhan GÜNLEMİŞ
01/12/1986
Istanbul
Perihan GÜLTEPE
01/12/1986
Istanbul
Ömer ALEVCAN
07/09/1994
Istanbul
Ali ALEVCAN
01/08/1991
Istanbul
Niyazi BULGAN
33947/12
19/04/2012
Mehmet KOCA
05/05/1964
Bursa
Oktay ÖNAL
34157/12
30/03/2012
Tuğrul Bilen ÜNAL
30/06/1945
Istanbul
39589/12
10/05/2012
Atilla DOĞAN
Istanbul
39641/12
23/05/2012
Mahmut Serdar USTAOĞLU
20/09/1963
Ankara
Türkay ASMA
39818/12
24/04/2012
Halil Barış ÇAKAR
08/09/1974
İzmir
Suat AYDINER
43811/12
25/03/2011
Emrah Suphi SAÇILANATEŞ
07/04/1978
Ankara
Tahsin Oktay DOĞAN
44968/12
14/05/2012
Vahide KAFADAR
15/09/1960
Bilecik
46051/12
24/04/2012
Serdar ESMEK
19/06/1976
Adana
47911/12
09/05/2012
Mustafa ZEYBEK
01/01/1949
Muğla
Necmettin YANKOL
48522/12
07/05/2012
Yıldız ÇAKMAK
15/03/1963
Aydın
Ayşe ALTINTAŞ
15/10/1959
Muğla
Dudu ÖZKAN
25/01/1962
Aydın
Aysel KARA
10/09/1962
Aydın
Mustafa İŞERİ
48976/12
23/05/2012
Hüsni BAĞTAŞ
01/01/1955
Van
Hamdi TURGUT
52483/12
11/05/2012
Harun KARAKAŞ
16/02/1977
Istanbul
52642/12
31/07/2012
Mehmet Emin SABAZ
28/07/1976
Tokat
55331/12
06/07/2012
Heval AYSELİ
01/01/1984
Istanbul
Mehmet Sani KIZILKAYA
55365/12
05/07/2012
Mustafa BALDAZ
27/03/1974
Istanbul
İlhami SAYAN
57107/12
28/06/2012
Remzi KILIÇ
05/07/1960
Bursa
Zehra KILIÇ
22/02/1998
Bursa
Fatih KILIÇ
22/04/1991
Bursa
Hüseyin KILIÇ
22/02/1998
Bursa
Ufuk KILIÇ
25/04/1986
Bursa
Tekin ÖZTÜRK
58984/12
25/06/2012
Karip YILDIRIM
04/04/1946
Kocaeli
Huriye Hülya YILDIRIM
01/01/1948
Murat ŞAHISTAN
59566/12
11/06/2012
Burhan KAFALI
02/04/1968
Kocaeli
Saide ARSLAN ÇALIŞKAN
59572/12
13/06/2012
Şahap EMİR
01/01/1952
Istanbul
ELTEKS ELAZIĞ ENTEGRE TEKSTİL SAN. VE TİCARET A.Ş
Istanbul
Kemal POLAT
60864/12
24/07/2012
İbrahim ÖREN
10/08/1969
İzmir
Serkan CENGİZ
62490/12
26/07/2012
Mahmut YILMAZ
01/01/1957
Trabzon
Mehmet YILMAZ
01/01/1977
Trabzon
62919/12
07/08/2012
Bayezit ÖĞÜTVEREN
07/01/1957
Istanbul
63829/12
25/07/2012
Muharrem DOĞRU
01/01/1989
Istanbul
Yusuf Kenan ALTAN
63869/12
31/07/2012
Ercan ÖZCAN
18/11/1975
Iğdır
63915/12
07/08/2012
Mustafa TAŞKALE
04/09/1964
Tunceli
Yıldız İMREK
69904/12
16/08/2012
Eyyup HOŞGÖR
26/01/1954
Lüleburgaz
İlhan DURMUŞ
71598/12
20/09/2012
Seyithan AKYÜZ
01/05/1981
İzmir
Reyhan YALÇINDAĞ BAYDEMİR
73491/12
08/09/2012
Doğan IŞIK
20/08/1956
Istanbul
Hüseyin Hami Şakir ÖZSOMAR
08/08/1958
Istanbul
Metin FİLORİNALI
75059/12
17/09/2012
Midhat ŞEREF
14/10/1948
Istanbul
Enver Arsal YILDIRIM
75275/12
08/10/2012
Adil Serdar SAÇAN
21/09/1962
Istanbul
Celal ÜLGEN
75763/12
19/09/2012
Hüseyin UNAT
01/01/1950
Mardin
Yahya TURAN
75769/12
19/09/2012
Mehmet Mahsum DEMİR
01/01/1963
Mardin
Yahya TURAN
79587/12
11/08/2010
Aydın ÇELİK
11/10/1970
Diyarbakır
Hayrettin GÜZEL
80855/12
15/10/2012
Davut ÇİÇEK
01/01/1954
Mersin
Murat KUTLAY
81576/12
21/09/2012
Işıl TAYDAŞ
11/08/1961
Istanbul
İpek KADİRHAN
81594/12
21/09/2012
Zehra YEREN
01/02/1971
Istanbul
İpek KADİRHAN
9339/13
17/12/2012
Yalçın TERZİOĞLU
01/02/1976
Istanbul
Nurettin ŞAHİN
11333/13
26/12/2012
Nadide KORKUT
11/05/1970
İzmir
Yasemin ŞENER
11335/13
24/12/2012
İlknur IŞINAY
23/07/1969
Gaziantep
11352/13
03/01/2013
Deniz SESLİ PINARBAŞI
27/11/1967
Istanbul
Mustafa Fahri REFİĞ
12494/13
18/01/2013
Salih KÖKLÜ
04/03/1954
Istanbul
İdris KARA
13373/13
06/11/2012
Ferit FİLİTOĞLU
21/05/1970
Tokat
18707/13
23/02/2013
Muvaffak ALTUĞ
07/10/1953
Niğde
26174/13
13/12/2012
Levent NEHİR
18/10/1956
Ankara
41822/13
21/09/2012
Yüksel ACAR
Isparta
Cengiz ACAR
Manisa
Necla KALFA
Manisa
Ayla ACAR
İzmir
Atakan ACAR
Manisa
Celal ACAR
Istanbul
Rauf ACAR
Istanbul
Leyla ACAR
Istanbul
Mehmet Asaf ACAR
Ankara
Sema ACAR
Manisa
Akil TANRIVERDİ
Istanbul
Emre TANRIVERDİ
Istanbul
Tolga Kürşat TANRIVERDİ
Saliha Nilde HAMŞİOĞLU
Ankara
İskender HAMŞİOĞLU
Istanbul
Semra HAMŞİOĞLU
Istanbul
İsrafil HAMŞİOĞLU
Bursa
Berkuk ÖĞÜNLÜ
Istanbul
İclal ACAR
Istanbul
Birgül ACAR
Istanbul
Celil ACAR
Istanbul
Cemal Yüksel ACAR
Aydın
Hüsniye TAŞDEMİR
Istanbul
Mustafa Aslan ACAR
Istanbul
Yalçın ACAR
Istanbul
Fikriye HAMŞİOĞLU
Mersin
Melih KAFKASLI
Manisa
Mehmet Cem ACAR
Istanbul
Bahri ACAR
İzmir
Tansel ACAR
İzmir
Fatma Yıldız PERVİŞ ACAR
İzmir
Aysel Raziye HAMŞİOĞLU
Isparta
Mete ACAR
Istanbul
Melahat ACAR
Ankara
Aynur YASUN
Ankara
Sabiha ERASLAN
Ankara
Dilek YILMAZ
Manisa
Timur HAMŞİOĞLU
Tekirdağ
Hamdi ACAR
Istanbul
Serpil ACAR
Istanbul
Ümit HAMŞİOĞLU
Manisa
Ahmet Nazım DEĞERLİ
Manisa
İlkay ERDEM
Isparta
Celal ACARGİL
Istanbul
Pınar ACARGİL
Istanbul
Seher ACARGİL
Istanbul
Vijdan KAYA ACAR
Antalya
Neriman HAMŞİOĞLU
Istanbul
Tülay HAMŞİOĞLU
Istanbul
Levin HAMŞİOĞLU
Istanbul
Rabia PELİT
Istanbul
Asuman DORUK
İzmir
Gülin Tijen ACAR
Bursa
Enis ACAR
Antalya
Ayla ACAR
Antalya
Nariye DERİN
Ankara
Şöhret Nahide KUTLU
Hatay
Şöhret COŞKUN
Istanbul
Ahmet Casim ACAR
Manisa
Ercan Yüksel ACAR
Istanbul
Şevket ÇİZMELİ
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy