Published on 18 December 2023
SECOND SECTION
Application no. 32039/21
Hesna Gülşah SUBAŞI against Türkiye
and 199 other applications
(see list appended)
communicated on 12 December 2023
STATEMENT OF FACTS
1. A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix.The circumstances of the case
2. The applications mainly concern the applicants’ conviction for membership of an armed terrorist organisation described by the Turkish authorities as the “Fetullahist Terror Organisation/Parallel State Structure” (Fetullahçı Terör Örgütü / Paralel Devlet Yapılanması, hereinafter referred to as “the FETÖ/PDY”), considered by the authorities to be behind the coup attempt that took place in Türkiye on 15 July 2016.
3. According to the information submitted by the applicants, the convictions were based, inter alia, on the applicants’ alleged use of the encrypted messaging application “ByLock”, which the domestic courts held was used exclusively by FETÖ/PDY members and which therefore constituted sufficient evidence to prove on its own that a person had been part of the FETÖ/PDY’s hierarchical structure.
4. The broader domestic background and context to the present applications was set out by the Grand Chamber in the case of Yüksel Yalçınkaya v. Türkiye ([GC], no. 15669/20, §§ 10-22 and 108-40, 26 September 2023).Relevant domestic law and practice
5. A description of the relevant domestic law and practice can be found in Yüksel Yalçınkaya (cited above, §§ 141-193).
COMPLAINTS
6. The applicants mainly complained that their trial and conviction for membership of the FETÖ/PDY had violated the principle of no punishment without law under Article 7 of the Convention and/or the right to a fair trial under Article 6 § 1.
QUESTIONS TO THE PARTIES
Since the issues raised by the present applications are already the subject of well-established case-law of the Court (see Yüksel Yalçınkaya v. Türkiye [GC], no. 15669/20, §§ 237-356, 26 September 2023), the Court does not put any questions to the parties or require any observations on these applications. However, if they so wish, the Government may submit observations on the complaints set out in the appended table, to the extent that they refer essentially to the factual aspects of the applications and not to preliminary objections or legal issues already decided by the Court in Yüksel Yalçınkaya (cited above) or other similar cases against Türkiye.
APPENDIX
List of applications raising complaints under Article 7 (no punishment without law) and/or Article 6 § 1 of the Convention (right to a fair trial)
(conviction for membership of the FETÖ/PDY based, inter alia, on the applicants’ alleged use of the encrypted messaging application “ByLock”)
No.
Application no.
Case name
Lodged on
Applicant
Year of Birth
Place of Residence
Nationality
Represented by
32039/21
Subaşı v. Türkiye
11/06/2021
Hesna Gülşah SUBAŞI
1987
Istanbul
Turkish
Ömer SUBAŞI
51731/19
Özdemir v. Türkiye
06/09/2019
Ali ÖZDEMİR
1962
Kayseri
Turkish
61481/19
Takyan v. Türkiye
12/11/2019
Mustafa TAKYAN
1992
Niğde
Turkish
2153/20
Öztürk v. Türkiye
24/12/2019
Süleyman ÖZTÜRK
1973
Adana
Turkish
3532/20
Kaya v. Türkiye
10/12/2019
Basri KAYA
1964
Adıyaman
Turkish
Şeyho SAYA
9528/20
Bedur v. Türkiye
27/12/2019
Serhan BEDUR
1986
Burdur
Turkish
10706/20
Cenik v. Türkiye
14/02/2020
Hüseyin CENİK
1993
Giresun
Turkish
13692/20
Yıldırım v. Türkiye
09/03/2020
Faruk YILDIRIM
1984
Kütahya
Turkish
15518/20
Karaca v. Türkiye
20/02/2020
İbrahim KARACA
1976
Çorum
Turkish
15663/20
Gül v. Türkiye
12/03/2020
Abdullah GÜL
1985
Trabzon
Turkish
16540/20
Sağıroğlu v. Türkiye
23/03/2020
Şaban SAĞIROĞLU
1973
Kayseri
Turkish
16595/20
Üzümcü v. Türkiye
23/03/2020
Hüseyin ÜZÜMCÜ
1984
Aydın
Turkish
16597/20
Gürültü v. Türkiye
24/03/2020
Selim GÜRÜLTÜ
1992
Gaziantep
Turkish
16976/20
Akar v. Türkiye
18/03/2020
Coşkun AKAR
1983
Adana
Turkish
Selim YILMAZ
17375/20
Çetin v. Türkiye
10/04/2020
Özer ÇETİN
1981
Balıkesir
Turkish
17973/20
Yiğit v. Türkiye
16/04/2020
Şener YİĞİT
1987
İzmir
Turkish
Umut YILMAZ
18477/20
Tolu v. Türkiye
21/04/2020
Yılmaz TOLU
1984
Gaziantep
Turkish
Ömer YÜZGEÇ
20869/20
Adiyeke v. Türkiye
11/05/2020
Ümran ADİYEKE
1992
Siirt
Turkish
Mehmet SATICI
21204/20
Atıcı v. Türkiye
04/05/2020
Nuh Ekrem ATICI
1983
Kastamonu
Turkish
İnan UZUN
25691/20
İnan v. Türkiye
08/06/2020
İbrahim İNAN
1986
Elazığ
Turkish
Sevim YILDIZ İNAN
25710/20
Taş v. Türkiye
08/06/2020
Mustafa TAŞ
İzmir
Turkish
Hasan Ali TAN
25720/20
Doğan v. Türkiye
08/06/2020
ÇETİN DOĞAN
1975
Kayseri
Turkish
Hasan Ali TAN
27262/20
Akdemir v. Türkiye
29/06/2020
Halil AKDEMİR
1977
İzmir
Turkish
Abdi YAŞAR
29910/20
Tikiçoğlu v. Türkiye
26/06/2020
Betül TİKİÇOĞLU
1983
Gebze
Turkish
Emin TELLİOĞLU
30664/20
Gökhasan v. Türkiye
02/07/2020
Ümit GÖKHASAN
1974
Istanbul
Turkish
Naim UZUN
36517/20
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
11/08/2020
Mikail YILMAZ
1988
Kocaeli
Turkish
Rukiye YILMAZ
38911/20
Arman v. Türkiye
31/08/2020
Abdi ARMAN
1983
Kütahya
Turkish
Hamd ZONTUR
39920/20
Akay v. Türkiye
04/09/2020
Hayrettin AKAY
1964
Çanakkale
Turkish
Eslem Feyza YAPRAK
40758/20
Efeakdoğan v. Türkiye
24/08/2020
Mehmet Ali EFEAKDOĞAN
1992
Turkish
Necati TAŞ
43451/20
Söyler v. Türkiye
04/09/2020
Murat Cem SÖYLER
1974
İstanbul
Turkish
Eslem Feyza YAPRAK
43607/20
Güleç v. Türkiye
16/09/2020
Rıdvan GÜLEÇ
1989
Ağrı
Turkish
Celal ZUNGULDAK
44516/20
Altıntaş v. Türkiye
03/10/2020
Emin ALTINTAŞ
1993
Denizli
Turkish
Hatice TELLİ
45774/20
Taşdemir v. Türkiye
30/09/2020
Hüseyin TAŞDEMİR
1984
Balıkesir
Turkish
Büşra TAŞDEMİR
45972/20
Üyer v. Türkiye
28/09/2020
Mesut ÜYER
1986
Adıyaman
Turkish
Yasemin ÜYER
47660/20
Obudan v. Türkiye
14/10/2020
Melike OBUDAN
1990
Osmaniye
Turkish
Süleyman Hüseyin YILMAZ
49203/20
Tuna v. Türkiye
21/09/2020
Mustafa TUNA
1972
Osmaniye
Turkish
Aslı TEKŞAHİN
49539/20
Eroğlu v. Türkiye
20/10/2020
Ali EROĞLU
1977
Manisa
Turkish
Veli TOPUZ
50072/20
Uzun v. Türkiye
06/11/2020
Hasan UZUN
1977
Kastamonu
Turkish
Zümrüt ŞAHİN
50111/20
Demir v. Türkiye
26/10/2020
Ferhat DEMİR
1978
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Şeyho SAYA
51220/20
Bulut v. Türkiye
30/10/2020
Ömer BULUT
1986
Erzurum
Turkish
Muhammed YILDIRIM
52069/20
Can v. Türkiye
20/11/2020
Ramazan CAN
1974
Adıyaman
Turkish
Şeyho SAYA
52462/20
Dağdaş v. Türkiye
19/11/2020
Şevket DAĞDAŞ
1961
Konya
Turkish
Zümrüt ŞAHİN
53148/20
Kahya v. Türkiye
23/11/2020
Veysel KAHYA
1970
Kütahya
Turkish
Bilal ŞAŞMAZ
53923/20
Ayık v. Türkiye
19/11/2020
Eren AYIK
1974
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Aslı TEKŞAHİN
54338/20
Özcimbit v. Türkiye
05/12/2020
Ömer ÖZCİMBİT
1985
Kirikkale
Turkish
Tunahan SANDALLI
54647/20
Yıldız v. Türkiye
25/11/2020
Ramazan YILDIZ
1981
Muğla
Turkish
İbrahim Halil TANGÖR
55016/20
Toka v. Türkiye
30/11/2020
Erdinç TOKA
1971
Balıkesir
Turkish
Zeynep TOKA
55098/20
Aşkın v. Türkiye
18/11/2020
Mehmet AŞKIN
1986
Malatya
Turkish
Şeyho SAYA
55103/20
Demir v. Türkiye
18/11/2020
Ömer DEMİR
1975
Adıyaman
Turkish
Şeyho SAYA
3808/21
Kuzucu v. Türkiye
30/12/2020
Tarık KUZUCU
1984
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Meryem YAŞAR KARAYAZGAN
6919/21
Uysal v. Türkiye
05/01/2021
Osman UYSAL
1970
Manisa
Turkish
Cemil Üneys UYSAL
7433/21
Karaca v. Türkiye
18/01/2021
İlyas KARACA
1978
Şanlıurfa
Turkish
Sakip YAŞAR
9442/21
Aktik v. Türkiye
28/01/2021
Cem AKTİK
1974
Gümüşhane
Turkish
Bülent YÜMİN
9674/21
Erbay v. Türkiye
29/01/2021
Mehmet ERBAY
1986
Manisa
Turkish
Arife YÜKSEKDAĞ ALTUNAY
10504/21
Yalım v. Türkiye
15/02/2021
Murat YALIM
1973
Kayseri
Turkish
Sueda YILMAZ
10553/21
Ergin v. Türkiye
01/02/2021
İsa ERGİN
1986
Adıyaman
Turkish
Şeyho SAYA
15304/21
Uzun v. Türkiye
12/03/2021
Selahattin UZUN
1986
Malatya
Turkish
İbrahim Halil UZUN
17369/21
Sarıgül v. Türkiye
23/03/2021
Adem SARIGÜL
1974
Erzincan
Turkish
Bülent YÜMİN
17410/21
Aktepe v. Türkiye
19/03/2021
Mustafa AKTEPE
1993
Erzurum
Turkish
Celal ZUNGULDAK
18214/21
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
30/03/2021
Ebubekir YILMAZ
1986
Aydın
Turkish
Buket YILMAZ
19729/21
YILDIRIM v. Türkiye
05/04/2021
İbrahim Hakkı YILDIRIM
1987
Antalya
Turkish
Hanife YILDIRIM
21183/21
Karaca v. Türkiye
16/04/2021
Pınar Ayşe KARACA
1994
Erzurum
Turkish
Muhammed YILDIRIM
22495/21
Yurttaş v. Türkiye
05/04/2021
Abdulkerim YURTTAŞ
1975
Erzincan
Turkish
Bülent YÜMİN
24961/21
Aktosun v. Türkiye
28/04/2021
Murat Can AKTOSUN
1991
Bursa
Turkish
Mustafa SAĞSÖZ
26066/21
İlhan v. Türkiye
03/05/2021
Mustafa İLHAN
1985
Manisa
Turkish
Gülsüm YİĞİT ÖZ
27318/21
Yener v. Türkiye
28/04/2021
Osman Nuri YENER
1992
Ardahan
Turkish
27355/21
Özbay v. Türkiye
10/05/2021
Fatih ÖZBAY
1975
Kütahya
Turkish
Meliha Gülsüm ŞAHİN SOYTÜRK
27614/21
Sert v. Türkiye
04/05/2021
Metin SERT
1986
Mersin
Turkish
27763/21
Tüzün v. Türkiye
18/05/2021
Mevlüt TÜZÜN
1988
Balikesir
Turkish
28475/21
Yavuz v. Türkiye
28/05/2021
Mehmet YAVUZ
1976
Kütahya
Turkish
28535/21
Avci v. Türkiye
26/05/2021
Sami AVCİ
1986
Turkish
Naim UZUN
28611/21
Erdoğmuş v. Türkiye
20/05/2021
Hüseyin ERDOĞMUŞ
1975
Kütahya
Turkish
28696/21
Çetinkaya v. Türkiye
01/06/2021
Emrah ÇETİNKAYA
1992
Istanbul
Turkish
28718/21
Yağmahan v. Türkiye
18/05/2021
İdris YAĞMAHAN
1992
Baman
Turkish
28777/21
Kırmacı v. Türkiye
20/05/2021
Emre KIRMACI
1986
Erzurum
Turkish
28876/21
Dayık v. Türkiye
28/05/2021
Mehmet DAYIK
1970
Isparta
Turkish
29026/21
Yılmaztürk v. Türkiye
26/05/2021
Hakan YILMAZTÜRK
1976
Manisa
Turkish
29278/21
Erdoğdu v. Türkiye
02/06/2021
Ahmet ERDOĞDU
1982
Eskişehir
Turkish
Ersoy YÜKSEL
29436/21
Aydın v. Türkiye
24/05/2021
Cihangir AYDIN
1986
Adana
Turkish
29498/21
Şeker v. Türkiye
28/05/2021
Kemal ŞEKER
1974
Rize
Turkish
29511/21
İsanç v. Türkiye
21/05/2021
Ahmet Turan İSANÇ
1976
Sivas
Turkish
Bülent YÜMİN
29911/21
Tecirli v. Türkiye
20/05/2021
Necip TECİRLİ
1977
Kahramanmaras
Turkish
30369/21
Şirin v. Türkiye
20/05/2021
Serdar ŞİRİN
1984
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
Figen YILDIZ
30383/21
Erdoğdu v. Türkiye
01/06/2021
Nazire ERDOĞDU
1986
İzmir
Turkish
Ersoy YÜKSEL
30392/21
Yalçın v. Türkiye
07/05/2021
Mustafa Onur YALÇIN
1980
Kocaeli
Turkish
30393/21
Ece v. Türkiye
21/05/2021
Mustafa ECE
1990
Isparta
Turkish
30465/21
Kesmeci v. Türkiye
26/05/2021
Veli KESMECİ
1989
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
30575/21
Yazıcı v. Türkiye
28/05/2021
Selamet YAZICI
1971
Konya
Turkish
30658/21
Koçer v. Türkiye
07/06/2021
Metin KOÇER
1977
Tokat
Turkish
31101/21
Kenan v. Türkiye
24/05/2021
Osman KENAN
1977
Trabzon
Turkish
Nagihan KENAN
33209/21
Yıldırım v. Türkiye
10/06/2021
Mehmet YILDIRIM
1975
Niğde
Turkish
Okan YILDIRIM
34752/21
Turgut v. Türkiye
18/06/2021
Recep TURGUT
1974
Kırıkkale
Turkish
Dilara YILMAZ
35375/21
Gonca v. Türkiye
25/06/2021
İbrahim GONCA
1988
Istanbul
Turkish
Muhammed YILDIRIM
35757/21
Vehapoğlu v. Türkiye
05/07/2021
Halil İbrahim VEHAPOĞLU
1988
Samsun
Turkish
İnan UZUN
36092/21
Tozlu v. Türkiye
07/06/2021
Mustafa Ali TOZLU
1975
Manisa
Turkish
Arife YÜKSEKDAĞ ALTUNAY
36727/21
Açıkel v. Türkiye
12/07/2021
Hakan AÇIKEL
1977
Ankara
Turkish
Demet YÜREKLİ
KAYAALP
38770/21
Dağdelen v. Türkiye
30/07/2021
Mehmet DAĞDELEN
1974
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
Hamdi YAKUT
39275/21
Keleş v. Türkiye
27/07/2021
Hulusi KELEŞ
1986
Mersin
Turkish
Şeyho SAYA
40447/21
Yeşil v. Türkiye
07/08/2021
Pakize YEŞİL
1974
Antalya
Turkish
Nurgül YAYMAN YILMAZ
40725/21
Çetin v. Türkiye
04/08/2021
İbrahim ÇETİN
1991
Manisa
Turkish
Arife YÜKSEKDAĞ ALTUNAY
41176/21
Yıldırım v. Türkiye
27/07/2021
Faruk YILDIRIM
1987
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
Fikri YILDIRIM
42569/21
Uranlı v. Türkiye
20/08/2021
Onur URANLI
1984
Samsun
Turkish
Muhammed YILDIRIM
45888/21
YILMAZ v. Türkiye
06/09/2021
Fettah YILMAZ
1986
Manisa
Turkish
Arife YÜKSEKDAĞ ALTUNAY
46544/21
Koçdoğan v. Türkiye
17/09/2021
Doğukan KOÇDOĞAN
1990
Istanbul
Turkish
Ömer YILDIRIM
47394/21
Güven v. Türkiye
22/09/2021
Uğur Muharrem GÜVEN
1986
Bilecek
Turkish
Nurullah YILDIRIM
47490/21
Şahin v. Türkiye
14/09/2021
Yusuf ŞAHİN
1975
Istanbul
Turkish
Huzeyfe YILDIZ
48379/21
Çalık v. Türkiye
21/09/2021
Nazım ÇALIK
1982
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
Yavuz YILDIZ
48442/21
Öz v. Türkiye
21/09/2021
Cihan ÖZ
1984
Gaziantep
Turkish
Ömer YÜZGEÇ
49442/21
Yanık v. Türkiye
22/09/2021
Onur YANIK
1991
Izmir
Turkish
Süleyman ŞAHİN
50149/21
Erciyes v. Türkiye
07/10/2021
Halil ERCİYES
1988
Erzurum
Turkish
Muhammed YILDIRIM
51087/21
Bozkuş v. Türkiye
07/10/2021
Salih BOZKUŞ
1977
Manisa
Turkish
Arife YÜKSEKDAĞ ALTUNAY
51870/21
Taşkır v. Türkiye
19/10/2021
Ali TAŞKIR
1982
Hatay
Turkish
Gülsüm Sena YAR
52270/21
Uzun v. Türkiye
18/10/2021
Ali UZUN
1995
Antalya
Turkish
Şahbanu ŞAHİN
52285/21
Kaygusuz v. Türkiye
04/10/2021
Mustafa KAYGUSUZ
1974
Sivas
Turkish
Naim UZUN
53022/21
Köklü v. Türkiye
15/10/2021
Soner KÖKLÜ
1977
Giresun
Turkish
Dilara YILMAZ
53183/21
Erbağcı v. Türkiye
15/10/2021
Selim ERBAĞCI
1981
Istanbul
Turkish
Dilara YILMAZ
53321/21
Kaynak v. Türkiye
15/10/2021
İlter KAYNAK
1971
Kırıkkale
Turkish
Dilara YILMAZ
56965/21
Tekten v. Türkiye
05/11/2021
Alper TEKTEN
1982
Istanbul
Turkish
Naim UZUN
59413/21
Karagöz v. Türkiye
01/12/2021
Burak KARAGÖZ
1992
Bursa
Turkish
Mustafa YELBEY
59515/21
Erciyas v. Türkiye
29/11/2021
Furkan Enes ERCİYAS
1985
Afyonkarahisar
Turkish
Figen ŞAHİN
59577/21
Selek v. Türkiye
24/11/2021
Gül SELEK
1984
İzmir
Turkish
Abdi YAŞAR
694/22
Uzunaslan v. Türkiye
22/12/2021
Ahmet UZUNASLAN
1970
Gaziantep
Turkish
Havva UZUNASLAN DEMİR
3424/22
Nalçacı v. Türkiye
03/01/2022
Orhan NALÇACI
1985
Çorum
Turkish
Mustafa YELBEY
4323/22
Çelik v. Türkiye
10/01/2022
Kamil ÇELİK
1969
Kocaeli
Turkish
İbrahım Halil YILDIZ
6591/22
Aydın v. Türkiye
26/01/2022
Esra AYDIN
1987
Kayseri
Turkish
Safiye YILMAZ
6791/22
Kızılgül v. Türkiye
27/01/2022
Bekir KIZILGÜL
1978
Ankara
Turkish
Gülhis YÖRÜK
6926/22
Kalyoncu v. Türkiye
10/12/2021
Kudret KALYONCU
1976
Turkish
Dilara YILMAZ
7164/22
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
10/12/2021
Halil İbrahim YILMAZ
1975
Istanbul
Turkish
Dilara YILMAZ
8786/22
Bayram v. Türkiye
03/02/2022
Şerif Ahmet BAYRAM
1966
Samsun
Turkish
Nilgün ŞAHİN POYRAZ
9327/22
Düzyol v. Türkiye
26/01/2022
Veysel DÜZYOL
1991
İzmir
Turkish
Abdi YAŞAR
9878/22
Ergün v. Türkiye
07/02/2022
Abdurrahman ERGÜN
1974
Adıyaman
Turkish
Şeyho SAYA
10609/22
Yüce v. Türkiye
16/02/2022
Cengiz YÜCE
1984
Adana
Turkish
Selhan SAĞIRER
11967/22
Aksoy v. Türkiye
15/02/2022
Murat AKSOY
1971
Samsun
Turkish
Nilgün ŞAHİN POYRAZ
14065/22
Gül v. Türkiye
11/03/2022
Beytullah GÜL
1988
Manisa
Turkish
Tuğçe Fatma YILDIZ
16578/22
Karaçil v. Türkiye
18/03/2022
Naciye Hilal KARAÇİL
1979
Çorum
Turkish
Ümit Yaşar YILMAZ
16665/22
Aksoy v. Türkiye
22/03/2022
Hamdi AKSOY
1971
Denizli
Turkish
Muhammed Berat YOLCU
16691/22
Avcı v. Türkiye
29/03/2022
Zeliha AVCI
1992
Manisa
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
16895/22
Karol v. Türkiye
18/03/2022
Ramazan KAROL
1983
Manisa
Turkish
Betül Nur YÜKSEL
17839/22
Tiraş v. Türkiye
05/04/2022
Murat TİRAŞ
1965
İzmir
Turkish
Abdullah Erkam TAMER
17960/22
Çiçek v. Türkiye
29/03/2022
Müslüm ÇİÇEK
1975
Istanbul
Turkish
Hacer ŞAHİN
18081/22
Erdem v. Türkiye
06/04/2022
Ahmet Turan ERDEM
1987
Sivas
Turkish
Şeyma YÜRÜK
19749/22
Türkoğlu v. Türkiye
08/04/2022
Şükran TÜRKOĞLU
1983
Balıkesir
Turkish
Mustafa YELBEY
20157/22
YILMAZ v. Türkiye
19/04/2022
Ahmet YILMAZ
1990
Balıkesir
Turkish
Nurullah YILDIRIM
20694/22
Akkoca v. Türkiye
15/04/2022
Veysel AKKOCA
1971
Adıyaman
Turkish
Şeyho SAYA
21581/22
Ayan v. Türkiye
18/04/2022
Özer AYAN
1978
Trabzon
Turkish
Yavuz YILDIZ
21627/22
Bozatlı v. Türkiye
13/04/2022
Coşkun BOZATLI
1985
Manisa
Turkish
Mustafa YELBEY
21796/22
Ergat v. Türkiye
30/04/2022
Maksut ERGAT
1974
İzmir
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
22146/22
Köksal v. Türkiye
29/04/2022
Serhat KÖKSAL
1996
Ankara
Turkish
Adnan ZEYBEK
25130/22
Savaş v. Türkiye
09/05/2022
Esma SAVAŞ
1986
Gaziantep
Turkish
Meryem YAŞAR KARAYAZGAN
25870/22
Koç v. Türkiye
22/04/2022
Yaşar KOÇ
1974
Istanbul
Turkish
Dilara YILMAZ
25883/22
Karaman v. Türkiye
22/04/2022
Mustafa KARAMAN
1975
Istanbul
Turkish
Dilara YILMAZ
25889/22
Erdoğan v. Türkiye
22/04/2022
Aysun ERDOĞAN
1978
Istanbul
Turkish
Dilara YILMAZ
26334/22
Yavuz v. Türkiye
22/04/2022
Zeynep YAVUZ
1989
Istanbul
Turkish
Dilara YILMAZ
26341/22
Özcan v. Türkiye
22/04/2022
Naci ÖZCAN
1974
Istanbul
Turkish
Dilara YILMAZ
28791/22
Turan v. Türkiye
20/05/2022
Gizem TURAN
1993
Bursa
Turkish
Mustafa YELBEY
29639/22
Temel v. Türkiye
26/05/2022
Muhammed Zeki TEMEL
1978
Hessen
Turkish
Fatih TOPAL
32242/22
Genç v. Türkiye
20/06/2022
Nuri GENÇ
1986
Bursa
Turkish
Mustafa YELBEY
32304/22
Yeşil v. Türkiye
15/06/2022
Zehra YEŞİL
1991
Aydın
Turkish
Meliha Gülsüm ŞAHİN SOYTÜRK
35440/22
Vural v. Türkiye
06/07/2022
Mehmet Erdem VURAL
1991
Istanbul
Turkish
Hamza Senih VURAL
37525/22
Türk v. Türkiye
14/07/2022
Murat TÜRK
1985
Kırıkkale
Turkish
Nurgül YAYMAN YILMAZ
39518/22
Koç v. Türkiye
26/07/2022
Ali KOÇ
1979
Bursa
Turkish
Tufan YILMAZ
39562/22
Arslan v. Türkiye
01/08/2022
Enes ARSLAN
1988
Çanakkale
Turkish
Nurullah YILDIRIM
40675/22
Bulut v. Türkiye
25/07/2022
Cafer BULUT
1972
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Fatma YILMAZ
41605/22
Obuz v. Türkiye
05/08/2022
Yunus Emre OBUZ
1992
Çanakkale
Turkish
Murat YILMAZ
41889/22
Tanrıkulu v. Türkiye
12/08/2022
Saim TANRIKULU
1974
Istanbul
Turkish
Dilara YILMAZ
41948/22
Bora v. Türkiye
02/08/2022
Ahmet BORA
1979
Balıkesir
Turkish
Mustafa YELBEY
41989/22
Tokgöz v. Türkiye
18/08/2022
Hasan TOKGÖZ
Istanbul
Turkish
Muhammet İmran YAVUZ
42436/22
Ercan v. Türkiye
08/08/2022
Ali ERCAN
1986
Turkish
Samet YILMAZ
42547/22
Boşcu v. Türkiye
09/08/2022
Müberra BOŞCU
1986
İstanbul
Turkish
Naim UZUN
43026/22
Yalçın v. Türkiye
26/08/2022
Mustafa YALÇIN
1970
Çanakkale
Turkish
Raziye YALÇIN
43181/22
Ülger v. Türkiye
12/08/2022
Fatih ÜLGER
1984
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Fatma YILMAZ
43777/22
Karaca v. Türkiye
31/08/2022
Kemal KARACA
1974
Artvin
Turkish
Safiye YILMAZ
44611/22
Kilar v. Türkiye
06/09/2022
Selçuk KİLAR
1990
İzmir
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
45912/22
Çetin v. Türkiye
23/09/2022
Süleyman ÇETİN
1988
Bilecik
Turkish
Nurullah YILDIRIM
46043/22
Küçükyıldız v. Türkiye
22/09/2022
Ali KÜÇÜKYILDIZ
1971
Tokat
Turkish
Hasan YILMAZ
46483/22
Altay v. Türkiye
22/09/2022
Ali ALTAY
1979
Bilecik
Turkish
Nurullah YILDIRIM
47038/22
Sarıaydın v. Türkiye
21/09/2022
Ekrem SARIAYDIN
1992
Istanbul
Turkish
Cemal ŞAHİN
48042/22
Beşbaş v. Türkiye
28/09/2022
Mustafa BEŞBAŞ
1973
Erzincan
Turkish
Bülent YÜMİN
48239/22
Uzun v. Türkiye
07/10/2022
Davut UZUN
1992
Istanbul
Turkish
Figen UZUN
48802/22
Tanyaş v. Türkiye
11/10/2022
Levent TANYAŞ
1975
Turkish
Adem UZAK
49106/22
Yağız v. Türkiye
07/10/2022
Reha YAĞIZ
1986
Ankara
Turkish
Ali YILDIZ
50314/22
İnci v. Türkiye
19/10/2022
İbrahim İNCİ
1973
Istanbul
Turkish
Elmas YUNUS
50437/22
Gündüz v. Türkiye
17/10/2022
Fatih GÜNDÜZ
1988
Ağrı
Turkish
Hilal Tuğçe ŞAHİN
51110/22
Özmen v. Türkiye
24/10/2022
Münevver ÖZMEN
1979
Antalya
Turkish
Zaliha VARLI
51398/22
Turgut v. Türkiye
14/10/2022
Yunus TURGUT
1989
Istanbul
Turkish
Nurgül YAYMAN YILMAZ
52003/22
Atik v. Türkiye
01/11/2022
YILMAZ ATİK
1981
İzmit
Turkish
İbrahim Halil UZUN
52302/22
Aslan v. Türkiye
02/11/2022
Alaattin ASLAN
1983
Antalya
Turkish
Zaliha VARLI
52528/22
Artun v. Türkiye
12/10/2022
Ramazan ARTUN
1973
Kocaeli
Turkish
Murat YILMAZ
53421/22
Derinkuyu v. Türkiye
03/11/2022
Mustafa DERİNKUYU
1986
Kahramanmaraş
Turkish
Fatma YILMAZ
54356/22
Altan v. Türkiye
17/11/2022
Akif ALTAN
1974
Bilecik
Turkish
Nurullah YILDIRIM
54955/22
Velioğlu v. Türkiye
15/11/2022
Selahattin VELİOĞLU
1993
Trabzon
Turkish
Abdullah VELİOĞLU
54958/22
Akyazı v. Türkiye
18/11/2022
Sümeyye AKYAZI
1985
Turkish
Naim UZUN
54961/22
Turan v. Türkiye
17/11/2022
Hüseyin Alptuğ TURAN
1982
Trabzon
Turkish
55403/22
Caymaz v. Türkiye
24/11/2022
Mehmet Orbay CAYMAZ
1987
Turkish
Eyyüp SAĞIR
57500/22
Vural v. Türkiye
06/12/2022
Murat VURAL
1978
Kayseri
Turkish
Selim YILMAZ
195/23
Yılmaz v. Türkiye
13/12/2022
Ömür Zehra YILMAZ
1987
Malatya
Turkish
İrfan YILMAZ
289/23
Uluhatun v. Türkiye
30/12/2022
Yunus ULUHATUN
1992
Bursa
Turkish
Figen UZUN
2452/23
Güneş v. Türkiye
29/12/2022
Ahmet Yaşar GÜNEŞ
1977
Bilecik
Turkish
Nurullah YILDIRIM
4518/23
Kara v. Türkiye
18/01/2023
Abdulkadir KARA
1970
Malatya
Turkish
Ali YÜCEL
8453/23
Danışmaz v. Türkiye
01/02/2023
Ramazan DANIŞMAZ
1972
Samsun
Turkish
İnan UZUN
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy