FIRST SECTION
DECISION
Application no. 35139/14
Temur Damyrovych YULDASHEV and Violeta Viktorivna YULDASHEVA against Ukraine and Russia
and 326 other applications
(see list appended)
The European Court of Human Rights (First Section), sitting on 5 May 2020 as a Committee composed of:
Aleš Pejchal, President,
Tim Eicke,
Jovan Ilievski, judges,
and Renata Degener, Deputy Section Registrar,
Having regard to the above applications lodged on the various dates indicated in the appended table,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
THE FACTS
1. A list of the applicants is set out in the appendix. They were represented before the Court by Ms N.Y. Tselovalnichenko, a lawyer practising in Kyiv.
The circumstances of the caseIncidents giving rise to the applications
2. The facts of the cases, as submitted by the applicants, may be summarised as follows.
3. The applicants argued that from the beginning of April 2014 onwards armed separatist groups had started to seize official buildings and territory in the east of Ukraine and announced the creation of two so-called “People’s Republics”; namely the “Donetsk People’s Republic” and the “Lugansk People’s Republic”. In response, on 14 April 2014 the Ukrainian Government had begun what they termed an “anti-terrorist operation”, involving the use of armed military force.
4. Some of the applicants also argued that Crimea had been “occupied” and “annexed” by the Russian Federation in February and March 2014.
5. The incidents which, according to the applicants, had taken place in the course of and subsequent to the developments in the preceding paragraphs and which formed the basis of their applications, can be summarised as follows:
-a number of houses belonging to some of the applicants in Eastern Ukraine had been damaged and, in some cases, completely destroyed during “shelling by pro-Russian militants or by Russian or Ukrainian armed forces”. As a result, some of the applicants had been forced to live in destitute conditions without running water, gas, electricity, heating, food supplies or medication. The constant shelling by heavy weapons had also endangered their lives. Some applicants had had to abandon their villages, towns and cities and fled to other parts of Ukraine. The applicants had also been unable to have access to Ukrainian courts to claim compensation for the damage caused to their properties because the jurisdictions of the courts in the areas in Eastern Ukraine which were not under the control of the Ukrainian Government had been transferred to the relevant courts in the neighbouring regions that were controlled by the Ukrainian Government;
-some applicants and their relatives had been injured during the shelling and some of their relatives had been killed;
-some applicants and their relatives had been arrested and detained unlawfully by members of armed separatist groups who also carried out a number of abductions, robberies, and perpetrated ill-treatment and killings;
-some of the applicants’ pension payments had been stopped by the Ukrainian Government;
-some applicants who lived in areas of Eastern Ukraine which were not controlled by the Ukrainian Government had been unable to vote during the Presidential and Parliamentary elections. They had also been afraid to speak the Ukrainian language and to express pro-Ukrainian views for fear of recriminations from the militants;
-there had existed no effective remedies within the meaning of Article 13 of the Convention for their complaints summarised above. Moreover, since the beginning of April 2014 official buildings in some parts of Eastern Ukraine had been seized and the activities carried out therein suspended and it had therefore been impossible for the applicants to have their Convention rights guaranteed effectively;
-a number of applicants, who are Crimean Tatars, had been forced to flee Crimea;
-some of the applicants who were living in various parts of Ukraine had been unable to freely reside and move through the territory of Crimea; and, finally,
-the applicants in fifty-seven of the applications directed their applications against the United Kingdom and alleged that, as well as the Russian Federation and Ukraine, the United Kingdom had also been responsible for their grievances. In that connection they alleged that the United Kingdom, by signing the Memorandum on security assurances in connection with Ukraine’s accession to the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons in Budapest on 5 December 1994, had become a guarantor of Ukrainian independence and security and had thus become duty-bound to take effective measures against the Russian Federation for “its military intervention in Ukraine”. As the United Kingdom had not taken any such measures, it bore partial responsibility for the above-summarised incidents.The Court’s decision to bar Ms N. Tselovalnichenko
6. On 4 December 2018, in its examination of a number of applications in which the applicants – like the applicants in the present applications – were represented by Ms Tselovalnichenko, the Court decided, under Rule 36 § 4 (b) of the Rules of Court, that in view of her fraudulent and abusive behaviour in a number of cases lodged with the Court Ms Tselovalnichenko should be permanently barred from representing or otherwise assisting applicants in both pending and future applications.
7. In order to inform all applicants represented by her, notably those residing in areas that could not be reached by post, the Court issued a press release on 12 December 2018 (ECHR 433 (2018)) and invited the media to inform the public about its decision to bar Ms Tselovalnichenko (see Chepelenko and Others v. Ukraine (dec.), nos. 15117/17, 18635/17, 18655/17, 251/18 and 3633/18, §§ 17-18, 28 January 2020).Attempts made to contact the applicants in the present applications
8. According to the information contained in the application forms submitted to the Court by the applicants in the present applications, the vast majority of them were living in the Donetsk and Luhansk regions of Eastern Ukraine at the time of the introduction of their applications. After issuing the above-mentioned press release on 12 December 2018, the Court sent letters to the applicants on 17 December 2018 with a view to notifying them that Ms Tselovalnichenko could no longer act as their representative. The letters also stated that it was open to the applicants to appoint new representatives to replace her at any time. Almost all of those letters were returned to the Court undelivered.
9. On 30 September 2019 a second attempt was made to contact the applicants and letters were sent to them once more. In those letters the applicants were asked to inform the Court by 25 October 2019 whether they wished to maintain their applications and, if so, to provide information about any important factual developments that might have taken place since their last correspondence to the Court. The applicants were warned that failure to reply to the Court’s letter by the above-mentioned deadline could lead the Court to conclude that they were no longer interested in pursuing their applications and to strike them out of its list of cases. Replies were received in a small number of cases only – in some of which the applicants informed the Court that they had appointed new legal representatives – and the Court will continue to examine those cases. The letters sent to the applicants in the present 327 applications were either returned to the Court undelivered or no replies were received from the applicants.
COMPLAINTS
10. In respect of their allegations summarised in paragraph 5 above, the applicants relied on, inter alia, Articles 2, 3, 5, 6, 8, 9, 10, 11, 13 and 14 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1.
THE LAW
11. Having regard to the similar subject matter of the applications, the Court finds it appropriate to examine them jointly in a single decision.
12. The Court notes that, at the time of the introduction of their applications, the vast majority of applicants were living in the territories of the Donetsk and Luhansk regions which were outside the control of the Ukrainian Government and in which the Ukrainian postal service Ukrposhta had suspended its operations because of frequent attacks on its vehicles and employees by armed groups (see Chepelenko and Others, cited above, §§ 21 and 23; see also Tsezar and Others v. Ukraine, nos. 73590/14 and 6 others, § 9, 13 February 2018). As detailed above, in addition to issuing the press release on 12 December 2018, the Court also made two attempts to establish direct contact with the applicants by sending them letters, but those attempts were unsuccessful.
13. As the application forms provided by the applicants did not indicate any other contact details ̶ such as alternative postal addresses, e-mails, telephone numbers etc. ̶ the Court was also unable to contact the applicants by such means.
14. Moreover, the Court has not received any correspondence directly from the applicants since the introduction of the applications. It must be stressed in this connection that Rule 47 § 7 of the Rules of Court requires applicants to keep the Court informed of any change of their addresses and of all circumstances relevant to their application. The Court considers that the fluid nature of the situation surrounding the applicants’ cases makes it all the more important for the Court to receive regular information and updates from the applicants.
15. The Court also reiterates that, on account of the independence of the legal profession from the State, the conduct of the legal representation is essentially a matter between the applicants and their lawyer (see Chepelenko and Others, cited above, § 33 and the case cited therein). Therefore, following the Court’s decision to bar the applicants’ representative, it was for that representative to inform her clients of such a pertinent development in their cases.
16. The Court is thus faced with a situation in which it is not being provided with any information by the applicants nor is it in a position to contact them, which makes it impossible for the Court to continue to examine these applications.
17. The Court considers that, in these circumstances, the applicants may be regarded as no longer wishing to pursue their applications, within the meaning of Article 37 § 1 (a) of the Convention. Furthermore, in accordance with Article 37 § 1 in fine, the Court finds no special circumstances regarding respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and its Protocols which require the continued examination of the case.
18. Finally, the Court reiterates that under Article 37 § 2 of the Convention it may decide to restore an application to its list of cases if it considers that the circumstances justify such a course.
19. In view of the above, it is appropriate to strike the cases out of the list.
For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,
Decides to join the applications;
Decides to strike the application out of its list of cases.
Renata DegenerAleš Pejchal
Deputy RegistrarPresident
Appendix
No.
Application no.
Case name
Lodged on
Applicant
Year of Birth
Place of Residence
Nationality
1.
35139/14
Yuldashev and Yuldasheva v. Russia and Ukraine
03/05/2014
Temur Damyrovych YULDASHEV
1969
Lugansk
Ukrainian
Violeta Viktorivna YULDASHEVA
1976
Lugansk
Ukrainian
2.
43147/14
Yefremova and Yefremov v. Russia and Ukraine
04/06/2014
Iryna Mykolayivna YEFREMOVA
1984
Oleksandrivsk
Ukrainian
Illya Ivanovych YEFREMOV
1978
Oleksandrivsk
Ukrainian
3.
43160/14
Budyk v. Russia and Ukraine
04/06/2014
Natalya Volodymyrivna BUDYK
1974
Gorlivka
Georgian
Vasyl Volodymyrovych BUDYK
1972
Gorlivka
Georgian
4.
43225/14
Demko v. Russia and Ukraine
04/06/2014
Oleksiy Petrovych DEMKO
1969
Makiyivka
Ukrainian
Maryna Viktorivna DEMKO
1969
Makiyivka
Ukrainian
5.
45295/14
Tantashova v. Russia and Ukraine
11/06/2014
Elvira Suleymanivna TANTASHOVA
1983
Ivano-Frankivsk
Ukrainian
6.
45336/14
Kravchenko v. Russia and Ukraine
11/06/2014
Valeriy Mykolayovych KRAVCHENKO
1970
Ivano-Frankivsk
Ukrainian
7.
50330/14
Vasin v. Russia and Ukraine
03/07/2014
Yuriy Anatoliyovych VASIN
1967
Lugansk
Ukrainian
8.
50336/14
Davlyatshyn v. Russia and Ukraine
03/07/2014
Yuriy Mantsufovych DAVLYATSHYN
1965
Lugansk
Ukrainian
9.
50345/14
Kichurka v. Russia and Ukraine
03/07/2014
Oleg Yosypovych KICHURKA
1965
Steenokkerzeel
Ukrainian
10.
50352/14
Reshetnyak v. Russia and Ukraine
03/07/2014
Oleksandr Vitaliyovych RESHETNYAK
1964
Veselenke
Ukrainian
Andriy Oleksandrovych RESHETNYAK
1988
Veselenke
Ukrainian
Larysa Grygorivna RESHETNYAK
1966
Veselenke
Ukrainian
11.
51256/14
Semystyaga v. Russia and Ukraine
01/07/2014
Volodymyr Fedorovych SEMYSTYAGA
1949
Lugansk
Ukrainian
12.
51880/14
Pargyelyan v. Russia and Ukraine
07/07/2014
Artur Vrzhevych PARGYELYAN
1962
Shchastya
Ukrainian
13.
51895/14
Malyy and Malaya v. Russia and Ukraine
07/07/2014
Oleksandr Oleksandrovych MALYY
1991
Synelnikove
Ukrainian
Tetyana Volodymyrivna MALAYA
1971
Synelnikove
Ukrainian
14.
51905/14
Nazarov and Nazarova v. Russia and Ukraine
07/07/2014
Ruslan Sergiyovych NAZAROV
1990
Synelnykove
Ukrainian
Zukhra Safar-Aliyevna NAZAROVA
1970
Synelnikove
Ukrainian
15.
51911/14
Zayika and Reznik v. Russia and Ukraine
07/07/2014
Volodymyr Volodymyrovych ZAYIKA
1985
Synelnikove
Ukrainian
Nina Oleksandrivna REZNIK
1962
Synelnikove
Ukrainian
16.
51917/14
Tkachenko v. Russia and Ukraine
07/07/2014
Sergiy Viktorovych TKACHENKO
1971
Shchastya
Ukrainian
17.
52720/14
Nesterenko v. Russia and Ukraine
14/07/2014
Vasyl Petrovych NESTERENKO
2014
Kramatorsk
Ukrainian
Iryna Anatoliyivna NESTERENKO
1977
Kramatorsk
Ukrainian
18.
52725/14
Grebenichenko v. Russia and Ukraine
14/07/2014
Pavlo Oleksandrovych GREBENICHENKO
1983
Lugansk
Ukrainian
19.
53482/14
Tatun v. Russia and Ukraine
07/07/2014
Taras Volodymyrovych TATUN
1981
Shchastya
Ukrainian
20.
54669/14
Nesterova and Nesterov v. Russia
26/07/2014
Svitlana Ivanivna NESTEROVA
1966
Kyiv
Ukrainian
Andriy Stanislavovych NESTEROV
1963
Kyiv
Ukrainian
21.
54684/14
Vasyushchenko v. Russia and Ukraine
26/07/2014
Oksana Valeriyivna VASYUSHCHENKO
1976
Yenakiyeve
Ukrainian
Oleksandr Anatoliyovych VASYUSHCHENKO
1972
Yenakiyeve
Ukrainian
22.
55591/14
Medvedyeva and Medvedyev v. Russia and Ukraine
30/07/2014
Kateryna Ivanivna MEDVEDYEVA
1952
Boryspil
Ukrainian
Volodymyr Anatoliyovych MEDVEDYEV
1979
Boryspil
Ukrainian
23.
55608/14
Sokolenko v. Russia and Ukraine
30/07/2014
Sergiy Viktorovych SOKOLENKO
1983
Kyiv
Ukrainian
24.
55619/14
Andrushchenko v. Russia and Ukraine
30/07/2014
Valentyna Ivanivna ANDRUSHCHENKO
1979
Kagarlyk
Ukrainian
Oleksandr Oleksiyovych ANDRUSHCHENKO
1981
Kagarlyk
Ukrainian
25.
55632/14
Dovnich v. Russia and Ukraine
30/07/2014
Kateryna Volodymyrivna DOVNICH
1955
Sytnyaky
Ukrainian
Oleg Viktorovych DOVNICH
1984
Makariv
Ukrainian
26.
55648/14
Novikova and Novikov v. Russia and Ukraine
30/07/2014
Lesya Sergiyivna NOVIKOVA
1979
Busheve
Ukrainian
Ruslan Oleksandrovych NOVIKOV
1974
Olshanytsya
Ukrainian
27.
57237/14
Ishchenko v. Russia and Ukraine
15/08/2014
Viktoriya Valeriyivna ISHCHENKO
1987
Kyiv
Ukrainian
Iryna Anatoliyivna ISHCHENKO
1964
Kyiv
Ukrainian
Valeriy Andriyovych ISHCHENKO
1965
Kyiv
Ukrainian
28.
58508/14
Khanin and Khanina v. Russia and Ukraine
25/08/2014
Yevgeniy Viktorovich KHANIN
1975
Zimogorye
Ukrainian
Viktor Nikolayevich KHANIN
1952
Rodakove
Ukrainian
Olga Ivanovna KHANINA
1953
Rodakove
Ukrainian
Artem Viktorovich KHANIN
1981
Rodakove
Ukrainian
29.
58781/14
Mamay v. Russia and Ukraine
16/08/2014
Pavlo Mykhaylovych MAMAY
1960
Donetsk
Ukrainian
Lev Pavlovych MAMAY
1985
Donetsk
Ukrainian
30.
58837/14
Malakhova v. Russia and Ukraine
16/08/2014
Olga Petrivna MALAKHOVA
1966
Slovyansk
Ukrainian
31.
58868/14
Orel v. Russia and Ukraine
16/08/2014
Oleksandr Sergiyovych OREL
1989
Sukha Kamyanka
Ukrainian
32.
61031/14
Lyesnov v. Russia and Ukraine
26/08/2014
Yuriy Volodymyrovych LYESNOV
1996
Lugansk
Ukrainian
33.
61037/14
Mangush v. Russia and Ukraine
26/08/2014
Oleksandr Oleksandrovych MANGUSH
1995
Lugansk
Ukrainian
34.
61040/14
Samarskyy v. Russia and Ukraine
26/08/2014
Sergiy Viktorovych SAMARSKYY
1962
Syevyerodonetsk
Ukrainian
35.
61048/14
Kryvenko v. Russia and Ukraine
26/08/2014
Ivan Oleksandrovych KRYVENKO
1957
Odesa
Ukrainian
36.
61054/14
Kravtsov v. Russia and Ukraine
26/08/2014
Oleg Grygorovych KRAVTSOV
1971
Slovyansk
Ukrainian
37.
61056/14
Khomenko v. Russia and Ukraine
26/08/2014
Volodymyr Mykolayovych KHOMENKO
1975
Myrolyubivka
Ukrainian
38.
64258/14
Yugosh v. Russia
20/09/2014
Kateryna Volodymyrivna YUGOSH
1985
Kyiv
Ukrainian
39.
64293/14
Yugosh v. Russia
20/09/2014
Ruslan Mykolayovych YUGOSH
1976
Kyiv
Ukrainian
40.
2875/15
Bukhonko v. Russia and Ukraine
29/12/2014
Denys Oleksandrovych BUKHONKO
1979
Stanytsya Luganska
Ukrainian
41.
2877/15
Gerasymchuk v. Russia and Ukraine
29/12/2014
Ganna Oleksandrivna GERASYMCHUK
1978
Stanytsya Luganska
Ukrainian
42.
4471/15
Sitnikov v. Russia and Ukraine
26/12/2014
Oleg Dmytrovych SITNIKOV
1996
Lugansk
Ukrainian
43.
4522/15
Mezentseva v. Russia and Ukraine
12/01/2015
Iryna Anatoliyivna MEZENTSEVA
1984
Amvrosiyivka
Ukrainian
44.
4531/15
Mezentsev v. Russia and Ukraine
12/01/2015
Dmytro Viktorovych MEZENTSEV
1968
Amvrosiyivka
Ukrainian
45.
4544/15
Kovalenko v. Russia and Ukraine
12/01/2015
Anatoliy Ivanovych KOVALENKO
1952
Amvrosiyivka
Ukrainian
46.
4962/15
Kovalenko v. Russia and Ukraine
12/01/2015
Zinayida Mykhaylivna KOVALENKO
1954
Amvrosiyivka
Ukrainian
47.
5221/15
Kovalyov v. Russia and Ukraine
01/10/2014
Oleksandr Volodymyrovych KOVALYOV
1958
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
48.
5304/15
Orel v. Russia and Ukraine
04/01/2015
Igor Yevgenovych OREL
1961
Stakhanov
Ukrainian
49.
5363/15
Lisnyy v. Russia and Ukraine
26/12/2014
Vasyl Mykolayovych LISNYY
1954
Yasynuvata
Ukrainian
50.
5372/15
Lisna v. Russia and Ukraine
26/12/2014
Tetyana Volodymyrivna LISNA
1958
Yasynuvata
Ukrainian
51.
5466/15
Kovalyova v. Russia and Ukraine
12/01/2015
Lyubov Mytrofanivna KOVALYOVA
1955
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
52.
5598/15
Ryabchynska v. Russia and Ukraine
26/12/2014
Olena Sergiyivna RYABCHYNSKA
1986
Lugansk
Ukrainian
53.
5618/15
Kovalyov v. Russia and Ukraine
12/01/2015
Andriy Oleksandrovych KOVALYOV
1986
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
54.
5619/15
Mishyn v. Russia and Ukraine
26/12/2014
Artem Gennadiyovych MISHYN
1986
Valuyske
Ukrainian
55.
5632/15
Prokopenko v. Russia and Ukraine
04/01/2015
Kateryna Stanislavivna PROKOPENKO
1975
Lugansk
Ukrainian
56.
8957/15
Vakulenko v. Russia and Ukraine
03/02/2015
Viktor Volodymyrovych VAKULENKO
1957
Metalist
Ukrainian
57.
9055/15
Motinov v. Russia and Ukraine
03/02/2015
Oleksiy Stanislavovych MOTINOV
1989
Krasnyy Luch
Ukrainian
58.
9057/15
Vakulenko v. Russia and Ukraine
03/02/2015
Ganna Vasylivna VAKULENKO
1931
Metalist
Ukrainian
59.
9060/15
Kravchenko v. Russia and Ukraine
03/02/2015
Olga Volodymyrivna KRAVCHENKO
1976
Lugansk
Ukrainian
60.
9076/15
Zolotukhina v. Russia and Ukraine
03/02/2015
Olena Viktorivna ZOLOTUKHINA
1970
Antratsyt
Ukrainian
61.
9082/15
Nosachova v. Russia and Ukraine
03/02/2015
Galyna Ivanivna NOSACHOVA
1971
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
62.
12986/15
Ratnikov v. Russia and Ukraine
26/02/2015
Sergiy Viktorovych RATNIKOV
1955
Syeverodonetsk
Ukrainian
63.
18165/15
Sydorenko v. Russia and Ukraine
30/03/2015
Ganna Vikrorivna SYDORENKO
1961
Donetsk
Ukrainian
64.
19479/15
Ovcharova v. Russia and Ukraine
14/04/2015
Galyna Stepanivna OVCHAROVA
1959
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
65.
19487/15
Ovcharova v. Russia and Ukraine
14/04/2015
Svitlana Vladyslavivna OVCHAROVA
1963
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
66.
19573/15
Drogalo v. Russia and Ukraine
14/04/2015
Nataliya Oleksandrivna DROGALO
1958
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
67.
19582/15
Shevchenko v. Russia and Ukraine
14/04/2015
Viktoriya Oleksandrivna SHEVCHENKO
1969
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
68.
19588/15
Zenzer v. Russia and Ukraine
14/04/2015
Oksana Yuryivna ZENZER
1970
Lugansk
Ukrainian
69.
19589/15
Irkliyevska v. Russia and Ukraine
14/04/2015
Olga Volodymyrivna IRKLIYEVSKA
1960
Donetsk
Ukrainian
70.
19597/15
Zenzer v. Russia and Ukraine
14/04/2015
Yuriy Ivanovych ZENZER
1963
Lugansk
Ukrainian
71.
19601/15
Stepanenko v. Russia and Ukraine
06/04/2015
Yuriy Petrovych STEPANENKO
1969
Donetsk
Ukrainian
72.
20127/15
Irkliyevskyy v. Russia and Ukraine
14/04/2015
Sergiy Oleksandrovych IRKLIYEVSKYY
1982
Donetsk
Ukrainian
73.
20151/15
Shmidt v. Russia and Ukraine
14/04/2015
Iryna Oleksandrivna SHMIDT
1968
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
74.
20165/15
Rylshchikova v. Russia and Ukraine
14/04/2015
Ganna Mykhaylivna RYLSHCHIKOVA
1964
Stanytsya Luganska
Ukrainian
75.
20166/15
Rylshchikova v. Russia and Ukraine
14/04/2015
Olena Mykhaylivna RYLSHCHIKOVA
1964
Stanytsya Luganska
Ukrainian
76.
20167/15
Buchylina v. Russia and Ukraine
14/04/2015
Yuliya Volodymyrivna BUCHYLINA
1976
Lugansk
Ukrainian
77.
22213/15
Klymenko v. Russia and Ukraine
23/04/2015
Oleksandr Oleksiyovych KLYMENKO
1972
Lugansk
Ukrainian
78.
22242/15
Kornilova v. Russia and Ukraine
23/04/2015
Olena Ivanivna KORNILOVA
1927
Lugansk
Ukrainian
79.
22517/15
Zinovyeva v. Russia
23/04/2015
Zhanna Ivanivna ZINOVYEVA
1975
Kyiv
Ukrainian
80.
22526/15
Panova v. Russia and Ukraine
23/04/2015
Polyna Mykhaylivna PANOVA
1957
Zolote
Ukrainian
81.
22531/15
Yakymov v. Russia and Ukraine
23/04/2015
Anatoliy Andriyovych YAKYMOV
1955
Zolote
Ukrainian
82.
22732/15
Panova v. Russia and Ukraine
23/04/2015
Maryna Mykolayivna PANOVA
1983
Zolote
Ukrainian
83.
22734/15
Dobrovolskyy v. Russia and Ukraine
23/04/2015
Viktor Vasylyovych DOBROVOLSKYY
1949
Zolote
Ukrainian
84.
22737/15
Dobrovolska v. Russia and Ukraine
23/04/2015
Svitlana Grygorivna DOBROVOLSKA
1954
Zolote
Ukrainian
85.
22747/15
Panov v. Russia and Ukraine
23/04/2015
Volodymyr Viktorovych PANOV
1979
Zolote
Ukrainian
86.
22756/15
Yakymova v. Russia and Ukraine
23/04/2015
Tamara Yukhymivna YAKYMOVA
1957
Zolote
Ukrainian
87.
22763/15
Manuylenko v. Russia and Ukraine
23/04/2015
Vitaliy Yegorovych MANUYLENKO
1953
Zolote
Ukrainian
88.
22776/15
Manuylenko v. Russia and Ukraine
23/04/2015
Iryna Viktorivna MANUYLENKO
1955
Zolote
Ukrainian
89.
22783/15
Mykhaylova v. Russia and Ukraine
23/04/2015
Galyna Leonidivna MYKHAYLOVA
1949
Zolote
Ukrainian
90.
22967/15
Klimenko v. Russia and Ukraine
21/03/2015
Oleksiy Oleksiyovych KLIMENKO
1937
Lugansk
Ukrainian
91.
25685/15
Gubska v. Russia and Ukraine
04/05/2015
Tetyana Oleksandrivna GUBSKA
1960
Lugansk
Ukrainian
92.
25734/15
Golovina v. Russia and Ukraine
04/05/2015
Lidiya Vasylivna GOLOVINA
1930
Slovyansk
Ukrainian
93.
25737/15
Spiridonova v. Russia
04/05/2015
Svitlana Vladyslavivna SPIRIDONOVA
1960
Donetsk
Ukrainian
94.
25738/15
Myronenko v. Russia and Ukraine
04/05/2015
Oleksandra Yakovlivna MYRONENKO
1929
Lugansk
Ukrainian
95.
30951/15
Bondarenko v. Russia and Ukraine
15/06/2015
Bogdan Vitaliyovych BONDARENKO
1983
Lugansk
Ukrainian
96.
30954/15
Ilchenko v. Russia and Ukraine
15/06/2015
Kostyantyn Grygoriyovych ILCHENKO
1959
Lugansk
Ukrainian
97.
30989/15
Andriyenko v. Russia and Ukraine
10/06/2015
Yuriy Petrovych ANDRIYENKO
1958
Lugansk
Ukrainian
98.
30993/15
Artemenko v. Russia and Ukraine
10/06/2015
Valentyna Oleksandrivna ARTEMENKO
1933
Lugansk
Ukrainian
99.
31003/15
Artemenko v. Russia and Ukraine
10/06/2015
Volen Mykhaylovych ARTEMENKO
1933
Lugansk
Ukrainian
100.
31005/15
Artemenko v. Russia and Ukraine
10/06/2015
Tetyana Volenivna ARTEMENKO
1978
Lugansk
Ukrainian
101.
31008/15
Borysov v. Russia and Ukraine
10/06/2015
Gennadiy Volodymyrovych BORYSOV
1959
Lugansk
Ukrainian
102.
31009/15
Gulyayev v. Russia and Ukraine
10/06/2015
Viktor Pavlovych GULYAYEV
1940
Lugansk
Ukrainian
103.
31011/15
Gulyayeva v. Russia and Ukraine
10/06/2015
Olga Viktorivna GULYAYEVA
1973
Lugansk
Ukrainian
104.
31013/15
Kurdumanova v. Russia and Ukraine
10/06/2015
Olena Ivanivna KURDUMANOVA
1972
Lugansk
Ukrainian
105.
31014/15
Kurdumanova v. Russia and Ukraine
10/06/2015
Vira Arkhypivna KURDUMANOVA
1946
Lugansk
Ukrainian
106.
31020/15
Stepanenko v. Russia and Ukraine
10/06/2015
Yuriy Petrovych STEPANENKO
1969
Donetsk
Ukrainian
107.
31022/15
Stepanenko v. Russia and Ukraine
10/06/2015
Nataliya Valentynivna STEPANENKO
1976
Donetsk
Ukrainian
108.
31025/15
Rylshchikova v. Russia and Ukraine
10/06/2015
Olena Mykhaylivna RYLSHCHIKOVA
1964
Stanychno-Luganske
Ukrainian
109.
31028/15
Irkliyevska v. Russia and Ukraine
10/06/2015
Olga Volodymyrivna IRKLIYEVSKA
1960
Donetsk
Ukrainian
110.
31032/15
Irkliyevskyy v. Russia and Ukraine
10/06/2015
Segiy Oleksandrovych IRKLIYEVSKYY
Donetsk
Ukrainian
111.
31034/15
Glushchenko v. Russia and Ukraine
10/06/2015
Vyacheslav Ivanovych GLUSHCHENKO
1980
Lugansk
Ukrainian
112.
31037/15
Yakushenko v. Russia and Ukraine
10/06/2015
Volodymyr Mykhaylovych YAKUSHENKO
1957
Lugansk
Ukrainian
113.
33161/15
Nyestyerova v. Russia and Ukraine
03/07/2015
Nina Mykolayivna NYESTYEROVA
1955
Lugansk
Ukrainian
114.
35112/15
Striletska v. Russia and Ukraine
10/07/2015
Liliya Gennadiyivna STRILETSKA
1986
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
115.
35119/15
Temchenko v. Russia and Ukraine
10/07/2015
Tetyana Mykolayivna TEMCHENKO
1966
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
116.
35144/15
Fyedosova v. Russia and Ukraine
10/07/2015
Olena Anatoliyivna FYEDOSOVA
1965
Donetsk
Ukrainian
117.
35151/15
Balagurak v. Russia and Ukraine
10/07/2015
Olga Petrivna BALAGURAK
1975
Stakhanov
Ukrainian
118.
35170/15
Zaplavska v. Russia and Ukraine
10/07/2015
Iryna Yevgenivna ZAPLAVSKA
1953
Lugansk
Ukrainian
119.
35873/15
Kolesnykov v. Russia and Ukraine
03/07/2015
Mykola Oleksiyovych KOLESNYKOV
1960
Rovenky
Ukrainian
120.
35900/15
Zaplavskyy v. Russia and Ukraine
10/07/2015
Sergiy Leonidovych ZAPLAVSKYY
1953
Lugansk
Ukrainian
121.
35923/15
Babenko v. Russia and Ukraine
10/07/2015
Yuriy Volodymyrovych BABENKO
1957
Lugansk
Ukrainian
122.
35932/15
Babenko v. Russia and Ukraine
10/07/2015
Volodymyr Yuriyovych BABENKO
1988
Lugansk
Ukrainian
123.
35939/15
Danile v. Russia and Ukraine
03/07/2015
Tetyana Volodymyrivna DANILE
1952
Krasnodon
Ukrainian
124.
35944/15
Shevchenko v. Russia and Ukraine
03/07/2015
Andriy Ivanovych SHEVCHENKO
1973
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
125.
35945/15
Babenko v. Russia and Ukraine
10/07/2015
Larysa Yuliyivna BABENKO
1959
Lugansk
Ukrainian
126.
35975/15
Dyusmyenyev v. Russia and Ukraine
10/07/2015
Oleksiy Ivanovych DYUSMYENYEV
1974
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
127.
35984/15
Kulikov v. Russia and Ukraine
03/07/2015
Ruslan Oleksiyovych KULIKOV
1978
Lugansk
Ukrainian
128.
35987/15
Kamuz v. Russia and Ukraine
03/07/2015
Roman Volodymyrovych KAMUZ
1983
Stanytsya-Luganska
Ukrainian
129.
35989/15
Pryshchepa v. Russia and Ukraine
10/07/2015
Nataliya Petrivna PRYSHCHEPA
1960
Lugansk
Ukrainian
130.
35997/15
Spiridonova v. Russia and Ukraine
10/07/2015
Viktoriya Oleksandrivna SPIRIDONOVA
1989
Kyiv
Ukrainian
131.
36000/15
Kamuz v. Russia and Ukraine
03/07/2015
Oleksandra Oleksandrivna KAMUZ
1982
Stanytsya-Luganska
Ukrainian
132.
36035/15
Logachov v. Russia and Ukraine
10/07/2015
Anatoliy Ivanovych LOGACHOV
1960
Debaltsevo
Ukrainian
133.
36051/15
Logachova v. Russia and Ukraine
10/07/2015
Nataliya Anatoliyivna LOGACHOVA
1956
Debaltsevo
Ukrainian
134.
36069/15
Svetlova v. Russia and Ukraine
10/07/2015
Nina Grygorivna SVETLOVA
1962
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
135.
36077/15
Povkh v. Russia and Ukraine
10/07/2015
Valentyn Ivanovych POVKH
1955
Lugansk
Ukrainian
136.
37136/15
Podolyanko v. Russia and Ukraine
29/07/2015
Nataliya Mykolayivna PODOLYANKO
1960
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
137.
37188/15
Stratilatov v. Russia and Ukraine
29/07/2015
Artem Olegovych STRATILATOV
1992
Debaltsevo
Ukrainian
138.
37278/15
Podolyanko v. Russia and Ukraine
17/07/2015
Anatoliy Vasylyovych PODOLYANKO
1956
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
139.
37293/15
Stratilatova v. Russia and Ukraine
17/07/2015
Kristyna Volodymyrivna STRATILATOVA
1976
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
140.
37295/15
Stratilatov v. Russia and Ukraine
17/07/2015
Sergiy Volodymyrovych STRATILATOV
1975
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
141.
37300/15
Mashchenko v. Russia and Ukraine
17/07/2015
Iryna Volodymyrivna MASHCHENKO
1960
Uglegirsk
Ukrainian
142.
37304/15
Pomnikova v. Russia and Ukraine
17/07/2015
Mariya Olegivna POMNIKOVA
1992
Lugansk
Ukrainian
143.
37325/15
Lopatina v. Russia and Ukraine
29/07/2015
Tetyana Ivanivna LOPATINA
1958
Vuglegirsk
Ukrainian
144.
37627/15
Stratilatova v. Russia and Ukraine
17/07/2015
Yevgeniya Sergiyivna STRATILATOVA
1997
Debaltsevo
Ukrainian
145.
37631/15
Logachova v. Russia and Ukraine
17/07/2015
Oksana Yuriyivna LOGACHOVA
1981
Debaltsevo
Ukrainian
146.
37671/15
Stratilatova v. Russia and Ukraine
17/07/2015
Svitlana Valeriyivna STRATILATOVA
1973
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
147.
37679/15
Shapovalova v. Russia and Ukraine
17/07/2015
Nina Gavrylivna SHAPOVALOVA
1959
Debaltsevo
Ukrainian
148.
37688/15
Shapovalova v. Russia and Ukraine
17/07/2015
Lyudmyla Anatoliyivna SHAPOVALOVA
1984
Debaltsevo
Ukrainian
149.
37703/15
Sukharevskyy v. Russia and Ukraine
17/07/2015
Volodymyr Mykolayovych SUKHAREVSKYY
1955
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
150.
37705/15
Kibalo v. Russia and Ukraine
04/07/2015
Lyudmyla Grygorivna KIBALO
1955
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
151.
37720/15
Kudrya v. Russia and Ukraine
04/07/2015
Yuriy Oleksiyovych KUDRYA
1961
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
152.
37723/15
Sukharevska v. Russia and Ukraine
17/07/2015
Tamara Volodymyrivna SUKHAREVSKA
2015
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
153.
37731/15
Melnikova v. Russia and Ukraine
04/07/2015
Valentyna Mykolayivna MELNIKOVA
1958
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
154.
37738/15
Kalashnikova v. Russia and Ukraine
17/07/2015
Lyudmyla Stanislavivna KALASHNIKOVA
1953
Komisarivka
Ukrainian
155.
37742/15
Dyusmyenyeva v. Russia and Ukraine
17/07/2015
Tetyana Oleksiyivna DYUSMYENYEVA
1951
Debaltsevo
Ukrainian
156.
49733/15
Naryadko v. Russia and Ukraine
17/09/2015
Volodymyr Pavlovych NARYADKO
1950
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
157.
49739/15
Naryadko v. Russia and Ukraine
17/09/2015
Ganna Fedotivna NARYADKO
1949
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
158.
49777/15
Chemet v. Russia and Ukraine
22/09/2015
Mykola Ivanovych CHEMET
1956
Lugansk
Ukrainian
159.
49786/15
Abesadze v. Russia and Ukraine
17/09/2015
Kateryna Vasylivna ABESADZE
1954
Molodogvardiysk
Ukrainian
160.
49844/15
Abesadze v. Russia and Ukraine
17/09/2015
Ketevani Vakhtangivna ABESADZE
1991
Molodogvardiysk
Ukrainian
161.
49858/15
Orashvili v. Russia and Ukraine
17/09/2015
Ramaz Akakiyevich ORASHVILI
1954
Molodogvardiysk
Ukrainian
162.
49861/15
Sychov v. Russia and Ukraine
17/09/2015
Igor Mykolayovych SYCHOV
1985
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
163.
49868/15
Abesadze v. Russia and Ukraine
17/09/2015
Vakhtang Georgiyovych ABESADZE
1953
Molodogvardiysk
Ukrainian
164.
49874/15
Sychova v. Russia and Ukraine
17/09/2015
Lyudmyla Petrivna SYCHOVA
1954
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
165.
49878/15
Sychov v. Russia and Ukraine
17/09/2015
Mykola Ivanovych SYCHOV
1950
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
166.
50133/15
Kadurin v. Russia and Ukraine
17/09/2015
Viktor Ivanovych KADURIN
1958
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
167.
50142/15
Vlasova v. Russia and Ukraine
17/09/2015
Olena Grygorivna VLASOVA
1966
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
168.
50148/15
Vlasov v. Russia and Ukraine
17/09/2015
Sergiy Rekovych VLASOV
1987
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
169.
50158/15
Koloda v. Russia and Ukraine
17/09/2015
Vitaliy Vasylyovych KOLODA
1966
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
170.
50193/15
Kozhukhov v. Russia and Ukraine
17/09/2015
Oleksandr Oleksandrovych KOZHUKHOV
1974
Telmanove
Ukrainian
171.
50251/15
Medintseva v. Russia and Ukraine
21/09/2015
Tetyana Anatoliyivna MEDINTSEVA
1958
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
172.
50253/15
Dyatlova v. Russia and Ukraine
21/09/2015
Zinayida Mefodiyivna DYATLOVA
1935
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
173.
50254/15
Trotska v. Russia and Ukraine
21/09/2015
Olena Sergiyivna TROTSKA
1954
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
174.
50256/15
Trotskyy v. Russia and Ukraine
21/09/2015
Mykola Opanasovych TROTSKYY
1954
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
175.
50262/15
Moroz v. Russia and Ukraine
21/09/2015
Darya Oleksandrivna MOROZ
1983
Lugansk
Ukrainian
176.
50326/15
Kulishova v. Russia and Ukraine
07/09/2015
Nataliya Vakhtangivna KULISHOVA
1982
Molodogvardiysk
Ukrainian
177.
50362/15
Sychova v. Russia and Ukraine
21/09/2015
Kateryna Mykolayivna SYCHOVA
1985
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
178.
50550/15
Morozov v. Russia and Ukraine
07/09/2014
Yuriy Viktorovych MOROZOV
1956
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
179.
50572/15
Morozova v. Russia and Ukraine
07/09/2015
Darya Yuriyivna MOROZOVA
1991
Khryashchuvate
Ukrainian
180.
50591/15
Balashenko v. Russia and Ukraine
07/09/2015
Volodymyr Vasylyovych BALASHENKO
1957
Molodogvardiysk
Ukrainian
181.
50615/15
Boldyryeva v. Russia and Ukraine
07/09/2015
Tetyana Mykhaylivna BOLDYRYEVA
1963
Molodogvardiysk
Ukrainian
182.
50616/15
Dydyk v. Russia and Ukraine
07/09/2015
Tetyana Yegorivna DYDYK
1931
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
183.
50803/15
Romanenko v. Russia and Ukraine
21/09/2015
Lyudmyla Ivanivna ROMANENKO
1956
Lugansk
Ukrainian
184.
50835/15
Velykokhatska v. Russia and Ukraine
21/09/2015
Nina Ivanivna VELYKOKHATSKA
1950
Lugansk
Ukrainian
185.
50837/15
Medintsev v. Russia and Ukraine
21/09/2015
Oleksandr Yevgenovych MEDINTSEV
1986
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
186.
50860/15
Boguta v. Russia and Ukraine
15/09/2015
Sergiy Valeriyovych BOGUTA
1975
Lugansk
Ukrainian
187.
50869/15
Vorobyov v. Russia and Ukraine
15/09/2015
Yevgen Viktorovych VOROBYOV
1979
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
188.
50883/15
Farsikov v. Russia and Ukraine
15/09/2015
Oleksiy Yegorovych FARSIKOV
1972
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
189.
50888/15
Orashvili v. Russia and Ukraine
15/09/2015
Maryna Mykhaylivna ORASHVILI
1965
Molodogvardiysk
Ukrainian
190.
50927/15
Bardin v. Russia and Ukraine
21/09/2015
Yevgen Yuriyovych BARDIN
1957
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
191.
50933/15
Khrystenko v. Russia and Ukraine
21/09/2015
Valentyn Radionovych KHRYSTENKO
1960
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
192.
50965/15
Farsikova v. Russia and Ukraine
15/09/2015
Mariya Afanasiyivna FARSIKOVA
1936
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
193.
50968/15
Bardina v. Russia and Ukraine
21/09/2015
Lyudmyla Volodymyrivna BARDINA
1957
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
194.
50980/15
Kushniruk v. Russia and Ukraine
15/09/2015
Olena Mykolayivna KUSHNIRUK
1970
Lugansk
Ukrainian
195.
50991/15
Shaulska v. Russia and Ukraine
15/09/2015
Galyna Mykolayivna SHAULSKA
1975
Telmanove
Ukrainian
196.
51011/15
Chernykh v. Russia and Ukraine
15/09/2015
Lyubov Mykhaylivna CHERNYKH
1953
Fabrychne
Ukrainian
197.
51047/15
Kramarenko v. Russia and Ukraine
15/09/2015
Yevgen Mykolayovych KRAMARENKO
1971
Debaltsevo
Ukrainian
198.
51058/15
Lupain v. Russia and Ukraine
15/09/2015
Oleksiy Dmytrovych LUPAIN
1980
Vuglegirsk
Ukrainian
199.
51067/15
Vereshchagina v. Russia and Ukraine
15/09/2015
Nataliya Valeriyivna VERESHCHAGINA
1978
Debaltsevo
Ukrainian
200.
51074/15
Krolevetska v. Russia and Ukraine
15/09/2015
Valentyna Sydorivna KROLEVETSKA
1956
Molodogvardiysk
Ukrainian
201.
51086/15
Krolevetskyy v. Russia and Ukraine
15/09/2015
Borys Vasylyovych KROLEVETSKYY
1957
Molodogvardiysk
Ukrainian
202.
51096/15
Zharikova v. Russia and Ukraine
15/09/2015
Valentyna Pavlivna ZHARIKOVA
1954
Khryashchuvate
Ukrainian
203.
51216/15
Gryazyeva v. Russia and Ukraine
28/09/2015
Lyubov Viktorivna GRYAZYEVA
1955
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
204.
51339/15
Nosach v. Russia and Ukraine
28/09/2015
Sergiy Mykolayovych NOSACH
1975
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
205.
51347/15
Nosach v. Russia and Ukraine
28/09/2015
Olena Volodymyrivna NOSACH
1975
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
206.
51349/15
Bakhmutchenko v. Russia and Ukraine
28/09/2015
Igor Valeriyovych BAKHMUTCHENKO
1970
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
207.
51354/15
Klyuchnikova v. Russia and Ukraine
28/09/2015
Valentyna Ivanivna KLYUCHNIKOVA
1953
Komuna
Ukrainian
208.
52013/15
Bakhmutchenko v. Russia and Ukraine
28/09/2015
Tetyana Volodymyrivna BAKHMUTCHENKO
1978
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
Dmytro Igorovych BAKHMUTCHENKO
2004
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
209.
53071/15
Trostynska v. Russia and Ukraine
15/10/2015
Liliya Anatoliyivna TROSTYNSKA
1936
Gorlivka
Ukrainian
210.
53076/15
Salova v. Russia and Ukraine
15/10/2015
Olga Ivanivna SALOVA
1964
Gorlivka
Ukrainian
211.
61176/15
Shalimova v. Russia and Ukraine
21/11/2015
Tetyana Valeriyivna SHALIMOVA
1987
Komuna
Ukrainian
212.
62043/15
Bondarenko v. Russia and Ukraine
24/11/2015
Svitlana Grygorivna BONDARENKO
1972
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
213.
62068/15
Pavlenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Mykhaylo Yuriyovych PAVLENKO
1959
Krasnodon
Ukrainian
214.
62116/15
Sapozhkova v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Valentyna Viktorivna SAPOZHKOVA
1953
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
215.
62125/15
Panko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Lyudmyla Semenivna PANKO
1953
Komuna
Ukrainian
216.
62128/15
Dyrda v. Russia and Ukraine
24/11/2015
Galyna Oleksandrivna DYRDA
1940
Zorynsk
Ukrainian
217.
62275/15
Panko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Roman Grygorovych PANKO
1974
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
218.
62276/15
Myakotkin v. Russia and Ukraine
24/11/2015
Igor Vadymovych MYAKOTKIN
1966
Odesa
Ukrainian
219.
62280/15
Vasylchenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Valentyna Ivanivna VASYLCHENKO
1940
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
220.
62282/15
Myakotkin v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Roman Vadymovych MYAKOTKIN
1975
Lugansk
Ukrainian
221.
62283/15
Koryavko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Lyudmyla Ivanivna KORYAVKO
1951
Stanytsya Luganska
Ukrainian
222.
62287/15
Rusinova v. Russia and Ukraine
24/11/2015
Oleksandra Antonivna RUSINOVA
1940
Kharkiv
Ukrainian
223.
62288/15
Rusinov v. Russia and Ukraine
24/11/2015
Dmytro Ivanovych RUSINOV
1973
Pervomaysk
Ukrainian
224.
62289/15
Rusinov v. Russia and Ukraine
24/11/2015
Anton Dmytrovych RUSINOV
1997
Pervomaysk
Ukrainian
225.
294/16
Kharman v. Russia and Ukraine
24/11/2015
Lidiya Stepanivna KHARMAN
1950
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
226.
303/16
Klymenko v. Russia and Ukraine
24/11/2015
Oleksandr Oleksiyovych KLYMENKO
1972
Lugansk
Ukrainian
227.
505/16
Fylymonenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Gennadiy Leonidovych FYLYMONENKO
1967
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
228.
731/16
Nosach v. Russia and Ukraine
24/11/2015
Grygoriy Viktorovych NOSACH
1954
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
229.
736/16
Alyokhina v. Russia and Ukraine
24/11/2015
Oleksandra Pavlivna ALYOKHINA
1933
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
230.
3870/16
Moroz v. Russia and Ukraine
24/11/2015
Kateryna Yuriyivna MOROZ
1996
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
231.
3999/16
Glushchenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Oleksandr Valeriyovych GLUSHCHENKO
1975
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
232.
4009/16
Glushchenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Sergiy Oleksandrovych GLUSHCHENKO
1996
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
233.
4013/16
Glushchenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Olena Viktorivna GLUSHCHENKO
1977
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
234.
4027/16
Astakhova v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Tamara Vasylivna ASTAKHOVA
1964
Vuglegirsk
Ukrainian
235.
4044/16
Lunina v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Ryta Mykolayivna LUNINA
1938
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
236.
4152/16
Ryabtseva v. Russia and Ukraine
24/11/2015
Olena Valentynivna RYABTSEVA
1987
Stakhanov
Ukrainian
237.
4158/16
Bogdanets v. Russia and Ukraine
24/11/2015
Galyna Vasylivna BOGDANETS
1958
Novosvitlivka
Ukrainian
238.
4164/16
Prysyazhnyy v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Mykola Vasylyovych PRYSYAZHNYY
1948
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
239.
4182/16
Danylenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Viktor Ivanovych DANYLENKO
1960
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
240.
4184/16
Danylenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Maksym Viktorovych DANYLENKO
1980
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
241.
4187/16
Danylenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Olena Petrivna DANYLENKO
1954
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
242.
4188/16
Mozgovenko v. Russia and Ukraine
24/11/2015
Larysa Oleksiyivna MOZGOVENKO
1943
Zorynsk
Ukrainian
243.
4198/16
Kubosha v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Lyubov Kondrativna KUBOSHA
1948
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
244.
4207/16
Kubosha v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Viktor Stepanovych KUBOSHA
1946
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
245.
4336/16
Prysyazhna v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Lyubov Mykolayivna PRYSYAZHNA
1954
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
246.
4393/16
Danylov v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Mykhaylo Sergiyovych DANYLOV
2012
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
247.
4395/16
Danylova v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Yuliya Volodymyrivna DANYLOVA
1987
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
248.
4403/16
Lipkin v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Anatoliy Ivanovych LIPKIN
1938
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
249.
4646/16
Kononenko v. Russia and Ukraine
24/11/2015
Olga Vasylivna KONONENKO
1959
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
250.
4661/16
Poveshchenko v. Russia and Ukraine
24/11/2015
Ganna Vasylivna POVESHCHENKO
1983
Donetsk
Ukrainian
251.
4676/16
Poveshchenko v. Russia and Ukraine
24/11/2015
Nina Volodymyrivna POVESHCHENKO
1951
Donetsk
Ukrainian
252
4709/16
Moroz v. Russia and Ukraine
24/11/2015
Yuriy Mykhaylovych MOROZ
1966
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
253.
4716/16
Moroz v. Russia and Ukraine
24/11/2015
Svitlana Ivanivna MOROZ
1969
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
254.
4747/16
Yurystovskyy v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Vasyl Vasylyovych YURYSTOVSKYY
1974
Lebedynske
Ukrainian
255.
4752/16
Polivoda v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Rayisa Ullivna POLIVODA
1936
Debaltsevo
Ukrainian
256.
4757/16
Yurystovska v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Olena Ivanivna YURYSTOVSKA
Lebedynske
Ukrainian
257.
4763/16
Yurystovska v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Viktoriya Vasylivna YURYSTOVSKA
1999
Lebedynske
Ukrainian
258.
4802/16
Yurystovskyy v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Vasyl Onufriyovych YURYSTOVSKYY
1944
Lebedynske
Ukrainian
259.
4818/16
Yurystovska v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Lyubov Yaroslavivna YURYSTOVSKA
1948
Lebedynske
Ukrainian
260.
4853/16
Ilyinova v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Lyudmyla Borysivna ILYINOVA
1949
Zorynsk
Ukrainian
261.
4893/16
Borysov v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Albert Yuriyovych BORYSOV
1966
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
262.
4902/16
Borysova v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Ganna Albertivna BORYSOVA
1994
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
263.
19238/16
Bragin v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
05/04/2016
Anatoliy Stepanovych BRAGIN
1942
Pavlopil
Ukrainian
264.
19242/16
Bragin v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
05/04/2016
Vitaliy Anatoliyovych BRAGIN
1973
Mariupol
Ukrainian
265.
19315/16
Shcherbakova v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
05/04/2016
Vira Semenivna SHCHERBAKOVA
1939
Pavlopil
Ukrainian
266.
19391/16
Kuzin v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
05/04/2016
Mykola Andriyovych KUZIN
1932
Pervomaysk
Ukrainian
267.
19414/16
Ladya, Pp v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
05/04/2016
LADYA, PP
1996
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
268.
26393/16
Sergiyiva v. Ukraine
26/10/2015
Lina Volodymyrivna SERGIYIVA
1961
Dnipro
Ukrainian
269.
27799/16
Mykhaylenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
25/02/2016
Tetyana Oleksandrivna MYKHAYLENKO
1962
Bayrachky
Ukrainian
270.
29978/16
Chernyavska v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
25/02/2016
Larysa Oleksandrivna CHERNYAVSKA
1971
Аntratsyt
Ukrainian
271.
29980/16
Rybak v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
25/02/2016
Mariya Leonidivna RYBAK
1985
Donetsk
Ukrainian
272.
29981/16
Klymenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
25/02/2016
Oleksandr Oleksiyovych KLYMENKO
1972
Lugansk
Ukrainian
273.
30078/16
Chernyavskyy v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
25/02/2016
Yanyk Olegovych CHERNYAVSKYY
1992
Antratsyt
Ukrainian
274.
30083/16
Rybak v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
25/02/2016
Sergiy Viktorovych RYBAK
1985
Donetsk
Ukrainian
275.
30100/16
Dmytrenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
25/02/2016
Svitlana Volodymyrivna DMYTRENKO
1970
Komuna
Ukrainian
276.
32693/16
Popova v. Russia and Ukraine
17/04/2016
Galyna Romanivna POPOVA
1946
Stanytsya Luganska
Ukrainian
277.
32733/16
Fedorova v. Russia and Ukraine
17/04/2016
Alla Viktorivna FEDOROVA
1974
Stanytsya Luganska
Ukrainian
278.
32813/16
Gerasymova v. Russia and Ukraine
17/04/2016
Olga Yegorivna GERASYMOVA
1964
Stanytsya Luganska
Ukrainian
279.
32822/16
Gerasymova v. Russia and Ukraine
17/04/2016
Valentyna Mykhaylivna GERASYMOVA
1985
Stanytsya Luganska
Ukrainian
280.
32844/16
Ryabukhina v. Russia and Ukraine
17/04/2016
Valentyna Petrivna RYABUKHINA
1940
Stanytsya Luganska
Ukrainian
281.
32888/16
Pozhydayev v. Russia and Ukraine
17/04/2016
Mykola Oleksandrovych POZHYDAYEV
1952
Stanytsya Luganska
Ukrainian
282.
32891/16
Rukavchuk v. Russia and Ukraine
17/04/2016
Olena Viktorivna RUKAVCHUK
1970
Stanytsya Luganska
Ukrainian
283.
32965/16
Malikova v. Russia and Ukraine
17/04/2016
Valentyna Afanasivna MALIKOVA
1943
Stanytsya Luganska
Ukrainian
284.
33006/16
Valuyska v. Russia and Ukraine
17/04/2016
Valentyna Yevgenivna VALUYSKA
1956
Stanytsya Luganska
Ukrainian
285.
33010/16
Valuyskyy v. Russia and Ukraine
17/04/2016
Oleksandr Mykhaylovych VALUYSKYY
1950
Stanytsya Luganska
Ukrainian
286.
33013/16
Stolyarov v. Russia and Ukraine
17/04/2016
Vasyl Andriyovych STOLYAROV
1936
Stanytsya Luganska
Ukrainian
287.
33021/16
Fedorova v. Russia and Ukraine
17/04/2016
Asya Ivanivna FEDOROVA
1940
Stanytsya Luganska
Ukrainian
288.
33023/16
Litvinov v. Russia and Ukraine
17/04/2016
Leonid Kyrylovych LITVINOV
1954
Stanytsya Luganska
Ukrainian
289.
33033/16
Satsyk v. Russia and Ukraine
17/04/2016
Andriy Danylovych SATSYK
1955
Stanytsya Luganska
Ukrainian
290.
33035/16
Kuzyuberdina v. Russia and Ukraine
17/04/2016
Nina Oleksandrivna KUZYUBERDINA
1949
Stanytsya Luganska
Ukrainian
291.
33085/16
Kolbayev v. Russia and Ukraine
17/04/2016
Oleksandr Vasylyovych KOLBAYEV
1979
Donetsk
Ukrainian
292.
33090/16
Kolbayeva v. Russia and Ukraine
17/04/2016
Olena Ivanivna KOLBAYEVA
1972
Donetsk
Ukrainian
293.
33289/16
Shumetov v. Ukraine
30/04/2016
Oleksiy Valentynovych SHUMETOV
1975
Lugansk
Ukrainian
294.
33303/16
Teneri, TOV v. Ukraine
30/04/2016
TENERI, TOV
2001
Lugansk
Ukrainian
295.
33308/16
Otsinka mayna ta maynovykh prav, TOV v. Ukraine
30/04/2016
OTSINKA MAYNA TA MAYNOVYKH PRAV, TOV
2012
Lugansk
Ukrainian
296.
38188/16
Ryabchynska v. Russia and Ukraine
23/06/2016
Alla Petrivna RYABCHYNSKA
1973
Slovyansk
Ukrainian
297.
38200/16
Ryabchynska v. Russia and Ukraine
23/06/2016
Violeta Sergiyivna RYABCHYNSKA
1996
Slovyansk
Ukrainian
298.
39926/16
Zholobova v. Russia and Ukraine
23/06/2016
Tetyana Kostyantynivna ZHOLOBOVA
1960
Lugansk region
Ukrainian
299.
39989/16
Sergyeyeva v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
23/06/2016
Valentyna Ivanivna SERGYEYEVA
1959
Vuglegirsk
Ukrainian
300.
40083/16
Chyrskov v. Russia and Ukraine
23/06/2016
Volodymyr Oleksandrovych CHYRSKOV
1959
Lugansk
Ukrainian
301.
40098/16
Voronko v. Russia and Ukraine
23/06/2016
Olena Ivanivna VORONKO
1966
Lugansk
Ukrainian
302.
40107/16
Voronko v. Russia and Ukraine
23/06/2016
Valeriy Oleksiyovych VORONKO
Lugansk
Ukrainian
303.
40113/16
Chyrskova v. Russia and Ukraine
23/06/2016
Tetyana Oleksandrivna CHYRSKOVA
1949
Lugansk
Ukrainian
304.
40142/16
Ronska v. Russia and Ukraine
23/06/2016
Oksana Sergiyivna RONSKA
1973
Lugansk
Ukrainian
305.
41229/16
Protasov v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
09/07/2016
Sergiy Yuriovych PROTASOV
1982
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
306.
41237/16
Korobko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
09/07/2016
Oleksandr Pavlovych KOROBKO
1969
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
307.
41243/16
Vodolazska v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
09/07/2016
Nataliya Ivanivna VODOLAZSKA
1982
Debalsteve
Ukrainian
308.
41250/16
Protasova v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
09/07/2016
Lyubov Pavlivna PROTASOVA
1963
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
309.
41258/16
Vodolazskyy v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
09/07/2016
Oleksiy Sergiyovych VODOLAZSKYY
1977
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
310.
41264/16
Profatylo v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
09/07/2016
Tamara Tymofiyivna PROFATYLO
1952
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
311.
41266/16
Parkhomov v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
09/07/2016
Oleksandr Mykolayovych PARKHOMOV
1954
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
312.
50493/16
Konstantynova v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
13/08/2016
Nadiya Yuriyivna KONSTANTYNOVA
1959
Vuglegirsk
Ukrainian
313.
50510/16
Pavlyuchenko v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
13/08/2016
Gennadiy Volodymyrovych PAVLYUCHENKO
1954
Vuglegirsk
Ukrainian
314.
50516/16
Fedotova v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
13/08/2016
Oksana Gennadiyivna FEDOTOVA
1984
Vuglegirsk
Ukrainian
315.
50521/16
Konstantynov v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
13/08/2016
Oleksandr Yuriyiovych KONSTANTYNOV
1980
Vuglegirsk
Ukrainian
316.
51399/16
Borysova v. Russia, Ukraine and the United Kingdom
24/11/2015
Inna Mykhaylivna BORYSOVA
1967
Debaltseve
Ukrainian
317.
79333/16
Kosachov v. Ukraine
10/12/2016
Vasyl Volodymyrovych KOSACHOV
1925
Lugansk
Ukrainian
318.
79338/16
Tselovalnichenko v. Ukraine
01/12/2016
Svitlana Vasylivna TSELOVALNICHENKO
1956
Lugansk
Ukrainian
319.
79390/16
Tselovalnichenko v. Ukraine
10/12/2016
Yevgeniy Ivanovych TSELOVALNICHENKO
1951
Lugansk
Ukrainian
320.
14010/17
Pryvatvtorm, TOV v. Ukraine
10/02/2017
PRYVATVTORM, TOV
2001
Kyiv
Ukrainian
321.
16386/17
Klymenko v. Ukraine
16/02/2017
Oleksandr Oleksiyovych KLYMENKO
1972
Lugansk
Ukrainian
322.
16771/17
Klimenko v. Ukraine
16/02/2017
Oleksiy Oleksiyovych KLIMENKO
1937
Lugansk
Ukrainian
323.
42405/17
Gromadska organizatsiya Luganska pravozakhysna grupa v. Ukraine
06/06/2017
GROMADSKA ORGANIZATSIYA LUGANSKA PRAVOZAKHYSNA GRUPA
2008
Lugansk
Ukrainian
324.
66858/17
Spiridonov v. Ukraine
20/08/2017
Oleksandr Oleksandrovych SPIRIDONOV
1964
Donetsk
Ukrainian
325.
68110/17
Vorobyova v. Ukraine
01/09/2017
Tetyana Borysivna VOROBYOVA
1958
Valuyske
Ukrainian
326.
68137/17
Vorobyov v. Ukraine
01/09/2017
Andriy Viktorovych VOROBYOV
1996
Valuyske
Ukrainian
327.
68181/17
Vorobyova v. Ukraine
01/09/2017
Svitlana Borysivna VOROBYOVA
1968
Valuyske
Ukrainian
Full & Egal Universal Law Academy